Are there any real magicians out there or is it all just trickery

MooseJam · 01-05-2008 05:26PM #1

So are there any real magicians with real magic powers or are all the illusions on telly just trickery ?

Gillo · 01-05-2008 06:26PM

I think most people will say it's trickery, but thats what makes a good magician the ability to make it look real.

Sir Digby Chicken Caesar · 01-05-2008 06:33PM

*bangs head off wall*

01-05-2008 09:35PM

* Joins Mordeth

orestes · 01-05-2008 09:41PM

Mordeth wrote: »

*bangs head off wall*

King Mob wrote: »

* Joins Mordeth

Guys, you're going about this all wrong

*bangs op's head off wall*

El_mariachi · 01-05-2008 09:53PM

orestes wrote: »

*bangs op's head off wall*

*Joins you*

Gillo · 01-05-2008 10:44PM

Mordeth wrote: »

*bangs head off wall*

Says magic word

Giant Rabbit appears

Who needs a wand anyway?

6th · 01-05-2008 11:12PM

Lads, address what he has said rather than just take pop shots.

??? · 01-05-2008 11:25PM

No one has ever successfully demonstrated magic, psychic, voodoo or any other 'power' in a controlled scientific test.

Every magic trick ever presented (yes even Jesus's) can be repeated and explained using trickery. To paraphrase The Amazing Randi: if Uri Geller is bending spoons with his mind he's doing it the hard way.

There. That is as fair an answer as any... And now... <joins in head banging>

Popinjay · 02-05-2008 01:53PM

??? wrote: »

No one has ever successfully demonstrated magic, psychic, voodoo or any other 'power' in a controlled scientific test.

Every magic trick ever presented (yes even Jesus's) can be repeated and explained using trickery. To paraphrase The Amazing Randi: if Uri Geller is bending spoons with his mind he's doing it the hard way.

What he said. Well put.

rossie1977 · 03-05-2008 12:44AM

yes james randi set up the The One Million Dollar Paranormal Challenge in the 1960s to find out if anyone on planet earth had a gift of magical powers or other such claims, so far nobody has even passed the preliminary test which really tells you everything you need to know........... nobody can perform real magic, nobody can foretell the future, nobody can talk to the dead or bend spoons with their mind etc

http://www.randi.org/joom/content/view/38/31/

Fremen · 03-05-2008 12:58AM

*Wham* *Wham* *Wham*

seraphimvc · 04-05-2008 07:08PM

i feel like my dreams destroyed by this thread...:(

would banging my head makes me feel better?*sigh*

MooseJam · 04-05-2008 07:12PM

rossie1977 wrote: »

yes james randi set up the The One Million Dollar Paranormal Challenge in the 1960s to find out if anyone on planet earth had a gift of magical powers or other such claims, so far nobody has even passed the preliminary test which really tells you everything you need to know........... nobody can perform real magic, nobody can foretell the future, nobody can talk to the dead or bend spoons with their mind etc

http://www.randi.org/joom/content/view/38/31/

how does uri geller bend spoons ?

??? · 04-05-2008 07:17PM

Permission to post a reveal to put this poor disalusioned soul out of his misery?

Nevyn · 04-05-2008 07:19PM

MooseJam wrote: »

So are there any real magicians with real magic powers or are all the illusions on telly just trickery ?

Dude wrong forum.

Gordon · 04-05-2008 07:42PM

Define magic.

04-05-2008 07:49PM

??? wrote: »

Permission to post a reveal to put this poor disalusioned soul out of his misery?

I was under the illiusion that because Geller was using the trick to defraud people that left the trick as fair game to be revealed.

And when MooseJam said real magic (as in magick with a k) I assumed he meant a paranormal ability that is manifested by the will of a person.
This is of course unless he was refering to Harry Potter magicians.

MooseJam · 04-05-2008 08:21PM

??? was kind enough to send me videos explaining it, thanks

6th · 04-05-2008 10:09PM

??? wrote: »

Permission to post a reveal to put this poor disalusioned soul out of his misery?

Permission denied.

04-05-2008 10:50PM

Sabotage wrote: »

Permission denied.

But Geller uses magic for evil.
Should we not put a stop to his nefarious schemes?
(It's not even a very good trick.)

6th · 05-05-2008 09:55AM

We've already had the thread about posting reveals.

05-05-2008 11:08AM

But does Gellers stuff actually count as magic (our kind not the kind with a k).
He's claiming that its not trickery but paranormal powers even though he's pretty obviously faking.
Is he covered by the magicians code?

Popinjay · 06-05-2008 08:38AM

King Mob wrote: »

But does Gellers stuff actually count as magic (our kind not the kind with a k).
He's claiming that its not trickery but paranormal powers even though he's pretty obviously faking.
Is he covered by the magicians code?

If any other magicians use spoon-bending in their acts (and some do), then they're covered by the magicians' code. Never mind that weird little Geller creep. I'd agree that it's a fairly common knowledge effect anyway but that still doesn't mean we won't upset some poor chappy who earns his bread in an honest manner with this effect.

EDIT: For the record I don't use it but what if poor Sabotage Jr. reads the forum and finds out how Daddy did the magic with the spoon today. Tears all round.

06-05-2008 02:40PM

Popinjay wrote: »

If any other magicians use spoon-bending in their acts (and some do), then they're covered by the magicians' code. Never mind that weird little Geller creep. I'd agree that it's a fairly common knowledge effect anyway but that still doesn't mean we won't upset some poor chappy who earns his bread in an honest manner with this effect.

EDIT: For the record I don't use it but what if poor Sabotage Jr. reads the forum and finds out how Daddy did the magic with the spoon today. Tears all round.

Ain't no Santa Clause neither.
But in fairness to the honest magicians(oxymoron?) they usually come up with better and more convincing ways to do the trick than Geller.
He's only got like 3 ways of doing it and he been doing for 20+ years.
Kinda lazy if you ask me.

zuroph · 06-05-2008 04:29PM

King Mob wrote: »

Ain't no Santa Clause neither.

:eek: you're not meant to post reveals!!!!

:(:(

Are there any real magicians out there or is it all just trickery

Comments