Paul Smeenus wrote: » No Mike Lowry? Really?
arsebiscuits1 wrote: » That one is a suprise to me also. Easily no 2 on this list
Paul Smeenus wrote: » I really would swap Lowry and Mcilroy there, but opinions are like ****holes etc etc
redmca2 wrote: » Jimmy O'Brien ???
AbusesToilets wrote: » Carberry should be on this list
Lucas44 wrote: » Max O’reilly surely has to be on this? Jamie Osborne too but may be a tad early to throw him in
bayern wrote: » does he? wasn't 1st choice for his irish u20 side and hardly been excellent for leinster this season. Very raw. Osborne not considered, seems to be more focused on centre these days.
bayern wrote: » he has made appearances for Leinster due to a rash of injuries, not because he is an outstanding talent who was demanding selection based on his performances for Leinster A.[ can’t have flannery on this list when he’s playing 12/ second choice 10 for Munster A meanwhile the other is playing for leinster in the pro14 was my point.. would be like putting Cormac foley down as a centre coming through cause he played there underage
bayern wrote: » You can and I did, if Flannery was on leinsters books he'd be playing 15 ahead of O'Reilly. Simple.
realhorrorshow wrote: » I've always thought O'Reilly would end up in the Sevens programme.
Lucas44 wrote: » Right you hold onto your hopes that munsters 5th choice 10 will be a top fullback in a few years and il take the actual fullback that has made his debut for leinster.
nerd69 wrote: » Saying one is better than the other is fine but it's a bit disingenuous to dismiss flannery as a 5th choice 10 when he's been a fullback first and foremost and played fullback for the irish 20s the year before rielly he only started playing 10 after harry byrne and Ben healy got hurt
bayern wrote: » O'Reilly also didn't make irish u20 squad when competing with Flannery for a spot in 2019.
realhorrorshow wrote: » O'Reilly was u19 in 2019.
bayern wrote: » He was out of school as a u19... he was in wider u20 training group but failed to make u20 squad.
nerd69 wrote: » To be fair a year makes a huge difference at that stage
bayern wrote: » Maybe.. the top prospects usually play u20 a year young if they are out of school though. O'Reilly is a good prospect but he isn't an elite one for me.
TRC10 wrote: » It depends, some players have 2 years of 20s and some players only have 1 year.