Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
If we do not hit our goal we will be forced to close the site.

Current status: https://keepboardsalive.com/

Annual subs are best for most impact. If you are still undecided on going Ad Free - you can also donate using the Paypal Donate option. All contribution helps. Thank you.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.

Baptismal Certs: Manditory or No?

13»

Comments

  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 25,617 Mod ✭✭✭✭Dades


    Glenster wrote: »
    Unfair discrimination is bad, and if they're doing that they're bad too, not allowing non catholics in because you dont like non catholics is wrong, but if it's for a budgetary reason, or the parents seem like the trouble-making kind I can understand where the schools are coming from.
    Location should be the deciding factor in determining who gets into state schools. If I applied to a school 5 miles away when there are 2 other schools closer, then I'd have no issue if the first choice school was full of local kids. We just don't want to be dropped down a list because the local bishop doesn't want our lack of belief in the school we're paying for.
    Glenster wrote: »
    Children have a constitutional right to an education, not a constitutional right to an education in whatever school they want, was the point I was clearly making.
    That rather disingenuous, as it is hardly what is being requested here.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 774 ✭✭✭PoleStar


    Here is an interesting viewpoint (not original Im afraid, it comes from Dawkins).

    There is no such thing as a Christian child or a Muslim child, merely a child with Christian (or Muslim) parents. A child of 4 years of age will have no real concept of what religion means.

    Consider this, children under the age of 16 are not allowed to have sexual intercours, are not allowed to consent (or refuse) medical treatments in hospital. Those under 18 are not allowed to vote, drink alcohol and smoke.

    How is it then that a child can have a label applied, by their parents, and that this label should have an influence on what school they go to.

    I am aware that under the age of 16, the parents are the legal guardians. However, the child would have no concept of religion, and thus how can a child be discriminated against based on a label applied?

    Perhaps we need a smart adult who cant get their "atheist" child into a catholic school to take a case on behalf of their child, arguing that the child cannot take that decision as to their religion given their young age! The parent could argue that it is not their position to a apply a religious label to their child as they wish for the child to decide themselves.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,485 ✭✭✭✭Ickle Magoo


    Glenster wrote: »
    No it's not, not unless the parents ask for it, which you said you didn't do.
    My friend is a primary school teacher and says she teaches religion to everybody, regardless of creed. They are seperated for the 1 day of preperation for communion at the church, but that's it.

    I hate to break it to you but neither teaching nor school protocol begins & ends with "your friend"... :confused:
    Glenster wrote: »
    *Shakes head*

    Children have a constitutional right to an education, not a constitutional right to an education in whatever school they want, was the point I was clearly making.

    No one is asking for carte blanche to pick schools, why are you having such difficulty grasping this, they are suggesting that state funded schools should no longer have legal carte blanche to give preference to children of one particular faith, whether that be when doling out places or deciding curriculum.
    Glenster wrote: »
    He implied that I was a skobe! Call the authorities!

    Seriously though do you not know what skobe means? It's like a rough person, like how D4ers used to refer to northsiders back in the late 90's.

    I guessed from the other words in the sentence what you were trying to infer. I'm not Irish, why would I know/need to know/ever want to know some quaint D4 colloquialism from the 90's?!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,492 ✭✭✭MementoMori


    If it ever came down to it, I'd have no qualms with providing a forged baptismal cert to any school that looked for.

    If any one got annoyed about it, I'd simply ask for foregiveness later, saying I had the best interest of the child in mind.

    Utter disgrace that an organisation that is best known for it's abuse of children, has such an influence on education in Ireland.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,485 ✭✭✭✭Ickle Magoo


    Glenster wrote: »
    but if it's for a budgetary reason, or the parents seem like the trouble-making kind I can understand where the schools are coming from.

    Schools paid for by tax payers money should have no right to cherry pick pupils, if they want to be snobbish or elite, they can ask the parents to fork out for full costs of their school. As long as schools are getting the majority of their funding from joe bloggs, then all the little joe bloggs jrs should have an equal chance of attending their local school.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 588 ✭✭✭anti-venom


    robindch wrote: »
    As donegalfella says, you'll find a baptismal certificate helpful when you're trying to get your kid into one of the schools controlled by the Vatican, and in this country around 92% of them are. Luckily, there are a few schools -- mostly around Dublin -- that admit kids based upon the order in which they applied (the "Educate Toschools), but the waiting list for all of them is quite long, so get your (future) kids name down early if you want a chance to get them in. If you apply to get into a school controlled by the Vatican, then the school board is legally permitted to allow the kids of more conformist people than you to skip past your position in the queue.

    Outside of that, your birth certificate is the most important document you need and that's something that the government will give you, not the church. In general, anything the church provides you with has the same legal authority as a membership card for your local video shop.gether"

    That said, if you bring your kid to hospital, you will be asked "what religion" he or she is. I don't understand what relevance this has to medical treatment and would be interested to hear any theories.


    It's entirely do do with pastoral care. If you have stated on admission to hospital that you are of a particular religion then, in the event that pastororal care is called for, the staff will know who to call, be it a rabbi, Imam, priest etc. Apart from this the hospital doesn't (shouldn't) particularly care what religion if any the patient is and it's of no relevence to their care plan. Off course, an an atheist, you could insist that no clerics are needed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,626 ✭✭✭Glenster


    I hate to break it to you but neither teaching nor school protocol begins & ends with "your friend"... :confused:
    I was merely giving you the input of someone who works in the school system, and actually knows what the 'protocols' are. Dont question her answers (or existance) just because they're not what you thought they were.
    No one is asking for carte blanche to pick schools, why are you having such difficulty grasping this, they are suggesting that state funded schools should no longer have legal carte blanche to give preference to children of one particular faith, whether that be when doling out places or deciding curriculum.

    We're talking about shoulds are we? Everyone should have everything they desire. But they dont.
    I was saying that schools care about other things far more than religion. I think I mentioned earlier on that prejudice based solely on faith is wrong. No-one is going to argue about that.

    I guessed from the other words in the sentence what you were trying to infer. I'm not Irish, why would I know/need to know/ever want to know some quaint D4 colloquialism from the 90's?!

    1.It's an awesome word. From an awesome decade. To the max.

    2. If it meant the same as the other words i wouldn't have used it. Tautology, innit?

    3.I was just trying to save you the embarrassment of using a slang word incorrectly, the most unhip thing a person can do.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,626 ✭✭✭Glenster


    Schools paid for by tax payers money should have no right to cherry pick pupils, if they want to be snobbish or elite, they can ask the parents to fork out for full costs of their school. As long as schools are getting the majority of their funding from joe bloggs, then all the little joe bloggs jrs should have an equal chance of attending their local school.

    Again maybe we're from two different worlds, I've always had plenty of schools to choose from. Distance was never really an issue for me. There were loads of schools around that I didn't go to 'cos they were no good, I tok a twenty minute bus drive to school every morning, and my brother who goes to public school doesn't go to his nearest school, his nearest and best school about ten minutes away.

    If local country schools are refusing local kids places, and the alternative is miles away, that's out of order. Is it happening? I dont know, you'd expect it to be on the joe duffy show a lot more if it were.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 504 ✭✭✭cypharius


    No, you don't need a baptismal cert, you might if it's for a catholic school, but for the love of raptor-jesus don't send your child to a catholic school.

    People seem to have this crazy idea that catholic schools are reasonable today, well only 4 years ago I was in catholic primary, and I can tell you that indoctrination is still on the agenda.

    I was first told about hell in primary school... do you want your child exposed to that? Or how about some Half-naked Jewish guy with schitzofrenia nailed to a plank of wood shown in pictures and statues throughout the school? That seem like a healthy environment for a young child?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,485 ✭✭✭✭Ickle Magoo


    Glenster wrote: »
    If local country schools are refusing local kids places, and the alternative is miles away, that's out of order. Is it happening? I dont know, you'd expect it to be on the joe duffy show a lot more if it were.

    Well, again, I can only offer anecdotes from various friends around the country and from what I've read on parenting forums...

    I would hazard a guess that if faith schools were offering everyone all the wanted then ET schools wouldn't exist, and neither would all the groups of parents around the country currently fighting for funding to get a local ET school, no?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,485 ✭✭✭✭Ickle Magoo


    Glenster wrote: »
    I was merely giving you the input of someone who works in the school system, and actually knows what the 'protocols' are. Dont question her answers (or existance) just because they're not what you thought they were.

    It's just one person in one school that you are claiming something about Vs what I have spoken in person to a school about - who is questioning who?! Lol.
    Glenster wrote: »
    We're talking about shoulds are we? Everyone should have everything they desire. But they dont.
    I was saying that schools care about other things far more than religion. I think I mentioned earlier on that prejudice based solely on faith is wrong. No-one is going to argue about that.

    You have consistently stated that schools have the right to pick and choose pupils and that you thought it was more likely that they were refusing entry based on academic, athletic or monitory reasons than faith. If you'd said the above, we wouldn't be having this conversation.
    Glenster wrote: »
    I was just trying to save you the embarrassment of using a slang word incorrectly, the most unhip thing a person can do.

    Unhip? The most unhip thing a person can do is say unhip, surely?

    And if posts come across as ignorant and uneducated & posters clearly not well travelled outside their own wee enclave can it be said that they were posted by a skobe?
    Glenster wrote: »
    Again maybe we're from two different worlds, I've always had plenty of schools to choose from. Distance was never really an issue for me. There were loads of schools around that I didn't go to 'cos they were no good, I tok a twenty minute bus drive to school every morning, and my brother who goes to public school doesn't go to his nearest school, his nearest and best school about ten minutes away.

    Well, clearly we're from different worlds because my parents just had a wide choice of secular schools to send me to.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 992 ✭✭✭LostinKildare


    I Googled "primary school baptismal cert" for pages in Ireland and from just the first few pages, came up with this sample of national schools that require birth certs:
    St. Mary’s Primary School, Dungarvan
    “PLEASE ATTACH (a) BIRTH CERT __ (b) BAPTISMAL CERT __. (It is imperative that these are given to the school)”
    http://www.stmarysdungarvan.ie/index_files/Enrolment Form.PDF


    Scoil Mochua, Celbridge
    “An original birth certificate, baptismal certificate, child’s PPS no. and a recent utility bill (eg. ESB or landline telephone) are required with the application.”
    http://www.scoilmochua.com/Parents/parents-enrolment.html

    St Mary’s Primary School, Edenderry
    “A Child should be enrolled by a parent or legal guardian. Enrolment for Junior Infants will take place in January over the period of a week. Parents will be required to present their child and the following documentation:
    - Birth Certificate for legal purposes
    - Baptismal Certificate for church purposes”
    http://stmpse.com/documents/pdf/Enrolment Policy.pdf

    Adamstown National School, Gorey
    "If you have child starting school in Adamstown National School in September 2010, please call to the school for an enrolment form or phone to have one posted out to you. A Baptismal Certificate is required."
    http://www.goreyguardian.ie/local-notes/adamstown-2089805.html

    St Joseph's Primary School, Gorey
    "If you intend enrolling your son in St Joseph's Primary School, Gorey for September 2008, application forms are now available from the school. We will also require your son's Baptismal Certificate and any relevant assessments and reports."
    http://www.enniscorthyguardian.ie/news/se-road-club-1344948.html

    Renmore, Galway
    “A specific enrolment application form will be provided by the Board of Management and the following information will be sought:
    · Pupil’s name, address, date of birth. . . .<SNIP>
    · Religion and Baptismal Cert.”
    http://www.renmoreschool.com/policies/enrolment.pdf

    In 2004 the former education secretary to the Archbishop of Dublin sent a memo saying that where there was over-subscription in schools, only Catholic students should be allowed in. (http://www.independent.ie/national-news/parents-give-false-address-in-bid-to-get-school-entry-41159.html)

    That same quick Google search turned up these schools that advertise their discriminatory practices in allocating school places to Catholics over non-Catholics. Your tax dollars at work!
    St. Anne’s Primary School, Navan.
    In allocating places priority is given to Roman Catholics.”
    http://www.stannesnavan.ie/downloads/st anne's enrolment policy 2010.pdf

    St Vincent’s Primary School, Glasnevin
    “The criteria for deciding on acceptance or refusal of applications, where the number of applicants exceeds the number of places available, is set down below in an open, transparent and fair manner.
    The Diocesan enrolment policy for primary schools is as follows;
    1 Brothers of boys already enrolled in the school.
    2 Catholic children of the parish including Catholic children of the Travelling Community resident in the parish.
    3 Catholic children who do not have a Catholic school within their boundaries.
    4 Any child who presents for a place.”
    http://www.vincentsprimary.com/admissions__policy.html

    Balscadden Primary School, Balbriggan
    “Children will be offered a place in Junior Infants on the basis of priority following the admittance policy outlined below.
    1. Those children who already have or had brothers or sisters in the school. Those children whose parent is a teacher in the school. {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available then places will be allocated on the basis of age.
    2. Those Catholic children who reside in Balscadden including Flemington, Flemington Park, Tubbersool, Tubbertown, Knocknagin - (combined). {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    3. Those Catholic children who reside in Ring Commons, Dermotstown, Delahasey, The Matt, Balrickard, Balgee, Knockbrack, Kitchenstown, East Curragh, Killougher, Hazardstown, Haystown, Whitestown, Reynoldstown, Balgaddy, Grangemount, Grougha Lane, Newtown -(combined). {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    4. Those children either of whose parents has formerly been a pupil at Balscadden Primary School. {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    5. Those Catholic children who reside in New Haven, Dún Saithne, Mount Rochford, Hamlet Close - (combined). {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    6. All children who live within the parish boundaries and are Catholic applying for a placement are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after the groups from (1) to (5) have been allocated places. {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    7. All children who live within the parish boundaries and are non Catholic applying for a placement are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after the groups from (1) to (6) have been allocated places. {If the number of these children exceeds the number of places available, then places will be allocated on the basis of age.}
    http://balscadden.com/Enrolment.htm

    St. Canice’s Boys School, Finglas
    “The school caters for:
    1. Brothers of boys in the school and brothers of girls in St Canice’s Girls’ School
    2. Catholic boys of the parish including boys of the Travelling Community resident within the parish.
    3. Catholic boys who live outside the parish and do not have a catholic school in their parish.
    4. All children who live within the parish boundaries but are not Catholic applying for a place are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after the groups from (1) to (3) have been allocated places.”
    http://www.stcanices.com/enrolment policy 11.03.09[1].pdf

    Scoil Diarmada, Castledermot
    “Our Enrolment policy is as follows:
    Places will be offered to:
    1. Catholic children of the Parish of Castledermot.
    2. Catholic children who do not have a Catholic school in their own area.
    3. Brothers and sisters of children in this school.
    4. Children of staff members.
    5. All children who live within the Parish boundaries but are not Catholic applying for a place are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after groups 1-4 have been allocated places.
    <snip>
    All applicants are to complete the application form and to submit it with a birth certificate and a baptismal certificate.”
    http://diarmada.scoilnet.ie/blog/2010/03/16/enrolment-policy/

    Lusk National School, Lusk Dublin
    “Parents should supply an original Birth/Adoption, Baptismal Certificate and a copy of a household utility bill with their application form.
    In the event of the number of children seeking enrolment in any given class/standard exceeding the number of places available the following criteria, in the order set out, will be used to prioritise children for enrolment:
    1 Children, who were unsuccessful above in their application the previous year, will be given priority in accordance with (a-f) above. This will not apply to children who have started in another school.
    2 Siblings (including step-siblings resident at the same address) who have reached the age of 5 years prior to the 1st March of the year of enrolment.
    3 All other applicants living within the parish shall be considered according to age and to the Roman Catholic ethos of Lusk N.S.. - priority to the oldest within this group.
    4. Children of current Lusk N.S. staff will be accepted in accordance with (a-f) in order to maintain the stability of the school environment.
    All children who live within the parish boundaries but are not Roman Catholic applying for a placement are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after the groups from 1,2,3 and 4 have been allocated places.”
    http://www.lusknationalschool.org/enrolment.html

    Scoil Mhuire Fatima, Drogheda
    “In the event of the number of children seeking enrolment in any given class/standard exceeding the number of places available preceding or during the school year (due to the Board of Management being unable to provide suitable accommodation, or recruit the required teaching staff) the following criteria will be used to prioritise children for enrolment:
    i. Catholic children of the parish, including children of Travelling Community resident within parish.
    ii. Sisters of children in the school.
    iii. Catholic children who live outside the parish and do not have a Catholic school in their parish.
    iv. All children who live within the parish boundaries but are not Catholic applying for a placement are entitled to a place if there are vacancies after the groups from (i) to (iii) have been allocated places.”
    http://scoilfatima.ie/sites/home.html

    St. Mary’s National School, Malin Head
    “In the event of the number of children seeking enrolment in any given class exceeding the number of places available preceding or during the school year (due to the B.O.M. being unable to provide suitable accommodation, or recruit the required teaching staff), the following criteria will be used to prioritise children for enrolment:
    brothers and sisters (including step-siblings, residents at the same address) of children already enrolled – priority to the oldest;
    children from Catholic families;
    children of inter-denominational marriages where one parent is Catholic;
    children of current school staff, priority to the oldest;
    children whose home address is closest the school, if the child is normally resident outside the parish/agreed catchment area”
    http://malinheadns.com/enrolment.html


    St. Patrick's Girls' National School, Foxrock
    "In the event that applications for enrolment exceed available places, applicant children will be enrolled strictly in accordance with the following criteria and in the following order:
    a. Catholic girls who are resident in the Parish of Our Lady of Perpetual Succour,
    Foxrock.
    b. Girls who have a sister at school in St. Patrick's Girls National School
    c. Girls who have a brother in St. Patrick's Boys National School
    d. Daughters of Staff of St. Patrick's Girls' National School

    And the following on a 'First come, first served' basis:
    e. Daughters of past pupils of the school
    f. Other girls living within the parish boundary
    g. Other girls living outside the parish boundary."
    http://hollyparkgns.ie/Photos_StartingSchool/Hollypark GNS Enrolment Policy.pdf

    Lest you think that the Protestant schools are any better:
    St. Matthew’s National School, Sandymount Dublin
    Children are admitted to the school under the following criteria:
    1. All applicants for Junior Infants must have attained their 4th birthday by September 1st in the year of admission. Preference will be given to older children.
    2. Children of Church of Ireland denomination.
    3. Children of other Protestant denominations.
    4. Brothers / sisters of existing or past pupils.
    5. The remaining places are allocated at the discretion of the Board of Management, bearing in mind the requirements of the Education Act 1998 and other legal requirements Applications will not be considered without a copy of your child’s Birth Certificate and, in the case of those claiming priority on religious grounds, proof of religious denomination (eg. Baptismal Certificate).
    http://www.stmatts.ie/documents/Application Form Web.pdf


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,866 ✭✭✭irishconvert


    PoleStar wrote: »
    Here is an interesting viewpoint (not original Im afraid, it comes from Dawkins).

    There is no such thing as a Christian child or a Muslim child, merely a child with Christian (or Muslim) parents. A child of 4 years of age will have no real concept of what religion means.

    Consider this, children under the age of 16 are not allowed to have sexual intercours, are not allowed to consent (or refuse) medical treatments in hospital. Those under 18 are not allowed to vote, drink alcohol and smoke.

    How is it then that a child can have a label applied, by their parents, and that this label should have an influence on what school they go to.
    .

    Are you saying a child under the age of 18 is unable to decide for themselves if they believe (or disbelieve) in the religion of the parents?


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 25,617 Mod ✭✭✭✭Dades


    Are you saying a child under the age of 18 is unable to decide for themselves if they believe (or disbelieve) in the religion of the parents?
    Kids can decide what they believe at any age, but maybe their "beliefs" shouldn't be given any status until they reach the age when they might be allowed think for themselves?


Advertisement