ciarriaithuaidh wrote: » The hard-on for Mikey Geaney persists, as does my belief that he isn't good enough.
toodleytoo wrote: » Any idea what James O' Donoghue's injury was?
keane2097 wrote: Looked like he twisted his ankle.
homerjay2005 wrote: » it really is bizzare. he wouldnt make a good senior club side in alot of counties. the man is stealing an intercountry career, should be nowhere the panel.
Prop Joe wrote: » Bonkers views on M.Geaney !! He would without a shadow be on my Kerry panel every day of the week,He has a uniqueness that no one else on the squad has. He brings a level of aggression that no-one else can bring. He is in the top 3/4 in the group for breaking balls Geaney brings hard running and a massive work rate that is only surpassed by Donnacha & Paul Murphy IMO. When we go to battle Geaney will be a valuable solider in our ranks
homerjay2005 wrote: » uniqueness in the sense, that nobody wastes as much ball as him. the fact that in 2014, Mayo left him on his own on the pitch and didnt bother marking him, says enough. its why them going down to 14 men made no difference and they actually got on top then.
windy shepard henderson wrote: » He can brake a tackle but his ball distribution is poor . He kicks a lot of aimless ball hoping to find a man rather then pick a pass It's something club players do to get themselves out of trouble I regard Paul as top class in almost every department as a forward . And the way Connor took his goal today he looks like a good prospect I keep thinking back to Clare v Kerry on 2014 in cusack park where a very young Jamie Malone gave him the run around i didnt expect to see Michael still in team 3 year's later
Prop Joe wrote: » I'm sure we can go back to alot of Kerry players championship debuts and say the same but he might prosper yet,Some guys are slow burners Darran O Sullivan was on the panel 4 years before he started a championship game,But i agree with you he must improve his decision making to make himself indispensable to this Kerry team
ciarriaithuaidh wrote: » Listen, Mikey Geaney is 28 this year..Darran (to use your own example) came off the bench in the 2005 final when he was 18. Over the next few years (in one of the best teams of that or any other era) he established himself to the point where he became a winning captain at the age of 23 and an Allstar and POTY nominee at 25. He’s been inconsistent for several reasons, injuries mainly but still..no comparison there. As to some of the other stuff you’ve posted on this page alone regarding him, all I can say is we must be watching different games. He brings nothing to any high-quality game in my view. His kicking and passing aren’t good enough and as someone mentioned, the likes of Mayo paid the “compliment” of not bothering to mark him in the 2014 semi final! You seem to think this backfired..but in actual fact, Mayo took a firm grip on that game despite being a man down (a half back no less!) and Geaney was taken off after 42 minutes. I have no ill will towards the fella on a personal level, not from a rival club or anything like that. Just calling it as I see it. He’s had multiple chances over 4/5 seasons and I’ve never seen him show anything remotely near the quality needed. You (and Fitzmaurice unfortunately) clearly have some sort of bias towards him for whatever reason. As I’ve stated multiple times, it’s baffling and one of a few strange calls there have been over recent seasons.
homerjay2005 wrote: » Aidan O Mahoney has retired one of my favourites players of the last 20 years, he has had an incredible career.
dobman88 wrote: » just an absolute horse that never gave up or knew when he was beaten. .
thesultan wrote: » Never the same player after the dive against Cork.
DDC1990 wrote: » Kerry have lost a great servant. Will never forget probably his finest moment- running himself into the ground in the Gaelic Grounds in 2014, to the point where he had to be carried off with both legs cramped up. Summed his whole career up. He gave everything for the cause- club and county.
ciarriaithuaidh wrote: » Spot on DDC, him being carried off that day in the Gaelic grounds utterly spent will be a lasting memory. Such a warrior. It's funny, was talking to a few people about him in last few days. He was unexceptional as a minor, didn't start on a fairly average team in 98. Made u21 team only in his last year, but by then was playing Sigerson with CIT and pushing on a bit. Worth remembering though that he was 24 before he made ANY appearance for Kerry, which when you look back on what he achieved afterwards, is fairly remarkable! It reminds me that 1)Jack O'Connor deserves massive credit for the revival from 2004 on and 2)Never write a guy off until he is given a chance to perform. Anyway, it's over to the next generation now. Word of Gooch and Donaghy continuing is no surprise but Donaghy especially won't be a guaranteed starter. They are huge influences on younger players though, so from that perspective alone it's good to have them around.