I've been wanting to get thoughts/insight on a situation I've found myself in with an acquaintance. Sorry it's a bit of a scroller. None of you are expected to read the whole thing. I have ASD and often experience trouble navigating social situations, especially with new people. I also often miss body language and subtle social queues. It causes a lot of stress when I meet new people, and I take a long time to get used to their mannerisms. Such is the situation with a relative newcomer to our social circle.
Firstly, I haven't known this guy for very long - 6 months at most. So I'm only just about learning how he works/interacts. He was brought into an online group by a mutual friend and at least in text, I thought we got along really well. We have very similar senses of humor and tastes. I suspect he may be untreated ADHD for various reasons but not sure if that's relevant to what I'm about to explain.
Problems arise when we're NOT just messaging. In group calls, etc, he will hardly ever talk to me directly. He'll usually respond if I say something to him, but not seek to engage me. The ONLY exception seems to be the few occasions where we found ourselves alone (either as teammates on a game or just waiting for everyone). Once again, when he actually tries I feel like we get along super well. I worry that maybe he's just being polite and pretending to be interested in what I'm saying? Again, I can't pick up if that IS the situation. He's a very sociable person and doesn't seem to have a hard time talking to anyone - he made quick friends with everyone - , so I guess it's possible him just being nice could seem like genuine friendliness, right?
It gets even worse when we're physically in each other's presence. Remember me saying he has no problems chatting to other people^^? If I actually think about the one or two times I've tried to talk to him face-to-face. It's impossible. He won't even look me in the eye. It usually starts off with me saying something, him acting like he's suddenly noticed I'm there. He's not loud or embarrassing about it, just looks at me wide-eyed like I gave him a fright. Maybe I'm just below his eyeline coz he'll then duck down and let me repeat whatever I said into his ear. Followed by a quick. "Heh. Right." And then walks away or talks to someone else. I feel like we never really get the chance to relate even though I try, and he doesn't approach me at all.
So maybe he's just distracted by the other people around? I thought so. Except the other day we found ourselves suddenly in each other's presence: I had stupidly left an ASOS package at my office and was complaining about it in the group chat. He mentioned my office was near his gym. I joked I'd give him a bottle of Baileys I got as an unwanted XMas present if he got it for me. He agreed. I told him there was no need as I could get it another day. He insisted. Free Baileys for the delivery and all.
He showed up at my house after the gym with the package, seemed cheerful enough to see me. I tried to make small talk with him...but he was immediately distracted by the dog. I quickly gave up and tried to give him the bottle, but he wouldn't take it. Said I was literally on his way home and he couldn't accept the payment. Walked away before I could argue. I went back inside, feeling guilty that I'd made him pick up the package for nothing, and texted him that his actions were appreciated, thank you, but completely unnecessary.
His exact response: "NAH that was too much for me to ask. You'll buy me a drink next time we see each other. Night!"
So I'm not in the clear, right? I still need to buy him a drink next time? It wasn't a gesture of friendship? Idk I guess as soon as I think we're becoming friendly, he acts... dismissive? Distant? I don't know how to describe it exactly.
I guess I'm confused as to why he doesn't seem to have any trouble getting along with anyone else. Then there just seems to be this sudden chill or offish nature when it comes to me. Clearly not meant, but I sense it. Could be he just doesn't like me, I know.