[RobertFoster]

I bought a replacement charger for an old laptop on eBay last Monday. The listing had the correct laptop name and model number, the size of the connector, voltage etc. However, when it arrived yesterday, I noticed both the connector size and voltage was incorrect (5mm/19V instead of 7.4mm/19.5V). I emailed the seller outlining the error, and they replied with the following:

Thanks for your useful message,
Sorry for late reply,we're afraid that our supplier may pack wrong item,could you kindly to keep the item and pay for 2GBP?then we send right item to you,or give better advice,forwards,thanks,
Warm regards,

The item came from the UK, but the seller is listed as being in Hong Kong.

This is the second time I've received an incorrect item from a seller on eBay. The first time (over 5 years ago now) the seller, a guy in the US, sent me the correct item as soon as I drew his attention to the error. He did this out of his own pocket, didn't ask for the incorrect item back, didn't ask for extra postage.

I'm concerned because the seller is requesting more money. I know it's only £2, but is there anything further that could go wrong if I agree to pay it? Any PayPal scam I may not know about? The fact that they state I don't have to post back the original (to HK I assume) makes me trust them somewhat as £2 is cheaper than whatever registered post would be, but I'm still wary. Saying "or give better advice" seems strange, but it could just be a language barrier thing.

What's recommended? Contest the £2 as it's the seller/suppliers fault, pay the £2 and hope that's the end of it, or something else?

[Zab]

Check up on ebay's and paypal's policies on this issue. As far as I'm aware ebay are a little iffy on who pays the return postage so your best bet may be to pay the £2 as you could get stiffed for return postage. On the other hand you could email them back with the suggestion that you not pay the £2 and they forward the correct item anyway. Other than conversing with the seller you can open a case with ebay. I'm not aware of any scam that would cost you more than the £2 if you choose to go that route.

[BengaLover]

The buyer must cover the cost of return postage.
However, if the seller values their reputation and feedback, then they might reimburse you.
If you open a pp dispute, then you will be required by paypal to send the item back to the seller, and if the seller is a dropshipper, then you will have to cover overseas postage cost.
Plus, you might never see the item or your replacement/refund if you dont send via registered mail..

[Max Power1]

Originally Posted by Zab

Check up on ebay's and paypal's policies on this issue. As far as I'm aware ebay are a little iffy on who pays the return postage so your best bet may be to pay the £2 as you could get stiffed for return postage. On the other hand you could email them back with the suggestion that you not pay the £2 and they forward the correct item anyway. Other than conversing with the seller you can open a case with ebay. I'm not aware of any scam that would cost you more than the £2 if you choose to go that route.

Theres no "iffy" about it, the buyer always pays for return shipment.

[Zab]

Originally Posted by Max Power1

Theres no "iffy" about it, the buyer always pays for return shipment.

Fair enough. Easy decision to pay the £2 then.

[BengaLover]

Normal post £2 yes, but he can always claim he never got the returned item...and you wont be able to prove it, and will lose the claim..