Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum
Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026
Fair City [News, Spoilers and Discussion v8] Read Post #1 Before Contributing
Comments
-
I thought it from the beginning, but I've revised it somewhat, so here goes.
Karen, being as she was mentally unstable, threw away her phone in the hopes that it would be found along with Oisin's trolling, malicious texts, then, still having the key to Orla's, let herself in and wrote ''slut'' across the fridge with her own lipstick.
I actually think that at some stage she took the scissors she used to cut her gloves in The Station with her, in the hopes to frame Orla for attempted murder, then maybe, when she had inflicted the damage on herself (which she never intended to be life threatening) hidden the scissors (wiped clean of her prints) in Orla's kitchen drawer.
But someone - I'm guessing Carol - saw her making her way into Orla's, found her in the process of tring to inflict injury on herself, tried to reason with her, then had a tussle when she realised her intent. Unfortunately, Carol, or Karen herself, managed to drive the scissors deep into her stomach in the course of the altercation.
An accident - not intentional murder (even though Karen, whom had not intended on killing herself, just hoped to frame Orla, ended up dead anyway).
IMO, Carol left the scene in a panic, and took the scissors with her, thinking Karen was already dead at that point, because she knew - what with her prior criminal record and tendency towards violence - that no one would believe her if her prints were found on the scissors.
So, that's just my humble opinion, hence Carol asking Jane to provide her with an alibi....
0 -
-
-
MsWesterosi wrote: »I thought it from the beginning, but I've revised it somewhat, so here goes.
Karen, being as she was mentally unstable, threw away her phone in the hopes that it would be found along with Oisin's trolling, malicious texts, then, still having the key to Orla's, let herself in and wrote ''slut'' across the fridge with her own lipstick.
I actually think that at some stage she took the scissors she used to cut her gloves in The Station with her, in the hopes to frame Orla for attempted murder, then maybe, when she had inflicted the damage on herself (which she never intended to be life threatening) hidden the scissors (wiped clean of her prints) in Orla's kitchen drawer.
But someone - I'm guessing Carol - saw her making her way into Orla's, found her in the process of tring to inflict injury on herself, tried to reason with her, then had a tussle when she realised her intent. Unfortunately, Carol, or Karen herself, managed to drive the scissors deep into her stomach in the course of the altercation.
An accident - not intentional murder (even though Karen, whom had not intended on killing herself, just hoped to frame Orla, ended up dead anyway).
IMO, Carol left the scene in a panic, and took the scissors with her, thinking Karen was already dead at that point, because she knew - what with her prior criminal record and tendency towards violence - that no one would believe her if her prints were found on the scissors.
So, that's just my humble opinion, hence Carol asking Jane to provide her with an alibi....
Interesting hypothesis. ☺ I hope it was Carol and she gets thrown in jail so we won't have to look at anymore of her snarling.0 -
Deleted User wrote: »the new detective is hot he was in cowboys and angels tears ago
Ahh, I forgot about that movie. 0 -
Advertisement
-
MsWesterosi wrote: »I thought it from the beginning, but I've revised it somewhat, so here goes.
Karen, being as she was mentally unstable, threw away her phone in the hopes that it would be found along with Oisin's trolling, malicious texts, then, still having the key to Orla's, let herself in and wrote ''slut'' across the fridge with her own lipstick.
I actually think that at some stage she took the scissors she used to cut her gloves in The Station with her, in the hopes to frame Orla for attempted murder, then maybe, when she had inflicted the damage on herself (which she never intended to be life threatening) hidden the scissors (wiped clean of her prints) in Orla's kitchen drawer.
But someone - I'm guessing Carol - saw her making her way into Orla's, found her in the process of tring to inflict injury on herself, tried to reason with her, then had a tussle when she realised her intent. Unfortunately, Carol, or Karen herself, managed to drive the scissors deep into her stomach in the course of the altercation.
An accident - not intentional murder (even though Karen, whom had not intended on killing herself, just hoped to frame Orla, ended up dead anyway).
IMO, Carol left the scene in a panic, and took the scissors with her, thinking Karen was already dead at that point, because she knew - what with her prior criminal record and tendency towards violence - that no one would believe her if her prints were found on the scissors.
So, that's just my humble opinion, hence Carol asking Jane to provide her with an alibi....
Interesting theory. It would leave the way open for everything to be revealed at some point in the future in the form of a "flashback".
I did think it very odd that Carol would lie to the police about a false alibi (or that Jane would go along with it - if someone asked me to give them an alibi, I would refuse point blank). This is a murder investigation after all, not the theft of someone's wallet.0 -
-
-
Once again, the pace of official action in Carrigstown is absolutely incredible.
On Sunday, Karen found herself a nice, clean, comfortable spot in the park in which to lie down and kick the bucket.
By Tuesday forenoon, the post-mortem has been conducted, the medical examiner's report has landed on the desk of the Murder Squad, the wake has been held , the funeral service over, and the burial been completed.
Such efficency is a credit to the Department of Justice, the undertakers, and the grave diggers........
Aoife, to the after - funeral attendees : "Please, if any of you know anything at all about the murder of my daughter, please go and talk to Sergeant Deegan."
Ah, Aoife, you're relatively new to Carrigstown, aren't you?
The residents (and ourselves) know that if a crime has been committed, probably the last person to approach is Sgt Deegan.
In the past three years, he has carved only three notches onto his belt regarding crimes solved in Carrigstown Garda District.
He was first on the scene when Charlotte, with unlawful intent and malice aforethought , kicked over a wheelbarrow, containing 2 turnips and a radish.
To be fair, he used his discretion in that occasion to let her off, after a grim warning (and dark insinuations regarding the Women's Prison in the Joy).
Then , there was the famous 'Case of the Missing Flower Pot', where, once again, Deegan, using his analytical mind, had the entire mystery solved before the first commercial break.
His last case was known to crime afficianados as the 'Great Missing Tail-light Affair.'
Once again, John Deegan, after a period of intense investigation, was able to bring the heinous, psychotic criminal to face a judge and jury and made to atone for his criminal ways.
( Sgt John has been on a well-deserved extended break, more or less, since then.)
It struck me tonight that the late, not- much - lamented Dan used to work in the hotel Gym, and ended up being murdered.
The late lamented Karen worked in the very same Gym, and within a few weeks, ended up also being murdered.
At this stage, poor Laura must be absolutely sh*tting herself!
You almost make laugh as much as I do watching an episode with these 0 -
MsWesterosi wrote: »I thought it from the beginning, but I've revised it somewhat, so here goes.
Karen, being as she was mentally unstable, threw away her phone in the hopes that it would be found along with Oisin's trolling, malicious texts, then, still having the key to Orla's, let herself in and wrote ''slut'' across the fridge with her own lipstick.
I actually think that at some stage she took the scissors she used to cut her gloves in The Station with her, in the hopes to frame Orla for attempted murder, then maybe, when she had inflicted the damage on herself (which she never intended to be life threatening) hidden the scissors (wiped clean of her prints) in Orla's kitchen drawer.
But someone - I'm guessing Carol - saw her making her way into Orla's, found her in the process of tring to inflict injury on herself, tried to reason with her, then had a tussle when she realised her intent. Unfortunately, Carol, or Karen herself, managed to drive the scissors deep into her stomach in the course of the altercation.
An accident - not intentional murder (even though Karen, whom had not intended on killing herself, just hoped to frame Orla, ended up dead anyway).
IMO, Carol left the scene in a panic, and took the scissors with her, thinking Karen was already dead at that point, because she knew - what with her prior criminal record and tendency towards violence - that no one would believe her if her prints were found on the scissors.
So, that's just my humble opinion, hence Carol asking Jane to provide her with an alibi....
Good post but with one little flaw- if its Carol then that means eventually it will be found out which means her going to jail which means her leaving the soap.
I know that aint happening, Aisling O Neil who plays her knows that aint happening so that leaves us with either Karen herself, Aoife or Manson.0 -
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Sean.. what are they trying to do to the chap. Any brief appearances he has on the soap he's being the prime suspect in some crime..
Around 2013, roughly, he was accused of robbery in Spar and leaving Christy for dead.
It seems like he has hardly been in the show since then and low and behold he gets a bit of a run in 2018 and he's chief suspect in Karen's murder!
He's the one fella in Carrigstown i'd put the mortgage on not committing anysort of crime. The chap is harmless..he wouldn't identify his own niece bouncing outside a pub
0 -
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
CollyFlower wrote: »Where was Carol when Karen was killed? I thought she was working in The Station at the time..
I'm sure she had left early after Karen hit her in the bathroom.0 -
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement