Polar Girl wrote: » A lot of my family and friends have asked what would I like, cash or presents. I have said well look whatever you want, we will appreciate anything but we have the house and everything we need so cash would be more practical. I see nothing wrong with saying this.
Polar Girl wrote: » Also for anyone who has their daddys pay for most of their wedding - isn't it easy to climb on on that very high horse of yours and bleat about we only want peoples presence- of course that is all you want- sure you hardly have to pay anything for your wedding yourself!
beegirl wrote: » This better not be aimed at me?!?! First of all, I was not "on my high horse" I simply said I didn't invite people so that they would give me loads of cash, I invited them because I want them there either way. Secondly I didn't say that my parents were paying for "most of" my wedding or that I hardly had to pay anything myself - I said they made a donation, which was a wedding gift not that it's any of your bloody business. Other than that it is our savings and sticking to a tight budget. How dare you assume anything about me, based on one post... talk about being on a high horse :mad::mad::mad:
Polar Girl wrote: » I think it is so funny to see people who are getting their parents to pay for half of their wedding getting on their high horses! Anyway We are having a small enough wedding, 90 guests, leaving out a lot of extras but spending a bit on food. A lot of my family and friends have asked what would I like, cash or presents. I have said well look whatever you want, we will appreciate anything but we have the house and everything we need so cash would be more practical. I see nothing wrong with saying this. We will not be in debt for the wedding as we are both working. If someone turned up with no gift I probably wouldn't really think much of it either way, if they were well off I would think of them as scabby but if they weren't well off I wouldn't think anything of it. I think some people are being dishonest saying oh I never wanted gifts and never thought about money. I will be totally honest and say that while obviously our friends and family being there means everything. We have wondered will we get many cash gifts and I think most people do. We are human and we do think these things. I would never go to a wedding, birthday party, barbeque without giving something. Why would anyone go to a wedding and give nothing? Sorry but that is tight especially if you see a girl with hair, make up done and a brand new dress yet they give no present. Come on people own up- that would piss you off!! Also for anyone who has their daddys pay for most of their wedding - isn't it easy to climb on on that very high horse of yours and bleat about we only want peoples presence- of course that is all you want- sure you hardly have to pay anything for your wedding yourself!
AARRRRGH wrote: » We used to give cash. We dont anymore. Too many people asked for cash and that annoyed me. Now its clocks, crystal or art for wedding presents.
Polar Girl wrote: » No need to get so upset.
aviendha wrote: » woooh there, a little bit on the sensitive side there!!!
whatdoicare wrote: » That sounds like you're trying to punish people- "You naughty wedding couple, asking for money- just for that, you're getting a clock!" Only in Ireland could a gift turn into a punishment, haha.
AARRRRGH wrote: » Good point. Ive been thinking about it though today. Going to a wedding in a few weeks and they asked for money again. I think now i'll get them a gift to a charity. eg i'll buy some goats for someone in Africa through Bothar.ie and put their name on it and give them the receipt. So now I am punishing them for being greedy, but helping someone else with it too.
whatdoicare wrote: » What I mean is, why do you feel you must give a gift and how did that lead to "I feel I am being forced to give something, so I'll punish people for making me"?
I don't think anybody thinks there is anything wrong with saying you'd prefer cash after you've been asked. It's when you make the request for cash as an assumption that you will be getting gifts that it's considered rude. Of course you will be getting gifts, you know it, your guests know it. But a gift is meant to be something you are given at the givers discretion, it's what gift means. Asking for a gift before one has been offered is the act of a spoiled child. And spending those gifts before you get them is very foolish.
AARRRRGH wrote: » Now maybe im wrong, but getting married used to be about having your friends celebrate your marraige and not about how much they would give you. I will give cash to couple who dont ask me for cash for going to their wedding. If they are polite to me, the gesture will be returned. Its a GIFT from me, not a ticket for your wedding. What would stop all this money grabbing is that if it became customary that nobody gave cash anymore for a wedding present. Then you'd see who really wanted you at their wedding. Im getting married this year and we are requesting that any gifts go to charity (a friend did this before, it was a great idea). People already pay enough just to come to a wedding ... clothes, transport, travel, hotel. It adds up. Im not asking them for anymore. Its my choice to ask them to the wedding without trying to extract cash from them.
Cincikchick wrote: » your own horse is no pony! Having close friends and family offer to pay for things in advance is IMO different to expecting general guests to pay for your day. Most parents and family will give as much as they can afford, and generally they will give this to you in advance of the day because that is practical. I think most people's objection is for couples to assume that the rest (or most) of the other expenses will be paid for by the rest of the guests. A risky strategy as you never know how much or what others will give....at least family generally tell you exactly what they are giving/paying for so no nasty shocks (would be a bit of a pisser if granny said she'd pay for the flowers and then gave you a candlestick on the day instead! )
Sabrielle wrote: » I am going to two weddings this year. Both weddings involve weekend hen parties, two night hotel stays and parties both the night before and day after the wedding. I think this puts huge pressure on guests and I've estimated that each wedding is going to cost 800 euro to go to and thats before a gift. Thats 1600 euro on weddings this year (different outfits have to be got because of overlap of wedding parties)
Cincikchick wrote: » Also, there is no pressure on you to have a different outfit for every wedding other than the pressure you put on yourself. Ask youself this - do you remember many outfits others wore at other weddings?
jkeane234 wrote: » I reckon a lot of people are talking bull saying they'd be happy with an empty card. If somebody showed up at any of my parties a few times in a row without a few drinks or a few burgers for the bbq, he wouldn't be invited again, if somebody slipped out on a round of drinks at the bar frequently, I wouldn't buy him another. Somebody showing up at any party & not contributing isn't a friend, he's a user. Same thing with a wedding, the couple have forked out a minimum of €60 a head for meals, drinks & entertainment & if you feel you can't contribute, then you can at least cut the costs for the couple by not showing up. If you are very close to the couple & really don't have any spare few pounds, they'll understand & be glad you managed to attend but that's not a get out clause for the majority of people who are just feeling a bit mean. If somebody feels the need to spite a couple by bringing a photo frame, they really shouldn't be going anywhere social & definitely not to a wedding. We always give €150 as a couple, a bit more if we are close to them, this covers the day & gives them a small few pounds towards their new life together, & hopefully they will do the same for me.