Tirlan share spin out

stanflt · 30-09-2024 4:06pm #1

time for voting again for another share spin out

Would I be right in saying that since 2013 the average co op share holder will have received from the spin out over 5000 plc shares over €80000 not including dividends

visatorro · 30-09-2024 4:27pm

as someone said to me in a former life, its all give give give, these bastards are up to something

kevthegaff · 30-09-2024 4:32pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058371368/tirlan-share-spin-out

Would that be from average sized herd?

older by the day · 30-09-2024 5:08pm

I often used to wonder, how all ye fellows up there had all the fine yards and machinery.

Don't tell me, ye are getting more free money.

jaymla627 · 30-09-2024 5:11pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122669346#Comment_122669346

Somethings going on, just after getting a text from milk advisor wondering why i havent registered to vote, you'd imagen they shouldnt even have access to that information let alone be basically demanding you register

jaymla627 · 30-09-2024 5:14pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058371368/tirlan-share-spin-out

Neighbour i rent my ground off has gotten 160k worth of shares from it, hasnt milked a cow in 30 odd years, their historical shares anyone milking in the 80's supplying them would have a ball of shares

GrasstoMilk · 30-09-2024 5:53pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058371368/tirlan-share-spin-out

we wouldn’t have got the colour of that here in share spin outs

whelan2 · 30-09-2024 5:57pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122669515#Comment_122669515

I got a text on Saturday morning from milk advisor. . Sick of texts from them about it, so I registered Saturday night. Nothing since, just a text from fmp

tripperman · 30-09-2024 6:09pm

Same here calls every second day till registered to vote, there's something about the whole thing that's very off putting

Siamsa Sessions · 01-10-2024 8:43pm

I’ve no dog in this race (yet) but a Tirlan supplier sent the following to a WhatsApp group I’m in today

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 9:43am

Lads ye need to check you got 2 emails, i only got the zoom one still waiting on voting one

Siamsa Sessions · 04-10-2024 10:21am

I see Jack Kennedy has come out against it, or at least said "Go aisy a minute lads" in the IFJ editorial this week. His argument seemed to be why would the co-op cash in PLC shares now when they're rising in value?

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 10:23am

Shares have nose dived since Tuesday

Siamsa Sessions · 04-10-2024 10:44am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122683056#Comment_122683056

On foot of a major shareholder selling a big lump of shares???

atlantic mist · 04-10-2024 11:11am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122683048#Comment_122683048

it doesnt really make sense…..we invested in glanbia for the value model…..now were doing a u turn and want a dividends, we had the opportunity at 51% shareholding to look for a higher dividends model but we chose the value model, plenty of value still in glanbia….once they sell of under performing slim fast brand…..the still have all our old coop premises to sell…e.g kilmeaden/snowcream

all our eggs in one basket……were dairy farmers we specialise…..the investment in glanbia is a good low risk investment, they are largest cheese manufacturers in US and are the value added aspect of dairy through whey

maybe i have to many eggs in one basket too, should i sell 10 cows and buy 5 pig and 5 sheep…..should i supply multiple coops is supplying one a risk….

the board and management opened up a can of worms linking coop shares to plc with no vision on where it ended, this is their attempt before they ride off into the sunset, expectation from dry shareholders is that it is a investment company not a coop from their perspective….

having to have a sgm is a good safety control on management on our largest investment, we have a history of both good and bad investments…..also provides stability to plc as 20% of shareholding is going nowhere, as a plc shareholder im happy with stability and value growth

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 11:44am

Supposedly going to resend links to zoom and voting at 1pm

stanflt · 04-10-2024 12:13pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122683056#Comment_122683056

I was on the Daviys site on Monday- the offer to buy was 16.81 and to sell was 14.90 which means that there were a lot of shares dumped to be sold

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 12:24pm

Still no voting email for me....

JeffKenna · 04-10-2024 1:41pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122683615#Comment_122683615

I seem to have got a few different e-mails, not sure what's going on

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 1:46pm

I still have none. They said voting will be open until 4.30 and they might come through by thrn

Say my name · 04-10-2024 2:16pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122684131#Comment_122684131

Think you may call the support helpline. 056 779 6099

whelan2 · 04-10-2024 2:19pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122684270#Comment_122684270

I have been on to them 4 times. They don't know what's wrong. Got the zoom link but no voting one. By the sounds of things in the background I'm not the only one

Say my name · 04-10-2024 2:26pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/122684284#Comment_122684284

Just after voting myself. They've gone through the whole alphabet of surnames in timed to vote in four groups. A to Z now. Got about three links reminders to vote. It was in the primary section emails on Gmail for me.