Communicators

[P]*Deus_Alpha · 13-05-2003 7:44pm #1

Don't get me wrong,i love Star Trek, but does anyone notice that sometimes the people on Star Trek don't press their communicator, they just say eg. "Worf to engineering". Does anyone know why they can mysteriously communicate without touching their communicator? oh and is the speaker in the badge or is it somewhere on the roof or something?

just something to think about,
i'm bored...

bubbles · 13-05-2003 7:49pm

When they are in certain areas of the ship, e.g bridge, enginnering they don't have to use their badges - the ship has a comm system too you know.

[P]*Deus_Alpha · 15-05-2003 6:47pm

oh, yeah. but wait, how does the computer know when to close the channel?

BoB_BoT · 15-05-2003 8:24pm

Em.. i'm guessing since computers are so advanced in the "future" that they can identify punctuation etc..... either that or it's magic

bizmark · 15-05-2003 11:34pm

um i can get my phone to ring someone by talking to it (you look like a twat but eh)..............so in the future why couldnt a computer that opers at the speed of light not be able to turn off a comms link

Riamfada · 15-05-2003 11:46pm

So lets say that Worf and Data are talking on the bridge,

Worf - So I was on call last night
Data - So
Worf - Well here's the thing
Data - Oh Gossip
Worf - The ship was about to explode and Picard said "lets send Worf to Enginnering"
Data - Yeah hes a big d**k when he does that. Dont you wish he'd drown in his Earl Grey.
Worf - Yeah what a tit.

So when Worf said "worf to enineering", Did EVERYONE in that section hear the conversation? Including all other senior staff. Wouldnt it be safer just to use the Aul telephone?

BoB_BoT · 16-05-2003 12:23am

It's a super computer!! it's kinda like Data only in ship form. Plus that and the space magic that floats around.

Michael Collins · 16-05-2003 12:48am

And how when picard says "picard to worf" worf hears "picard to worf" considering the computer couldn't know he was going to say worf at the end of the sentence?

bizmark · 16-05-2003 1:02am

maybe the computer delays the "picard to worf" bit for a second or 2 and then carrys on in real time........as they always pause for a responds

Riamfada · 16-05-2003 4:36pm

no one answered my question

BoB_BoT · 16-05-2003 7:45pm

To answer your question grimes I think we have to refer to puncuation/tone in their speach.
For example
Picard says: "Warf To Enginnering" in a loudish voice/tone so that the computer can register that he's talking to it.
Example 2: Picard talking to someone, "So I was on last night and I had to send Warf To Enginnering last night, the funny thing was that dumb klingon went"
Picard was talking to someone in the same tone and thus the computer knew it wasn't talking to him.

Riamfada · 17-05-2003 7:41pm

wow.... if the computer can do that in the 24th Century, Imagine the advancments in the "alternative" produts. He he he

Saruman · 21-05-2003 10:48am

The fact its fiction and is not real aside....

It is obviously tone of voice. When they use the communicator without pressing buttons, they always use a particular tone of voice, a tone of command.. The computer can obviously pick that up. Exactly the same as if i used primative voice software to run windows.. If i was just talking normally and happened to say "windows explorer" during the conversation then nothing would happen, if i use a loud voice of command up will come windows explorer.. its simple IMO!

Communicators

Comments