nav[aria-label="Primary Navigation"] { padding: 0; & ul { list-style: none; width: 100%; display: flex; flex-direction: row; justify-content: start; align-items: start; gap: 30px; padding: 0; & li { margin: 0; } & ul li { list-style: none; } } }

Child Item

Mayo GAA Discussion - Part 3

DoctaDee

Welcome to the Mayo GAA discussion thread - Chapter 3, yer trotting them out quicker than a Mills & Boon Romance !.

This is one of the most active forums on Boards.ie. As a result, discussion can get quite heated. But there are certain things posters must realise are simply not OK to post:

- Personal abuse

- Rumours about players'/managers'/anyone's personal lives.

- Trolling.

- Accusations of trolling. Report a post if you suspect it to be trolling.

Find more posts tagged with

Quick Links

Comments

km79

Is it Sunday yet

franklyon

I think Keith will come good, as for Ger, who else do you put in that position?

km79

Apparently Dublin joe is Reffing

seligehgit

Blackjack wrote: »

Kirby is still there, Nally or Boland in the forwards in place of Diarmuid if that's how it plays out.

Not sure if I'd start Danny Kirby,Shane Nally is more a half back or can play the middle.

It has been mentioned that Fergal Boland has been dropped from the panel?

Probably Donie Vaughan or Stephen Coen for me if Donie isn't an option for full back.

NabyLadistheman

Saturday was the first day since last years All-Ireland that Keegan seemed to be fully back to speed. Was moving across the ground much better

km79

Suarezistheman wrote: »

Saturday was the first day since last years All-Ireland that Keegan seemed to be fully back to speed. Was moving across the ground much better

That's true of a lot of them
The qualifiers have been a massive help to the likes of o shea and maybe now Boyle in that regard
I had hoped it would bring caff on too
I REALLY wanted him to come back to form of 2\3 years ago but I don't think it's to be

NabyLadistheman

km79 wrote: »

That's true of a lot of them
The qualifiers have been a massive help to the likes of o shea and maybe now Boyle in that regard
I had hoped it would bring caff on too
I REALLY wanted him to come back to form of 2\3 years ago but I don't think it's to be

Caff was never the quickest & rarely played his man from the front. He was an exceptional defender though & once his man got the ball he would either dispossess him or hold them up until support came. Unfortunately since his return from injury he does not have the legs to get 'touch tight' as could be seen by DOC's points in the first half & Colm O'Neill's turn in extra-time. It's sad to see an exceptional defender come to the end.

My main problem with this whole debacle is Rochford.

Why has no long-term option for FB being looked at throughout the course of the league? He is bringing on Crowe who got no game-time whatsoever. We went the full season last year without a recognised fb so hardly a new development. Nally who made an impact has been cast to the side & has hardly got a minute in the championship.

Why is Colm Boyle repeatedly being taken off? He has not finished many games over the course of the last 2 seasons. Also Rochford continuing to use Higgins/Boyle as sweeper is infuriating. Neither can play this position

seligehgit

Suarezistheman wrote: »

Caff was never the quickest & rarely played his man from the front. He was an exceptional defender though & once his man got the ball he would either dispossess him or hold them up until support came. Unfortunately since his return from injury he does not have the legs to get 'touch tight' as could be seen by DOC's points in the first half & Colm O'Neill's turn in extra-time. It's sad to see an exceptional defender come to the end.

My main problem with this whole debacle is Rochford.

Why has no long-term option for FB being looked at throughout the course of the league? He is bringing on Crowe who got no game-time whatsoever. We went the full season last year without a recognised fb so hardly a new development. Nally who made an impact has been cast to the side & has hardly got a minute in the championship.

Why is Colm Boyle repeatedly being taken off? He has not finished many games over the course of the last 2 seasons. Also Rochford continuing to use Higgins/Boyle as sweeper is infuriating. Neither can play this position

Great post.

seligehgit

Suarezistheman wrote: »

Caff was never the quickest & rarely played his man from the front. He was an exceptional defender though & once his man got the ball he would either dispossess him or hold them up until support came. Unfortunately since his return from injury he does not have the legs to get 'touch tight' as could be seen by DOC's points in the first half & Colm O'Neill's turn in extra-time. It's sad to see an exceptional defender come to the end.

My main problem with this whole debacle is Rochford.

Why has no long-term option for FB being looked at throughout the course of the league? He is bringing on Crowe who got no game-time whatsoever. We went the full season last year without a recognised fb so hardly a new development. Nally who made an impact has been cast to the side & has hardly got a minute in the championship.

Why is Colm Boyle repeatedly being taken off? He has not finished many games over the course of the last 2 seasons. Also Rochford continuing to use Higgins/Boyle as sweeper is infuriating. Neither can play this position

I think Boyler can give his all for 55 to 60 minutes and then he's simply nothing left in the tank.

Probably utilise that GPS device to track how much ground he's capable of covering.

Stoner

km79 wrote:

Apparently Dublin joe is Reffing

I love him

Shurimgreat

seligehgit wrote: »

I think Boyler can give his all for 55 to 60 minutes and then he's simply nothing left in the tank.

Probably utilise that GPS device to track how much ground he's capable of covering.

The GPS device thing is another infuriating thing about Mayo football.

Parsons was taken off against Dublin in 2015 because of it, or so they say. Dublin cleaned up in midfield after that. We didn't have one proper midfielder for the last 10 minutes. All we needed was a guy to catch a ball, nothing more.

I'd say the same happened with Andy Moran against Galway this year. Scores a great point when one was badly needed and then hauled to the sideline straight after. Probably based on the fact he tired in other games at that stage.

Any half decent reader of gaelic football can tell from looking at a player if they are going well or not. One day a player could tire early, another they could be flying in the last ten minutes. The fact the management are using GPS devices to make substitution decisions is worrying. Its failed them in several big games already.

blinding

There seemed to be management for the sake of management the last day .......

Too many substitutions and then Keegan goes Minor Loco.......

A simple plan with some simple alterations may be the way to go.....

naughto

Dublin Joe the ref on Sunday

Stoner

Shurimgreat wrote:

Parsons was taken off against Dublin in 2015 because of it, or so they say. Dublin cleaned up in midfield after that. We didn't have one proper midfielder for the last 10 minutes. All we needed was a guy to catch a ball, nothing more.

Did he have a broken hand then, or was that a different year.

[Deleted User]

naughto wrote: »

Dublin Joe the ref on Sunday

Joe McQuillan has never been a problem in my eyes.

He has only got the nickname "Dublin" Joe because of the perception that he gave Dublin a soft free that Cluxton converted to win the 2011, and that comes mainly from Kerry folk.

But Kerry blew a 5 point (I think) lead late in that game so they could really do with looking somewhere other than the ref to find out why they did not win.

seligehgit

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

Joe McQuillan has never been a problem in my eyes.

He has only got the nickname "Dublin" Joe because of the perception that he gave Dublin a soft free that Cluxton converted to win the 2011, and that comes mainly from Kerry folk.

But Kerry blew a 5 point (I think) lead late in that game so they could really do with looking somewhere other than the ref to find out why they did not win.

No problem with McQuillan either,did a decent job in the 2013 final.One of the better referees.I think it was more so the rumoured training sessions he took with the Dublin team that gave him his nickname.

seligehgit

Stoner wrote: »

Did he have a broken hand then, or was that a different year.

Broken finger I believe he played with,that was the 2015 replay.Ta an ceart agat.

Seamie had received his black card after his retaliatory push on Cooper and Barry Moran was out on his feet.

seligehgit

Latest Mayo News Football Podcast

Rebels Reeling,Rossies Ready.

http://themayonews.podomatic.com/enclosure/2017-07-24T08_25_41-07_00.mp3

Audioslaven

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

I’m struggling to have that sort of optimism about this team.

Over the years I have always called BS on the notion that a team is struggling to win games they should be winning will in some way flick a switch in early August and all is be well again.

This team are just that, they are struggling to win games they should be winning without too much fuss.

What pisses me off must about all this is that right now Kerry are not as good as what they were and not as good as they can potentially be (based on minor success).

And the same goes for Dublin based on last season and the league.

But low and behold when the chance to get both of them is there and win it all Mayo too are struggling.

I think Mayo will get past Roscommon, I think Galway were totally ill prepared for them, Mayo will be the opposite, that’s just the way Mayo are.

But once again I can see Mayo losing to a Kerry team that in the past few years they should be beating.

I hope I am wrong but if they are to beat Kerry they really need to sort out the backs as was highlighted on the Sunday Game last night.

High balls into Cafferkey will unfortunately kill them.

if you look at last year, we are definitely playing better than this time last year. Our performances were very flat last year. AOS is a different player this year and we seem to be playing better up front as well. We have more options from the bench although this didn't look like it against Cork.

Our issues lay around our defence and we are a little more open this year which is the worry but we had this to a degree last year as well and we gradually got better with Mcloughlin in as a sweeper.

You can lay the same with Kerry if you run at them. Cork did this to them as well. I think we will know a lot more come sunday in regards to Kerry and ourselves. Dublin are not a certain to come through the other side as well. Tyrone have definitely improved.

it will be interesting to see what Rochford decides around the full back and I really hope we see an improvement with either a change or playing a more defensive structure from our half backs/half forwards as it would be heart breaking to see some of these guys leave the intercounty scene without an All Ireland.

[Deleted User]

Audioslaven wrote: »

if you look at last year, we are definitely playing better than this time last year. Our performances were very flat last year. AOS is a different player this year and we seem to be playing better up front as well. We have more options from the bench although this didn't look like it against Cork.

Our issues lay around our defence and we are a little more open this year which is the worry but we had this to a degree last year as well and we gradually got better with Mcloughlin in as a sweeper.

You can lay the same with Kerry if you run at them. Cork did this to them as well. I think we will know a lot more come sunday in regards to Kerry and ourselves. Dublin are not a certain to come through the other side as well. Tyrone have definitely improved.

it will be interesting to see what Rochford decides around the full back and I really hope we see an improvement with either a change or playing a more defensive structure from our half backs/half forwards as it would be heart breaking to see some of these guys leave the intercounty scene without an All Ireland.

But the talk of this thread all through the qualifiers last year was "what are they doing with McLaughlin, this sweeper system is not working" until people actually realized it was working, and that they were not being opened up anything like they had been in previous years.

But this year that seems to have been abandoned and once again they are fragile at the back.

I hope Rochford has some master plan because it seems like a retrograde move.

I know Kerry are vulnerable when you run at them, but that's not what would worry me if Mayo were to meet them, it would be them opening Mayo up that I would be worried about.

Stoner

Fr Tod Umptious wrote:

But the talk of this thread all through the qualifiers last year was "what are they doing with McLaughlin, this sweeper system is not working" until people actually realized it was working, and that they were not being opened up anything like they had been in previous years.

That's not really fair, McLaughlin grew into the role, initially he had some poor games there but for the last few games he'd won people over with better performances. It wasn't a case that he was performing there but people just couldn't see it. There was Sunday Game time and write-ups dedicated to his early performances.

MaroonAndGreen

With Aidan O'Shea, both O'Connors and Andy Moran hitting form then the likes of Kerry have plenty to worry about from us too IMO.

yop

We worry about Roscommon first. What are peoples thoughts on the game?

If Roscommon get sucked in by the hype of winning (deservedly) the Connacht title then they could return to form. Though if they bomb us like they did Galway then you'd expect our FB line to suffer.
I can see this going to ET again, a shoot out of a game. Ref will need to be very strong in this game.
The 50k attendance could rattle the inexperienced Rossies but youth sometimes ignores that.

km79

Parsons injury is a. Hamstring
That's not good

blinding

km79 wrote: »

Parsons injury is a. Hamstring
That's not good

I don't think he was a 100 % the last day so is almost certainly out . We need all of our midfielders and maybe stopgap full backs so this is a worry....

Shurimgreat

I'm not McLoughlins biggest fan as he can be very inconsistent, but he's more useful in the forwards than in defence.

As someone said, it takes time to grow into a sweeper role and expecting someone like Higgins to get it right the first game is a bit much. Hopefully he learns from his mistakes.

Oldtree

yop wrote: »

We worry about Roscommon first. What are peoples thoughts on the game?

If Roscommon get sucked in by the hype of winning (deservedly) the Connacht title then they could return to form. Though if they bomb us like they did Galway then you'd expect our FB line to suffer.
I can see this going to ET again, a shoot out of a game. Ref will need to be very strong in this game.
The 50k attendance could rattle the inexperienced Rossies but youth sometimes ignores that.

I think we have been planning amd practicing all year for a fb problem in a game. The extra man being held back where necessary during a lot of matches to reinforce the rear is well tested now. We will see a much more defensive game with Aos and sos ploughing up the center and Donal

doing a lot of diagonal running.

The ball handling and low kick passing has improved greatly so probably a lot more slower buildups to retain posession and frustrate the opposition will feature.

I think patience will be a huge advantage for us in this one.

I'm so excited I can't think so who knows really

Shurimgreat

MaroonAndGreen wrote: »

With Aidan O'Shea, both O'Connors and Andy Moran hitting form then the likes of Kerry have plenty to worry about from us too IMO.

Meh...a few high balls from Kerry into our full back line and the game will be as good as over. Any perceived weak link and Kerry will target it repeatedly, that's what they did in 2014.

Kerry_2008

seligehgit wrote: »

No problem with McQuillan either,did a decent job in the 2013 final.One of the better referees.I think it was more so the rumoured training sessions he took with the Dublin team that gave him his nickname.

Its a bit of both. He was the 'in house' ref for the dublin training games. In the 2011 final in the last 10 mins he missed a double hop in front of the Dublin goals that would have given Kerry a handy free. And he only gave ger brennan a yellow for a blatant red that left declan o sullivan concussed. But, your right i think it was a 5 point lead we threw away in the last few minutes so cant blame anyone really.

He's one of the better refs out there. Far better than David Coldrick I think. I thought the ref in ye're game on saturday did a decent enough job as well.

km79

Donie is now likely to start around the middle id say
Stay of execution for Caff perhaps..........would love to see him out in a brilliant performance if this is the case
I just don't know if it's in him though