antiskeptic wrote: » I don't say unnecessarily. I say inextricably linked. And it seems that balance provides the inextricable link. Lest you manage to show (not assert) balance not required for perfect choice.
King Mob wrote: » Lots of waffle there. No much point in trying to address it only to get reams of word salad back.
nozzferrahhtoo wrote: » Are you a[wa]re of any arguments, evidence, data or reasons presented by this Jesus or anyone else that such a place exists?
harrylittle wrote: » I saw a few vids on u tube of near death experiences about hell and it spooked the daylights out of me.
antiskeptic wrote: » Infinite power cannot make a square circle. Nor can it make a straight stacked deck.
kelly1 wrote: » To the OP, yes, I very much believe so. Jesus taught about it and St Faustina was taken there:http://www.divinemercysunday.com/vision.htmhttps://aleteia.org/2013/10/25/3-absolutely-terrifying-visions-of-hell/ But I think you're asking this in the wrong forum. Of course atheists are going to deny the existence of hell!
kelly1 wrote: » No I can't offer an evidence that hell exists. It's purely a matter of faith. Having said that, I believe in hell because Jesus said it exists and I think there is very good evidence that Jesus existed and that he rose from the dead and that his claim to be God is true.
kelly1 wrote: » Oldrnwisr, again, I appreciate all the effort you've gone to in writing such long and well thought-out posts. And I thank others posters who have contributed positively to the discussion. But it's time for me to thrown in the towel and admit defeat. To quality this, I mean I don't see how I can convince anyone of my claims and at the same time, I don't think I've had my claims destroyed. It's just a stalemate. I might just come back with something, but this is a marker of sorts. Thanks. [Edit, oldrnwisr, I intend to go back and read your post]
kelly1 wrote: » No I can't offer an evidence that hell exists. It's purely a matter of faith.
kelly1 wrote: » Having said that, I believe in hell because Jesus said it exists and I think there is very good evidence that Jesus existed and that he rose from the dead and that his claim to be God is true.
BrokenArrows wrote: » There are 7+ billion people on the planet and every day countless thousands experience death followed by resuscitation.
Hotblack Desiato wrote: » They weren't dead though.
harrylittle wrote: » There are lots of people on utub claiming hell is real. In a court case if you have two or more witnesses you would have enough sufficient evidence to win most cases . On utube you have hundreds of witnesses.
harrylittle wrote: » There are lots of people on utub claiming hell is real.
In a court case if you have two or more witnesses you would have enough sufficient evidence to win most cases . On utube you have hundreds of witnesses.
jk23 wrote: » Honestly when I was driving today I was just thinking to myself how mad you he whole situation of how people found themselves here, we have no 100% sound theory as to how or what created the universe or what the purpose of life is. When the lights go out when we die my own theory is we awake in another consciousness in a new body most probably in the future and the cycle continues... this may sound crazy but its the way I feel about it at the moment anyway!!
jk23 wrote: » we have no 100% sound theory as to how or what created the universe or what the purpose of life is.
jk23 wrote: » When the lights go out when we die my own theory is we awake in another consciousness in a new body most probably in the future and the cycle continues... this may sound crazy but its the way I feel about it at the moment anyway!!
Neon_Lights wrote: » Just to follow up on the Hell, Norway ReferencesHell[font=arial,sans-serif] is a post [/font][font=arial,sans-serif]town[/font][font=arial,sans-serif] with two post codes: 7517 for delivery route addresses and 7570 for post-office boxes. [/font][font=arial,sans-serif]Hell[/font][font=arial,sans-serif] currently has a grocery store, gas station, a fast food shop and a retirement home. [/font]
dr.fuzzenstein wrote: » Leaving aside if Hell is real or not, I have a real problem with the very basic premise of hell, eternal damnation. There are so many problems with this. What about people of a different, or no, faith? What makes them wrong? Will everyone in India and China go to hell for not saying their bedtime prayers? What gives christians the right and the arrogance to say "I Alone Am Right!"? The argument "Well, all the thousands of other religions are wrong" is not even an argument. That is straight down the toilet. I will not even entertain the thought. Isn't God about forgiveness? And Jesus even more so, the old hippie? For that reason alone I would reject eternal damnation as a concept out of hand. It is merely a concept thought out to control the weak minded and with that you have critical mass, so the rest will run along with the idea. It's the bogeyman of the church to scare people into submission. I can only refer to my sig and say that my made up hogwash is at least as credible as yours (not you atheists ).
antiskeptic wrote: » people of other faiths and none, have as much potential access to heaven or hell as a person of Christian religion.
antiskeptic wrote: » I'd warn however, that you need to accept the model of God presented (for the sake of discussion) rather than Dawkinsian one frequently put forward in A&A
Mark Hamill wrote: » Thus making christian religion unnecessary? Superfluous? Might it be better to remove the complication of religion (think of all the horrors done in religions name) and let humanity try to sort the rest of it's problems?
Even going by your model of god (for the sake of argument we are not supposing your/Dawkins version of God where the joy is the joy of submitting to a tyrant. We are supposing the joy a joy that would satisfy anyone.), the premise still doesn't make any sense. Eternal punishment is equally opposite to eternal joy, but that doesn't make them equal to each other.
From our point of view, the "choice" offered to us is clearly stacked in such a way to make it no choice (Would you rather €1000 or a kick to the groin).
Going by your argument, there are people from 1000s of years ago, suffering eternally in hell. And they will do so forever. What purpose does that serve? It's eternal, so they can't learn from their mistakes, they can't improve themselves. They don't get anything out of it. The people they've wronged are long since in heaven and they don't get anything out of it. God can't get anything out of it. So what is it's purpose?
antiskeptic wrote: » For the purposes of discussion we are supposing sin attractive and goodness attractive. They ARE both attractive (even if the attraction appeals to different aspects of us). Otherwise we wouldn't partake of both.
antiskeptic wrote: » [those in hell] obtain the constitution they plumped for: to consist of everything they are already that isn't made in the image and likeness of God. I'm inclined to suppose that the restraining effect of a person being made with God characteristics once shorn from them, is what renderstwhile the person utterly ugly. The horror is already with in us, just tempered for now. Similar, but opposite to the heavenbound, who will be stripped of everything which isn't in the image and likeness of God. A case of thy will be done for all.
Gregk961 wrote: » If you have two other witnesses saying the opposite that's enough to lose most cases. You have hundreds of people on youtube claiming hell isn't real. Even by your own mind boggling logic this argument is rubbish.
harrylittle wrote: » To be a credible witness they must have died for a few minutes. I have not come across such people on utube but if can you give me some names so that I can check there vids out.
Mark Hamill wrote: » But sin is the act of making the choice. The thing you are choosing is still heaven or hell.
Really, my analogy just changes to "Would you rather €1000 tomorrow, or €1 today and a kick to the groin tomorrow?" It's still stacked.
If you understand and accept the question as valid then there is only one reasonable choice. If you choose hell then you don't understand the question in which case your choice is meaningless. If you reject the validity of the question then you either get hell anyway (classical christian interpretation) or you are judged based on your other actions regardless. Either of which amounts to means no choice. On every level, this amounts to no meaningful choice being made.
So, in order to avoid the problem of a nonsensical eternal punishment that exists in standard christian interpretations, you have created a hell that is, to put it simply, existence without god or his aspects? And that the people there knowingly choose that?
If they choose that, then how is hell a bad thing?
Everyone seemingly wants to be there. They aren't hurting anyone in heaven. The people in heaven want to be there and they don't effect anyone in hell. Everyone gets what they want, apparently.
qwadb78ejp260i wrote: » Yes, hell is real, and a distinct possibility for a great number of people, unless they repent sincerely. Your soul is eternal. An unrepentant sinner cannot enter into the joys of Heaven. An unrepentant sinner goes to hell, for all eternity.