biko wrote: » I would expect someone who moved here to have enough grá for the place to become a citizen.
bubblypop wrote: » But why should anyone pay huge money to become a citizen of Ireland?
bubblypop wrote: » No, he doesn't need to say anything. You do however. Do you think I have any say I now this country is run? I'm here over 30 years. Do other people have any say in how this country is run? What do you think should be the rule? Who gets a voice? Anyone who gets a vote? Anyone who pays taxes? How long should they pay taxes before they get a say? How long should anyone's taxes be paid before they take effect?
[Deleted User] wrote: » For myself, that depends. Are you now Irish, or have you retained your external citizenship? If you've commited to living in a country, then you should have a say.. now.. whether other people have to listen, is a different matter entirely. However, simply as a taxpayer, but not a citizen? I'd say your opinions counts for less. But yeah, you do have a say.... TBH everyone does. The point he's making is that often with other nationalities (about their countries) you would be told quickly that your viewpoints were not wanted. He's not actually saying you have no right to an opinion on the topic. He's pointing out a double standard that often exists.
Hamachi wrote: » Amazing that you actually needed to reiterate that explicitly, but there ya go...
[Deleted User] wrote: » The point he's making is that often with other nationalities (about their countries) you would be told quickly that your viewpoints were not wanted. He's not actually saying you have no right to an opinion on the topic. He's pointing out a double standard that often exists.
bubblypop wrote: » Just because someone has paid a few euros into the exchequer? Do people living in this country paying taxes not have some say into the day to day running of the country? I'm living in this country 30ish years, working and paying taxes, do I have any say?
Hamachi wrote: » Indeed. If Irish people were foolish enough to insert themselves into a crucial national conversation of another country, they would be told where to go pretty sharpish. There’s a mindset out there that because somebody has paid a few euros into the exchequer, they have an intrinsic right to lecture the natives on what’s good for them. What this mindset is incapable of acknowledging is that European natives have roots that go back centuries and are rarely willing to entertain the critique of relative newcomers. It’s why that hysteric, Ebun Joseph, is ultimately destined for obscurity.
Deleted User wrote: » There's just too much support for the diversity, identity politics, white guilt, and the need for racism to exist. It's present in RTE on both TV and Radio. It's pretty common in our national newspapers... and worse yet, it's common throughout our political system. It's got too much support from official sources for it to be dropped any time soon... at least not without some serious pressure from a 'greater' source (the EU, or massive public anger).
Hamachi wrote: » It’s why that hysteric, Ebun Joseph, is ultimately destined for obscurity.
Marcos wrote: » Would they be so sanguine about Irish people going to the likes of Germany, Portugal or elsewhere and telling them what they can and can't debate? I doubt it.
Hamachi wrote: » For the record, I lived in Germany for as long as that poster has lived here. I’m fairly senior in what I do any paid tens of thousands of Euros in tax to the German exchequer. Never once did it occur to me to have the audacity to lecture Germans on their immigration policy or the future demographic composition of their country. I’m not German, I never will be and have no right to insert myself in their affairs, regardless of what my opinions are on Chancellor Merkel’s decision to open the borders and dispense with the Dublin convention in 2015. Ireland doesn’t have a colonial past like Portugal, nor do we have the painful history of Germany. We’re fully entitled to have a robust debate on immigration and push back against the follies of a flawed politic like multiculturalism. People like you aren’t going to silence the conversation.
Necro wrote: » Mod: Another personalised post like the start of the one above and you won't be posting in this thread again. Post in a civil manner and you can discuss the matter all day till the cows come home if you like
Hamachi wrote: » Point out what’s wrong in my post. ‘You think’ does not an argument make ‘bubblypop’. For the record, I lived in Germany for as long as that poster has lived here. I’m fairly senior in what I do any paid tens of thousands of Euros in tax to the German exchequer. Never once did it occur to me to have the audacity to lecture Germans on their immigration policy or the future demographic composition of their country. I’m not German, I never will be and have no right to insert myself in their affairs, regardless of what my opinions are on Chancellor Merkel’s decision to open the borders and dispense with the Dublin convention in 2015. Ireland doesn’t have a colonial past like Portugal, nor do we have the painful history of Germany. We’re fully entitled to have a robust debate on immigration and push back against the follies of a flawed politic like multiculturalism. People like you aren’t going to silence the conversation.
bubblypop wrote: » Ah no, I did consider what was written. I still think the poster was wrong in what he post.
bubblypop wrote: » Ah no, I did consider what was written. I still think the poster was wrong in what he post. Ate you going to tell me I'm wrong?
"So, it's all non Irish living here you have a problem with then. At least you're consistent."
ExMachina1000 wrote: » https://www.newstalk.com/podcasts/highlights-from-newstalk-breakfast/page/2 I just listened to it. Less than 5 painful minutes of rubbish. Teachers should have anti racism training University lecturers should have anti racism training Students should have anti racism training The entire curriculum should be changed Teaching European history is promoting white supremacy
[Deleted User] wrote: » There is no discussion because you didn't take the time to consider what was written. Just as the person from Portugal did with my post. Just seeking something to be outraged over.
iebamm2580 wrote: » Heard Ebun Joseph on Newstalk yesterday morning around 7am bit after, saying irish schools are encouraging racism by teaching history which in turn teaches white supremacy, tbf the guy interviewer pulled her up on that allegation, about time somebody had the balls to, don't mean to be harsh but she comes across as very low on the intellect scale. She wants African history taught here and anti racism courses for all teachers and students(presumably courses taught by her), incredible people give her the time of day. People like her if given enough air time will create division and problems where none exist.
ExMachina1000 wrote: » Is is regularly on the radio or writing opinion pieces in newspapers. All are of the same theme- Irish people are racists. Why do they keep inviting her back on ? Why is anybody listening to her? She was sent packing from the UK and now we are stuck with her.
bubblypop wrote: » I don't need to argue with posters on here. It's obvious what their opinions are. I am not even going to comment on your personal abuse, just report it. The poster from Portugal is living in this country ten years, legally, I'm guessing working here & paying his taxes His opinion is every bit as valid as anyone else living here. In fact, he actually had some insights into immigration, but you dismissed him. There is no discussing anything with you.
Hamachi wrote: » You took that from my post. You’re not very bright, are you? While we’re on the topic of consistency, your unintelligent, puerile posting style is a constant. Would love to see a fleshed out argument from you, but that’s never going to happen, is it ‘bubblypop’..
bubblypop wrote: » So, it's all non Irish living here you have a problem with then. At least you're consistent.