Hawkeye9212 wrote: » Deserved a yellow at most.
larrya wrote: » As did Hogan’s on Barrett
digzy wrote: » Jesus, get over it. Ye took a 14 point hiding. Doesn’t happen ye too often
namloc1980 wrote: » Why isn't anyone criticising Hogan for costing his team the match? His elbow was completely uncalled for. But no, much easier to slam the referee for actually applying the rules.
Hawkeye9212 wrote: » Nope. That was a red.
jluv wrote: » I don't think he cost the team the match to be fair. Tipp would have won anyway based on the second half performance . And I feel he was hard done by,not that I disagree with the decision being played by the rules, but the ref chose to let a lot go before that and should have been consistent. He had no clue what happened, don't think linesman knew anything more. It seemed the decision was made by ref after look at the player..yellow but wouldn't have changed the result I think..
holyhead wrote: » Not sure about the result staying the same with Hogan on the pitch for the full match. Psychology plays a large part in sport and if it was felt Hogan's sending off was harsh it could have led to 'it's not our day' mind set. Look we'll never know but the game was neck and neck until his sending off. Ideally we needed a goal once we went a few points up in the first half.
jluv wrote: » I guess my point was you cant blame him based on the decision that the ref made. Harsh IMO. But Tipp in the second half were phenomenal. Their passing was fantastic. Felt it was their day..
TheRiverman wrote: » Jackie Tyrell talking rubbish.
castletownman wrote: » If the Sunday game are going for score of the year then Wexford have a good chance between Liam Ryan in the semi-final and Conor Mac in the Leinster final
Hawkeye9212 wrote: » What's he saying?
larrya wrote: » a loose shoulder come elbow
TheRiverman wrote: » In the spirit of the All Ireland Final,Richie Hogan shouldn't have got a red card,no one on the panel agreed with him.
Limpy wrote: » Dowling is surely going to win that.
larrya wrote: » Congrats to tipp but red card completely changed the game and I think it was harsh, Barrett made the most of it and should be embarrassed looking back.saying that tipp looked to be getting on top at the time
lawred2 wrote: » Not harsh. Got a right rattle from an elbow. Why he should be embarrassed only God knows!?[/quote