Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

PSYCHOLOGY versus PSYCHIATRY (through Medicine)

Options
  • 15-11-2014 11:07am
    #1
    Registered Users Posts: 108 ✭✭


    Hi all, I am currently a 6th year student sitting the Leaving Cert in 2015.

    At present I am debating about whether to psychology (Trinity is my first choice) or medicine (NUIG is my preference). My passion lies within caring for people with mental health issues, and I feel like if I do go down the medical route the only job that would suit me would be that of a psychiatrist. I am immensely interested in people, behaviour, personality and the mind, more so than for example the respiratory system. I know that is a huge thing to say but I honestly can't see myself as a GP or consultant of some other form.

    My issue with doing medicine is that I have a multitude of other interests, and I don't want my job to be my whole entire life. I adore literature, languages, politics, debating, creative writing, art, music, cooking.. When it comes down to it, I am in between doing something with science, and doing something with the arts/humanities. If I had to choose, I would consider myself to be more 'artsy' than 'sciencey'. I think that I would prefer studying psychology to studying medicine. Also, I am conscious of the fact that I could completely change my mind on finishing my degree, therefore studying psychology (possibly with French or English Literature as part of the TSM) would leave me with more options, whereas if I do medicine I'm basically hemming myself into psychiatry.

    My question is which job would be more ''enjoyable''? Which would enable me to pursue the better, well-balanced lifestyle? I understand that both professions require dedication, perseverance and many long years of training and studying. I believe a psychiatrist requires 8 years post-grad study (I would be qualified at the age of 32) and a clinical psychologist requires about 5 or 6, as the doctorate programme is extremely difficult to get into. (I would be qualified at about the age of 28).

    I believe I have the personal qualities to fit either profession, and have always been the friend that people go to with their problems, which I gain a sense of fulfilment from working through. If I was to go into psychiatry, I would hopefully be a part of a new generation of psychiatrists who focus on medication only as a last resort.

    I have been advised my my teachers and even a lecturer of psychology at UCD to go down the medicine route. This is because, according to them, I could always go back and study psychology as in 'interest subject' later on in life. Also, they have said that the focus would not be on 'giving out pills', but that I could do courses that would enable me to practise psychotherapy etc. (That was a worry of mine). Finally, I have been told that 'the main difference' between being a clinical psychologist and being a psychiatrist is 'about 100k'). Now, I am firmly opposed to choosing any profession based on salary, and I am aware that as a clinical psychologist you can earn over 100,000 per year, which is more than comfortable. So even though a psychiatrist earns just short of 200,000, would they have the spare time for it actually to be worthwhile having a higher income? Basically, would a clinical psychologist on 100,000 enjoy a better LIFESTYLE (less hours, less responsibility, more time to pursue other interests) than a psychiatrist on 180,000 (whose job may be more of a vocation?)

    I am aware that this is ridiculously long, apologies! I would really appreciate some advice/information as I have yet to come across someone in a similar dilemma. It is an enormous decision! Thankyou so much for reading :)


Comments

  • Registered Users Posts: 337 ✭✭Beca19


    You say you would prefer studying psychology than medicine - that is your answer! If you have a massive interest in the mind and behaviour but little interest in anatomy, biology, etc then you will not enjoy studying medicine. What is the point in spending 5/6 years studying medicine and not enjoying it before you're able work with the only the mind (ie psychiatry)?? If you do Psychology you'll be able to do what you want straight away. I don't know anything about salaries but if what you say is true, you'll definitely have a comfortable life as a psychologist. Also, TSM sounds like a good option for you if you want to keep your options open, it seems like a great course and I'm quite interested in it too. Anyway I'd say go with your heart rather than your head this time! Good luck whatever you choose to do


  • Registered Users Posts: 46 IncognitoX


    As has been already mentioned, you have to keep in mind that if you go down the Medicine route, the majority of the things you study will be unrelated to your area of interest and where you want to end up. Perhaps 20% (I've no idea, random figure) may be related to the mind and psychiatry and you'll have to put in a lot of time and effort into the other 80% of unrelated stuff which you have no interest in.


  • Registered Users Posts: 22 mendelmania


    I'm having the same dilemma as you! I went to a guidance counsellor and I reckon I'm going to just go for the psychology because of the added pressure of the HPAT and whatnot. Also I think the TSM option helps keep more doors open.

    Out of curiosity what's your Myers Briggs type? That can be somewhat of an indication career-wise.


  • Registered Users Posts: 108 ✭✭etherealfairy


    I'm having the same dilemma as you! I went to a guidance counsellor and I reckon I'm going to just go for the psychology because of the added pressure of the HPAT and whatnot. Also I think the TSM option helps keep more doors open.

    Out of curiosity what's your Myers Briggs type? That can be somewhat of an indication career-wise.

    I think that's the route I'm going to head down too! Might see you there :-) I'm ENFP, what are you? (So TSM probably would suit me more!


Advertisement