Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

IBS

  • 28-11-2014 2:47pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,297 ✭✭✭


    My doctor recently suggested that I may have irritable bowel syndrome, but he didn't offer me any test to confirm it.
    How is it diagnosed? And what do people find is a trigger for them? For me so far I have identified greasy food, dairy - cream in particular and stress. Is there anything people eat or take to relieve the discomfort? I'm under a lot of stress at the moment with college and personal stuff.
    Would love some feedback on peoples experiences.


«13

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    My doctor recently suggested that I may have irritable bowel syndrome, but he didn't offer me any test to confirm it.
    How is it diagnosed? And what do people find is a trigger for them? For me so far I have identified greasy food, dairy - cream in particular and stress. Is there anything people eat or take to relieve the discomfort? I'm under a lot of stress at the moment with college and personal stuff.
    Would love some feedback on peoples experiences.

    Diagnosis of exclusion unfortunately. List of symptoms can be vast and could be anything or IBS.

    Talk to your doc or pharmacist. It depends on what your symptoms are as to what meds you could take.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    My experience:
    IBS-C. Chronic. Long term. Constantly flared.

    Pain. Exhaustion. Bleeding. Chronic constipation.

    Triggers: fibre, vegetables, wheat, stress.

    Meds: all of the laxatives (movicol, dulcolax, picolax, preps, enemas), buscopan, colpermin, zoton, pain meds when badly flared.

    Multiple hospital admissions.

    Tests... Colonoscopy, barium, laparoscopy, endoscopy...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,297 ✭✭✭hairyprincess


    Jeez sullivlo, you have been through the wringer! Have you tried any non medications, such as herbal tea or acupuncture?
    I don't get constipation, I get diarrhoea really badly. The food I can control, it's the stress that's the problem.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 30,731 ✭✭✭✭princess-lala


    Hairyprincess do you get spasms?

    I've had ibs for about 15 years. Kinda just learned to live with it until early this year when I was also diagnosed with crohns. Now I can't "just live with it"

    I swear my Coloflac to help with the spasms.

    I go from severe diarrhea to constipation so rarely take anything for those.

    Have you looked into your diet?

    I am starting the FODMAPs diet soon! Apparently its supposed to be brilliant for ibs sufferers


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,297 ✭✭✭hairyprincess


    Hairyprincess do you get spasms?

    I've had ibs for about 15 years. Kinda just learned to live with it until early this year when I was also diagnosed with crohns. Now I can't "just live with it"

    I swear my Coloflac to help with the spasms.

    I go from severe diarrhea to constipation so rarely take anything for those.

    Have you looked into your diet?

    I am starting the FODMAPs diet soon! Apparently its supposed to be brilliant for ibs sufferers

    I do sometimes have spasms, not always though.

    The fodmap diet looks interesting, I'll look into it further when I get all this college work out of the way.

    My doctor recommended Bloateze which I have found to help during a bad spell. They contain charcoal.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,129 ✭✭✭PucaMama


    i have had IBS for a few years now. mostly IBS-D. flare ups are awful. its mostly stress that starts it off. that and too much dairy or greasy food.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,297 ✭✭✭hairyprincess


    PucaMama wrote: »
    i have had IBS for a few years now. mostly IBS-D. flare ups are awful. its mostly stress that starts it off. that and too much dairy or greasy food.

    They seem to be my triggers too. How were you diagnosed? Have you tried the fodmap diet?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,129 ✭✭✭PucaMama


    They seem to be my triggers too. How were you diagnosed? Have you tried the fodmap diet?

    only diagnosed really by ruling out other things :( had colonoscopys etc

    havnt tried that try to keep a normal balanced diet as much as i can cus it seems to help my thyroid issues and pcos


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 30,731 ✭✭✭✭princess-lala


    The fodmaps diet can only be done by a dietician.

    I had looked it up when my GI mentioned it and he told me to look into it but not start until I meet the dietician, I am under one but she doesn't do it!

    Its very specialised and hard. Then in the way you reintroduce foods has to be done in a specific way.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 35 bonnie_


    I have just recently started on a low fodmap diet after 10 years of suffering with IBS. I can't recommend it highly enough and I can't believe it took so long to hear about this.

    I've just finished a 4 week exclusion diet and I have had a huge improvement in my symptoms. It's certainly not easy to exclude all fodmaps completely, especially when eating out. I found garlic and onion the most difficult to avoid. I am now at the point where I can start reintroducing to see what my tolerance is to certain foods. I am pretty sure already my issue is with Fructans so I expect I'll be keeping my intake of these to a minimum for life. Definitely there is no going back now... I was referred to a dietican who put me on this diet.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    I did FODMAP over the summer and found it spectacular for the spasm / bloat / D related symptoms. It was tough to cut them all out though because they are in EVERYTHING.

    I'd defo recommend FODMAP as a route to go - particularly for the identification of triggers. I know my triggers now so tend to just avoid what hurts.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    Going to try the formal diet again, I had some booklets from the dietician I visited that recommended it,but I put them aside and can't find them.having recently eaten out, my stomach or gut has returned to spasms,damn uncomfortable,but I'm still not sure where to start. What do I start the diet on,what do i exclude?
    Can't seem to eat anything without side effects,


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    cerastes wrote: »
    Going to try the formal diet again, I had some booklets from the dietician I visited that recommended it,but I put them aside and can't find them.having recently eaten out, my stomach or gut has returned to spasms,damn uncomfortable,but I'm still not sure where to start. What do I start the diet on,what do i exclude?
    Can't seem to eat anything without side effects,

    I assume you mean the FODMAP diet.

    In which case, Google a list of foods with FODMAPs in them and cut everything out for 6 weeks. You'll be living off bland food for a while - no onion, garlic... Many veg are gone too. Meats are okay. But it's very restrictive.

    Track your symptoms. Keep a food diary of EVERYTHING you eat. Even a piece of chewing gum. It could be a month before you notice any sort of change. No jars of sauces, everything home cooked. It's the only way to guarantee what is going into your meals.

    Then slowly reintroduce foods - one at a time. Day one - 1 portion, day 2 - 2 portions, day three - 3 portions. And track your symptoms. The reintroduction is hard. Particularly if you get symptoms. But track all food and all symptoms.

    There should eventually be a pattern.

    Best of luck with it.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    sullivlo wrote: »
    I assume you mean the FODMAP diet.

    In which case, Google a list of foods with FODMAPs in them and cut everything out for 6 weeks. You'll be living off bland food for a while - no onion, garlic... Many veg are gone too. Meats are okay. But it's very restrictive.

    Track your symptoms. Keep a food diary of EVERYTHING you eat. Even a piece of chewing gum. It could be a month before you notice any sort of change. No jars of sauces, everything home cooked. It's the only way to guarantee what is going into your meals.

    Then slowly reintroduce foods - one at a time. Day one - 1 portion, day 2 - 2 portions, day three - 3 portions. And track your symptoms. The reintroduction is hard. Particularly if you get symptoms. But track all food and all symptoms.

    There should eventually be a pattern.

    Best of luck with it.

    Yes I meant Fodmap, it auto corrected itself without me noticing.
    I even was beginning to suspect toothpaste and mouthwashand low and behold it has sorbitol in it too
    I already cut out loads of stuff, certain veg and onions and garlic in cooked food and am giving up rice milk after already giving up dairy milk, I still have the odd yogurt and infrequently a little cheese, but very rarely.

    I'm mostly wondering what to survive on for the initial exclusion period, ie what's considered to be OK?
    Currently I have porridge made with water and either home made bread or a variety I've had before that I didn't think gave bad side affects.
    Anyone come across any made up charts that you can fill in the food taken that put out results? Might try do something in excel, probably won't have the time and just do it on paper.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    cerastes wrote: »
    Yes I meant Fodmap, it auto corrected itself without me noticing.
    I even was beginning to suspect toothpaste and mouthwashand low and behold it has sorbitol in it too
    I already cut out loads of stuff, certain veg and onions and garlic in cooked food and am giving up rice milk after already giving up dairy milk, I still have the odd yogurt and infrequently a little cheese, but very rarely.

    I'm mostly wondering what to survive on for the initial exclusion period, ie what's considered to be OK?
    Currently I have porridge made with water and either home made bread or a variety I've had before that I didn't think gave bad side affects.
    Anyone come across any made up charts that you can fill in the food taken that put out results? Might try do something in excel, probably won't have the time and just do it on paper.

    If you google the FODMAP diet it will bring up plenty of resources.


  • Registered Users Posts: 712 ✭✭✭chancer12


    Really desperately looking for advice. My daughter (20) has tested negative for IBS and for a range of foodstuffs. However, she still suffers bloating and dreadful pain. 10 days ago she ate a bruschetta with feta cheese and pesto and was in agony afterwards - had to go to bed. She then didn't poo for a full week. Prior to that she had been doing really well. This was obviously an allergic reaction but we don't know what to. Really don't know where to turn, someone recommended a nutritionist in Rathgar (they are a nutritional healthcare practice) but I don't know if this is the route to go? Any tips much appreciated


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    chancer12 wrote: »
    Really desperately looking for advice. My daughter (20) has tested negative for IBS and for a range of foodstuffs. However, she still suffers bloating and dreadful pain. 10 days ago she ate a bruschetta with feta cheese and pesto and was in agony afterwards - had to go to bed. She then didn't poo for a full week. Prior to that she had been doing really well. This was obviously an allergic reaction but we don't know what to. Really don't know where to turn, someone recommended a nutritionist in Rathgar (they are a nutritional healthcare practice) but I don't know if this is the route to go? Any tips much appreciated

    What test had she done that said she was negative for IBS? Because as many have said previously IBS is a diagnosis of exclusion and there is no real "test" for IBS.

    What tests for foods has she done?

    Has she done a poo yet?

    First step would be to talk to GP again about controlling the constipation if she hasn't gone yet. pharmacist could help either.

    In terms of food reactions, if it's an allergy an IgG test will need to be done but for this to work fully, the diet needs to be full of trigger foods. It's a vicious circle.

    I met with a dietician in the Hermitage and did the FODMAP diet with her to determine my trigger foods for symptoms. This could be a route for your daughter to go down.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 738 ✭✭✭scrimshanker


    Chancer12, it's a dietician you will want, not a nutritionist.


  • Registered Users Posts: 712 ✭✭✭chancer12


    Tnx, she went to the Slievemore Clinic and had allergy tests done but she can't find the list and I'm having no luck getting through to them. Will go back to the GP tomorrow because I'm getting really worried now. She has a good diet, doesn't eat processed foods and we've tried a gluten free diet which helped initially, then she tried wholewheat pasta and where it worked initially it then caused a worse effect.

    Yes, the laxatives worked at the weekend but she's really pale and wan and suffering headaches from it all. I'm not sure how the GP established she didn't have IBS because she has been attending all medical appointments on her own for a number of years and I'm only involved when things don't work out which can make it difficult to get a whole picture together. A friend with a medical condition who works in health is talking again about the process of elimination and mineral deficiencies and enzymes in food which is all double dutch to me. I rang a clinic she recommended but they are talking about a stool test in the UK which costs Stg 243. I'd pay it if I thought it would identify the issue. Others are now talking about the possibility of Crohns and that's what's taking me back to the GP. Unfortunately she's also going overseas to college for next year so this has suddenly become a crisis.

    appreciate any thoughts on further testing .... where and what


  • Registered Users Posts: 712 ✭✭✭chancer12


    Gosh, I'm really showing my ignorance but tbh I'm in a bit of a flap. Will look further into that


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 2,965 ✭✭✭Help!!!!


    To be honest it is best to change your diet. Stay away from wheat based products & dairy. There are so many alternatives out there, most supermarkets have gluten free/free from ranges. Try Lactose free milk & cheese. Buy coconut/corn/gluten free flour & make your own bread/pancakes etc. For constipation drink lots of water, eat fruit/veg especially prunes. For spasms buy the ibs relief tablets from chemist. they should have peppermint in them, or drink peppermint tea
    After so many years struggling with IBS I now have it almost under control, where I can now enjoy bread on occasions
    Its all trial & error what works for me may not work for someone else but it may help


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    chancer12 wrote: »
    Tnx, she went to the Slievemore Clinic and had allergy tests done but she can't find the list and I'm having no luck getting through to them. Will go back to the GP tomorrow because I'm getting really worried now. She has a good diet, doesn't eat processed foods and we've tried a gluten free diet which helped initially, then she tried wholewheat pasta and where it worked initially it then caused a worse effect.

    Yes, the laxatives worked at the weekend but she's really pale and wan and suffering headaches from it all. I'm not sure how the GP established she didn't have IBS because she has been attending all medical appointments on her own for a number of years and I'm only involved when things don't work out which can make it difficult to get a whole picture together. A friend with a medical condition who works in health is talking again about the process of elimination and mineral deficiencies and enzymes in food which is all double dutch to me. I rang a clinic she recommended but they are talking about a stool test in the UK which costs Stg 243. I'd pay it if I thought it would identify the issue. Others are now talking about the possibility of Crohns and that's what's taking me back to the GP. Unfortunately she's also going overseas to college for next year so this has suddenly become a crisis.

    appreciate any thoughts on further testing .... where and what

    Perhaps request a referral to a gastroenterologist for further testing. They're who would rule out chrons etc.

    Google FODMAP - it's a thorough food exclusion diet that can help to identify trigger foods.

    The GP should have a range of meds at their disposal if the OTC meds don't help. I have about 4 different antispasmodics to take for pain depending on my symptoms (some constipate though so be mindful of that).

    Don't be afraid of a trip to a&e if the pain is too severe though.

    Edit: also, wholemeal foods are a massive trigger for me so look at ruling out more than white stuff.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,772 ✭✭✭mg1982


    Had an appointment with Gastro doctor in hospital yesterday. After an endoscopy and scans he believes i have IBS and is putting me on tablets. Im glad i have a diagnosis because i been suffering with my stomach more and more the last few years and i didnt know what the hell was going on. At this stage the only foods that dont seem to make me feel ill are rice pasta and corn flakes, everything else just flattens me. I just hope the medication will help.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,207 ✭✭✭witchgirl26


    I've been suffering for about 14 years with IBS (9 officially per diagnoses). I was managing it really well up until about a year or so ago when I put on a bit of extra weight & now it's hitting in harder that previously.

    I did the FODMAPs app to get an idea & think it'll be something I'll persue with a trained professional as it did seem to help. And I'd love to be able to cut down on some of the tablets I'm on.

    Chancer12 - I think maybe have an open discussion with your daughter as to how concerned you are. I know I was in a similar position of attending all my GP visits myself and I'm not going to lie - it was embarrassing as hell to describe my bowel functions to someone. I think the first few times I went, I might have underplayed what was going on. Definitely ask your daughter to talk to the GP about some relief for the spasms and for something to help regulate movement. Over the counter, I found that Fybogel was really good for getting some normality to my functions.

    Like sullivlo I found that it wasn't just white bread etc that I had a problem with. Too much fibre in my diet led to more problems. I also got a colonoscopy to rule out any other things such as Crohns as some of the symptoms can be so similar. My health insurance covered most of the cost of going private for this (I would have been waiting approx 1 year at least as was "non urgent").


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    I've had IBS for 12 years, mostly D but can lean towards C at times.

    I'm normally good for spasms and it's mostly that my digestion feels aggravated and raw along with GERD and racing heart. Stress and hot weather makes it worse. I've had times when I can eat anything I want and have no symptoms at all, and as an avid foodie, those times are bliss :)

    I've done FODMAPs and while it works during a mild flare, it's useless when I'm having a really bad flare. Then I can only eat cheese, meat and freshly cooked rice (has to be freshly cooked as resistant starch in reheated rice can cause issues when I'm very sensitive). No fruit, no veg, no spices whatsoever. It's really dull but worth it to ease the flare.

    The best 'medication' I've found is Krill oil + vitamin D. Calms the gut inflammation right down (for some reason NSAIDs make the situation worse). In my experience a short course of 4 weeks is all that's necessary.

    I believe my whole issue is related to dysbiosis of my gut bacteria that was probably brought on by a series of strong broad spectrum antibiotics I took related to dental treatment in my early 20's.

    I'm going to try a protocol soon that will attempt to address the dysbiosis for the medium to long term. I'll report back with details if I have any success with it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    I think mine started after I got a tummy bug in Morocco a few years ago. Never right since.

    I also have GERD. Back to the GI next month - GP says I need an endoscopy to see what's caused the new GERD symptoms (chronic chest pain / reflux when exercising - defo reflux though, not heart related, have had the tests and when I drink gaviscon it goes away).


  • Registered Users Posts: 355 ✭✭River Song


    Hi all,

    Just diagnosed with post-infectious IBS this afternoon. Symptoms started 3 weeks ago today, ended up in hospital in America while there with work - thought it was food poisoning or gastroenteritis. Had bad vomiting, diarrhea, and was badly dehydrated. Following this, as soon as I got home that Thursday morning (was hospitalized the Sunday night/Monday morning), I've had bad stomach cramps, more frequent bowel movements, changes in them, and different foods (especially breads) have been setting me off. Been to get bloods and other tests and all point to IBS. Have to redo bloods in a few weeks too to double check.

    Started the low-FODMAP diet the other day, and taking probiotics. Given Buscopan and Colpramin for the beginning. Good to know others are going through similar.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,567 ✭✭✭Iseedeadpixels


    Is Fybogel good for someone with IBS-D? I was advised to take it but keep reading its best for IBS-C, I dont want to take it and put myself in a awkward situation in work :pac: Anyone with IBS-D have experience with this?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    Is Fybogel good for someone with IBS-D? I was advised to take it but keep reading its best for IBS-C, I dont want to take it and put myself in a awkward situation in work :pac: Anyone with IBS-D have experience with this?

    I have IBS-C and it clogged me up so bad that I ended up in hospital. It might be worth trying as it forms a gel with water so it might make things more solid for you. Talk to your doctor / pharmacist though.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,567 ✭✭✭Iseedeadpixels


    sullivlo wrote: »
    I have IBS-C and it clogged me up so bad that I ended up in hospital. It might be worth trying as it forms a gel with water so it might make things more solid for you. Talk to your doctor / pharmacist though.

    Cheers Pharmacist said its the best so hoping Im ok with it, Ill try it tomorrow evening and see how I am in work Thursday, being off Friday helps incase I have a bad few days.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    mg1982 wrote: »
    Had an appointment with Gastro doctor in hospital yesterday. After an endoscopy and scans he believes i have IBS and is putting me on tablets. Im glad i have a diagnosis because i been suffering with my stomach more and more the last few years and i didnt know what the hell was going on. At this stage the only foods that dont seem to make me feel ill are rice pasta and corn flakes, everything else just flattens me. I just hope the medication will help.

    what scans did you get? what tablets are they putting you on?
    I've been suffering for about 14 years with IBS (9 officially per diagnoses). I was managing it really well up until about a year or so ago when I put on a bit of extra weight & now it's hitting in harder that previously.

    I did the FODMAPs app to get an idea & think it'll be something I'll persue with a trained professional as it did seem to help. And I'd love to be able to cut down on some of the tablets I'm on.
    Over the counter, I found that Fybogel was really good for getting some normality to my functions.

    Like sullivlo I found that it wasn't just white bread etc that I had a problem with. Too much fibre in my diet led to more problems. I also got a colonoscopy to rule out any other things such as Crohns as some of the symptoms can be so similar. My health insurance covered most of the cost of going private for this (I would have been waiting approx 1 year at least as was "non urgent").

    Is app a typo for diet? if not I must look into that, I might retry the fybogel again. Ive had D predominant for 10 years and it interferes in my life so much that its difficult to plan anything.
    I've had IBS for 12 years, mostly D but can lean towards C at times.

    I'm normally good for spasms and it's mostly that my digestion feels aggravated and raw along with GERD and racing heart. Stress and hot weather makes it worse. I've had times when I can eat anything I want and have no symptoms at all, and as an avid foodie, those times are bliss :)

    I've done FODMAPs and while it works during a mild flare, it's useless when I'm having a really bad flare. Then I can only eat cheese, meat and freshly cooked rice (has to be freshly cooked as resistant starch in reheated rice can cause issues when I'm very sensitive). No fruit, no veg, no spices whatsoever. It's really dull but worth it to ease the flare.

    The best 'medication' I've found is Krill oil + vitamin D. Calms the gut inflammation right down (for some reason NSAIDs make the situation worse). In my experience a short course of 4 weeks is all that's necessary.

    I believe my whole issue is related to dysbiosis of my gut bacteria that was probably brought on by a series of strong broad spectrum antibiotics I took related to dental treatment in my early 20's.

    I'm going to try a protocol soon that will attempt to address the dysbiosis for the medium to long term. I'll report back with details if I have any success with it.

    I heard something like this about reheated rice, Ive been eating rice as my main part of a meal for at least 5 years, although I still eat potato as I think the fibre in them (especially the skin) may help.
    Never heard of krill oil, I'll have to look into that, Ive been giving everything a go, but I really think its dysbyosis myself too.
    In the last 8 months Ive read more about the role bacteria play in the gut than I have in the remaining 10 years Ive had IBS. Id been prescribed antibiotics when I was younger, but think I had some after a routine surgery, since that time my gut was different than it was before but not bad, Id about 2 or 3 bad bouts when IBS came onto the scene, back then I used to get bad spasms and was basically how IBS introduced itself to me as what I thought was really bad indigestion.
    In hindsight I feel I may have suffered some food poisoning which triggered it, and due to the use of antibiotics, feel that its possible what Ive gotten may have come from a number of sources, namely how some non beneficial bacteria can spread.
    Recently Ive been trying specific probiotics, Id had what I felt was some success with one as I searched for a type that had a specific constituent sachromyces boulardi) a yeast that affects bacteria in the gut, along with certain bacterial strains in the tablets, (Unfortunately it seemed to lose effectiveness after a time of use, I tried another which has another probiotic but seemed less effective.
    Im sure people will recoil, but Im honestly considering FMT as a treatment, just not sure how to get a willing donor.

    Modern medicine, in my experience is that they dont know or care as its not cancer! and it cant be treated with a prescription.
    On top of that there seems to be a lot of information pointing to what causes IBS and other gut problems and the role bacteria play in the gut aiding the immune system among other things.

    We are basically transportation devices to move bacteria around, wholesale undermining their balance is not helpful. I think that has been done with foods produced in modern farming and with overuse of antibiotics.
    There a re so many things I cannot eat, annoyingly some of the foods that are supposed to be good prebiotics for bacteria that aid us, such as brocolli, I try to eat some greens but the affect it has on me isnt good.
    Ive made up water kefir and am looking into kefir milk and sourdough bread to make myself, Im even thinking of growing some of my own food just to try it, big problem to me is meat,cant raise enough of that! antibiotics again in mass farming.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    cerastes wrote: »

    I heard something like this about reheated rice, Ive been eating rice as my main part of a meal for at least 5 years, although I still eat potato as I think the fibre in them (especially the skin) may help.
    Never heard of krill oil, I'll have to look into that, Ive been giving everything a go, but I really think its dysbyosis myself too.
    In the last 8 months Ive read more about the role bacteria play in the gut than I have in the remaining 10 years Ive had IBS. Id been prescribed antibiotics when I was younger, but think I had some after a routine surgery, since that time my gut was different than it was before but not bad, Id about 2 or 3 bad bouts when IBS came onto the scene, back then I used to get bad spasms and was basically how IBS introduced itself to me as what I thought was really bad indigestion.
    In hindsight I feel I may have suffered some food poisoning which triggered it, and due to the use of antibiotics, feel that its possible what Ive gotten may have come from a number of sources, namely how some non beneficial bacteria can spread.
    Recently Ive been trying specific probiotics, Id had what I felt was some success with one as I searched for a type that had a specific constituent sachromyces boulardi) a yeast that affects bacteria in the gut, along with certain bacterial strains in the tablets, (Unfortunately it seemed to lose effectiveness after a time of use, I tried another which has another probiotic but seemed less effective.
    Im sure people will recoil, but Im honestly considering FMT as a treatment, just not sure how to get a willing donor.

    Modern medicine, in my experience is that they dont know or care as its not cancer! and it cant be treated with a prescription.
    On top of that there seems to be a lot of information pointing to what causes IBS and other gut problems and the role bacteria play in the gut aiding the immune system among other things.

    We are basically transportation devices to move bacteria around, wholesale undermining their balance is not helpful. I think that has been done with foods produced in modern farming and with overuse of antibiotics.
    There a re so many things I cannot eat, annoyingly some of the foods that are supposed to be good prebiotics for bacteria that aid us, such as brocolli, I try to eat some greens but the affect it has on me isnt good.
    Ive made up water kefir and am looking into kefir milk and sourdough bread to make myself, Im even thinking of growing some of my own food just to try it, big problem to me is meat,cant raise enough of that! antibiotics again in mass farming.

    Are you my twin? I pretty much had a very similar experience.

    DEFINITELY try the krill oil, it's miracle for chronic D, It's honestly the best thing I've tried.

    Does anyone in Ireland even do FMT? I know you can get it done in UK for 5K sterling which is so much when it's not a guaranteed cure! There are some DIY efforts on some forums that are just like :eek::eek::eek:

    Iseedeadpixels, careful with fybogel, I'm taking psyllium at the mo (main ingredient in fybogel) and I'm tapering it VERY slowly (had only 1/2 teaspoon!) and god did I know all about it! I'm on super low fodmap at the moment as well. I'm hoping to stick with the psyllium until I can tolerate 4 teaspoons. It's vile but I'm trying to get my body to tolerate it so it can increase the effectiveness of some very very strong probiotics.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    Are you my twin? I pretty much had a very similar experience.

    DEFINITELY try the krill oil, it's miracle for chronic D, It's honestly the best thing I've tried.

    Does anyone in Ireland even do FMT? I know you can get it done in UK for 5K sterling which is so much when it's not a guaranteed cure! There are some DIY efforts on some forums that are just like :eek::eek::eek:

    Iseedeadpixels, careful with fybogel, I'm taking psyllium at the mo (main ingredient in fybogel) and I'm tapering it VERY slowly (had only 1/2 teaspoon!) and god did I know all about it! I'm on super low fodmap at the moment as well. I'm hoping to stick with the psyllium until I can tolerate 4 teaspoons. It's vile but I'm trying to get my body to tolerate it so it can increase the effectiveness of some very very strong probiotics.

    Maybe? :(
    Where do you get the krill oil? online? health food shop? Im planning to look into digestive aids (alpha galactosidase?), definitely been told twice Im not lactose intolerant and have done the tests for Crohns and Ceoliacs? (sic), but I have considered the root cause being inability to digest foods by not producing enzymes, and then how bacteria play a role in that later in the Large Intestine. Mine (D) isnt so chronic as it was, used to be pretty bad though, so much so that I would be in agony, but I have other symptoms
    I did have a SIBO test and am due one again, when I asked what they tested for and how they tested, I got no clear answer??? I dont know if they are looking for something specific or something not present?? or some very specific things, which may or may not have any effect on what problems I have.
    The Fybogel I dont find too bad tastewise, not great but, (compared to say, clean prep) havent had it in a while, I was advised about western diets and fibre but additional fibre and certain fruits made me much worse, I eat a bowl of porridge every morning, winter or summer, it seems to not have a negative affect, compared to weetabix or bran or other sugar laden cereals which can have a negative affect, even the more sugar laden normal cereals arent as bad as additional fibre laden types I considered.

    Mostly my diet is low sugar too, highly processed foods are out, Pizza or takeaway, or eating out is a no, although from time to time I fall off the wagon. I still eat meat but am concerned about antibiotics in them, just dont know how much it might affect me??? I could cut out meat but that would be difficult plus the range of my diet is very limited already. I cut out peas due to FODMAP, but I try eat rocket, and spinach from time to time and while I like cheese, the outcome is unknown in advance, and I hardly drink any alcohol anymore (very little and not regularily, the outcome is also uncertain as sometimes I can have a red wine with no affects and others I do).

    Whats the protocol you mentioned you are planning for resolving any bacterial imbalance? Im interested to know, as per FMT, Im willing to try pretty much anything at this point, I really need to look into kim chi, we did our own bread but it was from packets, I want to try a sourdough or spelt to make using the now idle bread machine. I think pro/prebiotic natural foods especially that we can prepare and take regularily may be a help with a boost from synthetic or processed pro/prebiotics from time to time, but I consider any dysbyosis needs to be addressed, probably likely, firstly.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    I think all IBS is cyclical which is why it's so hard to pin down what's provoking it. Something you eat one day can be just fine the next.

    I've been through the gamut of digestive supplements, enzymes, beteine hcl you name it. Some helped for a while but nothing helped as consistently as the krill oil. You can pick it up in boots or any healthfood shop, sort of expensive but worth it.

    I was reluctant to post my current protocol, cos I'm not sure if it's going to work but it's tapering up psyllium to a steady dose of 4 teaspoons per day (currently up to 1tsp and not really doing great, but your supposed to persevere) while eating ultra low fodmaps (Meat, cheese, rice, coconut oil - that's it!) for two weeks. Then once dose is steady take a 6 day course of Elixa probiotic. It's 10 tablets (!) in the morning on an empty stomach.

    I took Elixa before and didn't have much success which is why the psyllium is there to 'carry' the probiotic into every corner of the bowel.

    I should be done in two weeks so will report back when I'm done. I'm looking forward to eating a wider variety of food in any case!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,772 ✭✭✭mg1982


    @cerastes I had a CT scan on my stomach just to rule out other cause and it came up clear. The medication im currently on is spasmanol but im only on it for less than a week. Its not doing a whole pile yet. Been looking down the pro-biotic route myself and was taking one called Alflorex and it did help alleviate symptoms. Trouble is its expensive.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,921 ✭✭✭deisedude


    mg1982 wrote: »
    @cerastes I had a CT scan on my stomach just to rule out other cause and it came up clear. The medication im currently on is spasmanol but im only on it for less than a week. Its not doing a whole pile yet. Been looking down the pro-biotic route myself and was taking one called Alflorex and it did help alleviate symptoms. Trouble is its expensive.

    On alflorex myself. Its expensive at 33 euro for a months supply but well worth it in my opinion.

    Not a miracle drug or cured or anything but makes life so much easier


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    mg1982 wrote: »
    @cerastes I had a CT scan on my stomach just to rule out other cause and it came up clear. The medication im currently on is spasmanol but im only on it for less than a week. Its not doing a whole pile yet. Been looking down the pro-biotic route myself and was taking one called Alflorex and it did help alleviate symptoms. Trouble is its expensive.

    Alflorex was the other probiotic I finished recently, I'm not sure if it has made a difference for me at all really, saw it recently mentioned on TV and the reports seemed very good. Worth a try and I think no harm anyway, but pricey. I think it might be hard to determine or assess a benefit but unlikey to make things worse.
    I'll look into elixa too, do you take the psyllium husk as fybogel from sachets? If so, is it the type with mebeverine in it or without?
    I've considered glucosamine? Not that it seems unusual, for tissue repair of the bowel wall lining, need to check the name.
    If it seems like I'm clutching at straws, its probably because I'm willing to try anything given that modern medicines answer is to just live with it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,207 ✭✭✭witchgirl26


    cerastes wrote: »

    Is app a typo for diet? if not I must look into that, I might retry the fybogel again. Ive had D predominant for 10 years and it interferes in my life so much that its difficult to plan anything.



    Nope not a typo. The university who developed FODMAPS have an app for iPhone (probably android too) that gives you an idea of what foods are high or low & gives you a week run of the diet itself. I used it to give me an idea of whether it would work for me or not. Not it's not cheap (€7.99) but worth it.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    I suffer from IBS since I had my last child 20 years ago. My doc tried everything he could think of and nothing seemed to work. While waiting for a prescription in my local chemist, the chemist came out to me and asked if I'd tried Linseeds. They changed my life! I sprinkle a dessert spoon full on my breakfast and am now down to one attack a year and haven't needed medical help in about 10 years. I take 2 Buscopan for the bad attacks.
    Foods can play Hell, but it's just trial and error as to what you can tolerate.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    Nope not a typo. The university who developed FODMAPS have an app for iPhone (probably android too) that gives you an idea of what foods are high or low & gives you a week run of the diet itself. I used it to give me an idea of whether it would work for me or not. Not it's not cheap (€7.99) but worth it.

    I have that app too and you need to be careful as even though something is listed as 'green' it doesn't mean it's fodmap free. For example oranges are listed as low in polyols, but it still has some, so you can't eat them with impunity.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,601 ✭✭✭cerastes


    I suffer from IBS since I had my last child 20 years ago. My doc tried everything he could think of and nothing seemed to work. While waiting for a prescription in my local chemist, the chemist came out to me and asked if I'd tried Linseeds. They changed my life! I sprinkle a dessert spoon full on my breakfast and am now down to one attack a year and haven't needed medical help in about 10 years. I take 2 Buscopan for the bad attacks.
    Foods can play Hell, but it's just trial and error as to what you can tolerate.

    Linseeds, anything is worth knowing if its helped someone.
    The only thing is IBS being what it is, peoples symptoms and how they are affected are different.
    I will still try them, any idea how long you were taking them for a noticeable effect?
    I actually chew a teaspoon of fennel seeds, Id do it once or maybe twice a day, at breakfast and then at a later meal, kind of a licorice taste


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,207 ✭✭✭witchgirl26


    I have that app too and you need to be careful as even though something is listed as 'green' it doesn't mean it's fodmap free. For example oranges are listed as low in polyols, but it still has some, so you can't eat them with impunity.

    Oh definitely. I think the app is great for giving an idea of what the diet is all about but having tried it, I'm going to get referred to a professional to do it properly.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    cerastes wrote: »
    Linseeds, anything is worth knowing if its helped someone.
    The only thing is IBS being what it is, peoples symptoms and how they are affected are different.
    I will still try them, any idea how long you were taking them for a noticeable effect?
    I actually chew a teaspoon of fennel seeds, Id do it once or maybe twice a day, at breakfast and then at a later meal, kind of a licorice taste

    I felt the difference after about a week. My motions were more regular. I used suffer constipation rather than diarrhoea but no longer. I ran out of linseeds once and tried to go without for about a week and ended up in Hospital! Anything is worth trying. They work for me, but that's not to say they'll work for everyone. I used buy the Linusit, but now buy Tesco own brand. They are much cheaper and do the same job. I also find mint tea good, but cannot tolerate Colpermin! It's all trial and error.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,047 ✭✭✭Daisy78


    After many ibs free years it's reared its ugly head again. Today was horrific, violent spasms and up and down to the toilet all day. Stress seems to trigger my symptoms (although red wine was another culprit). I seem to have severe symptoms for a day and back to normal again apart from feeling wiped. My doctor put me on a course on anti depressants solely for this purpose and it definitely helped, I havent had any flare ups since. But it seems to have returned. I really don't want to go on anti depressants again for this and I can't really cut out stress as much as I would like to. Has anyone had good experience with Buscopan or similar for more immediate relief? I've tried Colpermin but it's useless, may as well be chewing smarties.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    Daisy78 wrote: »
    After many ibs free years it's reared its ugly head again. Today was horrific, violent spasms and up and down to the toilet all day. Stress seems to trigger my symptoms (although red wine was another culprit). I seem to have severe symptoms for a day and back to normal again apart from feeling wiped. My doctor put me on a course on anti depressants solely for this purpose and it definitely helped, I havent had any flare ups since. But it seems to have returned. I really don't want to go on anti depressants again for this and I can't really cut out stress as much as I would like to. Has anyone had good experience with Buscopan or similar for more immediate relief? I've tried Colpermin but it's useless, may as well be chewing smarties.

    Buscopan, spasmonal and clonfec work better than colpermin for spasms imo.


  • Registered Users Posts: 110 ✭✭candle_wax


    I've been taking Alflorex for the past three or four months but can't say I notice much difference - and it's a pretty expensive habit! (I have IBS-D) I have Buscopan also but not sure it helps. I never used Colpermin but used to get the 200mg peppermint capsules from Holland and Barrett which are the same I think. Took them religiously, but again, not sure they ever did anything... At this stage Immodium is the only thing I know definitely helps me, but I just carry it around like a security blanket and only take it every few weeks - usually pre-emptively, if I'm going out for dinner with friends or something.

    I've had symptoms since I was about 16. Got much, much worse when I was about 19 - I'm convinced a trip to central America triggered something. It then almost suddenly improved by 50/60% after some weird stomach bug a good few years later (it was like something was reset - sounds bizarre I know...).

    Other stuff that helps:
    Losing weight. The IBS is probably now at the best it's been since I was a teenager. I wasn't crazy overweight, but have lost two and a half stone and it definitely helped.

    The other major "revelation" moment was cutting out wheat - I'm not super strict, but never eat bread/pasta/pastry anymore. I'm on a half-hearted fodmap (non-supervised) whereby I just avoid the high foods, but at some stage will probably end up doing it properly. I have the book and enjoy dipping into it.

    No alcohol - I have a pint of stout or half glass of wine about once a month (I'm wild!)

    My doc keeps mentioning stress as a possible trigger, but I really don't think that's an issue for me at all.

    Anyway, the IBS still baffles me (it can just be so seemingly random...!) and makes me miserable about once a fortnight, and I *hate* that so much of my daily life is spent thinking about digestion/toilets/being embarrassed. But I realise there are far more serious conditions I could have, and my IBS could be much worse than it is now.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    OK, abandoning the psyllium husk experiment. Was making things so much worse without any sign of getting better. It's funny some people do really well on it but it totally disagrees with me.

    I have discovered something that really helps with bloating though, ginger root capsules.

    You can eat ginger too but it's just more convenient to take the caps, which are just dehydrated ginger.

    Ginger is very anti-inflammatory too so would be good for anyone going through an IBS-D flare. Ginger also calms down the vagus nerve so anyone who gets 'fluttery' in their heart during an attack would find it good too. (though I can't emphasise enough that any abnormal heart rhythm needs to be checked out by a doctor first to rule out something more serious)

    You can eat ginger, take the caps or make ginger tea, the caps are probably the strongest but I've found all three really soothing.


  • Registered Users Posts: 183 ✭✭Strawberry Swan


    I was wondering if anyone has exercise induced IBS-D? Is it even a thing? It's not confirmed yet that I do have IBS as I only recently went to my doctor but my symptoms point to it. It came on first while I was running and then it started when I wasn't running. Now I cant run at all without going and after cycling sometimes too.

    Also, I was wondering if anyone has done Fodmap who is a vegetarian? I am giving up one food group at a time so as to not give up too many things at once. I've started with lactose and it doesn't seem to have much effect so far.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,994 ✭✭✭sullivlo


    I was wondering if anyone has exercise induced IBS-D? Is it even a thing? It's not confirmed yet that I do have IBS as I only recently went to my doctor but my symptoms point to it. It came on first while I was running and then it started when I wasn't running. Now I cant run at all without going and after cycling sometimes too.

    Also, I was wondering if anyone has done Fodmap who is a vegetarian? I am giving up one food group at a time so as to not give up too many things at once. I've started with lactose and it doesn't seem to have much effect so far.

    FODMAP works better if you eliminate everything at once and then reintroduce foods at varying quantities.

    As for exercise, I have IBS-C so id love if going for a run helped!! What kind of food do you eat before a run? Do you use any supplements while exercising (gels / electrolytes)? Do you get D symptoms all the time or is it just exercise induced?


  • Registered Users Posts: 183 ✭✭Strawberry Swan


    I'd normally eat a sandwich before a run. It would be roughly three hours before. I don't take any supplements. I'm gonna try running in the morning when my stomach is empty. I get D on the days I don't run too. It's usually every day or second day.

    I'd like to do Fodmap all at once but I'm wary of not getting enough nutrients, especially giving up the legumes which would be a source of a lot of my protein. I'll study the food groups more closely to see if I can do it while getting enough nutrients.


  • Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement