whisky_galore wrote: » The dress is fine. You'd swear she had 'yellowed up' and wore a lampshade on her head with the level of outrage.
Swanner wrote: » Why not though. Where are the lines here ? I honestly don’t get the difference between wearing clothes from, and eating food from another culture. I genuinely have no idea why one is offensive and the other isn’t. Am I missing something obvious ?
Fourier wrote: » In my experience this is always an X-American thing, i.e. Chinese-Americans might complain, but people from China don't care (just as we don't care when they wear western clothes). However, as somebody mentioned above, how much of this is really going on in Ireland? I don't think I've ever encountered this in real life, outside of some young people in college, who still don't do it as much as Americans and practically stop on leaving college.
storker wrote: » Yes, the obvious thing is that this cultural misappropriation nonsense is complete and utter horsesh1t. The history of mankind is a history of sharing, learning, borrowing everything from technologies to food and cuisine, medicines and clothing and hairstyles. It's how we learn from each other and progress.The idiots who want to turn this concept on its head and weaponise it to use as a stick to beat people with are just malignant half-wits who are best ignored, in much the same way as you'd ignore the provocative slurrings of a drunk...and for similar reasons.
FTA69 wrote: » 2) This isn't America, I wish we weren't constantly discussing identity politics and culture wars on this board.
Wibbs wrote: » Just look at this happy Chinese couple enjoying their day out racist culturally appropriating bastards! >-< Or this apparently friendly waving leader of the Chinese nation, the western suit and tie appropriating cunt. I say we riot and break out the opium and gunships. There may be feasting on goo. Yet another reason I don't do Twatter. I'd be banned within 12 hours.
bodice ripper wrote: » I wore one of these to my debs back in y2k.
Defunkd wrote: » I'd understand his outrage if she was mocking chinks
Omackeral wrote: » Christ.
Defunkd wrote: » You outraged, paddy? Or just outraged on behalf of a billion others?
sabat wrote: » I know, you'd think that by 2018 people would have learned to say 'Chinamen.'
metaoblivia wrote: » This sort of crap pisses me off. If you go through the replies, plenty of Chinese people are saying she looks beautiful and they're not offended at all. And yet other people - usually Americans - are saying she doesn't understand the history of the dress and that she would need permission from several different Chinese people before being allowed to wear it. First of all, how do they know she doesn't understand the history of the dress? And as for asking for permission, that's completely ridiculous, although it looks like she had plenty of permission from actual Chinese people. And what, she's supposed to post a picture with a complete history of the dress along with the names of every Chinese person who gave her permission? It's laughable.
Outlaw Pete wrote: » I think cultural appropriation is disgraceful. As a people we endured oppression from the British Empire for hundreds of years, and survived famines, chunky knitwear was at times most likely all that stood between us and death. My great great great great great grand daddy died on a coffin ship. Not because he starved, or had scurvy, but because he left his aran jumper at home and yet would ya look at these fools.......... Survived? SURVIVED? Not many. And those are NOT traditional Aran jerseys. They are a modern distortion of the style... Not the same at all, at all. Bastardised. And they are not 'chunky"either!l :rolleyes: