Big Bag of Chips wrote: » By the way, I personally know of someone who behaved pretty much as your husband is. Accusing his wife of exactly the same things. In front of their baby smiling at her telling her "when you're old enough I'm going to tell you exactly what a slut your mother is. The town bike" etc etc. She had had 1 sexual partner before him. Turns out he had a liking for prostitutes.. For the entirety of their relationship/marriage. I'd be very wary of anyone so vocally accusing someone of something like this, without any real basis.
Emme wrote: » Your husband’s behaviour is completely out of order. Good luck OP and stay safe. Women's Aid might be a good place to start. However if you decide to go DO NOT LET YOUR Husband KNOW YOU ARE GETTING COUNSELLING OR CONTEMPLATING LEAVING. Have everything planned on the quiet before you go. Women's Aid will tell you why this is so important. You are pregnant now and at your most vulnerable. Make sure you have plenty of support from friends and family. Take care.
The Princess Bride wrote: » He's not going to change, I hope you realise this.
YoungRogerian wrote: » Folks, could we not advise her without being so judgemental. I agree that the relationship doesn't seem healthy for this lady, but we don't know this guy or anything about him but what we've heard from one anonymous person on the internet. We don't know what underlying issues are behind his infidelity or his insecurity. Maybe the man has in built insecurities that make him compare himself to others. Maybe he thinks his wife will eventually leave him as no one could choose him when there are other options available? Or maybe he is just an arsehole? But my point is, none of us know this man so why are we being judge jury and executioner?
YoungRogerian wrote: » It is not the responsibility of the OP to live her life by what makes her husband happy.
YoungRogerian wrote: » She needs to do what is right or her and I genuinely wish that for her, but let's not rush to make this guy that none of us bar the OP know into some sort of super villain.
YoungRogerian wrote: » He is seeking professional help, hopefully that will help him find his answers too. All human beings are flawed, support this lady and give her the empathy she deserves, but don't deny it to him.
YoungRogerian wrote: » None of us know the time or the hour when we will make a mess of things. I know I for one wouldn't like being condemned for my mistakes by random strangers on the internet.
YoungRogerian wrote: » I'm also, not one bit interested in having an argument about this. I actually totally understand the reaction of people to this. It was my initial reaction too. I was about to post in agreement with the people simply calling this man a word beginning with d. Then I took a step back, I read all the reactions and the lack of any attempt to understand this man's thought process concerned me. His behaviour is objectively wrong. He is the 'bad guy', but good and bad, right and wrong are of no benefit in understanding the psychology of human behavior. This man's (appalling) behaviour is coming from a narrative of his own construction, based on how he has experienced the world. The condemnation this man is receiving, from people, I reiterate, who do not know him, is perfectly understandable given the facts presented to us. However it is totally useless in terms of facilitating real and lasting change. I want to believe this man can change, I'm sure his wife wants to believe he can change. I also want to believe this man is not all bad, if I can't believe that, then I would simply have to abandon all faith in humanity. His wife obviously doesn't believe he is all bad or she wouldn't have been with him in the first place. Our very survival as a human race depends on our ability to learn and grow. There is plenty satisfaction for the victim of such bad behaviour in condemnation and it is absolutely understandable, but look at how many opportunities for reconciliation would have been missed if no one ever attempted to understand the other person. Not excuse their behaviour, not justify it, just understand. Take Jo Berry and Pat Magee. When Pat Magee planted the bomb that killed Jo's father, understandably she was angry. If she had let that anger consume her, no one could blame her. Instead she reached out to the man, took on his story, said her piece and created a dialogue. Not only are the two now friends, but the organisation they started "Building Bridges for Peace" does great work in reconciliation. Similarly, the man I take my username from, Carl Rogers, did plenty of meaningful work on reconciliation. If we never allow for the possibility o personal growth and change, then we just repeat the same cycles over and over again. I have no idea if this man is genuinely willing to change or even capable of it. All I'm saying is give him the opportunity. It's a totally separate issue to what his wife needs to do to stay safe, but it's not completely irrelevant, especially given that there are kids involved who will want their dad in their lives. I hope the OP frees herself from this abusive situation, but I also hope her husband gets his s**t in order. I don't think those two wishes are mutually exclusive.
GingerLily wrote: » ^^^ I wish you had as much compassion for the OP as you do for her abusive husband.
Ursus Horribilis wrote: » You also said in another thread that you're perpetually single and don't see yourself ever meeting someone. So maybe you don't understand how relationships work.
YoungRogerian wrote: » GingerLily wrote: » ^^^ I wish you had as much compassion for the OP as you do for her abusive husband. I have plenty compassion for her. I made that clear. People will misinterpret my posts as they see fit. I'm blue in the face from saying this man's behaviour is wrong and that she needs to remove herself from the situation. Even a cursory glance at my posts would show this. If random strangers on the internet are choosing to misread my posts to suit an agenda, that really isn't any of my concern.
YoungRogerian wrote: » why are we being judge jury and executioner? let's not rush to make this guy that none of us bar the OP know into some sort of super villain I for one just can't fathom throwing this man to the wolves I can't condemn the man The condemnation this man is receiving the rest of you are adjusting the noose in order to hang this man frankly horrifying rush to condemn
YoungRogerian wrote: » I know I for one wouldn't like being condemned for my mistakes by random strangers on the internet
YoungRogerian wrote: » my post was clearly not aimed at the OP
YoungRogerian wrote: » support this lady and give her the empathy she deserves, but don't deny it to him
GingerLily wrote: » Curosry glance? You've almost written a book here! When someone needs advice regarding leaving an abusive relationship I don't think it's wise to consider any empathy to the abuser. Not yet.
YoungRogerian wrote: » All I am saying here is that IF and it is a huge if, this man genuinely wants to change, that he be given that opportunity. Not once did I say she should stay with him.
BBFAN wrote: » What on earth has any of the above got to do with OP? No-one is saying this man deserves a life of misery, just that he doesn't deserve the wife he has, that's all.
Helppls18 wrote: » Thank you for all the replies. We endured a very hard Xmas, I was emotionally drained trying to keep things "normal" for the kids. HB attending a psychotherapist, its helping and marriage counselling starts next week.
Helppls18 wrote: » Sad to say most of you were right he hasnt changed. Hes had a few sessions of therapy, we done couples counselling but its back to me being a bad person for having ONS before him he can't handle it and cant get over it. He is having hypnosis tomorrow. Its a last ditch attempt but I don't think I can live like this anymore and will need to seperate, the stress the anxiety the worry. No one knows I've never been as scared or lonely in my life
Helppls18 wrote: » No one knows I've never been as scared or lonely in my life