caff wrote: » I would agree with this, although also add that government decisions can hugely affect land value also. Simply improving transport to reduce commuting time can open up large areas of existing housing on lower value land to people. House prices are largely fixed its the location that adds value.
Jasper79 wrote: » In a fair society where everybody pulled their weight perhaps it would.
Deleted User wrote: » Have you any idea how skewed towards those who are already well off our housing 'market' is? We are fast moving towards a world in which those with inherited privilege can simply own three a few houses and live off rent for their entire lives, whilst average WORKING people cannot own a house at all. Or just look over the water to London. Is this what we want? A city in which a nurse or a bus driver (lazy feckers!) can't dream of owning a house anywhere that doesn't involve a 90 minute commute to work every day. Whilst the 'supply' that is supposedly desperately needed is bought as empty investments by people who don't even live there. It's time to put the 'only lazy / feckless people can't afford houses' line to bed. It's not true any more. And anyway, high house prices are bad for our economy and indeed bad for everyone other than speculators and landowners. At the bottom end your 'scroungers' are on the street but in the middle hard working couples are spending a huge chunk of income on a shoe box. Housing policy should be based around removing speculation out of the housing market (why do we NEED speculation after all?) and focusing on policies that deliver affordable housing for all. Kind of sad that this is somehow controversial.
Joe Late Notch wrote: » I don't think a lot of companies have any major advantage in being in and around Dublin to be honest. Particularly ones with big manufacturing plants etc.
Shelflife wrote: » Again you may well be correct, my point is that businesses should be encouraged to set up outside of Dublin and re energise rural communities and take the heat out of the housing problem in Dublin. A 3 bed house in Castlebar is approx €1000 per month cheaper than a 3 bed house in Lucan thats roughly €12k a year into your hand disposable income or roughly €24k a year gross .
FrStone wrote: » Well I think there should be very little help for the one or two property landlord... In his budget speech, Michael Noonan mentioned the need for a professionalisation of the rental sector. If we encourage large rental companies in to the country we will increase the quality and standard of rental housing.
murphaph wrote: » Erm...maybe a workforce is an advantage? My company has its headquarters in Munich...right in the centre. Rent is €25 per m² per month. Why don't we move out of Munich? Because the employees want to live there. My boss doesn't like spending half a million on rent each year but to attract skilled staff he has to.
Joe Late Notch wrote: » Have they? I can't say they have stood out to me as being hit particularity hard in comparison to anyone else.
JustTheOne wrote: » Where is this golden entitled rule you speak of? is it.
Joe Late Notch wrote: » Do you really think a multinational offering high skilled high paying jobs will have any difficulty in attracting peope to where ever they set up. The lower cost of living and the fact an awful lot of people don't want to be stuck in a big city are also big incentives. I can't even bear the thought of having to live in Dublin. Also we aren't taking about setting up on the Arran islands. 30 mins or so outside cork or Galway city won't give the slightest problem but open up so much opportunity for housing in small towns etc with empty houses. It's already the case just look at where the big pharma and medical device companies are in cork, they are out in the county.
pwurple wrote: » Newacc2015,. There are more urban centres in this country than just Dublin. I've always lived in cities too. London, joburg, Amsterdam. And i would not like to live rurally either. But there's more to Ireland than one piddling city. I've lived in Cork for the last few years. Heaps of work around for me, public transport, loads of shops, pubs, restaurants, an airport. Anyone in Galway or Limerick city can get to Shannon airport and go to Europe or transatlantic, so your post just comes across as a smidge inexperienced.
Joe Late Notch wrote: » Do you really think a multinational offering high skilled high paying jobs will have any difficulty in attracting peope to where ever they set up. The lower cost of living and the fact an awful lot of people don't want to be stuck in a big city are also big incentives. I can't even bear the thought of having to live in Dublin.
tommybrees wrote: » Living in a small town in Tipperary. Easily over 200 houses empty here which require very little work to modernize. Plenty people available to work hard for probably minimum wage. So cost of upgrading these property's is not going to bankrupt somebody.
Riverireland wrote: » You'd have to ask why Alan Kelly is doing nothing with these. In his local area and all.
newacc2015 wrote: » How many large US companies are located in the middle of no where? None that I can think of, as well paid, educated people want to live in young vibrant cities like NYC, Atlanta, Dallas. I would earn prefer earn €35k in Dublin, than €45k in Leitrim. What Im going to do in Leitrim with all my money and zero social scene? There is no much more than money at play than picking a place to live.
newacc2015 wrote: » Most people from the sticks cant imagine living in Dublin. But the fact is most people from America or Europe that work for multinationals have lived in cities most of their life. Like them, I think living in a rural area is my version of hell.
newacc2015 wrote: » Europeans like the fact they can go from Barrow street and be on a flight back to Germany for the weekend in less than 90 mins. Thats not possible living in Galway.
newacc2015 wrote: » Im sure IDA have tried to selling that living in the arse hole of no where is great. But I imagine most MNCs see that trade off of slightly cheaper living is not worth the drop in quality of life
John_Rambo wrote: » Most Irish rural born people I know in Dublin wouldn't dream of heading home to live .
The_Conductor wrote: » Intel and Hewlett Packard- when determining their locations- stated the chosen development locations had to be within 30 minutes of Dublin airport and on the outskirts of Dublin- as mentioned above- because this is where their multinational staff want to work.
Joe Late Notch wrote: » How about we worry less about where the europeans and americans will live as we have our own highly skilled workers who are happy to live outside of Dublin. I know only a few who moved to Dublin in the first place as people I know generally don't like the idea of living there and the ones that are there have either already moved home or are just waiting until both partners can get a job at the same time. I probably only know maybe 7 or 8 people who moved to Dublin (including a sibling) and I can't see any if them there in 5 years or less even, 3 have already moved home to settle down another couple have gotten married and are really trying their best to make the move soon also.
Mrs OBumble wrote: » Yes, speaking for Galway I can say with absolute certainty that they do have some difficulty. There are people who grew up around the area, who've done their 10 or so years in Dublin and now started a young family and want to move back home. Sometimes they have the right skills that a multi-national wants - but sometimes they don't.
Mrs OBumble wrote: » But people who don't have either of these motivations see a small city with crap shopping (even the locals go to Limerick/Athlone/Dublin for stuff), not enough schools (only easing now as new ones are opened years after they were needed) bad traffic and very-small-town attitudes which make it very hard for blow-ins to become part of the community. And they see that they will be working with people who have chosen to sacrifice their career for lifestyle - this can be unattractive ("graveyard of ambition"). Even some locals say that the best thing about Galway is the express bus to Dublin.
Mrs OBumble wrote: » Some come anyway for the job - but stories where multi-nationals have changed their mind and laid highly-skilled people off three month after setting up a new team make people nervous about moving to an area where there is a small pool of other potential employers. (Not rumour, BTW, I can name company/people where this has happened.) Also, employers who do set up in these locations are sometimes low payers: I'm thinking of on German multi-national in the East of Galway city, and one large Irish company in the west, but of who have specific reputations as places to avoid just because of this. In general, apart from the most difficult-to-hire developers, Galway salaries are a good bit lower than the equivalent job in Dublin.
Mrs OBumble wrote: » And that's Galway, which does actually have a housing shortage as well: I've just sucked up a 20% rent increase because basically I have no option, anywhere else will cost as much. If you think about Castlebar or Ballina or wherever, you have smaller town, no express bus, far less cultural life etc. It IS hard for employers to recruit there.