Best signing of January?

eirebhoy

Well, who was the best signing of the transfer window (probably the most lively winter window since it was introduced)? Not who is the best player, take potential, etc. into consideration.

RuggieBear

Ferguson - Blackburn to Rangers

well i'd like to rule out Villa's panic buy.....

p.pete

Reid - Forest to Spurs

Well, Pelagrinho was free so I find it hard to argue against him in terms of value for money. Bellamy is on loan so I'd argue against his inclusion but hopefully he does well at Celtic. Bias has made me go for Morientes Hopefully we'll look back at the 6mil and think it was a bargain...

eirebhoy

Beattie - Soton to Everton

Well, not really value for money. Potential etc. should be taken into a/c.

BTW, Celtic have an option to buy Bellamy for £5m at the end of the season so if he's good and doesn't cause any trouble he'll stay. BTW, that £5m is the same as the £5m that it would have cost to get Camara permanantly.

KdjaCL

Arteta good player just hope he gets protected and gets to play ball.




kdjac

mike65

Reid - Forest to Spurs

Well there's only 1 name that says "world class" and 6 million-odd for 3.5 years sounds like pretty good VFM too.

Mike.

Shred

Reid - Forest to Spurs

Already voted for this on Sky's website - Mr. Sanchez all the way and not because I support LFC, his name is synonymous with quality

Big Nelly

Boumsong - Rangers to Newcastle

I would think Reid.....really because of potential.....if he becomes the player we hope he will become then Spurs can sell him for 3 times what they paided for him,.....he is also young!!

Big Nelly

Boumsong - Rangers to Newcastle

RuggieBear wrote:

well i'd like to rule out Villa's panic buy.....

I guess you are refering to Djemba Djemba./.....I actually tink for the money they paid and he is only 23-24 that it was good VFM

eirebhoy

Beattie - Soton to Everton

Shred wrote:

Already voted for on this on Sky's website - Mr. Sanchez all the way and not because I support LFC, his name is synonymous with quality

And Kaka is synonymous with shít.

meditraitor

Reid - Forest to Spurs

Nando y Reid, two best buys IMO

Guy:Incognito

Reid - Forest to Spurs

p.pete wrote:

Well, Pelagrinho was free so I find it hard to argue against him in terms of value for money. .

I wouldnt, i reckon hes worth exactly what was paid. :mad:


What was the quote on the match day coverage of his first game? oh yeah "like laurant Blanc, without the skill"

MrJoeSoap

Boumsong - Rangers to Newcastle

No Jamie Redknapp? You're having a laugh!

meditraitor

Reid - Forest to Spurs

MrJoeSoap wrote:

No Jamie Redknapp? You're having a laugh!

with louise at home, no wonder theres no JR

Chucky the tree

Reid - Forest to Spurs

i am probaly biased, but i think morientes.

Draupnir

Djemba - Man Utd to Villa

i went for pandiani, i reckon he will bang in goals for Birmingham, a top striker in my opinion. interesting to see if he settles after his recent comments though

DEmeant0r

I'd say Mido for Liverpool, he's quick young and he partnered Drogba up front before Drogba left for Chelsea

Chucky the tree

Reid - Forest to Spurs

did he not sign fo spurs?

eirebhoy

Beattie - Soton to Everton

Aye, Spurs got him on loan for 18 months.

DEmeant0r

Oops, I did mean Spurs Brain did work a moment there.

DoctorEdgeWild

Pandiani - Deportivo to Birmingham

I went for Beattie, I think he'll do well now. Hopefully get some good service and score some special goals.

eirebhoy

Beattie - Soton to Everton

Suprised noone has gone for the 40 time capped Candela, he's still only 31, hardly past it yet.

joe.

Ferguson - Blackburn to Rangers

I guess I've never heard of the guy before. Will see now what he's made of.

pickarooney

Ferguson - Blackburn to Rangers

Went for Bellamy as I think he'll make the most difference to the club he signed for of all the ones listed. Plus, the fact they can get shot of him in May if he continues to be a prick.

mayordenis

Reid - Forest to Spurs

its gotta be mori for me, 6m was very cheap for him.

Juan Pablo

Djemba - Man Utd to Villa

No Kizito Musampa up there He'll be a star on the left wing for City this season, remove some of the massive burden that has been placed on little Shauney