Deleted User wrote: » That's astonishing if true. Absurd. If Cowan Dickie is out I suspect Kelleher is in for a call up but given the first two replacements who knows.
LuckyGent88 wrote: » Navidi for Tipuric is completely understandable but Adam beard for Jones!!! Really. That’s mind boggling.
thomond2006 wrote: » OUTRAGE
Downlinz wrote: » Delighted for Murray, well deserved. If it goes well for him we'll hopefully see him return as Ireland captain as well, we've been missing a good leader since Best retired.
lawrencesummers wrote: » Who do you think should have been captain instead?
RugbyLover123 wrote: » Fair enough Navidi but Adam Beard… Wouldn’t surprise me at all if Gatland says to Scott Baldwin to replace LCD, seems only Welsh get called up.
thomond2006 wrote: » Kelleher is next man up at hooker, sure he's been training with them!
RugbyLover123 wrote: » I know yeah but knowing Gatland he’ll probably go ahead and pick a Welsh lad instead
Podge_irl wrote: » Some reward for a pretty mediocre performance for Murray. I'm amazed its not Farrell but implies that Aki/Henshaw is the starting centre partnership.
LuckyGent88 wrote: » Who else would have been in consider to replace Tiperic?? Coombes
Buer wrote: » It's absolutely not Gatland is selecting a certain squad for a certain job. It's not who we see as the best players. I said Ball in a previous post but it may as well be Beard. Another 120kg, tough, niggly lock. He's not deviating from his plan. Navidi and Beard should not come as a shock. Murray is an absolutely mental call though. Massive credit to him but I'm not sure he has ever even captained Munster more than once or twice or been in the Irish leadership group. Some honour for him.
sydthebeat wrote: » Delighted for Murray... Kick in the balls for farrell but gats probably not looking at him as a starter now. Navidi makes sense and good on him, he's the type of player we need against the SAs. Less said about beard the better. What's the point of bringing locks as sixes and then bringing a bean pole 5??
Deleted User wrote: » To be fair - you nearly called it and I see your logic but I don't rate Beard at all and certainly not in the same regards as some of the other options. He's been poor in a poor Ospreys team that won 2 games all season last year and I didn't think he added much to the Welsh grand slam team in 2019. A random series of events during this years six nations glossed over what was otherwise a very poor Welsh outfit and I fear Gatland's loyalty to certain players is going to catch up with him on this tour.
awec wrote: » Lineout. Beard won’t start but he is a rock solid lineout option for the bench.
ClanofLams wrote: » James Ryan is injured been reported now.
awec wrote: » Straw clutching that I’d say.