Mossie1975 wrote: » I find Damian’s voice easier to listen to (and I’m a fan of the Cork accent).
Joe_ Public wrote: » Same guy who was on the arts show last week? Sounds the same anyway.
Beechwoodspark wrote: » It’s almost as if they go, Feck, we have to fill 5 minutes of time during the second half of the show - Ring the muppets guy again
Chalk McHugh wrote: » Who's this new tough Damien guy i'm reading about here? Surely not the same watery, safe pair of hands, never ask the hard questions, RTE lifer that did Liveline for a while? Not a chance i'd tune in to this programme with this lad.
A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: » Damien O'Reilly has found his ideal niche if you ask me. He's good on Countrywide, but I wouldn't get the impression he's particularly passionate for farming. He was interviewing a really interesting farmer about biodiversity a couple of weeks back, and O'Reilly's boredom was nearly audible. He's performing out of his skin on this programme. I like Brendan O'Connor but would much prefer to see O'Reilly in this slot. Very sharp, well prepared, and he has more of a voice for radio than O'Connor has.
Brendan Bendar wrote: » Like to see him getting a few ‘harder issues’ and a bunch of motor mouths to facilitate. For me the good thing is that he is ‘not from the journalist gene pool’ ie the Main papers like Sarah and Brendan, bar maybe some farming journals maybe.
ShamNNspace wrote: » I think the best use of o Connors voice would be as an incentive to remove the patrons from various public houses when they reopen.. Perhaps he could make a recording to be played over the tannoy as part of phase 4 reopening or whatever it is
Del.Monte wrote: » as for his replacement on that show this week, Marty Morrissey, unlistenable to.
A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: » What does Marty Morrissey know about farming? I'd happily listen to him chat all day about Munster hurling, but some of the gigs he gets in RTE are inexplicable. I think some RTE bosses must view him as funny in an ironic sort of way, which is condescending both to Morrissey and the listener. Let him do what he's good at.
spakman wrote: » They put very little thought into it. They think Marty Morrissey = GAA = "down the country" = farming. Perfect fit!
Brendan Bendar wrote: » A lot of shade being thrown at Marty Morrissey here - undeserved in my opinion. In my opinion Marty is perhaps the most versatile presenter in all RTE. Now, that’s not saying he is best at everything, no way, but to be able to handle multiple subjects with competence, think on his feet, and present these subjects confidently without ‘strain’, I can’t think of anyone in RTE presenter team who can equal him. Feel free to nominate anyone who you think can?
A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: » Damien O'Reilly? Miriam can throw her hand at anything, she'll be the boss of us someday (President). Philip Boucher Hayes has done everything from Crimeline to Drivetime to Liveline, very dexterous broadcaster. Just can't agree with you on this one, Chief. Did you hear Morrissey doing Countrywide on the weekend? Not great, I don't remember it having any farming content at all. Not good enough.
Brendan Bendar wrote: » Never heard Damian or Miriam broadcasting Gaelic Games Boucher-Hayes for me comes across as an over smug individual who is ok in small doses Miriam with the D4 accent “ Moi ghasts todai are” Couldn’t take that for too long. Didn’t hear Marty on CW over the weekend but would suggest that content would be the producers call. If Rte were a team I suggest Marty would be it’s most valuable and versatile player.?
Brendan Bendar wrote: » Never heard Damian or Miriam broadcasting Gaelic Games
A Tyrant Named Miltiades! wrote: » And what? I never heard Micheál Ó Muircheartaigh presenting Countrywide, either, because he wouldn't know a bull from a steer. So he was never offered the gig. An encyclopedic knowledge of GAA is no substitute for a basic knowledge of farming. This is not a controversial point. Look, I am not an unreasonable man Brendan. If Morrissey wants to dance with the stars, or pursue some lifestyle shows, more luck to him. But I will begrudge him a farming slot where he contributes precisely nothing to the topic. There are plenty of up-and-coming agri guys capable of the job. Frank McNulty would be an obvious choice.
generalgerry wrote: » I think it's important not to make the judgement on one weekend of Damien. He did a good job, but he has possibly been waiting a long time for this opportunity and this may not be the level of broadcast that he can do on a consistent basis. To use a farming proverb for him, one swallow does not a summer make.