shaungil wrote: » You could argue that club players that get to that level are almost a better bet because they haven't had the semi professional environment for 6 years and so their potential ability to improve is far higher as they enter the professional environment.
Heymans wrote: » Whats Barrons and Kellehers throwing like?
Heymans wrote: » If that's case how do you explain the Michael's SCT hockeying the Belvo U20's last season 56 -0. I doubt the standard at AIL level is as good as schools. Certainly there's not the commitment there from players as there would be in school training every day. Going on to play adult rugby is a hobby - playing schools is a vocation.
iminterestd0 wrote: » Michaels SCT side had several future pros, Belvo 20s had none.
iminterestd0 wrote: » Heymans wrote: » If that's case how do you explain the Michael's SCT hockeying the Belvo U20's last season 56 -0. I doubt the standard at AIL level is as good as schools. Certainly there's not the commitment there from players as there would be in school training every day. Going on to play adult rugby is a hobby - playing schools is a vocation. Michaels SCT side had several future pros, Belvo 20s had none.
The Lost Sheep wrote: » In many clubs kids between their club, their school and the top players in regional/provincial squads are getting as much training as any schools player and if theyve turned 18 while still in secondary school and in a stronger club they can play adult rugby well above school standards.
Heymans wrote: » Rubbish. Clubs are far behind schools in coaching standards. Certainly the consistency a schools players gets coaching is far more frequent than club players. And then there's all the analysis that goes along with schools rugby - this doesn't happen at club level. On top of that there is the S & C that goes on in schools that deosn't happen in clubs. There is no comaparrisson of the workload a schools player does versus club.
The Lost Sheep wrote: » You said there is a buffer. There isnt. You said kids from youths rugby arent playing to same standard for first 14 years that is completely untrue. Overwhelming majority of kids start playing rugby in rugby clubs playing mini rugby there We are seeing more and more progress from youths rugby and the top players between their clubs and leinster squads are getting as much/as good training as the schools.. And players are certainly picked on a meritocratic basis.
Heymans wrote: » Of course it's not nonsense. It is in fact very true to say that. Point to me a club competition that equals the Leinster senior or Junior Cups. There is so much prestige associated with the Cups that schools literally do everything in their power to win it. That involves much larger populations than are associated at one man and his dog clubs. The level to which schools players are coached is close to professional - you don't see that with clubs and you can't see it with clubs who only coach in the evening times. For those who start their minis in clubs there is a gaping hole in the gap between lining out for your club on the weekend to training day in and day out with your school to fight for representing them in the Cup. All in all there is a wide chasm between the two and the club players are molly coddled by the big wigs in Leinster Rugby to make themselves feel they are reaching outside the main catchment areas and are doing more for the game. It's nonsense and players should be picked on meritocracy.
The Lost Sheep wrote: » That isnt true at all. And where are you getting 14 years from? Majority of kids in rugby schools start their rugby in mini rugby and even first year of youths rugby in rugby clubs. And not playing the schools cup doesnt at all mean theyre not tried or tested. That is a load of nonsense to suggest that.
Heymans wrote: » You get the feeling that there is a buffer put in place for Club players. They don't play to the same level as schools players for the first 14 years of their rugby playing life and therefore are not tried and tested under pressure. I can't help but feel they are molly coddled to "spread" the game further. Kind of like socialism. They are allowed to develop better than schools players who lose conditioning due to overplay.
iminterestd0 wrote: » It was a weak club age group for the leinster 20's, only 3 players in squad: Daragh Bolger(Prop/Clontarf) Declan Adamson(Hooker/Clontarf) Martin Moloney(Backrow/Athy/Lansdowne) The u19's were very strong with club players: Marcus Hanan(Prop/Clane) Charlie Ward(Prop/Tullow/Clontarf) Harry Noonan(Prop/Greystones/Old Wesley) Mark Nicholson(Hooker/Wicklow) Luke Thompson(Hooker/Wicklow/Lansdowne) Brian Deeny(Lock/Wexford/Clontarf) Shane Murphy(Scrumhalf/Skerries) Paddy McKenzie(Outhalf/Wicklow/Old Wesley) Mikey McGiff(Centre/Clontarf) Luis Faria(Centre/Wanderers/DUFC) Matthew Jungmann(Wing/Seapoint)
Ayewserious wrote: » Is Byron not in the sub academy?
iminterestd0 wrote: » Some Leinster Sub Academy players: Giuseppe Coyne(LH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) Thomas Clarkson(TH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) - u19 Charlie Ward(TH Prop/Clontarf/Tullow) - u19 Declan Adamson (Hooker/Clontarf/Fintans) John McKee((Hooker/OB/Campbell) - u19 Charles Ryan(Lock/UCD/Blackrock) Cian Prendergast(Lock/UCD/Newbridge) - u19 Brian Deeny(Lock/Clontarf/Wexford) - u19 Ronan Foley(Backrow/UCD/St. Marys) - u21 Ronan Watters(Backrow/St. Marys/St. Marys) Martin Moloney(Backrow/Lansdowne/Athy RFC) Mark Fleming(Backrow/UCD/Glenstal) Cormac Foley(Scrumhalf/UCD/St. Gerards) David Hawkshaw(Outhalf/Clontarf/Belvedere) Conor Kelly (Outhalf/Clontarf/Roscrea) David Ryan(Centre/UCD/St. Michaels) Liam Turner(Centre-Wing/DUFC/Blackrock) Peter Maher(Wing/Old Belvedere/Belvedere) - u21
iminterestd0 wrote: » On outhalf, they have plenty of talent coming through, obviously replacing Sexton will be near impossible but they are producing talented 10's Ross Byrne(23) Ciaran Frawley(20) Harry Byrne(19) David Hawkshaw(U20) Hooker on the otherhand is weak below Kelleher, they've brought in McKee from Ulster so I'm guessing they are hoping he could be the next player into academy, Barron in schools otherwise but he is several years away. But he could be a candidate to join the academy straight from school.
iminterestd0 wrote: » Is centre the weakest area in Leinster underage rugby?
DonVito wrote: » Surprised we haven't seen or heard anything more of the 'Rock wingers - McMahon and Donnelly. Also, I was expecting a lot from John Maher.
Tarf1234 wrote: » Updated/added more - Brian Deeny in Tarf and played at the weekend
iminterestd0 wrote: » iminterestd0 wrote: » Some Leinster Sub Academy players: Giuseppe Coyne(LH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) Thomas Clarkson(TH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) - u19 John McKee((Hooker/OB/Campbell) - u19 Declan Adamson (Hooker/Clontarf/Fintans) Charles Ryan(Lock/UCD/Blackrock) Cian Prendergast(Lock/UCD/Newbridge) - u19 Brian Deeny(Lock/Clontarf/Wexford) - u19 Ronan Foley(Backrow/UCD/St. Marys) - u21 Ronan Watters(Backrow/St. Marys/St. Marys) Martin Moloney(Backrow/Lansdowne/Athy RFC) Cormac Foley(Scrumhalf/UCD/St. Gerards) David Hawkshaw(Outhalf/Clontarf/Belvedere) Conor Kelly (Outhalf/Clontarf/Roscrea) Liam Turner(Centre-Wing/DUFC/Blackrock) Peter Maher(Wing/Old Belvedere/Belvedere) - u21
iminterestd0 wrote: » Some Leinster Sub Academy players: Giuseppe Coyne(LH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) Thomas Clarkson(TH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) - u19 John McKee((Hooker/OB/Campbell) - u19 Declan Adamson (Hooker/Clontarf/Fintans) Charles Ryan(Lock/UCD/Blackrock) Cian Prendergast(Lock/UCD/Newbridge) - u19 Brian Deeny(Lock/Clontarf/Wexford) - u19 Ronan Foley(Backrow/UCD/St. Marys) - u21 Ronan Watters(Backrow/St. Marys/St. Marys) Martin Moloney(Backrow/Lansdowne/Athy RFC) Cormac Foley(Scrumhalf/UCD/St. Gerards) David Hawkshaw(Outhalf/Clontarf/Belvedere) Conor Kelly (Outhalf/Clontarf/Roscrea) Liam Turner(Centre-Wing/DUFC/Blackrock) Peter Maher(Wing/Old Belvedere/Belvedere) - u21
iminterestd0 wrote: » Some Leinster Sub Academy players: Giuseppe Coyne(LH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) Thomas Clarkson(TH Prop/DUFC/Blackrock) - u19 John McKee((Hooker/OB/Campbell) - u19 Charles Ryan(Lock/UCD/Blackrock) Cian Prendergast(Lock/UCD/Newbridge) - u19 Brian Deeny(Lock/Clontarf/Wexford) - u19 Ronan Foley(Backrow/UCD/St. Marys) - u21 Ronan Watters(Backrow/St. Marys/St. Marys) Martin Moloney(Backrow/Lansdowne/Athy RFC) Cormac Foley(Scrumhalf/UCD/St. Gerards) David Hawkshaw(Outhalf/Clontarf/Belvedere) Liam Turner(Centre-Wing/DUFC/Blackrock) Peter Maher(Wing/Old Belvedere/Belvedere) - u21