General Rugby Discussion II

Buer wrote: »

I would have thought that a top class No. 7 is often the most noticeable player on the field. McCaw, Dusautoir, Warburton, McCaw, Pocock etc. All of them were probably the most celebrated and marked men in their teams for a number of seasons at their peak.

McCaw - so good you name him twice!

I'm not overly familiar with all of the nuances in rucks so a lot of time I only notice when there has been a turnover - and I saw nobody who was as good as Pocock at poaching opposition ball while taking the punishment of the opposition clear out.

MOD NOTE

The inter- Provincial baiting needs to stop there's no place for it here or on any thread on the forum

kuang1

aloooof wrote: »

Apropos of nothing, what is it about accounts with new-ish join dates that are definitely, definitely not re-regs...

It was the most evidence this week so far, that the 6n is in fact, back!

aloooof

Apropos of nothing, what is it about accounts with new-ish join dates that are definitely, definitely not re-regs...

bilston wrote: »

Its crazy. They should all be ashamed of themselves.

We criticise amateurs for doing it, but these guys are professionals and we aren't talking about a bunch of 22 year old either. Their actions won't help the Barbarians brand.

Sadly I think the Barbarians are probably past their sell by date anyway in the professional era.

Maybe a touch less self righteousness might be in order. The barbarians is a day out with your mates for a fee.

Nobody takes it seriously.

molloyjh wrote: »

Well this post is.......unnecessary.

Although it doesn't make me wonder yet again why some people seem to wallow so much in misery & spite. It can't be healthy.

Chill out man.....

Never more chilled in my life - I love level 5 lockdown!

I love rugby too - but only a fool would suggest that loving Irish rugby means that I must also love the ludicrous sight and sound of plump Munster rugby supporters singing a song about some God-forsaken waterlogged fields around a small Connacht town, written by a Dub!

And don't get me started about singing about standing up and talking you know what!

Mod: Banned for trolling. No need to respond.

bilston wrote: »

OK...I'll bite for the craic...you never rated BOD??

Care to explain why?

Because he could not pass a ball to save his life. The ball could end up anywhere.

Squidgy Black

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Scotland v Georgia not on now? Can't find it anywhere

7pm itv4

Scotland v Georgia not on now? Can't find it anywhere

bilston

Larbre34 wrote: »

So Robshaw issues a grovelling proforma apology a the same moment the match is ****ing well cancelled. What an absolute bunch of ****wits to a man.

I know you can't fine a Barbarian, but really if these 12 guys want to be taken seriously again they should be donating many thousands of pounds to some effort to support the front line or furloughed workers.

Its crazy. They should all be ashamed of themselves.

We criticise amateurs for doing it, but these guys are professionals and we aren't talking about a bunch of 22 year old either. Their actions won't help the Barbarians brand.

Sadly I think the Barbarians are probably past their sell by date anyway in the professional era.

Buer

Deleted User wrote: »

I'll put it this way, I would normally never notice a number 7 in rugby but he stood out multiple times in every game it seemed like.

I would have thought that a top class No. 7 is often the most noticeable player on the field. McCaw, Dusautoir, Warburton, McCaw, Pocock etc. All of them were probably the most celebrated and marked men in their teams for a number of seasons at their peak.

bilston

Pelezico wrote: »

If you want to make a god out of this lad go ahead. He never won much and was injured all the time. Never rated BOD.

OK...I'll bite for the craic...you never rated BOD??

Care to explain why?

Larbre34

So Robshaw issues a grovelling proforma apology a the same moment the match is ****ing well cancelled. What an absolute bunch of ****wits to a man.

I know you can't fine a Barbarian, but really if these 12 guys want to be taken seriously again they should be donating many thousands of pounds to some effort to support the front line or furloughed workers.

StackSteevens wrote: »

In all fairness that was a welcome contribution to World Rugby Culture which I fully supported!

Few things on earth make me want to projectile vomit more than hearing a crowd of overweight tomaytoes tunelessly singing The Fields of Athenry or Stand up and Sh1te. In terms of utterly nauseating, they come second only to the haka.

What sickens my hole is the silence when opposition players kicking for goal.

This is Munster..spiritual home of rugby nonsense...really hole sickening behaviour

molloyjh

StackSteevens wrote: »

In all fairness that was a welcome contribution to World Rugby Culture which I fully supported!

Few things on earth make me want to projectile vomit more than hearing a crowd of overweight tomatoes tunelessly singing The Fields of Athenry or Stand up and Sh1te. In terms of utterly nauseating, they come second only to the haka.

Well this post is.......unnecessary.

Although it doesn't make me wonder yet again why some people seem to wallow so much in misery & spite. It can't be healthy.

Chill out man.....

molloyjh wrote: »

Piping music over the speakers to drown out opposition supporters.

In all fairness that was a welcome contribution to World Rugby Culture which I fully supported!

Few things on earth make me want to projectile vomit more than hearing a crowd of overweight tomatoes tunelessly singing The Fields of Athenry or Stand up and Sh1te. In terms of utterly nauseating, they come second only to the haka.

Pelezico wrote: »

Everyone who retires nowadays is considered to be an all time great.

That currency is pretty devalued. He was good. Lots of players are good.

I think Pocock is someone who re-defined the standard for his position though. Pocock was the one everyone looked to as the best of the best. He used to get turnovers he had absolutely no right get due to his unique body shape and centre of gravity.

I'll put it this way, I would normally never notice a number 7 in rugby but he stood out multiple times in every game it seemed like.

OldRio wrote: »

Robshaw?
I'm not one for gossip but I have friends who are neighbours of the Robshaws. 'Par for course' is all I'm saying.

So the Robshaws really enjoy eating in Italian restaurants? I am shocked to my core.

Buer

mfceiling wrote: »

Stephen Jones (I know I know) wrote about them a few weeks past in the Sunday times and to be fair to them they have done a lot for the local community as a club.
From youth foundations to helping ex prisoners find employment etc it seemed to paint them in a decent enough light.
Their wage policy though was a joke but outside of that a lot of clubs could do worse than implement some of their better ideas. No?

Millwall also found employment for some ex-cons although that was generally on the pitch.

Ah, I'm being something of a sh*t stirrer. I think nobody would give a f*ck about Saracens breaking the salary cap if they didn't beat Munster and Leinster in recent years. The French wage bills are comfortably the biggest but nobody has mentioned them since Toulon won the European Champions Cup. Odd that.

In relation to their community involvement, Saracens aren't thick. They're very savvy in their dealings off the field and know that to become the club they want to be and generate the support they desperately want, they have to reach out to those around and they've been excellent at that. Irish rugby is quite good at it but probably not in the same approach in terms of outreach to the less fortunate.

sydthebeat wrote: »

not many "good" players get nominated for world player of the year on 3 separate occasions.

in fact only 5 others players hold that honour
O driscoll, McCaw, Carter, O Farrell and B Barrett

not bad company to be in

If you want to make a god out of this lad go ahead. He never won much and was injured all the time. Never rated BOD.

molloyjh

mfceiling wrote: »

Stephen Jones (I know I know) wrote about them a few weeks past in the Sunday times and to be fair to them they have done a lot for the local community as a club.
From youth foundations to helping ex prisoners find employment etc it seemed to paint them in a decent enough light.
Their wage policy though was a joke but outside of that a lot of clubs could do worse than implement some of their better ideas. No?

And remember some of their terrible ones. Piping music over the speakers to drown out opposition supporters. The pathetic fat lady nonsense. The ticket refund stunt re Gavin Henson.

There are plenty of reasons that people dislike the club even before the salary cap stuff.

Dave_The_Sheep

https://twitter.com/therugbypaper/status/1319628669179072514

Reporting the Baabaas/England game is off.

mfceiling

Buer wrote: »

They are to rugby what Millwall was to football in the 1970s and 1980s.

"We are Saracens. Nobody likes us and we don't f*cking care."

Stephen Jones (I know I know) wrote about them a few weeks past in the Sunday times and to be fair to them they have done a lot for the local community as a club.
From youth foundations to helping ex prisoners find employment etc it seemed to paint them in a decent enough light.
Their wage policy though was a joke but outside of that a lot of clubs could do worse than implement some of their better ideas. No?

yerrahbah

https://twitter.com/FoyChris/status/1319628417982222344

Dopes

sydthebeat

Pelezico wrote: »

Everyone who retires nowadays is considered to be an all time great.

That currency is pretty devalued. He was good. Lots of players are good.

not many "good" players get nominated for world player of the year on 3 separate occasions.

in fact only 5 others players hold that honour
O driscoll, McCaw, Carter, O Farrell and B Barrett

not bad company to be in

OldRio

StackSteevens wrote: »

Whatever about the club and players that - according to the great rugby guru Gerry Thornley - we are all expected to hate [although my understanding is that we are still allowed to give Mark McCall a free pass], in what way is this incident "par for the course" for Robshaw?

Robshaw?
I'm not one for gossip but I have friends who are neighbours of the Robshaws. 'Par for course' is all I'm saying.

Clegg wrote: »

David Pocock has retired. The best player over the ball I've ever seen and one of the all time greats. He's only 32 as well. He played in the most physically demanding position in rugby and picked up a lot of injuries.

On the topic of Australian opensides, they've had an almost unbroken run of world class players. George Smith to David Pocock to Michael Hooper. The careers of all three overlapped too. Which is pretty incredible.

https://twitter.com/pocockdavid/status/1319522303374286848?s=19

Everyone who retires nowadays is considered to be an all time great.

That currency is pretty devalued. He was good. Lots of players are good.