Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Do I have to invite my father to my wedding

  • 24-08-2018 10:54pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 635 ✭✭✭


    Ok I'm feeling guilty I'm not inviting my father to my wedding. He really wants to come I've had his partner call me to say how much it would mean to him and that he really wants to come. He said he'll sit in the back and not make any fuss but it will cause a stir.

    He left when I was a small baby had no contract what so ever for well over 20 years. He made contact a few years ago. I meet him twice since both times I had to drive 5 hrs to where he lives and both times were a disaster. We had been talking on the phone approx 1 a week until a year ago and it just fell off then. We have nothing in common and it was always me that called.

    My mam says she doesn't mind if he comes but I know it will upset her. I'm putting her feelings first. But I still feel guilty as his partner said I'm excluding him from such an important event in my life. I don't really know what to do. I am feeling guilty that I'm doing something wrong so just looking for some outside opinions please.

    Thanks


Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 118 ✭✭Plague Maiden


    <SNIP - No need to quote OP in first response>

    I think it's very understandable that you're not inviting him. Try not to feel bad. You're doing the right thing in putting your mam first. Your dad excluded himself from your life so both he and his partner will have to accept that a lot of water has gone under the bridge over the past two decades. If you want to mark the occasion with your father perhaps you and your wife/husband could arrange a small celebration with him and his partner. A nice resteraunt, whatever. Just something to let him know that his best wishes and congratulations matter, regardless of what's happened in the past. It's your wedding day. Enjoy it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,796 ✭✭✭✭Exclamation Marc


    Tricky situation but if both times you have met him it's been a disaster, it says it all really.

    And realistically, your wedding is you and your partners day. Have there who you want.

    Booze and a tricky relationship do not go well together and you don't want something ruining your big day. Also, if it'll upset your mum, who's been with you through the years, it's not worth sacrificing her day of pride for someone who hasn't made much of an effort with you.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,268 ✭✭✭✭uck51js9zml2yt


    Its your right to invite who you want.

    But just to add.a friend of mine found out his father was alive having been told by his mother that he left and had no interest in him. He contacted his father and found out the truth. They met for the first time the day before his wedding and they now have a relationship and him siblings.

    You could let him come to the ceremony and not the meal.
    You never know that it might start mending some fences.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 942 ✭✭✭Ghekko


    "But I still feel guilty as his partner said I'm excluding him from such an important event in my life."

    Ask her was it ok that he missed over 20 birthdays, first day at school, graduation, etc etc. They were all important events in your life so why does he want to rock up to this one so badly? I wouldn't feel guilty for not wanting to invite him. He's clearly made no effort with you when you did reunite. I can't understand why he'd want to be there when he hasn't seen or spoken to you in a year, unless it's for show. I don't know what to advise you regarding your decision but I will say that you do not need to feel a shred of guilt if you don't invite him. And his partner should keep her nose out of it! If he wants to make things up to you he shouldn't have her calling you, he should be making a huge effort all by himself.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,796 ✭✭✭✭Exclamation Marc


    You could let him come to the ceremony and not the meal.
    You never know that it might start mending some fences.

    If the father and partner are agitating to go to the ceremony, they might push to be included or come later.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,278 ✭✭✭mordeith


    No you don't have to invite him. You've got nothing to lose if he gets the hump. Have a relaxed happy wedding day instead.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,767 ✭✭✭GingerLily


    I didn't invite my 'father' to my wedding - he's a stranger, so why would I?

    Forget about the wedding - do you want a relationship with him?
    Does he make an effort?
    Do you want to?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,420 ✭✭✭splinter65


    I like the suggestion about arranging for you both to meet he and his partner for lunch instead.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,767 ✭✭✭GingerLily


    splinter65 wrote: »
    I like the suggestion about arranging for you both to meet he and his partner for lunch instead.

    Exactly, sometimes an occasion can force an issue, for the good or for worse. The underlying reason should be more then just the wedding.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,920 ✭✭✭Cash_Q


    I was at a wedding recently where the groom had his dad who raised him since birth, and his biological father who has been kind of in his life since the last few years , during which time my friend has lived abroad anyway so their face to face interactions have been minimal. His dad was in the front row, at the top table, mentioned in the ceremony and speeches, while his father was not mentioned until a token line at the end of the speeches. The father spent the entire day telling everyone who he was, annoying the photographer for family shots, was a nightmare on the dance floor and most of us suspected this man was on drugs. He spent a fair bit of the day fighting with his other biological kids that were also guests, but were not raised alongside my friend.

    This man is a stranger to you essentially. Your mother is more than likely being protective saying that she doesn't mind, but it is not appropriate that he is there when he hasn't been involved in your life, and your two interactions have already been awful and had the burden of responsibility lie with you to make It happen i.e. travelling 5 hours to meet him. His partner is being manipulative to say that you should have him there. Your wedding day is such an emotional time and you'll be so busy on the day being pulled left and right by people you love, you don't want to be distracted from that. Say he just sits in the corner - you'll feel guilty. Say he is mingling with everyone bragging about who he is - you'll be mortified. If his partner is already making you feel guilty, she's likely to cause a scene on the day if she doesn't feel there's enough attention on him.

    The idea of a lunch is nice, but I'd find it very awkward personally, and it further highlights the separation between him and your life, I wouldn't bother personally.

    As another poster says, where was he all your life? Why now does he get to step in at the most important moment?

    Put yourself, your partner and your real family first, and don't worry about what anyone else thinks.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 111 ✭✭NOVA MCMXCIV


    Well you don't have to if you don't want to. It is your day – and your happiness IS the most important thing. Having said that, just to offer an alternative point of view – is it possible that someday you might regret this? You say you feel guilty – to me anyway, this suggests that he's not a complete (insert unpleasant word here). If he was – then you wouldn't even be in a predicament – it would be VERY easy for you, i.e. he's not coming and that's that, sort of thing. I have read your post a couple of times, so have totally taken on board everything you've said – I just think that it is YOU, that should be the one to make the decision. It's easy for people on the internet to say 'f*** the old man' – but human relationships are SO complex. None of us here REALLY know anything about you – or your father.

    That's why this:


    YOU have to follow YOUR heart – and do whatever YOU FEEL is right, whatever that may be – and regardless of what anybody else thinks...

    Whatever happens – YOU'RE GONNA HAVE THE BEST DAY!!!! GOOD LUCK!!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,111 ✭✭✭SirChenjin


    Ghekko wrote: »
    "But I still feel guilty as his partner said I'm excluding him from such an important event in my life."

    Ask her was it ok that he missed over 20 birthdays, first day at school, graduation, etc etc. They were all important events in your life so why does he want to rock up to this one so badly? I wouldn't feel guilty for not wanting to invite him. He's clearly made no effort with you when you did reunite. I can't understand why he'd want to be there when he hasn't seen or spoken to you in a year, unless it's for show. I don't know what to advise you regarding your decision but I will say that you do not need to feel a shred of guilt if you don't invite him. And his partner should keep her nose out of it! If he wants to make things up to you he shouldn't have her calling you, he should be making a huge effort all by himself.

    +1 to all of this and especially the bolded part.

    You mentioned that it would upset your mother also. That would decide it for me.
    If he wants to be a part of your life after being out of it for so long, he needs to make an effort, and that -in my opinion - does not mean you being guilted into having him there for this particular day.

    I like the suggestion upthread about meeting up for lunch or something. Does he really want a relationship or just to be there on your wedding day... You are the one who has tried to create and maintain contact. And it only seems important to him / his partner (!) now because it is a big day in your life. Naw.

    What about all the other either ordinary or special days over the years, when he wasn't there? Or the days / times that maybe were tough for you or your mam?

    Forget about guilt and have a great day.


  • Administrators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 14,903 Admin ✭✭✭✭✭Big Bag of Chips


    Maybe it's the partner pushing this more than your father. Maybe his partner feels he should be there more so than him. If you invite him, do you also have to then invite his partner. If you weren't going to invite him then don't let anyone else influence you. It is a day for you and your new husband/wife to relax and enjoy surrounded by people who are happy for you and want the best for you.

    It sounds like he wants to be there (or his partner thinks he should be there) 'just because'.

    You, and your mother, have managed for over 20 years without him being there for special occasions. Why should this say be any different?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,557 ✭✭✭✭lawred2


    Ok I'm feeling guilty I'm not inviting my father to my wedding. He really wants to come I've had his partner call me to say how much it would mean to him and that he really wants to come. He said he'll sit in the back and not make any fuss but it will cause a stir.

    He left when I was a small baby had no contract what so ever for well over 20 years. He made contact a few years ago. I meet him twice since both times I had to drive 5 hrs to where he lives and both times were a disaster. We had been talking on the phone approx 1 a week until a year ago and it just fell off then. We have nothing in common and it was always me that called.

    My mam says she doesn't mind if he comes but I know it will upset her. I'm putting her feelings first. But I still feel guilty as his partner said I'm excluding him from such an important event in my life. I don't really know what to do. I am feeling guilty that I'm doing something wrong so just looking for some outside opinions please.

    Thanks

    I wouldn't feel too bad about it. Even when you did see him it was you traveling. He sounds like a selfish git.

    Tell his auld boot to keep her trap shut as well.. she's nothing to you.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,189 ✭✭✭✭Sleeper12


    When my friend got married he wanted to inv his fat that he hadn't seen since he was 4. His brothers talked him out of it as the man was violent to the mother and left with no contact. So the father wasn't invited

    A few years later the mother makes contact with her ex husband followed by the four sons. Not long after the father dies. All the family upset and all attend the funeral in another part of the country.

    To this day my friend regrets not inviting his father to the wedding.

    No one here knows you or your family. Only you can make this decision. The only advice I can give is don't forget that it is YOUR wedding. You & your partner. Your day. You should do it your way


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 851 ✭✭✭vintagecosmos


    You had to travel 5 hours to meet him.
    You would have to call.
    He isn't bothered it seems and is using the event to play the "poor me" sympathy card with his partner. My father is the same. It's all about them. He is making your special day about himself.

    He will play the victim regardless of what you do so follow your instinct. Just be prepared that if you do invite him there will be hassle over where he sits. Does he get a mention in speech. Him and his partner talking ****e.

    Go for lunch. On your terms. Not his. Will you drive 5 hours for this too? If he is genuinely interested he will make the effort. If not then remember life is too short and spend quality time with your mum instead. All the best.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,514 ✭✭✭bee06


    But I still feel guilty as his partner said I'm excluding him from such an important event in my life.

    You’re not excluding him. He excluded himself by his behaviour for your entire life. Do what your gut tells you. Don’t listen to his partner as she doesn’t have your best interests at heart.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,695 ✭✭✭December2012


    Dont deel bad about not inviting him.

    A wedding is only for close friends and family. He is not close family. He may be in the future. You not inviting him does not prevent you habing a relationship with him if thats what yiu want.

    You did not exclude him. He excluded himself by staying away.

    He cannot be your dad only when it's convenient and public.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 189 ✭✭Little Less Conversation


    Why don't you give him a reason to travel 5 hours to see you? Invite him to the wedding.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,495 ✭✭✭✭eviltwin


    He couldn't even be bothered to contact you himself. Says it all really. Personally I wouldn't even be organising a lunch. Why should you always be the accommodating one here? If he cared he'd make more of an effort.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,495 ✭✭✭✭eviltwin


    Why don't you give him a reason to travel 5 hours to see you? Invite him to the wedding.

    His child is enough of a reason, he shouldn't have to wait for a flashy event like a wedding.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,420 ✭✭✭splinter65


    eviltwin wrote: »
    His child is enough of a reason, he shouldn't have to wait for a flashy event like a wedding.

    People rewrite history as the years go by. He ran away from the responsibilities of parenthood and then stayed away using all kinds of mental gymnastics to forget that he was a father.
    Then you start imagining that it’s not that you ran away , you were “excluded” “shunned”, so, not entirely your own fault.
    It’s a short hop then to feeling that you’ve a “right” to be involved in your now adult child’s life, in particular the festive occasions. She/he needs to respect the fact that you are the other parent, and he/she should forgive , as you have forgiven.
    I have witnessed all this in my family and it never ends well.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,222 ✭✭✭✭Dial Hard


    Forget how your mother might feel, forget how he might feel - what do YOU want??? That is literally all that matters in this equation.

    And completely ignore all the "But what if you regret it in years to come???" nonsense. We can't live our lives based on abstract notions of what we might regret in later life, everyone needs to make the best decisions for themselves based on how they feel *now*. You'd drive yourself demented otherwise.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 111 ✭✭NOVA MCMXCIV


    Dial Hard wrote: »
    Forget how your mother might feel, forget how he might feel - what do YOU want??? That is literally all that matters in this equation.

    And completely ignore all the "But what if you regret it in years to come???" nonsense. We can't live our lives based on abstract notions of what we might regret in later life, everyone needs to make the best decisions for themselves based on how they feel *now*. You'd drive yourself demented otherwise.
    My words are not nonsense. People regret things. Sometimes – other people are right, sometimes we are not ready *now* for what's actually *right*. It is sensible, to consider – that one might regret this. It would be unnecessarily reckless to ignore this consideration. It's easy to say 'we can't live our lives based on abstract notions of what we might regret in later life' – when it's not your life. My words are not nonsense – nobody's' are, if we all offered the same advice – the OP wouldn't be any better off. Maybe having the question 'will you regret this?' – will make it crystal clear, that she *won't* indeed regret this? It *is* sensible, to consider – that one might regret this. It *would* be unnecessarily reckless to ignore it. The answer is within you OP. Good luck!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,854 ✭✭✭✭silverharp


    Dial Hard wrote: »
    Forget how your mother might feel, forget how he might feel - what do YOU want??? That is literally all that matters in this equation.

    And completely ignore all the "But what if you regret it in years to come???" nonsense. We can't live our lives based on abstract notions of what we might regret in later life, everyone needs to make the best decisions for themselves based on how they feel *now*. You'd drive yourself demented otherwise.

    as a rule for life i dont know about this, its tends to "feel better" avoid certain things or get the righteous dig in but when it comes to parents in particular they wont be around forever and it does hurt if you left something unresolved, nothing abstract about it

    A belief in gender identity involves a level of faith as there is nothing tangible to prove its existence which, as something divorced from the physical body, is similar to the idea of a soul. - Colette Colfer



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,695 ✭✭✭December2012


    I think a wedding day should be all about two people coming together to celebrate their love. It's not about reconciliation with absent parents if the person getting married doesn't want that


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,749 ✭✭✭Flippyfloppy


    My words are not nonsense. People regret things. Sometimes – other people are right, sometimes we are not ready *now* for what's actually *right*. It is sensible, to consider – that one might regret this. It would be unnecessarily reckless to ignore this consideration. It's easy to say 'we can't live our lives based on abstract notions of what we might regret in later life' – when it's not your life. My words are not nonsense – nobody's' are, if we all offered the same advice – the OP wouldn't be any better off. Maybe having the question 'will you regret this?' – will make it crystal clear, that she *won't* indeed regret this? It *is* sensible, to consider – that one might regret this. It *would* be unnecessarily reckless to ignore it. The answer is within you OP. Good luck!

    On the other side of the regret coin, It's very possible that OP could regret inviting him to such an intimate occasion.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,644 ✭✭✭✭punisher5112


    Op sorry to sound harsh but you owe him nothing and especially having his wife or girlfriend call you like that is not on....

    None of her business and he can feel bad all he wants, he left and had nothing to do with you.

    Sounds like he is playing the poor me trick to pull on your heart strings.


    Sad as it is it's about you and your fiance's day.

    Include all those close and don't have people that will only cause stress or just randomers.

    Ha e a great day and sure offer to meet up but let him do some work to come to you from now on.

    Put it this way if it was me I would be the one going to my child and can't honestly believe the stress he is bringing on at such a time.

    Why all of a sudden did he make contact or did you ever ask.

    Hope you all have a great wedding and try and leave all that stress behind.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,396 ✭✭✭DivingDuck


    Some things to consider:

    Would it make you feel happy to know he had been present for your wedding? If that answer to that is no, you really don't need to ask yourself any more than that. He was content enough to be no part of your life for two decades and has made no effort to bridge the gap since, so you do not owe him anything. You definitely don't owe his partner anything, and you have no information as to why she might be pushing this— her reasons could be sweet and genuine, or they could be selfish and malicious.

    If it would make you happy to know he'd been present at the wedding, its completely understandable to think about inviting him, but there are still a few other things to consider. Yes, you might regret not inviting him— But what about regretting that you did?

    Would he actually go, or is he just looking for the invite so he can feel included? If he hasn't made any effort for you all these years, why would he make one for this? If he did go, can be be trusted to remain in back like he says? Is there a possibility that he'll spoil the day? Would this be another "disaster" with the two of you meeting again? Would he get into fights with your siblings/aunts/uncles? How upset would your mother be if he were present? Does she have a partner who filled the "dad" role for you growing up, and would this hurt him? Where does your own partner stand on all of this? How does he feel about the man who has caused so much hurt for his beloved attending his wedding, and would there potentially be upset between them?

    Ultimately, you have no obligation to this man who made no effort to parent you throughout your childhood, and who has made no effort to reach out to you since. Your wedding is about celebrating the love you and your partner share in the company of those who also love you. Does that even apply to your father? Has he done anything to show he loved you, and do you feel loved by him?

    Invite him if you think it won't spoil the day and you want him there. Don't invite him if you don't genuinely want him there or you have concerns he'll detract from the enjoyment of your wedding.

    You have no obligation to do anything. He had his chance at a special day, but this one is yours.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 635 ✭✭✭heretothere


    Thanks everyone for all the responses. We've been back in contact for 5 years if a relationship hasn't developed in that time I don't think it will. I don't really think he'd cause a scene on the day I just think it'd cause a stir amongst my family.

    My fiance doesn't think I should invite him and it's his day too! He thinks it will end up upsetting me. I don't think I'll meet him for lunch it's a 10 hour round trip to get up to where he lives.

    I suppose the guilt is I'm a bit of a pleaser I don't like to be the cause of hurt for anyone. But where was he all my life I remember crying on my communion because I was convinced he would appear but the reality was he was gone to another country had another family and pretty much had forgotten I existed.

    He was near 30 when I was born he should have accepted his responsibility.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,396 ✭✭✭DivingDuck


    Its understandable to want to please people, but you have to remember: you're people, too. (As is your fiancee, and your mother.)

    Is the wedding going to be near him, or something? If he hasn't once in five years made the effort to come closer to where you live, I don't know why he'd even want an invite as surely it would be just a huge expense and hassle from his perspective.

    I'm so sorry you have to deal with this when looking forward to what should be a lovely happy day for you and yours.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,644 ✭✭✭✭punisher5112


    Thanks everyone for all the responses. We've been back in contact for 5 years if a relationship hasn't developed in that time I don't think it will. I don't really think he'd cause a scene on the day I just think it'd cause a stir amongst my family.

    My fiance doesn't think I should invite him and it's his day too! He thinks it will end up upsetting me. I don't think I'll meet him for lunch it's a 10 hour round trip to get up to where he lives.

    I suppose the guilt is I'm a bit of a pleaser I don't like to be the cause of hurt for anyone. But where was he all my life I remember crying on my communion because I was convinced he would appear but the reality was he was gone to another country had another family and pretty much had forgotten I existed.

    He was near 30 when I was born he should have accepted his responsibility.

    Very sad really is.

    I think he is very selfish to be honest playing the poor me card.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 942 ✭✭✭Ghekko


    Thanks everyone for all the responses. We've been back in contact for 5 years if a relationship hasn't developed in that time I don't think it will. I don't really think he'd cause a scene on the day I just think it'd cause a stir amongst my family.

    My fiance doesn't think I should invite him and it's his day too! He thinks it will end up upsetting me. I don't think I'll meet him for lunch it's a 10 hour round trip to get up to where he lives.

    I suppose the guilt is I'm a bit of a pleaser I don't like to be the cause of hurt for anyone. But where was he all my life I remember crying on my communion because I was convinced he would appear but the reality was he was gone to another country had another family and pretty much had forgotten I existed.

    He was near 30 when I was born he should have accepted his responsibility.


    You have listed very valid reasons not to invite him. I think at this point you know you won't invite him as the only people you would please would be him and his interfering partner and neither of them deserve that pleasure. Think of your mother who raised you and made you who you are today, your loving fiancé who has your best interests at heart, and most of all yourself. You are a caring person with that sense to please everyone. However, this time you certainly don't need to please these 2 people who are practically strangers to you. Next time you get a call from his partner let it be the one where you tell her a firm no. You don't even need to give her any explanation. Same if he bothers to call you.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,168 ✭✭✭Ursus Horribilis


    It's good that you've referred to yourself as a pleaser. From what you've told us, that's the only reason why you'd even entertain the thought of inviting your father. Sorry to put it crudely but he sounds like he has been little more than a glorified sperm donor in your life. That little anecdote about your first communion will really get up the noses of separated parents who are doing everything they can to be a part of their kids lives. A biological connection to someone does not mean that you'll live happily ever after - you already know this because of what has happened to date. I've seen threads here from people who've been very hurt because their mother/father/siblings don't want anything to do with them. It's easy for me to sit behind a screen and say "Don't invite him" because I'm not emotionally involved. Rationality often goes out the window when it comes to family matters and how people feel about relatives.

    It's telling that it was your father's partner who made the phone call. It makes me wonder who's pulling the strings here and why. It sounds more like an optics thing than a genuine interest in being there on that day. It also shows what little relationship there is between you when he can't even pick up the phone and ring you himself. I think if you invite him, he'll be a sideshow to the day even if he just sits in at the back and doesn't cause a stir. I too think your mother's being diplomatic here. I can't see why she or any other member of your family would want him there. They'll have seen what his absence did to the family over the years. Perhaps some of them will have seen your tears on First Communion Day. To some extent it'll turn into a day about him instead of what it's supposed to be about. Your wedding and your new life.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 111 ✭✭NOVA MCMXCIV


    You are all judging this man – none of us know him, or his circumstances. I'm not standing up for him – because I don't know him, but neither do you all. Yet you're assigning all these connotations and characteristics on him. Maybe he is an absolute b*stard? Maybe he's just a fool? Maybe he made a series of terrible mistakes? Maybe he's a ruthless b*stard, who consciously made these mistakes – and just doesn't care! Maybe he is a very poor communicator? Maybe he is a bad man? Maybe he is a good man? I don't know – but none of you do either!!

    The answer is within YOU OP! Good luck! And best wishes...


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,168 ✭✭✭Ursus Horribilis


    True, none of us knows the man. But, I cannot see any reason why he should come. If he was trying to patch things up with his daughter I would say yes, why not. But from what she has told us, their meetings to date have been "a disaster". They no longer speak on the phone and she was the one doing the chasing. Anybody can be a father. Being a dad is a completely different thing.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 942 ✭✭✭Ghekko


    You are all judging this man – none of us know him, or his circumstances. I'm not standing up for him – because I don't know him, but neither do you all. Yet you're assigning all these connotations and characteristics on him. Maybe he is an absolute b*stard? Maybe he's just a fool? Maybe he made a series of terrible mistakes? Maybe he's a ruthless b*stard, who consciously made these mistakes – and just doesn't care! Maybe he is a very poor communicator? Maybe he is a bad man? Maybe he is a good man? I don't know – but none of you do either!!

    The answer is within YOU OP! Good luck! And best wishes...

    Well unfortunately the op doesn't really know him either because this man made choices in his life that excluded his daughter from being a part of it. Sure we don't know anyone discussed on any thread yet many of us try to advise based on what information we are given - that's the reality of an anonymous chat forum.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,168 ✭✭✭Ursus Horribilis


    It's also telling that her fiancé doesn't think he should come either. He will have heard the stories from our OP and perhaps travelled with her to meet her father. She's a grown woman and she's free to accept or reject the advice given to her here.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 111 ✭✭NOVA MCMXCIV


    She's a grown woman and she's free to accept or reject the advice given to her here.
    This we can agree on! I'm out...

    Best wishes to all!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Hi OP I had a similar thing with my dad last year and I choose not to invite him. I had different circumstances but the lack of a healthy two way relationship was the same. At any stage if he had rang or even text I would have wobbled but he didn't and it seems your dad is getting others to do tge talking for him here as well.

    If your Dad cared enough he would make the effort to be part of your life and not just for the big moments either.

    Don't feel guilty if you don't have him there but do it for yourself not anyone else. He has time to make the effort still so why isn't he?

    This is not on you OP he can do better but is still choosing not to.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,396 ✭✭✭DivingDuck


    You are all judging this man – none of us know him, or his circumstances. I'm not standing up for him – because I don't know him, but neither do you all. Yet you're assigning all these connotations and characteristics on him. Maybe he is an absolute b*stard? Maybe he's just a fool? Maybe he made a series of terrible mistakes? Maybe he's a ruthless b*stard, who consciously made these mistakes – and just doesn't care! Maybe he is a very poor communicator? Maybe he is a bad man? Maybe he is a good man? I don't know – but none of you do either!!

    All advice requires a judgment. You are also judging the man in question, you're just finding him less guilty than the rest of us based on the fact that OP feels guilty about not inviting him. Others are focusing on the fact that she hasn't expressed any feeling of genuine desire to have him at the event.

    Nobody has told the OP that she can't invite him, they are only giving their opinion that she is entitled to choose whether to do so or not based on her feelings and her expectations and her desires rather than on his.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,495 ✭✭✭✭eviltwin


    You are all judging this man – none of us know him, or his circumstances. I'm not standing up for him – because I don't know him, but neither do you all. Yet you're assigning all these connotations and characteristics on him. Maybe he is an absolute b*stard? Maybe he's just a fool? Maybe he made a series of terrible mistakes? Maybe he's a ruthless b*stard, who consciously made these mistakes – and just doesn't care! Maybe he is a very poor communicator? Maybe he is a bad man? Maybe he is a good man? I don't know – but none of you do either!!

    The answer is within YOU OP! Good luck! And best wishes...

    I'm not judging him. I just don't believe the OP's wedding day is the appropriate setting to bring him back into the fold. It's an emotional day for everyone as it is, completely wrong place and time imho.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,128 ✭✭✭dellas1979


    Hi OP,

    All my life I was in a bad habit of being a people pleaser. "The peace keeper. Come to me with your problem, and I just about sort it out for you. I'll wear the problem. In fact, I'll make the problem mine. I'll make it all grand." Some awful things were done to me by friends/bfs//family/people, that is, until I changed my mindset to look after myself first.

    I'd take on everyone's problems and make excuses for everyone's bad behaviour. I'd conditioned myself to do this.

    Thing is, I'd forgotton about myself. What I believed. And what I wanted. As I say to myself, I had to cut the ****.

    Only you know the background of what has happened, and how you feel about the situation/him. Youve to stand up and make the decision on what you feel is best for you. Not a decision based on what would make him feel better.

    At the end of the day, our parents are just people. This guy is just a man. He doesnt hold any power over you.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 635 ✭✭✭heretothere


    I don't know him at all really. He doesn't seem like an awful guy. His other daughter who he did raise can't stand him so maybe he wasn't great but people grow and learn.

    I don't hate him, I don't really have it in me to hate anyone. The funny thing is I don't actually know if I would have been better off if he had stayed. I ended up being raised by my grandparents who I adored. But was teased by some girls in school. I remember one girl saying are you that awful that neither of your parents wanted you. But that poor girl I found out years later had a horrendous home life. No I didn't have 'parents' but I had an abundance of unconditional love and my man would visit a lot. It was just a very very small rural town and I was the only child not being raised in a traditional way. I knew 1 boy who's parents weren't together but they both lived in town.

    I'm not saying it would be easier on a child now. But def more socially acceptable


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Hi OP,

    I wanted to reply to you as I've also decided not to invite my Dad to our wedding next year.

    It's a different set of circumstances. My parents separated when I was 12 and he basically went off to live the single life while leaving us (his 3 children) with my Mum who was an abusive alcoholic. We barely saw him or heard from him.

    He's very narcissistic and I think he's more concerned now about what others will think of him not being invited rather than wanted to be there for me. I'm saying this as I'm wondering if this is what's going on for your 'Dad' too? He's more bothered that others will wonder why he isn't there and it reflects badly on him.

    It sounds to me that he doesn't really have any right to be there and you should stick to your guns. It's a deeply personal decision though. I was able to work through a lot of my issues amd guilt by seeing a counsellor. Would that be something you'd consider?

    Whatever you decide, have a brilliant day and enjoy this lovely time. Don't let it be about anyone else you and your fiancé.


  • Administrators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 14,903 Admin ✭✭✭✭✭Big Bag of Chips


    My friend uninvited her father to her wedding 20 years ago. He had been abusive to her mother, and eventually walked out on her and 5 children when they were all only small. She had little or no relationship with him after that. I was surprised when she told me she has asked him to give her away. I just assumed her mother would give her away, but 20 years ago, tradition would have still been strong. Anyway, despite having little or no relationship for the previous 15 years, once she asked him to give her away, he then started calling the shots. Told her he wouldn't sit beside her mother in the church. Demanding how the top table would be organised to suit him, and include his partner at the time.

    My friend was so so upset, in the lead up to the wedding. He basically told her if she wouldn't organise things the way he wanted then he wouldn't go. So she just said "fine", and that was that. Her mother walked her down the aisle and it was so emotional. It was just right. I think if her father had walked her down (even if he didn't cause a fuss), it would have just been a weird situation, because everybody there would have known the history of the relationship.

    Her father didn't go to her wedding, and 20 years later she has absolutely zero regrets. Her only regret is that she asked him in the first place.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,551 ✭✭✭SeaFields


    OP I have been at several weddings recently where a parent hasn't been invited. It's only a decision you can make but don't think you will be unique for not inviting a parent. People will understand that it is a difficult decision to make but will support your decision.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 774 ✭✭✭FurBabyMomma


    If he wants to go so much, why hasn't he asked you himself? How could you trust him to even show up, given the request is not coming from him directly? It's very sad that you're the one expected to do the running OP, especially when he has failed to take advantage of the last 5 years to build any sort of meaningful relationship with you.


  • Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 25,948 Mod ✭✭✭✭Neyite


    My impression is that his partner is focused on wanting people to think that he's a better dad than he actually is. That it's not about you, your relationship with your father, or his feelings on attending, that it's just that it looks bad for them if your father does not go to your wedding. That it shows people what a sh!te father he's been all your life. She's right but that's not a reason to invite him to your wedding.

    The last time you wore a white dress, he broke your heart with his disregard for you. Think carefully before you give him the chance again - at the very least, I'd expect you to hear his reasons for wanting to come from himself directly to you, not via his partner. If he really really wanted to come, he could easily pick up the phone to tell you why himself. The fact that he hasn't done that, says a lot.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,057 ✭✭✭.......


    You dont have to invite him and you dont have to feel bad about that.

    Its very cheeky of his partner to be trying to guilt you into inviting him. Just tell her that you want to spend your wedding day with the people you are close to and thats that.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement