Game Golf

tbayers · 04-05-2018 6:59pm

TitianGerm wrote: »

So if I mark a shot as a "Postional" shot when editing a round it'll exclude the shot from the averages when you pick the P-Avg tab?

I'll have to do that with my gap wedge as I use that around the green chipping.

I haven't really being doing it and it still has the no with all to pick up on a mis hit. Although I rarely use my 56 degree for full shots therefore has a very low average distance.

callaway92 · 10-09-2018 11:49am

How are people currently finding Game Golf?

I'm coming up with a product at the mo in regards to Golf Data and it has many of the same ideas but doesn't go as in-depth (as far as right now goes anyway).

More of a basic tracking scores site etc.

Kiith · 21-03-2019 10:43am

I just bought this after talking to one of the boards lads last week, and seeing it when browsing Amazon last night. Their targeted ads obviously did their job. Looking forward to seeing how it actually works, and i don't expect tagging the clubs on will be much of an issue. Will be nice to get a good idea of my distances, accuracy and general info.

I tend to forget everything bar the good and bad shots, so seeing a full overview of my round will be helpful. Won't make me better on it's own, but should give me some good info to help me work to improve my game.

Worst comes to worst i'll sell it in a few months :P

willabur · 21-03-2019 11:01am

While it is fun to check specific things after a round it is something that is only really useful after 5-10 rounds to see what are the patterns in your play.

E.g. I am far more likely to leave my approach short than long or left or right. This tells me I am under clubbing myself on approach shots

If their shots 'gained Vs' is accurate It also confirms to me that I am woeful putter.

spacecoyote · 21-03-2019 2:54pm

Kiith wrote: »

I just bought this after talking to one of the boards lads last week, and seeing it when browsing Amazon last night. Their targeted ads obviously did their job. Looking forward to seeing how it actually works, and i don't expect tagging the clubs on will be much of an issue. Will be nice to get a good idea of my distances, accuracy and general info.

I tend to forget everything bar the good and bad shots, so seeing a full overview of my round will be helpful. Won't make me better on it's own, but should give me some good info to help me work to improve my game.

Worst comes to worst i'll sell it in a few months :P

Think it might have been me, when you guys picked mine up on the course?

One thing I do tend to do is keep a card with my scores on it & also not a quick guide on pin position on the green.

Something like FL for Front Left, BC for Back Centre. It lets me get a bit more meaningful detail on the greens.

It will try it's best to put a pin position in, but is not generally that accurate.

Maybe I'm overly anal with it though, so it might be overkill

Agreed re the point above, you will need a bunch of rounds in there before you get meaningful numbers

Kiith · 21-03-2019 4:43pm

Yeah, was interested after talking to you, but I hadn't even thought about buying it until i was looking at something to spend a €200 one for all voucher i got from work for Christmas. Saw that and just said what the hell. Will be fun to see data if nothing else.

Still have the voucher (as they don't work on Amazon), so i guess i'll just buy a new club as well :P (unless i can find somewhere to get lessons with it).

gypsy79 · 27-03-2019 12:41pm

willabur wrote: »

If their shots 'gained Vs' is accurate It also confirms to me that I am woeful putter.

They dont know where the pin is, it could be you are an awful chipper

Or choose to putt when you should be chipping

willabur · 27-03-2019 12:55pm

Putts Vs '' doesn't rely on position or distance from the pin. It just counts the number of times you used the putter vs the average

So it doesn't need to know where the pin is in order to come up with what is an indicator of an issue, not an absolute diagnosis

gypsy79 · 27-03-2019 12:59pm

willabur wrote: »

Putts Vs '' doesn't rely on position or distance from the pin. It just counts the number of times you used the putter vs the average

So it doesn't need to know where the pin is in order to come up with what is an indicator of an issue, not an absolute diagnosis

Not on the PGA tour, afaik it takes into account distance

Same point applies either way. You may not be chipping close as others, or putting when others are chipping

willabur · 27-03-2019 1:04pm

yep, which is gamegolf providing value

spacecoyote · 27-03-2019 2:44pm

gypsy79 wrote: »

Not on the PGA tour, afaik it takes into account distance

Same point applies either way. You may not be chipping close as others, or putting when others are chipping

It doesn't include putts from off the green in your putting stats

gypsy79 · 27-03-2019 2:55pm

spacecoyote wrote: »

It doesn't include putts from off the green in your putting stats

But gamegolf does! Hence my point that it isn’t a reliable measure. I own one btw

Useful for club distances but limited

willabur · 27-03-2019 3:57pm

surely if it is the same for everyone then the measurement is reliable if not 100% fully understood

spacecoyote · 27-03-2019 6:03pm

gypsy79 wrote: »

But gamegolf does! Hence my point that it isn’t a reliable measure. I own one btw

Useful for club distances but limited

Per the above from my last GameGolf round, you can see that I took 5 shots on the hole. Shot 3 is a putt from "Off Green". So I took 3 shots with my putter, but at the bottom it lists 2 putts on the hole.

If you don't explicitly tell it that you're putting off the green, generally I know that it will default each putt you take onto the green.

Below is direct from the Gamegolf FAQ. As you can see for putting it states "All shots on the green".

Their putting example is pretty clear too in relation to it. So as long as you're updating your rounds with some degree of accuracy it should give a relatively reasonable measure

The Strokes Gained Overview shows a breakdown of where you are losing (or gaining) strokes in the four major categories (Off the Tee, Approach, Short Game, Putting) compared to a scratch golfer.

Definition of Categories:
Off the Tee: First shot on all Par 4 and Par 5 holes.
Approach: All shots over 100 yards/meters away from the hole that aren't par 4 or 5 tee shots. This will include the first shot on par 3 holes.
Short Game: All shots within 100 yards/meters of the hole that aren't on the green.
Putting: All shots on the green.

Update (Jan 2016):
Round Filter: Defaulted to All Rounds, there is a filter option view data from Last 1, 3, 5, 10, 15 rounds or select the individual rounds for analysis

Vs Handicap Filter: Defaulted to "Vs Scratch," there is a filter option to compare the data to different handicap groups (scratch, 5 Hcp, 10 Hcp, 15 Hcp, 20 Hcp, 25 Hcp), which GAME GOLF is able to calculate from all the users' shot data.

How we calculate strokes gained:
Strokes gained calculates how many strokes you gain (or lose) on each shot compared to how a baseline group (scratch golfers, PGA Tour Pros, etc.) performs from an identical position. The factors that determine your position are the distance away from the hole and the lie type (tee, fairway, rough, bunker, green) of the ball.

For example, let's say you are comparing yourself to a PGA Tour Pro for an 8-foot putt. The PGA Tour Pros average 1.5 strokes to hole out from 8 feet (approximately 50% 1-putt, 50% 2-putt, and virtually 0% 3-putt). Therefore, if you hole out the 8-foot putt, you GAIN 0.5 strokes compared to the Tour Pro. However, if you 2-putt the 8-foot putt, then you LOSE 0.5 strokes compared to the Tour Pro.

The same methodology can be applied to any combination of distance away from the hole and lie type.

Using our extensive database, we are able to create the scratch golfer baseline for every position on the golf course, which is used for calculating your strokes gained. Finally, after categorizing your shots we take your average strokes gained or lost and normalized it to represent an 18-hole round.

Note: Based on the typical amateur golfers in our system (higher than scratch golfers), the +/- notation has been flipped. Thus, the number presented in the bar graph represents the strokes you have to improve per round to be equivalent to scratch.

TitianGerm · 28-03-2019 10:01am

Kiith wrote: »

Yeah, was interested after talking to you, but I hadn't even thought about buying it until i was looking at something to spend a €200 one for all voucher i got from work for Christmas. Saw that and just said what the hell. Will be fun to see data if nothing else.

Still have the voucher (as they don't work on Amazon), so i guess i'll just buy a new club as well :P (unless i can find somewhere to get lessons with it).

What made you go with Game Golf over Shot Scope (€199 in McGuirks)?

No need to tag your shots with Shot Scope and has the added benefit of being a very reliable GPS watch as well?

Kiith · 28-03-2019 10:40am

To be honest, i'd never even heard of that. Looks pretty great though...wonder if i could return the Game Golf, as i do like having it on my watch (and i can't do that with Game Golf, which is annoying).

TitianGerm · 28-03-2019 11:01am

Kiith wrote: »

To be honest, i'd never even heard of that. Looks pretty great though...wonder if i could return the Game Golf, as i do like having it on my watch (and i can't do that with Game Golf, which is annoying).

Amazon should refund you no problem.

I find it very good, it does miss the odd shot but very easy to add in while editing your round. The watch also gives you distance to front middle or back of the green and to hazards. You also tag the pin position on the green using the watch.

If your ever up around Wexford I have a Shot Scope that you can try if you want.

Kiith · 28-03-2019 11:13am

Does it actually need to be connected to the phone during the round? One of my issues with Hole19 and my Samsung watch has been with it losing connectivity, and it only seems to give me accurate data about 50% of the time. If this works on its own, seems like a no brainer to refund with Amazon and get this at McGuirks with the one4 all voucher.

TitianGerm · 28-03-2019 11:17am

Kiith wrote: »

Does it actually need to be connected to the phone during the round? One of my issues with Hole19 and my Samsung watch has been with it losing connectivity, and it only seems to give me accurate data about 50% of the time. If this works on its own, seems like a no brainer to refund with Amazon and get this at McGuirks with the one4 all voucher.

No. It stores all the info on the watch, then you can connect it via Bluetooth to your phone or USB to the PC to download your information. You don't need to do this after every round either as it stays on the watch until you transfer it. It's just easier to edit a round when it's still fresh in your head.

Iang87 · 20-05-2019 4:39pm

Hi Lads,

Sorry was browsing the thread so apologies if I'm repeating stuff.

Do I have it correct thinking that you can use game golf with the shot scope v2 watch or am I putting 2 conversations together.

cheers

TitianGerm · 20-05-2019 4:44pm

Iang87 wrote: »

Hi Lads,

Sorry was browsing the thread so apologies if I'm repeating stuff.

Do I have it correct thinking that you can use game golf with the shot scope v2 watch or am I putting 2 conversations together.

cheers

Separate systems.

Iang87 · 20-05-2019 4:51pm

TitianGerm wrote: »

Separate systems.

Ah I see. How do you go about using the Game golf system.

I'm interested in finding trends that I have. For example I feel like i'm always missing my 8 iron left or right but the lads I play with say its not as often as I think I am and i'm only focussing on the misses

tbayers · 20-05-2019 5:01pm

Iang87 wrote: »

Ah I see. How do you go about using the Game golf system.

I'm interested in finding trends that I have. For example I feel like i'm always missing my 8 iron left or right but the lads I play with say its not as often as I think I am and i'm only focussing on the misses

Get the shotscope, have it over a year now and it is perfect for what you want it for. Don't have to tag clubs either and it's hassle free. Only thinking you have to do is remember to tell watch how many putts you take. Tabs take care of the rest.

pakman · 21-05-2019 9:56am

tbayers wrote: »

Get the shotscope, have it over a year now and it is perfect for what you want it for. Don't have to tag clubs either and it's hassle free. Only thinking you have to do is remember to tell watch how many putts you take. Tabs take care of the rest.

Need to be disciplined about editing your rounds too. I've played maybe 8 rounds with it but left 4-5 too long to remember accurately shot for shot. Just a matter of practice is suppose.

Other issue I have is placing a ball marker gets confused with taking it out of the cup so pin placement can be off.

TitianGerm · 21-05-2019 10:03am

pakman wrote: »

Need to be disciplined about editing your rounds too. I've played maybe 8 rounds with it but left 4-5 too long to remember accurately shot for shot. Just a matter of practice is suppose.

Other issue I have is placing a ball marker gets confused with taking it out of the cup so pin placement can be off.

When you pick your number of putts over the hole it sets that as the pin position doesn't it?

pakman · 21-05-2019 10:14am

TitianGerm wrote: »

When you pick your number of putts over the hole it sets that as the pin position doesn't it?

Yeah its as much me getting used to exactly that rather than weakness in the watch. if you forget and move off to another hole it does its best to guestimate I think.

After years with Garmin you just need to condition yourself but its worth keeping in mind for how accurate initial rounds will be.

KG_SouthTipp · 05-06-2019 4:08pm

Hi Guys,

Question for the owners of Shotscope. I just purchased and its charging as I type. I am reading the manual and its states it is vital that practice strokes are taken before each shot to maximize data collection. It actual says they recommend multiple practice strokes for each shot! Do you find this is the case? Could you otherwise miss some data when you review your round? I dont normally take many practice swings and I feel this could slow my game up?

Thanks

Beaulieu · 05-06-2019 5:03pm

KG_SouthTipp wrote: »

Hi Guys,

Question for the owners of Shotscope. I just purchased and its charging as I type. I am reading the manual and its states it is vital that practice strokes are taken before each shot to maximize data collection. It actual says they recommend multiple practice strokes for each shot! Do you find this is the case? Could you otherwise miss some data when you review your round? I dont normally take many practice swings and I feel this could slow my game up?

Thanks

Have Shotscope since 2018. Not a problem at all. You will usually end up editing a round (very simple process) - weakeness if any is the putts but if you edit post round its easy to remember this.

KG_SouthTipp · 05-06-2019 5:08pm

Thanks very much Beaulieu, I look forward to trying it out.

Also, I noticed on the box it states average improvement over 30 rounds is a reduction of 2.7 shots........is this realistic? Obviously i am sure it depends if you are a regular golfer or not

Beaulieu · 05-06-2019 10:08pm

KG_SouthTipp wrote: »

Thanks very much Beaulieu, I look forward to trying it out.

Also, I noticed on the box it states average improvement over 30 rounds is a reduction of 2.7 shots........is this realistic? Obviously i am sure it depends if you are a regular golfer or not

Depends on your starting handicap;)...I find its excellent on what they call P-Avg essentially your median distance per club.
Also -which side of the fairway/rough do you hit more often. Its a statistician's dream.
One point to mind also -you must download the course once before going out to play. It doesn't automatically pick it up.

Game Golf

Comments