Late Late Show/FF party political broadcast

bonzos · 22-05-2010 2:00pm #1

Is anyone else sickened by the FF party poltical broadcast by Ryan Tub and Mary O Rourke on the Late Late last night...surely our tv licence should not be wasted on this trash

Sulmac · 22-05-2010 2:52pm

One more reason to watch Jonathan Ross on a Friday night.

baalthor · 22-05-2010 3:43pm

At least this time she didn't come out with the "My brother really won the Presidential election cos he got the most votes" stuff.
I've heard her on about this several times on RTE and she's never been challenged by the interviewer.

Some more things we can thank Mary for:

Screwing up the LUAS system in Dublin.

Mary Coughlin as Minister for Enterprise: Mary advised Mary to go for an economics type portfolio as women get didn't promoted to them very much so Mary decided to "have a go" ...

walrusgumble · 22-05-2010 6:45pm

same auld guff from her aswell (ie sad story about turning on the radio at home - i do not mean to be disrepectful there, but she said those things before in other interviews) I would be very interested in hearing her stories which she would have written if bertie did not stop her, after all 30 years in politics, yet not one real question about her time in office etc. rubbish. no hard questions, which i do believe she could have dealt with. she might give guff but she is well able to handle her interviewer.

why was she brought on? did some big movie star cancel at last minute

imme · 22-05-2010 7:18pm

was she not on it about a year ago as well? maybe they just keep having the same guests.

mike65 · 22-05-2010 7:22pm

Mary is never off the media. She is on RTE Radio one, Newstalk or Today Fm at least a few times every week.

anymore · 22-05-2010 7:23pm

bonzos wrote: »

Is anyone else sickened by the FF party poltical broadcast by Ryan Tub and Mary O Rourke on the Late Late last night...surely our tv licence should not be wasted on this trash

Tubridy's brother is a FFer - is he a Councilor ?
This probably explains why so much time was given to Bertie Ahern to make 'Personality ' appearences on RTE. Miriam O callaghan's brother is also, I think , An FFer.

Liam Byrne · 22-05-2010 7:31pm

I wouldn't mind politicians being put through their paces.

But the level of bias shown is sickening......watch the interview with the disgraced Ahern and the incompetent Cowen versus the less-than-convincing, but far less objectionable Kenny.

Tubridy let the first two waffle and joke their way out of tough questions, while barely letting Kenny finish.

As a result I haven't watched this FF lackey on TV since.

FlutterinBantam · 22-05-2010 7:40pm

Mammy is going through life as if she had nothing to do with the FF Govt. over the past years.

Media outlets love her as she always has something to say, however the content of what she says is useless.

My personal stance is that I would totally ignore ANYTHING Mammy O'Rourke says on any media outlet as she has no standing, no power, no influence,no part in any decision making of any consequence.

She is just going through the motions waving in the breeze and the media only love her because she is always available

She don't fool the Flutther:cool:

flutered · 22-05-2010 7:52pm

even in my worst possible condition i would not watch that schite on a friday night.

Sulmac · 22-05-2010 7:54pm

anymore wrote: »

Tubridy's brother is a FFer - is he a Councilor ?
This probably explains why so much time was given to Bertie Ahern to make 'Personality ' appearences on RTE. Miriam O callaghan's brother is also, I think , An FFer.

Ryan's brother, Garrett, ran for FF in the Dublin City Council local elections last year - thankfully he wasn't elected.

His Facebook page is quite insightful:

Garrett Tubridy thinks that the local elections should be about the next 5 years, not the last 10; about the candidate, not the party; about new ideas, not more-of-the-same.

Eh, right.

Also, before the election (granted, it was at least a month or two before), Ryan and Garrett both appeared on... Seoige! Shock/horror, I know. :rolleyes:

Tubridy has a lot of connections to FF, if Wikipedia is anything to go by:

Niall Andrews, a maternal uncle, was an MEP, while another maternal uncle David Andrews was a government minister. Tubridy was educated at Blackrock College and University College Dublin, where he studied Arts. He was a member of the Kevin Barry Cumann of Fianna Fáil while in UCD and was active in the UCD Students' Union, as well as the Dun Laoghaire branch of Ógra Fianna Fáil. Two of his first cousins, Barry Andrews and Chris Andrews, currently serve as Fianna Fáil TDs, with the former Minister of State for Children in the government of Brian Cowen. His grandfather, Todd Andrews, was a prominent associate of Fianna Fáil founder Éamon de Valera and held a number of posts in semi-state companies. On the Tubridy side of the family, Ryan is the grandson of TD Seán Tubridy.

They shouldn't have any politicians on the Late Late Show - unless it's for a certain debate and, even then, all parties should be represented.

oppenheimer1 · 22-05-2010 7:57pm

Liam Byrne wrote: »

I wouldn't mind politicians being put through their paces.

But the level of bias shown is sickening......watch the interview with the disgraced Ahern and the incompetent Cowen versus the less-than-convincing, but far less objectionable Kenny.

Tubridy let the first two waffle and joke their way out of tough questions, while barely letting Kenny finish.

As a result I haven't watched this FF lackey on TV since.

I didn't see the Bertie, but thought he was quite hard on Cowen. As for the Enda interview, it was Kenny that dug his own grave rather than it being a Paxman-esque interview.

[mod edited out the last line as it's just throwing the thread off-topic in a silly way (see later mod post), refer to me by PM for a chat if you have an issue with this - sceptre]

maynooth_rules · 22-05-2010 8:37pm

RTE promoting Fianna Fail........well I never:rolleyes:

sceptre · 22-05-2010 8:38pm

If we could all remember this isn't chat night at the London Palladium... the PM feature is more than available to people who want to discuss their political affiliations or mast-pinnings back and forth... it's pointless for the rest of us. I've deleted it. You might agree with the OP or not, try posting about that as it's what the thread is for (please remember that in future, one or two of you are serial off-topickers and it's easier if you remember that now rather than me reminding you formally later).

/mod

trapsagenius · 22-05-2010 10:15pm

Liam Byrne wrote: »

I wouldn't mind politicians being put through their paces.

But the level of bias shown is sickening......watch the interview with the disgraced Ahern and the incompetent Cowen versus the less-than-convincing, but far less objectionable Kenny.

Tubridy let the first two waffle and joke their way out of tough questions, while barely letting Kenny finish.

As a result I haven't watched this FF lackey on TV since.

In fairness, the interview with Bertie hardly mattered as he's already fnished.

Tubridy was equally hard on Cowen and Kenny, IMO-Cowen just came across as far better, which is saying something.

Riddle101 · 22-05-2010 11:04pm

I pray for the day when someone walks onto the Late Late show and starts calling Ryan Tubridy a censor. Well maybe not a censor but I wish someone would put him in his place and tell him that what he is doing is wrong.

Never have I seen such favortism and bias shown to people like Ryan does to FF and FG. If he's going to talk to politcal parties, either talk to them all equally or don't even bother having any political parties because he's just as bad as Fox News or Sky News, even though they are both owned by Rupert Murdoch. But all i'm saying is, I wish Ryan would stop acting like a tool and get serious.

Mister men · 22-05-2010 11:13pm

I wrote a letter to RTE a few months back to complain that i was'nt happy about the late late show being used as a party political broadcast vehicle for the FF party. I was in particular disgusted by the roasting Enda Kenny got on the show whilst Brian Cowen got a free pass even though he is in essence responsible for the sorry state of the nation.

I am still awaiting RTE's reply.

Agent Smith · 22-05-2010 11:16pm

trapsagenius wrote: »

Tubridy was equally hard on Cowen and Kenny,

You must have watched Different interviews then the rest of us

eoinbn · 22-05-2010 11:36pm

The Late Late show certainly needs to cut all political guest while Tubridy is presenter. I have watched about 20 minutes of the LLS in the last few months and both seemed to be pointless interviews with two 'former' FF TD's. The reason I say former is because their work in politics is over-McDaid ran because he didn't like the other FF candidate and Rourke ran because she wanted to prove that she could win the seat back after losing it in 2002. The McDaid interview was just a platform for the man to clear his good name with regard to the drink driving charge and to tell the country that he wanted FF out of office to save the party as Ireland needs a strong FF party...

Liam Byrne · 23-05-2010 12:07pm

trapsagenius wrote: »

In fairness, the interview with Bertie hardly mattered as he's already fnished.

He's still - allegedly - a TD (even though he seems to be off spouting ****e and "buke" signing on our time).....we're still paying him a fortune....

How is that "finished" ?

Plus he And for someone who couldn't remember where a year's salary came from, he'd just written a book!!!

Any decent interviewer would have gone to town on him for the above irony alone, not to mention the fact that his rebuke to those warning him has come to pass.

No, Ahern was allowed to answer deflect a question about signing cheques for misappropriation of charity funds by saying "eh, heh....well I never liked de shirts"

trapsagenius wrote: »

Tubridy was equally hard on Cowen and Kenny, IMO-Cowen just came across as far better, which is saying something.

I didn't see Tubridy interrupt Cowen once. He might have been equally "hard", but he certainly wasn't as open to listening to answers, or pressing as hard for answers to the questions that the interviewee tried to avoid / re-formulate.

I will say that Cowen appeared to give straighter answers, however he avoided allocating blame to FF, which might have been the start of this recovery had he put country before party and used this as a platform to say "right lads, we ****ed up, badly, and I'm sorry; but let's get things back on track" rather than the lies that we usually hear which absolve Cowen and FF of their input.

Actually....forgive me if I'm wrong, but was this FF love-in the only live show that Cowen has participated in since the crisis started ?

steelcityblues · 23-05-2010 2:15pm

Tubridy strikes me as a wimp, who is afraid of losing his coveted position in Official Ireland, and of course his above healthy salary, in not creating memorable TV through grilling Ireland's corrupt and cowardly!

FlutterinBantam · 23-05-2010 2:49pm

Mister men wrote: »

I wrote a letter to RTE a few months back to complain that i was'nt happy about the late late show being used as a party political broadcast vehicle for the FF party. I was in particular disgusted by the roasting Enda Kenny got on the show whilst Brian Cowen got a free pass even though he is in essence responsible for the sorry state of the nation.

I am still awaiting RTE's reply.

And you will be.

No doubt you got a generic 'your comment has been passed on....' reply and other bulldust you usually get from that publicly funded establishment.

Poly · 23-05-2010 8:04pm

Mister men wrote: »

I wrote a letter to RTE a few months back to complain that i was'nt happy about the late late show being used as a party political broadcast vehicle for the FF party. I was in particular disgusted by the roasting Enda Kenny got on the show whilst Brian Cowen got a free pass even though he is in essence responsible for the sorry state of the nation.

I am still awaiting RTE's reply.

last year , Paul Williams was on Tubridy Tonight, he abruptly cut Williams off when he was in the middle of an anti-FF rant

I sent in a complaint:
“Following Paul Williams appearance on Tubridy, I would like to
complain about Ryan abruptly changing the subject when Williams was
criticising government policy.

It is blatantly biased and unfair that Williams could not make his
point because Tubridy is a Fianna Fail sympathiser
It is ironic that Williams was attempting to talk about the government
suppressing information when he was interrupted by Ryan.

If Tubridy is going to continue censor his guests then perhaps you
should preface his show with a “This is Party political broadcast”
statement?

I am interested to hear your response.”

After chasing up the editorial team several times, I eventually received the following:

“Dear Mr ******

Thank you for your email in relation to Paul Williams’ appearance on Tubridy Tonight on the 11th April 2009.

All RTÉ presenters are obliged to be objective, impartial and fair in their treatment of matters of current debate. Ryan Tubridy is fully aware of his responsibility in this regard. The fact that he has a brother running for Fianna Fáil in the local elections should not influence his handling of political issues.

In regard to the interview with Paul Williams Ryan’s only concern was to keep the discussion going and not to dwell excessively on Paul Williams’ views of Government policies. Paul Williams had made his point and Ryan wanted him to move on. It was as simple as this. It had nothing whatsoever to do with any political views which Ryan might hold and certainly had nothing to do with censorship as you allege.

You claim that Ryan Tubridy is a “Fianna Fáil sympathiser”. RTÉ has no reason to believe this is true. We are aware of his family’s connections to Fianna Fáil, but we are not aware of any political views he may hold.

Yours sincerely

************
Series Producer
Tubridy Tonight”

I'd say you could expect something similar.

Liam Byrne · 23-05-2010 8:29pm

RTE wrote: »

All RTÉ presenters are obliged to be objective, impartial and fair in their treatment of matters of current debate. Ryan Tubridy is fully aware of his responsibility in this regard. The fact that he has a brother running for Fianna Fáil in the local elections should not influence his handling of political issues.

I love the passiveness in that entire paragraph......"obliged to be", "aware of his responsibility" and "should not".

No hint that he "was", "stuck to his responsibility" and "does not".

RTE wrote: »

You claim that Ryan Tubridy is a “Fianna Fáil sympathiser”. RTÉ has no reason to believe this is true. We are aware of his family’s connections to Fianna Fáil, but we are not aware of any political views he may hold.

They obviously don't watch Tubridy either!

Wolfe Tone · 23-05-2010 8:59pm

In fairness now political bias is hardly something Ryan brought along with him. Gaybo was partial to a bit of that himself also.

Sulmac · 23-05-2010 10:26pm

MUSSOLINI wrote: »

In fairness now political bias is hardly something Ryan brought along with him. Gaybo was partial to a bit of that himself also.

Indeed, Gaybo even had part of a show practically dedicated to Brian Lenihan Sr. at the start of the 1990 presidential election campaign.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IaLUyhL5Ow

You could say he was even "rewarded" by getting his cosy little number as chair of the Road Safety Authority.

Poly · 24-05-2010 7:48am

In fairness to Kenny, He always came across as impartial.

anymore · 24-05-2010 11:10am

Poly wrote: »

last year , Paul Williams was on Tubridy Tonight, he abruptly cut Williams off when he was in the middle of an anti-FF rant

I sent in a complaint:
“Following Paul Williams appearance on Tubridy, I would like to
complain about Ryan abruptly changing the subject when Williams was
criticising government policy.

It is blatantly biased and unfair that Williams could not make his
point because Tubridy is a Fianna Fail sympathiser
It is ironic that Williams was attempting to talk about the government
suppressing information when he was interrupted by Ryan.

If Tubridy is going to continue censor his guests then perhaps you
should preface his show with a “This is Party political broadcast”
statement?

I am interested to hear your response.”

After chasing up the editorial team several times, I eventually received the following:

“Dear Mr ******

Thank you for your email in relation to Paul Williams’ appearance on Tubridy Tonight on the 11th April 2009.

All RTÉ presenters are obliged to be objective, impartial and fair in their treatment of matters of current debate. Ryan Tubridy is fully aware of his responsibility in this regard. The fact that he has a brother running for Fianna Fáil in the local elections should not influence his handling of political issues.

In regard to the interview with Paul Williams Ryan’s only concern was to keep the discussion going and not to dwell excessively on Paul Williams’ views of Government policies. Paul Williams had made his point and Ryan wanted him to move on. It was as simple as this. It had nothing whatsoever to do with any political views which Ryan might hold and certainly had nothing to do with censorship as you allege.

You claim that Ryan Tubridy is a “Fianna Fáil sympathiser”. RTÉ has no reason to believe this is true. We are aware of his family’s connections to Fianna Fáil, but we are not aware of any political views he may hold.

Yours sincerely

************
Series Producer
Tubridy Tonight”

I'd say you could expect something similar.

What pert almost doubled the RTE licence fee ?
RTE are still paying tribute to FF for this remarkable generosity !

BehindTheScenes · 24-05-2010 1:44pm

See FF= turn off the telly.

JonathanAnon · 24-05-2010 5:29pm

I thought the character assassination of Enda Kenny by Mary O'Rourke and Kenny Tubridy was disgusting. When Pat Kenny was on the show (and now on The Frontline), he was objective and you can never really tell his political opinions. Tubridy wears his FF colours on his sleeve.

And Mary O'rourke claiming that she "always speaks her mind"... she's only started speaking her mind NOW, because she knows she wont be running for office next time. Cant stand her..

Liam Byrne · 24-05-2010 6:25pm

JonathanAnon wrote: »

I thought the character assassination of Enda Kenny by Mary O'Rourke and Kenny was disgusting.

Should this be O'Rourke and Tubridy ?

Just asking, because as I said I haven't watched it since the Ahern/Cowen love-in vs Enda Kenny hatchet job fiasco.

trapsagenius · 24-05-2010 10:19pm

Agent Smith wrote: »

You must have watched Different interviews then the rest of us

Come off it.While Tubridy may have cut across Kenny more, he still asked Cowen some potentially very sticky questions (the one about drinking too much is the one that sticks in my mind).Lets not forget that Tubridy gave Kenny a good few "easy" questions at the start of the interview. The fact Kenny came across so badly, while Tubridy might have played his part, is more down to his own ineptitude rather than any other factor.

If you cannot see this then I'm sorry, but you are as blinkered as some of the FFers you (presumably) claim to oppose.

Liam Byrne wrote: »

He's still - allegedly - a TD (even though he seems to be off spouting ****e and "buke" signing on our time).....we're still paying him a fortune....

How is that "finished" ?

Plus he And for someone who couldn't remember where a year's salary came from, he'd just written a book!!!

Any decent interviewer would have gone to town on him for the above irony alone, not to mention the fact that his rebuke to those warning him has come to pass.

No, Ahern was allowed to answer deflect a question about signing cheques for misappropriation of charity funds by saying "eh, heh....well I never liked de shirts"

Finished from the point of view that Bertie will not be leader of FF during the next election, and most likely will not be running as a TD.Giving Ahern a grilling would not really have done FF any harm as he is in the party's past now.

Liam Byrne wrote: »

I didn't see Tubridy interrupt Cowen once. He might have been equally "hard", but he certainly wasn't as open to listening to answers, or pressing as hard for answers to the questions that the interviewee tried to avoid / re-formulate.

I will say that Cowen appeared to give straighter answers, however he avoided allocating blame to FF, which might have been the start of this recovery had he put country before party and used this as a platform to say "right lads, we ****ed up, badly, and I'm sorry; but let's get things back on track" rather than the lies that we usually hear which absolve Cowen and FF of their input.

Actually....forgive me if I'm wrong, but was this FF love-in the only live show that Cowen has participated in since the crisis started ?

I'm not going to come out and defend Cowen-I don't like the man as Taoiseach (and I'm indifferent about Tubridy).I just think calling the late late a party political broadcast is a bit much and that blaming Tubridy for Kenny's shambolic interview is ridiculous.

Liam Byrne · 24-05-2010 10:29pm

trapsagenius wrote: »

Come off it.While Tubridy may have cut across Kenny more, he still asked Cowen some potentially very sticky questions (the one about drinking too much is the one that sticks in my mind).

Cutting across = not letting answer.

If you ask sticky questions, then you let someone answer.

trapsagenius wrote: »

The fact Kenny came across so badly, while Tubridy might have played his part, is more down to his own ineptitude rather than any other factor.

At least you admit it. So the point is : why did he choose to play a part ?

trapsagenius wrote: »

Giving Ahern a grilling would not really have done FF any harm as he is in the party's past now.

I'm not talking about "doing FF harm".....I'm talking about asking the required questions and not accepting an elected representative laughing and sneering about shirt styles when asked about his role in corruption.

trapsagenius wrote: »

I just think calling the late late a party political broadcast is a bit much and that blaming Tubridy for Kenny's shambolic interview is ridiculous.

Kenny can come across however he comes across. That's not the point.

The point is that Tubridy treated people from different parties differently; that is what is partisan and objectionable.

trapsagenius · 24-05-2010 10:38pm

Liam Byrne wrote: »

Cutting across = not letting answer.

If you ask sticky questions, then you let someone answer.

The point I was trying to make is that he gave both of them hard interviews-just in different ways.

Liam Byrne wrote: »

At least you admit it. So the point is : why did he choose to play a part ?

Obviously I don't know the answer to this but if I had to guess I would say it's because Kenny had not really been asked a hard question by an interviewer in a long time and Tubridy went in with the intention of giving him a good going over.

Liam Byrne wrote: »

I'm not talking about "doing FF harm".....I'm talking about asking the required questions and not accepting an elected representative laughing and sneering about shirt styles when asked about his role in corruption.

I don't think comparing the Bertie interview to Cowen's or Kenny's is fair because, as I stated previously, the peak in Bertie's career is passed.He may have gone easy on him, but I don't see how this compares to Cowen or Kenny

Liam Byrne wrote: »

Kenny can come across however he comes across. That's not the point.

The point is that Tubridy treated people from different parties differently; that is what is partisan and objectionable.

But you see, I don't think he treated them differently.I think he gave them both hard interviews, just in different ways.

Liam Byrne · 24-05-2010 10:47pm

trapsagenius wrote: »

But you see, I don't think he treated them differently.I think he gave them both hard interviews, just in different ways.

Cowen : tough enough questions (even though some of them were irrelevant because they were about drinking and not about the mistakes he made as Minister for Finance) and let him answer

Kenny : tough enough questions and refused to let him answer, continuously interrupting

Seems very different to me.

Mal-Adjusted · 25-05-2010 12:29am

trapsagenius wrote: »

The point I was trying to make is that he gave both of them hard interviews-just in different ways.

what interviews were you watching?

trapsagenius wrote: »

Obviously I don't know the answer to this but if I had to guess I would say it's because Kenny had not really been asked a hard question by an interviewer in a long time and Tubridy went in with the intention of giving him a good going over.

and he went into the interview with Cowen with the intention of boosting him up a bit. that's the problem...same with Bertie (who was more at fault than anyone!)

trapsagenius wrote: »

I don't think comparing the Bertie interview to Cowen's or Kenny's is fair because, as I stated previously, the peak in Bertie's career is passed.He may have gone easy on him, but I don't see how this compares to Cowen or Kenny

*Facepalm*
the man squandered the greatest period of wealth the country's ever seen, he's being investigated for cover-ups over his time as minister for finance and teoiseogh( sorry about the spelling) and you honestly don't see how this compares?

trapsagenius wrote: »

But you see, I don't think he treated them differently.I think he gave them both hard interviews, just in different ways.

um...you already said this.

danman · 25-05-2010 8:15am

That's it, I've had enough....

Mary O'Rourke is on newstalk breakfast now.
She seems to be on every day.

If she's not sucking up to Ivan Yates, she's on lunchtime with Eamon Keane.

Newstalkss bias towards FF is getting ridiculous at this stage.

Ivan and Eamon probably compare their FF teeshirts and tie pins in the corridors.
They're supposed to be unbiased, but they constantly suck up to this woman and her party.

Time for me to stop listening to Newstalk.

Poly · 25-05-2010 8:19am

danman wrote: »

That's it, I've had enough....

Mary O'Rourke is on newstalk breakfast now.
She seems to be on every day.

If she's not sucking up to Ivan Yates, she's on lunchtime with Eamon Keane.

Newstalkss bias towards FF is getting ridiculous at this stage.

Ivan and Eamon probably compare their FF teeshirts and tie pins in the corridors.
They're supposed to be unbiased, but they constantly suck up to this woman and her party.

Time for me to stop listening to Newstalk.

Ivan is a blueshirt

thebman · 25-05-2010 8:35am

trapsagenius wrote: »

I don't think comparing the Bertie interview to Cowen's or Kenny's is fair because, as I stated previously, the peak in Bertie's career is passed.He may have gone easy on him, but I don't see how this compares to Cowen or Kenny

Really going after Cowen or Bertie could have made Turbridy a name for giving political interviews. He chose not to and one has to ask why.

Little to be gained from grilling Kenny yet he did anyway. You cut people short in interviews when your trying to make them feel under pressure and get them to say something they'll regret.

Contrast with Cowen's interview where the hardest question asked appears to be about him liking the odd drink which is not a difficult question unless your actually an alcoholic.

But you see, I don't think he treated them differently.I think he gave them both hard interviews, just in different ways.

I disagree completely and I don't care for any of them.

danman · 25-05-2010 8:37am

Poly wrote: »

Ivan is a blueshirt

Perhaps I should have made my smiley bigger, or had more of them.

The point is, there are very few people that don't have some sort of political bias.

Ivan is a former FG TD and minister. While Eamon Keanes uncle was a FG TD.
Perhaps they shouldn't interview politions, in case they show bias?

Or perhaps, bias is only bad if reflects one way?

It's quite easy to see political commentators bias, very few of them hide it very well.

Perhaps the FFers on here should start threads against these commentators?

eoin5 · 25-05-2010 9:09am

thebman wrote: »

Little to be gained from grilling Kenny yet he did anyway. You cut people short in interviews when your trying to make them feel under pressure and get them to say something they'll regret.

What was nice about the Bertie one was he was relaxed enough to say that he wouldnt have taken the money if he knew he was going to be caught, an outright admission of greed and corruption, although I dont think it was Ryans idea to lull him into a false sense of security.

aDeener · 25-05-2010 10:38am

Liam Byrne wrote: »

Cowen : tough enough questions (even though some of them were irrelevant because they were about drinking and not about the mistakes he made as Minister for Finance) and let him answer

Kenny : tough enough questions and refused to let him answer, continuously interrupting

Seems very different to me.

tubridy didnt make kenny do that weird perverted like grin after every comment he made though!

was i the only one that noticed that?

Liam Byrne · 25-05-2010 1:14pm

aDeener wrote: »

tubridy didnt make kenny do that weird perverted like grin after every comment he made though! was i the only one that noticed that?

No, but that's probably because it was similar to the smug grin that Ahern had when he said that he would have done things differently if he'd known he'd get caught.

trapsagenius · 25-05-2010 4:43pm

Liam Byrne wrote: »

Cowen : tough enough questions (even though some of them were irrelevant because they were about drinking and not about the mistakes he made as Minister for Finance) and let him answer

Kenny : tough enough questions and refused to let him answer, continuously interrupting

Seems very different to me.

Kenny didn't even get tough enough questions-he had a nice long run in of relatively easy ones.Even the SF question, which he completely bottled, wasn't that hard-simple answer:there economic policies make no sense.And he did ask Cowen a question or two about mistakes he made, didn't he?

Anyone have the Kenny interview to make sure I'm not imagining things?

Mal-Adjusted wrote: »

what interviews were you watching?

This point was already made.While I'm not going to say "thanks whore"...O wait, just did.;)

Mal-Adjusted wrote: »

and he went into the interview with Cowen with the intention of boosting him up a bit. that's the problem...same with Bertie (who was more at fault than anyone!)

Really?Any proof of this?

Mal-Adjusted wrote: »

*Facepalm*
the man squandered the greatest period of wealth the country's ever seen, he's being investigated for cover-ups over his time as minister for finance and teoiseogh( sorry about the spelling) and you honestly don't see how this compares?

I would ask you to re-read my post.I don't think the Bertie interview can be compared to Kenny's or Cowen's because the peak of his political career has passed-He is, for all intents and purposes, part of FF's past now.

Both Cowen and Kenny are at their peaks, which is why their interviews can be compared.I mean, one or the other will most likely be Taoiseach after the next GE.

Mal-Adjusted wrote: »

um...you already said this.

:rolleyes:
You don't miss much, do you??

I repeated it to emphasise my point and also because I felt it was the required answer in both instances.

thebman wrote: »

Little to be gained from grilling Kenny yet he did anyway. You cut people short in interviews when your trying to make them feel under pressure and get them to say something they'll regret.

Little to be gained?Could you explain this point?Tubridy's job is to do an interview, not to do an interview that will grab headlines or boost his career.And maybe "grilling" is the wrong word because when I think of an interviewer "grilling" a political leader I think it's a good thing, instead of leaving them escape through a barrage of soundbites.

thebman wrote: »

I disagree completely and I don't care for any of them.

And I disagree with you, but such is life I suppose.

thebman · 25-05-2010 9:32pm

trapsagenius wrote: »

Little to be gained?Could you explain this point?Tubridy's job is to do an interview, not to do an interview that will grab headlines or boost his career.And maybe "grilling" is the wrong word because when I think of an interviewer "grilling" a political leader I think it's a good thing, instead of leaving them escape through a barrage of soundbites.

Turbridy's job when interviewing politicians is to find the answers to questions the public would like answered that politicians will always try to dodge since they can't even answer relatively simply questions.

Turbridy didn't even ask the questions. He might as well have been interviewing Jordan instead of Brian Cowen.

By little to be gained I mean he doesn't look like a serious presenter. It isn't doing anything for his career but if his sole ambition is to have a job for life in RTE then it looks like he will be safe as long as FF are in power anyway.

Late Late Show/FF party political broadcast

Comments