Iwannahurl wrote: » Of course, for many people it's "Holloween" apparently...
Stench Blossoms wrote: » ... When times were tough I went out dressed in a black bag.
Mrs OBumble wrote: » Ahh, I don't think so: "Halloweening: The act of a women eating a butterfinger then blowing a male (boyfriend), then while chocolate and peanutbutter is still slathered ..." ref: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Halloweening
fishy fishy wrote: » trick or treat is an absolute American thing. It was never heard of in Ireland until maybe the early 80's when it became cool to ape whatever the Americans were doing. Until then we stuck to our dressing up with coal on faces, black bags as costumes, pagan ghosts and bonfires. anyone who think "trick or treat" has always been around are just too young to realize any different. The world WAS here before you were born you know. :D
inisboffin wrote: » ublin whose estate has plenty of 'egged and toiletpapered' houses when treats werent forthcoming.
Miss Lockhart wrote: » My parents are in their late 60s and they used the term "Trick or Treat".
fishy fishy wrote: » well since "trick or treat" was only "invented" in N. America in the 1950's I can only assume that your parents must have invented it, or they are American, or picked it up from Americans. Trick or treat is a very new thing compared to Halloween. Halloween and going out "mumming" or singing door to door is a celtic pagan tradition which goes back as far as at least the 19 century.
fishy fishy wrote: » In North America, trick or treat has been a customary Halloween tradition since at least the early 1950s. The tradition of going from door to door receiving food already existed in Great Britain and Ireland in the form of "souling", where children and poor people would sing and say prayers for the dead in return for cakes While going from door to door in disguise has remained popular among Scots and Irish, the North American custom of saying "trick or treat" has recently become common. above from wikipedia. I think if your parents were using it in the 50's in ireland, people would have had no clue what they were on about.
Irishgoatman wrote: » I'm in my late 60's and I grew up in England. I have no recollection of doing anything for/on Halloween. The only time we went door to door was the week before Christmas when we went carol singing. And we always did well for money that week.
antoobrien wrote: » Don't they celebrate a gang of catholics nearly making a mess of parliment a few days after holloween? For those without clue or a or a sense of humour http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guy_Fawkes
Miss Lockhart wrote: » Perhaps not, but that doesn't change the fact that that is what they remember doing. Earlier you said that the phrase was only invented in the 50s. Your own link says there are references to it from the 20s and 30s. You are speaking like you are an authority on the subject but your facts don't stack up. Like I said, I can only share my own experiences and those of my family. It might not suit your viewpoint but I can't help that.
fishy fishy wrote: » did ye not have bonfire night.
_Whimsical_ wrote: » I always did it as a child as did all of the children in my estate and my class in school. It's by no means a new americanisation thing. ...
_Whimsical_ wrote: » ... I think most parents are probably reluctant to allow their kids do it unaccompanied and children over 8 most likely don't want to go with parents and children under that are only able to walk to next door neighbours or very nearby houses. ...
antoobrien wrote: » I've a neighbour whose family is from Nottingham - they celebrate the 5th.
mathepac wrote: » Nov 5th is Guy Fawke's night. A Catholic Yorkshireman who tried to blow up James I and the House of Lords and restore a Catholic (Spaniard ?) to the throne of England, he was a hero much maligned by Brits since.
vicwatson wrote: » In town for few days anything going on tonight for children apart from goin around the houses in Galway City (we'll do that too) ? Happy Halloween y'all !