jluv wrote: » But as a KK person I can see where he is coming from. As a rival supporter you'd support the decision of the ref and welcome it. But...in light of how the game was being reffed it was a harsh decision.
Lefty Bicek wrote: » Limpy wrote: » Dowling is surely going to win that. I'd give it to Callanan for the goal against Wexford. Best goal since John Fenton against Limerick. The traditional skill of ground hurling beats any of that new-fangled batting ****e any day of the year.
Limpy wrote: » Dowling is surely going to win that.
Hawkeye9212 wrote: » This Sunday Game format is rubbish. All of the lads look like they are attending a wedding.
Limpy wrote: » Those "liam" licence plates are fair annoying. There on every second car to u see
crossman47 wrote: » I haven't seen any comment on the point given by Hawk Eye. I'm convinced there is something wrong. There is no way a goalie can bend his wrist backwards so the ball in his hand has gone behind the crossbar.
threeball wrote: » I think shinty is the game for you
mountgomery burns wrote: » It's a bit disappointing to see pundits incapable of parking their allegiances when giving analysis. Getting well paid for it, if you can be impartial then you shouldn't be given the opportunity. To be fair it's not just about today, as an example I've a lot of time for Cummins but he wasn't objective discussing whether Heffernan should be banned for the final the last day either.
Mokuba wrote: » Very surprised by how Kilkenny capitulated after the (deserved) red card, tactically so poor.
marvin80 wrote: » Before the red I felt Tipp were atrocious and Kilkenny should have had them dead and buried. A Kilkenny team from a few years ago would have punished them. Once Hogan got the red I couldn't see them winning.
Road-Hog wrote: » Do sky tv do a highlights program.....?
Hawkeye9212 wrote: » Cody's comment about the refs taking their time to make a decision is embarrassing.
marvin80 wrote: » Shefflin today and Tyrrell tonight two more embarrassing examples as well
Hawkeye9212 wrote: » Two wrongs don't make a right.
crossman47 wrote: » Yes. They wanted to be sure they were right which is what Cody says he wanted.
Lefty Bicek wrote: » IS there any need for it ?
threeball wrote: » They need to sort this Hawkeye sh1t out. Hogan just said there wasn't a hope it was over. Like most suspected.
slegs wrote: » crossman47 wrote: » Yes. They wanted to be sure they were right which is what Cody says he wanted. He only wanted them to do what he wanted not to be right. Kilkenny don’t lose very much and aren’t taking it very well. The comments for Shefflin and Tyrell on television re the sending off are disgraceful. It was a clear red card irrespective of Barrett’s reaction. Cody also very ungracious. It’s not like they lost by a point. They were hammered. I think Tipp would have won easily anyway (we will never know). Kilkenny have a style that is based on aggression and a sending off is always possible when you play on the edge. All this playing the victim stuff smells of sour grapes.
jluv wrote: » But if the decision was against you.? Two wrongs just means two wrongs.. I honestly don't think that ref or linesman saw what happened. One player going in hard. One player stepped back. Got caught. No objection. Player makes a meal of it, ref put in a position. For those critics saying the kk anylists are playing it down. Of course you would. If any other team had to defend it they w..
TheRiverman wrote: » Brendan Cummins just briefly mentioned that he wouldn't agree that it was a point.I would definitely like to hear more goalkeepers views on it.
Road-Hog wrote: » Mokuba wrote: » A red card, while damaging, is not a death knell and plenty of teams have gone on to win or draw games after getting them. Off the top of my head, the last 3 red cards Tipperary have gotten in the championship:v Wexford this year - down by 5 and came back to win v Waterford last year - down by 11 and came back to draw v Limerick in 2016 - Played virtually the whole game with 14 and won well. Very surprised by how Kilkenny capitulated after the (deserved) red card, tactically so poor. Will the ‘red/lobster faced one’ be tempted to throw in the towel this year after kk’s worst final defeat in living memory.....?
Mokuba wrote: » A red card, while damaging, is not a death knell and plenty of teams have gone on to win or draw games after getting them. Off the top of my head, the last 3 red cards Tipperary have gotten in the championship:v Wexford this year - down by 5 and came back to win v Waterford last year - down by 11 and came back to draw v Limerick in 2016 - Played virtually the whole game with 14 and won well. Very surprised by how Kilkenny capitulated after the (deserved) red card, tactically so poor.
slegs wrote: » He only wanted them to do what he wanted not to be right. Kilkenny don’t lose very much and aren’t taking it very well. The comments for Shefflin and Tyrell on television re the sending off are disgraceful. It was a clear red card irrespective of Barrett’s reaction. Cody also very ungracious. It’s not like they lost by a point. They were hammered. I think Tipp would have won easily anyway (we will never know). Kilkenny have a style that is based on aggression and a sending off is always possible when you play on the edge. All this playing the victim stuff smells of sour grapes.
ArnoldJRimmer wrote: » Well one reason is that you're unnecessarily using an insulting phrase when asking a question about Brian Cody. Like him or not, he's the greatest manager of all time and deserves a little bit more respect than that
