Same As wrote: » Won't be surprised if at least one more of the 30+ club calls it a day. Eoghan O Brien (24/25) Darragh Roche (25) Eddie Horan (19/20) These have all been called in.
thesultan wrote: » Tommy Walsh hasn't been a patch on his return from oz..
Same As wrote: » Clifford our sole (questionable) All Star nominee.
dobman88 wrote: I rarely agree with this fella but he has a point. I thought the general consensus was the All Stars are pretty much nonsense. Cant remember the last time, if ever, I actually went looking to see the all star team and who made it
Spacific wrote: » It really depends on what the All Stars are based on? Is there a set criteria? Does it include the National League?
dobman88 wrote: » https://www.irishexaminer.com/sport/gaa/arid-40207835.html?fbclid=IwAR20k8c0wZxGyb4vHFuMImvOffFosoNMItqmIn4nSk0j8kePszXlgDN8GgI
awaywithyou wrote: » no mention of dara roche??
Poor_old_gill wrote: » The whole Clifford thing reminds me of 2014 when all the dubs were up in arms over Connolly not winning footballer of the year. The main argument for being that he did so well for Vincent’s winning the All Ireland club- the only year I can remember a lads club form being the main driving force behind winning a POTY. Lundy was nearly as good for corofin the following year and wasn’t even nominated for an All Star
cms88 wrote: » Ye but that's different, as is everything when it comes to Dublin players according to ome of their fans. When Keegan and Andy Moran won POTY Dubs were mad telling everyone how the award didn't matter etc yet it became very important again when i Dublin player won it.
Poor_old_gill wrote: » I have never before or since heard a players club form being brought into it. I genuinely thought it was Dublin fans doing their ‘we’re salt of the earth, craic merchants’ thing until I realised some were serious. I still find it funny that they didn’t think Mayo players should win POTY because they didn’t win a final but a Dublin player beaten in a semi should
cms88 wrote: » At one time is did afaik. Kevin O Brian won one in 1990 on the back of winning a club All-Ireland. But i think at the time it factored in everthing, well as much as it could, league, championship club
Same As wrote: » Shane Enright was fairly frank in his interview on The GAA Hour this week. Well worth the listen, around 20 minutes long.
thesultan wrote: » Have you a link?