The Boards.ie Pro Wrestler of The Week 2011/12

thebostoncrab · 30-07-2011 3:54pm #1

Hi all, just another idea to keep this place busy!

So I know some of you follow 411mania.com for wrestling news and what not, and they have a neat little feature on their website called Wrestler of the Week. Basically the writers from Saturday-Monday morning vote on the top five wrestlers of the week. Number 1 gets 5 points, 2 gets 4 etc etc. Then the lists are all combined and you have your top 5 for that week.

I have been thinking of doing our own version for awhile but have been waiting for the perfect week, and with Mondays date being the 1st of August it seems like the perfect time to begin.

So, if you wish to take part, here are The Rules:

1)PM me between now (Saturday) and 11am Monday with your top 5.

2) Rank your top 5 clearly Number 1, Number 2 etc. If there is no clear indication as to who is placed where then your vote won't count.

3) You can vote for your wrestlers any way you want and from any company. (Following kayfabe, in ring performance, career milestones, most talked about this week etc.)

4) Please only use the past week for your reasons to vote. For example don't vote for CM Punk this week because of MITB since it took place a few weeks ago.

5) The person who comes first each week will be awarded 10 points, second will get 8, third 6, fourth 4 and fifth second.

6) Come the first week of August 2012 we will have the Boards.ie Pro Wrestler of The Year 2012.

So get Pming! I'll be keeping this post updated throught the year so you can see how everyone is doing with each week.

Year Standings So Far

1) Chrisitan (10)

2) Rey Mysterio (8)

3) John Cena (6)

4) Zack Ryder (4)

5) Sheamus (2)

D2D · 30-07-2011 7:29pm

Done:)

Bounty Hunter · 30-07-2011 7:54pm

great idea, might need to make sure you bump the thread every week to keep interest up but it could work really well imo and give a proper indication of who the best current wrestlers are. I'll have my votes in whenever i get around to watching SD, busy as f*ck atm.

thebostoncrab wrote: »

6) Come the first week of August 2012 we will have the very first Boards.ie Pro Wrestler of The Year.

Actually I think Danielson was crowned Boards.ie Pro Wrestler of The Year for the calender year of 2011 in that big American top 30 thing I ran but this would be a much better way of judging who was truely the MVP of the year week in week out and much better judges the effect of injuries etc cos they will only be scoring points on weeks they are involved

thebostoncrab · 30-07-2011 8:12pm

Ah yes that's true, whoops!

Aye I'll bump it each Saturday to keep everyone aware, should be interesting! And if folks feel like writing a short line or two as to why they voted for their guys then that'll give me something to post with each result. (Thanks to D2D since it was his PM that made me think that!)

thebostoncrab · 30-07-2011 8:13pm

Ah yes that's true, whoops!

Aye I'll bump it each Saturday to keep everyone aware, should be interesting! And if folks feel like writing a short line or two as to why they voted for their guys then that'll give me something to post with each result. (Thanks to D2D since it was his PM that made me think that!)

DM_7 · 30-07-2011 8:28pm

Why is it by PM?

Since its a discussion forum shouldn't the picks be posted here for all to read.

thebostoncrab · 30-07-2011 9:09pm

It's just for the count. The votes will all be made public on the Monday and open for discussion.

starviewadams · 31-07-2011 2:00am

Sent!

JP Liz V1 · 31-07-2011 6:35pm

Mine sent now

Bounty Hunter · 31-07-2011 6:55pm

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Mine sent now

+1

I really like how this could give a proper representation of who is performing the best week by week i.e Cena/Danielson would usually win something like this as they garner both ends of the fan support but in this it will be who does the most/best for just that week. Bryan didnt have a match this week just interupted Wades promo and therefore didnt even make my top 5

DM_7 · 31-07-2011 7:48pm

thebostoncrab wrote: »

It's just for the count. The votes will all be made public on the Monday and open for discussion.

Right so, fair dues to you for making the effort.

Hangballlouie · 31-07-2011 9:27pm

Is it ok if I get involved in this? I have only just started posting in this forum, but I think this is a great idea, plus it gives me a chance to start posting straight away!!

thebostoncrab · 31-07-2011 9:38pm

It's open to everyone

Welcome to the forum!

Hangballlouie · 31-07-2011 9:44pm

thebostoncrab wrote: »

It's open to everyone

Welcome to the forum!

Thanks

Hangballlouie · 31-07-2011 10:10pm

Mine sent

thebostoncrab · 31-07-2011 10:14pm

Good response so far guys! Remember you have until 11am tomorrow to get your week one votes in!

CMpunked · 31-07-2011 10:36pm

Maybe it could be an idea if people run down a show and just name the wrestlers who were on said shows during the week.

I can barely remember monday at this stage.

Edit:
Heres a rundown of all wrestlers involved this week on Raw, Smackdown, Superstars and Impact-

RAW:
Rey Mysterio
Miz
Dolph Ziggler
Evan Bourne
The Bellas
Eve
Maryse
Melina
Kelly Kelly
Triple H
John Cena
R Truth
John Morrison
Zack Ryder
Alberto Del Rio
Kofi Kingston

Smackdown:
Christian
John Morrison
Tamina
Alicia Fox
Rosa Mendes
AJ
Natalya
Kaitlyn
Mark Henry
Zack Ryder
Teddy Long
David Otunga
Michael McGillicutty
The Uso's
Johnny Curtis
Cody Rhodes
Ted DiBiase
Ezekiel Jackson
R Truth
Orton

Superstars:
Heath Slater
Trent Barreta
Chris Masters
Santino Marella
David Otunga
Michael McGullicutty
Jack Swagger
Alex Riley

NXT:
Derrick Bateman
Darren Young
Titus O'Neil
Hornswoggle
AJ
Maryse
JTG
Vladimir Kozlov
Yoshi Tatsu
Tyson Kidd

IMPACT:
Kurt Angle
Hulk Hogan
Gunner
RVD
Sting
Brian Kendrick
Alex Shelly
Austin Aries
Abyss
Crimson
Bully Ray
Winter
Angelina Love
Tara
Ms. Tessmacher
Mr. Anderson

Ridley · 31-07-2011 10:53pm

CMpunked wrote: »

Maybe it could be an idea if people run down a show and just name the wrestlers who were on said shows during the week.

Punk and all the background talent (if you want to vote Chris Masters for sliding his head into the shot) count aswell for Raw, no?

CMpunked · 31-07-2011 10:56pm

Ridley wrote: »

Punk and all the background talent (if you want to vote Chris Masters for sliding his head into the shot) count aswell for Raw, no?

The list is partially inaccurate, i just lifted it from reports and looked out for names that were mentioned as part of angles.

Bounty Hunter · 31-07-2011 11:15pm

As is often the case the answers in the OP

thebostoncrab wrote: »

3) You can vote for your wrestlers any way you want and from any company. (Following kayfabe, in ring performance, career milestones, most talked about this week etc.)

so if you want to vote for the Masterpiece for spraying Rey with champers (not even sure if he did myself) then go ahead. Lets just try and actually vote for the 5 people who you think for whatever reason were the best 5 wrestlers of the week. Hpowever a list like cmpunked's will make it easier cos obviously most people would be more likely to vote for people who had matches etc.

thebostoncrab · 31-07-2011 11:29pm

Chris Masters is too good for any wrestler of the week list

Cheers for the list Punk!

sliotor · 01-08-2011 10:44am

Right sent you my five cheers.

thebostoncrab · 01-08-2011 12:38pm

A great response for Week 1, here are the votes:

Dare_2_Defy:

1) CM Punk - Obvious choice tbh. Comeback might've been rushed but this storyline is just awesome

2) Rey Mysterio - Won the title in a pretty good match with Miz, deserves the number 2 spot this week

3) John Cena - The WWE Champ deserves his spot after beating Rey for the title

4) Christian - Nice win in a great match against JoMo on SD.

5) Cody Rhodes - Another win for Rhodes again. Building himself up nicely

Starviewadams:

1.Rey Mysterio:Two great matches on Raw with Miz and Cena.

2.R-Truth:Good promo work on both Raw and SD! and good match with Randy Orton.

3.Christian:Good little match with JoMo on SD! and good promo work with Triple H.

4.Zack Ryder:First win on Raw in 2011 and did well as Teddy Long's assistant on SD!.Good week for him

5.Daniel Bryan:Liked his angle with Wade Barrett on SD!

Bounty Hunter:

5. Sheamus - Dont think he actually had a match but he really impressed me without doing much today, he's over and he knows it. If he keeps up even the simple little bits of he's doing like his big grin then he will very quickly be one of the biggest faces in the WWE

4. Christian / Orton: Im sure you will allow my next choice but if not both of these as once more they keep their long ass feud interesting which alone impresses me tbh. If i had to pick one i'd go Christian.

3. HHH - I'm really enjoying HHH's first week as the boss and I guess im just really enjoying the fresh vibe he has brought to it evn though a lot of that is simply the storyline change and not just trips

2. Rey Mysterio - Im not a huge fan of rey's telegraphed moves like many on boards but the guy had 2 great matches matches on Raw and long ones at that and was imo the driving force behind both matches being so good. Normally he would be no.1 after a week like this.

1. WWYKI - Many wont agree with number 1 but to each theoir own and my reason is he has fgone from zero to not just an internet hero in the space of a week. He couldent get on either SD or Raw till now yet this week he pulled double duty, first squashing Cole then becoming Teddy Longs assistant and appearing in multiple segments. Def my Broski wrestler of the week

JP Liz V1:

1. Christian
2. John Cena
3. Austin Aries
4. HHH
5. R Truth

Machismo Fan:

1. Rey Mysterio
2. John Cena
3. Sheamus
4. Austin Aries
5. Sting

DM-ICE:

No 1: Randy Orton. Played his persona brilliantly this week. Put on a decent match but his after match antics were fantastic. I loved how he accidentally scared the life out of some children at ring side. He is the complete opposite of Cena in a the face role.

No 2: Christian, he put on a good match with Jo Mo, had a promo with HHH and was the perfect foil for Ortons craziness at the end of Smackdown.

No 3: Rey mysterio, two good matches. He delivers every-time and ridiculously underrated.

No 4: Cena, had a good match with Rey, "Won" the title and he was excellent in the post match return of Punk. He genuinely is a good actor.

No 5: Dolph Ziggler, he won his match with style, spoke for himself instead of using Vickie and showed great intensity.

Spongey1975:

1. Cena
2. Orton
3. Christian
4. Mysterio
5. Zack Ryder

Hangballlouie:

Number 1: Mark Henry
Really enjoying this new heel run. Just hope they don't mess it up.
Number 2: Sheamus
His interaction with Henry was great, both came out strong, plus he is getting great pops.
Number 3: Zack Ryder
Showed that he has the charisma to be on tv all the time. Some good stuff on smackdown but I hope he gets some ring action in the next few weeks.
Number 4: Cody Rhodes
I thought his new persona would get old quickly but it hasn't. Great to watch, and getting better in the ring every week.
Number 5: R-Truth
The little Jimmy thing is getting a little annoying but he is so watchable. Great interaction with HHH.

JBnaglfar:

5: Christian - I'm enjoying his heel work and he had a good match against John Morrison.

4: R Truth - Another heel who has been doing some good stuff lately. He had great promos on Raw and Smackdown.

3: Zack Ryder - Good to see him make an appearance on Raw, and with his new position on Smackdown he should get a lot more TV time.

2: Sheamus - I am really enjoying his face turn and thought he got a great reception on Smackdown. The face turn will probably come with a push too, so his future looks bright.

1: Rey Mysterio - Rey takes the number one spot having won the WWE title for the first time, even if it was a short reign. He also had two good matches on Raw.

Sliotor:

1- Dolph Ziggler. I thought his match with kofi was good .

2- Christian. His match with JM was class and he played his part well while making Morrison look good.

3- Alex Shelly. Good match and put aries over and plus good to see him in singles environment.

4- R-Truth. Comedy wise his great and had solid match aswell against orton.

5- Morrison. Good to see him back and had class match against christian.

And this weeks top 5 are....

5) Sheamus with 24 Points

4) Zack Ryder with 28 Points

3) John Cena with 36 Points

2) Rey Mysterio with 54 Points

1) Chrisitan is your first Wrestler of the Week with 60 Points!

Thanks to everyone who voted this week! Here is the year standings so far and I look forward to your votes next week:

1) Chrisitan (10)

2) Rey Mysterio (8)

3) John Cena (6)

4) Zack Ryder (4)

5) Sheamus (2)

Bounty Hunter · 01-08-2011 1:12pm

Week 1s results have been added to the hot links sticky (post 5 with the boards.ie HOF) as will hopefully all weeks results as long as this runs.

CMpunked · 01-08-2011 1:59pm

I knew i shouldnt have slept in..

JP Liz V1 · 02-08-2011 11:10am

Yay Christian No. 1 this week

thebostoncrab · 02-08-2011 12:48pm

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Yay Christian No. 1 this week

I was questioning if I should vote or not since I could see the positions with each vote I thought it would be unfair for me to vote, but if I did Rey would have won wrestler of the week! Would have given Sara Del Ray number three for beating Claudio Castagnoli in Chikara and Cena would have been my number two, with Aries at 4 and Ryder at 5

JP Liz V1 · 06-08-2011 10:00pm

Bump as reminder to vote for week 2

thebostoncrab · 07-08-2011 1:16am

Just remember this weeks PPV y'all for your votes. I'm expecting a huge surge on Sunday night/monday morning

Bounty Hunter · 07-08-2011 4:17am

btw tbc you should vote just vote before everyone else, tis what i did with my US top 30 last year, that way its not as if you voting is unfair cos you know peoples positions etc cos you would have already voted before they got into those positions.

no reason you should miss out just cos you had the idea

thebostoncrab · 08-08-2011 11:38am

Leaving votes open until 10pm tonight because I have only recieved two Pms so far...

DM_7 · 08-08-2011 9:21pm

Oh Shoot forgot about it.

Working on it now.

thebostoncrab · 10-08-2011 10:20pm

JP Liz V1:

1. Christian
2. CM Punk
3. Daniel Bryan
4. Austin Aries
5. Beth Phoenix

The Boston Crab:

1: Kurt Angle
2: CM Punk/HHH
3: Christian
4: Sara Del Ray
5: R Truth

DM-ICE:

1. CM Punk - Loved his opening promo on RAW.

2. Christian - Great again this week, the tag match at the end of Smackdown was executed brilliantly.

3. D Bryan - super (if short) match with Kidd

4. R-Truth - Truth was great on RAW and Smackdown. Played his part in excellent Tag match

5. Randy Orton - For playing his part in previously mentioned tag match and I enjoyed the contrast with the end of this weeks smackdown and the previous week.

CM Punked:

5. Beth Pheonix
On monday she reignited some long lost focus on the womens division.
4. R-Truth
Being in two tag team matches this week on raw and smackdown would seem bad, but he was quite entertaining in both.
3. Kurt Angle
Won the tna title in a decent match with sting at hardcore justice.
2. CM Punk
cut another excellent promo on monday night on raw and is again, the focal point of the coming week.
1. Christian
Excellent match on smackdown and had quite a good finish which seen him pick up a win over Orton.

super182:

1. christian
2.sheamus
3.ryder
4.cm punk
5. r-truth

Machismo_Fan:

1. Kurt Angle
2. Christian
3. JoMo
4. Austin Aries
5. Sting

And the week two winners are...

1) Christian (52)
2) CM Punk (38)
3) Kurt Angle (26)
4) Daniel Bryan (12)
5) R Truth (10)

The year end stadnings look like this so far after week two...

1) Chrisitan (20)

2) Rey Mysterio (8)
CM Punk (8)

4) John Cena (6)
Kurt Angle (6)

6) Zack Ryder (4)
Daniel Bryan (4)

8) Sheamus (2)
R-Truth (2)

CMpunked · 11-08-2011 12:57am

Liz will be happy.

thebostoncrab · 11-08-2011 7:53am

I'm surprised Kurt didn't win this week!

JP Liz V1 · 14-08-2011 1:19pm

It might be best to leave votes open again this week until tomorrow night over Summerslam being on

thebostoncrab · 14-08-2011 1:31pm

I shall indeed, just like last week with HJ.

thebostoncrab · 15-08-2011 11:54pm

Votes for last week close Tuesday at 6pm.Please do not include tonights Raw.

paddyismaddy · 17-08-2011 4:02pm

is it too late oh well here anyways

punk
bryan
sheamus
christian
orton

thebostoncrab · 18-08-2011 3:34pm

paddyismaddy:

1) CM Punk
2) Daniel Bryan
3) Sheamus
4) Christian
5) Randy Orton

Machismofan:

1. Randy Orton
2. Alberto Del Rio (the poor guy finally broke through)
3. John Cena
4. Christian
5. Crimson (he was actually cheered on iMPACT!)

JP_LIZ_V1

1. Punk
2. Christian
3. Cena
4. Bryan
5. Robert Roode

Bounty Hunter:

1. CM Punk - The segment on Raw then the PPV, he is why I bother my hole downloading SS when China has blocked youtube and most streaming sites.

2. John Cena - Give the devil his due, Cena was invloved and great in exactly what got Punk my no.1 spot.

3. Sheamus - okay im turning into a mark for our boy these days but then again so is the WWE audience.

4. Orton/Christian - another great PPV bout after of course once more being a big part of SD before it, the blue brands Punk/Cena.

5. ADR - he completed his destiny this week and although not everyone is sold on him im a fan of this heelishly good new champ

The Boston Crab (Lifted from my choices for 411manias WOTW):

1)CM Punk/John Cena
Both men went out and, in my eyes, performed better than at their MITB match. The two have a natural chemistry in the ring that brings out the very best in one another.

2)Randy Orton/Christian: Just like Punk and Cena, these two put on the best match of their series and almost stole the show. Brilliant ending and a contest than had me second guessing the whole time.
3)Cody Rhodes: Thank God the IC Title is around the waist of this man. If there was anyone on the roster who deserved it more than Cody then I have clearly been watching a different show than everyone else.
4)Shinsuke Nakamura
5)Hector Garza

And the week three winners are...

5) Daniel Bryan (12) & Sheamus (12)
4) Randy Orton (24)
3) Christian (26)
2) John Cena (30)
1) CM Punk (40)

Which makes the year end standings look like this after week 3:

1) Chrisitan (26)

2) CM Punk (18)

3) John Cena (14)

4) Rey Mysterio (8)

5) Kurt Angle (6)
Daniel Bryan (6)

7) Zack Ryder (4)
Randy Orton (4)
Sheamus (4)

10) R-Truth (2)

rovert · 18-08-2011 3:40pm

I really need to skew this list with my contrarian NXT & Superstars picks. :pac:

thebostoncrab · 21-08-2011 7:43pm

Votes have started on 411 so here is the reminder to vote for this weeks WOTW!

thebostoncrab · 22-08-2011 7:44am

Closing tonight at 10 so get those votes in!

thebostoncrab · 23-08-2011 10:55pm

JP LIZ:

1. Sheamus
2. CM Punk
3. Alberto Del Rio
4. Austin Aries
5. Tyson Kidd (I kid you not even though he has lost his matches I am very impressed by him)

Machismo Fan:

1. Alberto Del Rio
2. Daniel Bryan
3. Rey Mysterio
4. Mexican America
5. Jesse Sorensen

CMPunked:

5. Wade
4. Jo-Mo
3. Mark Henry
2. Daniel bryan
1. Alberto

TheBostonCrab: (Lifted from my 411mania votes)

1) Alberto Del Rio
Our new WWE Champion put on two great matches this week with Rey Mysterio and Daniel Bryan. His reign is off to a great start.

2) Austin Aries: 'The [COLOR=blue ! important][COLOR=blue ! important]Greatest [COLOR=blue ! important]Man[/COLOR][/COLOR][/COLOR] That Ever Lived' came out on top of the X Division gauntlet and is the number one contender to the X-Division Title.
3) Mark Henry: Is having the run of his career and looks like he could beat Orton for the World [COLOR=blue ! important][COLOR=blue ! important]Heavyweight [COLOR=blue ! important]Championship[/COLOR][/COLOR][/COLOR].
4) El Generico
5) Daniel Bryan/Rey Mysterio

And the week four results are:

1) Alberto Del Rio: 36
2) Daniel Bryan: 18
3) Austin Aries: 12
Mark Henry: 12
4) Sheamus: 10
5) Rey Mysterio: 8
CM Punk: 8

Making the year end standings so far after week 4...

1) Chrisitan (26)

2) CM Punk (20)

3) John Cena (14)
Daniel Bryan (14)

5) Alberto Del Rio (10)

6) Rey Mysterio (10)

7) Sheamus (8)

8) Kurt Angle (6)
Austin Aries (6)
Mark Henry (6)

11) Zack Ryder (4)
Randy Orton (4)

12) R-Truth (2)

DM_7 · 23-08-2011 11:04pm

Sorry, I forgot about this again.

But I have to say I haven't a clue who some of this weeks vote getters actually are.

thebostoncrab · 23-08-2011 11:30pm

When 411 post their indie/ Japan/ Mexico updates in the staff section for the WOTW I'll copy and paste them here to try help

CMpunked · 24-08-2011 12:06am

This week was a tough week to try and figure out where to give votes.

This thread is starting to give me more and more reason to watch Nxt and Superstars.

JP Liz V1 · 28-08-2011 10:25pm

Bump reminder for Week 5 votes

The Boards.ie Pro Wrestler of The Week 2011/12

Comments