juice1304 wrote: » Well maybe everyone else who graces gods earth is not as perfect and need the test so as not to injure themselves, others or the animal they are shooting. I have had close calls with "experienced hunters" several times, someone shooting right past my head while stalking because they saw a deer i was ten paces ahead of them.., ive seen people accidentally discharge not unloading climbing over a fence etc.. Many people are ignorant to what caliber they should be actually using instead of being sold whatever the local dealer has who himself may not have a clue.. The same goes for the type of ammunition people should use, or shot placement. Also i am Irish and hunt in Ireland. Like i have already said "If" it were run properly and was "free" it would be nothing but good. So please hold of on burning me at the stake. And i don't see the great surprise to this in all fairness considering it is the same throughout Europe and is even mandatory in the land of the gun across the atlantic.
Best Bitter wrote: » . I am sure that erveryone who passes the exam will have learned something new!
Best Bitter wrote: » Passing an exam is a prerequisite to being allowed to hunt in many European countries. Not like it is in Ireland, where anyone with a rifle can hunt on privately owned land after getting a licence.
Obviously the issue for most people isn`t the "enormous financial impact" of maybe € 300 which sitting the exam might cost. Instead, it is a matter of wanting to continue doing something the way its previously been done.
So everyone, let`s not complain and instead sit down and start stuying for the exam. I am sure that erveryone who passes the exam will have learned something new!
juice1304 wrote: » I found the standard of shooting to be quite shocking considering the majority of the shots were supported and all within 100m some of them were shooting three times..
juice1304 wrote: » Well maybe everyone else who graces gods earth is not as perfect and need the test so as not to injure themselves, others or the animal they are shooting. I have had close calls with "experienced hunters" several times, someone shooting right past my head while stalking because they saw a deer i was ten paces ahead of them.., ive seen people accidentally discharge not unloading climbing over a fence etc..
Many people are ignorant to what caliber they should be actually using instead of being sold whatever the local dealer has who himself may not have a clue.. The same goes for the type of ammunition people should use, or shot placement.
And i don't see the great surprise to this in all fairness considering it is the same throughout Europe and is even mandatory in the land of the gun across the atlantic.
juice1304 wrote: » Also find yourselves lucky in Germany it is €3000 to do the hunting licence with a 75% fail rate the majority of the courses are run over a six month period too and unless you own land yourself it is crazy money like 700 a hecter where i am at the moment, along with the fact that the hunter pays the farmer for any damage to the land, crops, equipment or fencing etc.. that the animals do throughout the year. A friend of mine had to pay out €20,000 last year from damage done by the wild boar.
cavan shooter wrote: » could be running the courses for all you know...:rolleyes:
dto001 wrote: » https://www.change.org/p/heather-stop-the-hcap-becoming-mandatory-for-deer-hunting
juice1304 wrote: » dto001 wrote: » You are saying that knowing about diseases is not about field craft that i will have to disagree with you on. I'm not saying I know it all at all but as you are saying everything that is run in Ireland....... and if this gets through it will end up a money maker for these organisations and the time to stop is now not in a couple of years when everyone say ''o s*@te we shouldn't have let that happen then and my kids are saying why do I have to pay for all this when you didn't!!! If the world was a perfect place all these "good ideas" would be workable but unfortunately common sense does not prevail anymore but greed does!!! You are saying that knowing about diseases is not about field craft that i will have to disagree with you on. I'm not saying I know it all at all but as you are saying everything that is run in Ireland....... and if this gets through it will end up a money maker for these organisations and the time to stop is now not in a couple of years when everyone say ''o s*@te we shouldn't have let that happen then and my kids are saying why do I have to pay for all this when you didn't!!! If the world was a perfect place all these "good ideas" would be workable but unfortunately common sense does not prevail anymore but greed does!!! Im saying it is not like in England or Germany where you have to do a hunting apprenticeship and have to go out with other hunters who actually teach you everything in the field. Which would take away your chance to teach your young lad. Where as in ireland you answer a list of questions that can be learned off in ten minutes.
dto001 wrote: » You are saying that knowing about diseases is not about field craft that i will have to disagree with you on. I'm not saying I know it all at all but as you are saying everything that is run in Ireland....... and if this gets through it will end up a money maker for these organisations and the time to stop is now not in a couple of years when everyone say ''o s*@te we shouldn't have let that happen then and my kids are saying why do I have to pay for all this when you didn't!!! If the world was a perfect place all these "good ideas" would be workable but unfortunately common sense does not prevail anymore but greed does!!! You are saying that knowing about diseases is not about field craft that i will have to disagree with you on. I'm not saying I know it all at all but as you are saying everything that is run in Ireland....... and if this gets through it will end up a money maker for these organisations and the time to stop is now not in a couple of years when everyone say ''o s*@te we shouldn't have let that happen then and my kids are saying why do I have to pay for all this when you didn't!!! If the world was a perfect place all these "good ideas" would be workable but unfortunately common sense does not prevail anymore but greed does!!!
grassroot1 wrote: » Yes but you are in Germany and we are in Ireland. I shoot by the good graces of my neighbours I dont need a test or an exam. There are plenty of good books on stalking and deer management. I can zero my rifle at anytime I dont need anyone to hold my hand. What exactly will a made up course do for me or my sport?
juice1304 wrote: » The course has nothing to do with fieldcraft it is a shooting exam and a test to see if you can identify potential diseases and where to shoot the deer along with basic law in relation to hunting deer. I have nothing to do with any of these organizations nor would i as i have seen how they are all run like everything in Ireland it is usually a bunch of idiots looking for control. However, i will say in a sense the test is not a bad idea. I already did the HCAP a few years ago simply to have it. And while at the tests there were many many "expert deer stalkers" there who of course knew it all up until the point they had to tick the few multiple choice question and shoot the few shots. I found the standard of shooting to be quite shocking considering the majority of the shots were supported and all within 100m some of them were shooting three times.. I think how it will end up with one of these groups running **** courses is a shame, but if it were done right and not at a crazy cost the idea is good. If it was done how it is done in America it would be great. Also find yourselves lucky in Germany it is €3000 to do the hunting licence with a 75% fail rate the majority of the courses are run over a six month period too and unless you own land yourself it is crazy money like 700 a hecter where i am at the moment, along with the fact that the hunter pays the farmer for any damage to the land, crops, equipment or fencing etc.. that the animals do throughout the year. A friend of mine had to pay out €20,000 last year from damage done by the wild boar.
Best Bitter wrote: » The comments posted on this forum,"MANDATORY CERTIFICATION FOR DEER HUNTERS" really are surprising. I welcome this decision, it was long overdue!!! Passing an exam is a prerequisite to being allowed to hunt in many European countries. Not like it is in Ireland, where anyone with a rifle can hunt on privately owned land after getting a licence. Obviously the issue for most people isn`t the "enormous financial impact" of maybe € 300 which sitting the exam might cost. Instead, it is a matter of wanting to continue doing something the way its previously been done. So everyone, let`s not complain and instead sit down and start stuying for the exam. I am sure that erveryone who passes the exam will have learned something new!
gunny123 wrote: » Do the deer poachers have to pass this exam too ?
cavan shooter wrote: » I got this as an e mail from Countryside alliance, so dont think its a rumour anymore:http://countrysideallianceireland.org/ie/shooting/mandatory-certification-for-deer-hunters-from-1st-january-2018?utm_campaign=197068_MANDATORY%20CERTIFICATION%20FOR%20DEER%20HUNTERS%20FROM%201st%20JANUARY%202018&utm_medium=dotmailer&utm_source=Countryside%20Alliance&dm_i=44G9,4824,1MJ8JH,GGJ8,1
meathstevie wrote: » A If we all need to pass an exam I suggest that the minister publishes an invitation to tender with the conditions attached very swiftly. If this is supposed to start in eight weeks it'll have to be done at the speed of light. Since this will involve amounts of money far in excess of the threshold to not go public it's actually already impossible to start this from January 2018. .