Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Anyone tried dating agency??

  • 24-04-2018 5:21pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34


    Hello everyone, just considering joining a dating agency. Has anyone here tried one? could you recommend any?


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,145 ✭✭✭Katgurl


    Yes a few years ago. A terrible experience. I would not recommend. Tinder (or equivalent) and real-life stuff like clubs etc are a way better bet. I know they are time-consuming and frustrating but think about it; it is very rare to meet someone you connect with. How likely is it that they will be on the books of your matchmaker?

    I met my guy on tinder a couple of years later. I had to date a lit of frogs first though unfortunately.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    Katgurl wrote: »
    Yes a few years ago. A terrible experience. I would not recommend. Tinder (or equivalent) and real-life stuff like clubs etc are a way better bet. I know they are time-consuming and frustrating but think about it; it is very rare to meet someone you connect with. How likely is it that they will be on the books of your matchmaker?

    I met my guy on tinder a couple of years later. I had to date a lit of frogs first though unfortunately.


    Agree with katgul. Don't part with your hard earned cash and hand it over to these the place I regrettably used was horrendous so unprofessional so so rude and arrogant - once they take your money you'll never hear from them and if you read all the previous posts on dating agencies they more or less say the same thing. Unfortunately I didn't read them before signing up.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,131 ✭✭✭misstearheus


    Never tried Dating Agencies but I know a couple of girls who have and the common theme seems to be nightmare experience(s) and waste of money.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34 ronaldol


    Thanks guys for your replies....finding it really tough to meet people. I'm on tinder & pof for over a year & haven't even had a date


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    It's a pity single women in Ireland have such a hard time finding ways to meet men sober.

    I was set up with my other half through a mutual friend. I just don't trust myself to make an important decision like choosing a life partner unless I'm in my full senses.

    The pub scene is a whole barrel of issues. You see a fellow you like: you won't be able to hear one word out of three he says, so you won't have a clue about his personality.

    Making the move: do you stand there passively making goo-goo eyes? Do you brazenly walk up and pray he's not waiting for his girlfriend? What if you're not up to his standards and he shakes his head at you? Worse, what if you're not up to his standards but he just wants to use you for practice then stops calling?

    Your friends are probably there, and so are his, so you're both going to be nervous about getting shot down.

    There's a man behind the bar selling ethanol mixed nicely which will reduce your anxiety but also wreck your ability to make sensible decisions.

    So, two drunk anxious people, who can't hear each other speak, being judged by their social circles, trying to figure out if they should try to start a process that has the ultimate aim of merging their lives together.

    And that's the very best we can do? That's the pinnacle of the Irish way of forming romances?

    I hope our culture eventually manages to find a better way.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    ronaldol wrote: »
    Thanks guys for your replies....finding it really tough to meet people. I'm on tinder & pof for over a year & haven't even had a date

    There's a really huge girl at work, no oil painting even if she lost all the weight. She met her husband on pof and they've just announced she's having their second baba.

    I'm not saying you're doing anything wrong, some people just click well, and pof doesn't deserve any other credit than helping them meet, all the rest was done by the two people.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    This is what drives girls like myself to these so called matchmakers who take complete advantage of the situation
    Going out for a drink is lovely if it was just that. But 4/5 pubs later and it just begins to feel like actual work - all I want is to be at home curled up under my bed covers. The pub scene takes a lot of energy, between blaring music, being pushed and shoved and don't even get me started on trying to order a drink at the bar...it's not my cup of tea but I do it as what's the alternative?...Saturday night with Miriam...No thanks
    I have tried the whole taking evening classes, joining a gym, volunteering, online dating and it's just never led me to anything in terms of meeting fellas

    It was so much easier in my college days and early on in my working career whereby you're part of a big institution and can 'spot' other guys on a regular basis. Not just a quick glance in a bar whilst passing by each other and then never to be seen again.

    Now I just focus being in the present as I've spent way too long worrying about how, where, when, who - whatever will be will be


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    This is what drives girls like myself to these so called matchmakers who take complete advantage of the situation
    Going out for a drink is lovely if it was just that. But 4/5 pubs later and it just begins to feel like actual work - all I want is to be at home curled up under my bed covers. The pub scene takes a lot of energy, between blaring music, being pushed and shoved and don't even get me started on trying to order a drink at the bar...it's not my cup of tea but I do it as what's the alternative?...Saturday night with Miriam...No thanks
    I have tried the whole taking evening classes, joining a gym, volunteering, online dating and it's just never led me to anything in terms of meeting fellas

    It was so much easier in my college days and early on in my working career whereby you're part of a big institution and can 'spot' other guys on a regular basis. Not just a quick glance in a bar whilst passing by each other and then never to be seen again.

    Now I just focus being in the present as I've spent way too long worrying about how, where, when, who - whatever will be will be

    Just wondering, were there no fellas at all who wanted to meet you?

    Some men are really good at picking up women in a bar setting, they have a loud voice, confident body language and are usually easy on the eyes.

    I don't know why these men would do online dating. So if you want one of these men, you'll have to go to the places they do.

    Don't answer unless you are totally comfortable. Or do, you're in charge.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    With the pub scene I get chatted up and a number of times have been asked for my number but no follow through...then of course with some I just wouldn't be giving my number to them
    As for online dating I dabbled with it but probably gave up too soon. But again it suits some people and works for them but not for others


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    With the pub scene I get chatted up and a number of times have been asked for my number but no follow through...then of course with some I just wouldn't be giving my number to them
    As for online dating I dabbled with it but probably gave up too soon. But again it suits some people and works for them but not for others


    Here's an idea, and don't throw it out the window before you have chewed it over for a week or two: how about you exchange numbers with the next guy who you like the look of?

    Then, wait a week, and text him a suggestion for a date.

    I coached my cousin when he was a shy lad, and one thing he often said was it's awful that women don't want to take the initiative, but still behave like prim little ladies from a Jane Austen book. Not accusing you of this, but it's certainly a thing that plenty of Irish women do.

    I've heard so many girls say, "why won't he make a pass?" and not seem to realise that it's the 21st century and that's not the only way any more.

    We're out of the old days now, and probably a lot of men want women with a go-getter attitude to life. Men have to be careful not to connect with a life partner that is too passive to operate well in these modern, demanding times.

    It is totally OK to decide you want the men to make the first move, if that is your preference. I won't tell you what to do. You know what you want better than anyone.

    But there are some men who like a woman who goes for what she wants (romantically, I mean. I don't mean you have to be easy to get into bed!).

    So if you are open to the idea of making a move, you will expand the number of possible partners for yourself.

    And remember that this is all with the aim of finding a life partner. It makes sense that you will have to have a few series of dates with different fellas before you hit the jackpot with the guy who likes you as much as you like him.

    Have you seen old, badly matched couples? That's not a good road.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 41 swaner


    Katgurl wrote: »
    Yes a few years ago. A terrible experience. I would not recommend. Tinder (or equivalent) and real-life stuff like clubs etc are a way better bet. I know they are time-consuming and frustrating but think about it; it is very rare to meet someone you connect with. How likely is it that they will be on the books of your matchmaker?

    I met my guy on tinder a couple of years later. I had to date a lit of frogs first though unfortunately.

    Exactly, I was involved in such thing, because of a friend of mine, so sharing your experience.
    Hookup sites (http://onenightstand1.com/sex-hookup-sites) and apps like Tinder, Bumble, Down, Pure, etc can do a much better job and most of them is free to use...
    Or simple examining social circles of your friends on FaceBook can do sometimes a job...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    swaner wrote: »
    Exactly, I was involved in such thing, because of a friend of mine, so sharing your experience.
    Hookup sites (http://onenightstand1.com/sex-hookup-sites) and apps like Tinder, Bumble, Down, Pure, etc can do a much better job and most of them is free to use...
    Or simple examining social circles of your friends on FaceBook can do sometimes a job...

    The problem there is that Tinder filters out all the people who don't photograph well, or just don't know how to take a good picture. Lots of men look a lot better in person than on a phone screen.

    By depending on Tinder instead of real life, you're also going up against harder competition. If you meet a person in real life, you can let your personality and body language help you.

    But on Tinder, he may get another match with a boring, stupid cold-hearted girl who just looks amazing on a phone screen.

    I'd bet huge money that couples who met on Tinder will have vastly more divorces than couples who met face-to-face.

    Does anyone think the opposite?

    In short, join whatever agency or website that helps you see people for the first time in real life, face to face. Use Tinder for casual, first-date sex, if that is what you enjoy, because that's what it is for. It's a gay men's casual sex app for people with the desire for immediate, anonymous, relationship-free sex.

    That's not me, and I don't think it's for many women on boards.ie. For a few nymphomaniacs, it is perfect, but those girls know how to pick men up in real life too. And the men who do well on Tinder are very eager to meet the nymphos. Nymphos are much more likely to be able to do all the complicated tricks that porn actresses do. I would need years of yoga and fitness training to do that stuff, even if I was so inclined.

    I'm saying: social media is only good as an introduction. If you actually want to select a guy without meeting him first, you have to accept that the chances of it going badly are much higher.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,145 ✭✭✭Katgurl


    erudec wrote: »
    The problem there is that Tinder filters out all the people who don't photograph well, or just don't know how to take a good picture. Lots of men look a lot better in person than on a phone screen.

    By depending on Tinder instead of real life, you're also going up against harder competition. If you meet a person in real life, you can let your personality and body language help you.

    But on Tinder, he may get another match with a boring, stupid cold-hearted girl who just looks amazing on a phone screen.

    I'd bet huge money that couples who met on Tinder will have vastly more divorces than couples who met face-to-face.

    Does anyone think the opposite?

    In short, join whatever agency or website that helps you see people for the first time in real life, face to face. Use Tinder for casual, first-date sex, if that is what you enjoy, because that's what it is for. It's a gay men's casual sex app for people with the desire for immediate, anonymous, relationship-free sex.

    That's not me, and I don't think it's for many women on boards.ie. For a few nymphomaniacs, it is perfect, but those girls know how to pick men up in real life too. And the men who do well on Tinder are very eager to meet the nymphos. Nymphos are much more likely to be able to do all the complicated tricks that porn actresses do. I would need years of yoga and fitness training to do that stuff, even if I was so inclined.

    I'm saying: social media is only good as an introduction. If you actually want to select a guy without meeting him first, you have to accept that the chances of it going badly are much higher.

    I don't agree with this. Tinder doesn't have to replace real life. The two aren't mutually exclusive. I wasn't interested in hookups so i made that clear. I met guys IRL but just happened to meet my boyfriend on tinder. (Granted, he had a few casual encounters on it before me.)

    When using tinder i was quite open-minded about the pics but ruthless about the messaging. If they didnt catch my attention / tried to make the conversation sexual early on in used the unmatch function. It's better to get a date organised quite quickly I'm if he looks and sounds interesting. No need to go sharing all your personal info or innermost thoughts, just see do you have rapport.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    Guys want speed on dating sites, whereas women want comfort. The two things don't align. Feeling like you're just a number and you've received a cut-and-copy message or an uninventive "hi how are you" is about as romantic as a hole in the head. So women hate online dating, and men hate online dating because the women don't respond (wonder why) and they can't get the dates fast enough.

    I've only ever had luck with it when I set my own standards with the fella and spent some time building a rapport before meeting. I wouldn't let him move it to whatsapp within seconds of exchanging messages and wouldn't agree to meet after 5 messages. Instead, I've have a few messages to see if I could get a real conversation going beyond "how long have you been single", and if I could (most of the time - nope!) I'd ask the lad for his email and continue the conversation there. Build a bit of rapport and ask him to call me if he's interested in a date. If he didn't call, he wouldn't get the date. If he did, we'd chat and see if there was any level of interesting engagement, and based on that, if I liked the sound of him, we'd set a date.

    That way at least you know you've got a bit of banter with the guy and even if there's no spark, at least you're spending a few hours with an interesting person. As opposed to that "jesus how do i get out of this one" that frequently used to happen when i let a lad shoehorn me into a date after 5 minutes of "hi how are you" "fine, you"...zzzzz

    So in summary, whether it's a dating agency or tinder or pof or whatever, it's very much about your approach. Don't put in the time to do some screening and to actually build a connection and you'll meet every boring chancer in the book.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Guys want speed on dating sites, whereas women want comfort. The two things don't align. Feeling like you're just a number and you've received a cut-and-copy message or an uninventive "hi how are you" is about as romantic as a hole in the head.

    Not everyone can be a wordsmith. That's why I don't recommend social media except as a means of meeting people in real life. I think meetups should be where it's at.

    If you can't see a person in real life, you won't know if you have chemistry.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    You got me thinking there and I realise I did pluck up the courage in the past to go pursue a couple of guys I was keen on. We were working in the same organisation but because it didn't lead to anything romantically I thought maybe it's the guys who like to do the chasing as I suppose I had high expectations (would have been egged on by others as they too seemed to think there was potential for something to blossom) ....but alas no joy so I said to myself 'right I gave that a go but ain't chasing after any guy anymore'
    It can deflate your confidence especially with the ones who you might be bumping into at your workplace - but I do have to say it hasn't left me scarred unlike other avenues I've explored!
    I once got talking to a really lovely guy in a pub in Dublin few years back by pure accident it was very busy and packed and as I was passing him I asked if he knew where the loos were located. But as it happened he was in the same boat and we just hit it off. Both up from the country for the night and it just seemed to have a good flow to it. Unfortunately I was then duped by a friend of mine at the time who I brought into the conversation but who then decided to ask him straight out which one of us was he interested in (when I did eventually get to go the bathroom)
    So I came back to a very different scenario.
    Anyways my point is I have stepped up and made first move but probably in a subtle way but not in last year.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    I once got talking to a really lovely guy in a pub in Dublin few years back by pure accident it was very busy and packed and as I was passing him I asked if he knew where the loos were located. But as it happened he was in the same boat and we just hit it off. Both up from the country for the night and it just seemed to have a good flow to it. Unfortunately I was then duped by a friend of mine at the time who I brought into the conversation but who then decided to ask him straight out which one of us was he interested in (when I did eventually get to go the bathroom)
    So I came back to a very different scenario.
    Anyways my point is I have stepped up and made first move but probably in a subtle way but not in last year.

    If the "very different scenario" was the "really lovely guy" shifting your "friend" then he wasn't really lovely and she certainly isn't your friend.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    No Enme that wasn't the case but she made sure she was fully in the picture when she got me gone and like I said we we're friends at the time but unfortunately some people don't know the true meaning of that.
    I was responding to a post from Erudec about girls approaching guys in social settings but I guess it highlights other problems you are faced with on these nights out..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 41 swaner


    Katgurl wrote: »
    erudec wrote: »
    The problem there is that Tinder filters out all the people who don't photograph well, or just don't know how to take a good picture. Lots of men look a lot better in person than on a phone screen.

    By depending on Tinder instead of real life, you're also going up against harder competition. If you meet a person in real life, you can let your personality and body language help you.

    But on Tinder, he may get another match with a boring, stupid cold-hearted girl who just looks amazing on a phone screen.

    I'd bet huge money that couples who met on Tinder will have vastly more divorces than couples who met face-to-face.

    Does anyone think the opposite?

    In short, join whatever agency or website that helps you see people for the first time in real life, face to face. Use Tinder for casual, first-date sex, if that is what you enjoy, because that's what it is for. It's a gay men's casual sex app for people with the desire for immediate, anonymous, relationship-free sex.

    That's not me, and I don't think it's for many women on boards.ie. For a few nymphomaniacs, it is perfect, but those girls know how to pick men up in real life too. And the men who do well on Tinder are very eager to meet the nymphos. Nymphos are much more likely to be able to do all the complicated tricks that porn actresses do. I would need years of yoga and fitness training to do that stuff, even if I was so inclined.  

    I'm saying: social media is only good as an introduction. If you actually want to select a guy without meeting him first, you have to accept that the chances of it going badly are much higher.

    I don't agree with this. Tinder doesn't have to replace real life. The two aren't mutually exclusive. I wasn't interested in hookups so i made that clear. I met guys IRL but just happened to meet my boyfriend on tinder. (Granted, he had a few casual encounters on it before me.)

    When using tinder i was quite open-minded about the pics but ruthless about the messaging. If they didnt catch my attention / tried to make the conversation sexual  early on in used the unmatch function. It's better to get a date organised quite quickly I'm if he looks and sounds interesting. No need to go sharing all your personal info or innermost thoughts, just see do you have rapport.
     That is "positive" usage of Tinder I would say ... :) I mean better than other people (women) using it... :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,192 ✭✭✭TeaBagMania


    I came to the ladies lounge looking for ideas or the best places I should go to meet an Irish wife. its difficult when your only in county a few weeks a year on holiday.

    its been mentioned before but id like to reiterate going to the Gym.
    I have met the most down to earth and best quality people at the gym as well as multiple opportunity to make new partners or wife if I so desired.
    Give it a try, and a positive side effect is better health, its a win win situation

    so what's the lowdown on the match making festivals? is it legit or just a reason to get smashed and have a laugh


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    I've been going to the gym for decades and have yet to actually meet or befriend anyone in there. An independent gym and a regular group fitness class outside of that. I could think of nothing worse than using it as stalking grounds for my dating life! I'm big into my fitness and like to use it as my me-time and to focus on that. I find most people are the same - they'll smile and be friendly but are very much there to get the job done.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,192 ✭✭✭TeaBagMania


    Maybe Ireland is different in that respect. My experience has been just the opposite.

    Almost everyone is up for a short chat between set's, however, there are a few diehard focused people that just don't want to have a conversation but they are ulta rare.

    I think "stalking ground" is a bit extreme, just be yourself and you'll find many friends


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    Maybe Ireland is different in that respect. My experience has been just the opposite.

    Almost everyone is up for a short chat between set's, however, there are a few diehard focused people that just don't want to have a conversation but they are ulta rare.

    I think "stalking ground" is a bit extreme, just be yourself and you'll find many friends

    I just wouldn't venture into a workout with the aim of meeting someone is all. My experience of the gym is that most people are the same. Earphones in, endorphins flowing, head elsewhere. Job done and leave. I'm by no means a hardcore fitness fanatic, and there'll sometimes be a bit of friendliness at the water fountain or some advice from someone who clearly knows their sh1.t. But I wouldn't factor it in when I'm trying to expand my dating horizons.

    Some of the group fitness classes can be more social, I go to one that has a pretty active social media platform and there's always brunches happening etc. But they tend to be at least 80% female in my experience so not an option as far as meeting men goes!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    Calling all single ladies in the ladies lounge we need to come up with a plan for uniting people wanting the same thing !!!!??
    Forget your speed dating and matchmaking agencies - something else must be waiting to be explored - shouldn't be this hard
    Anyone into events planning !!?? ;-)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    Calling all single ladies in the ladies lounge we need to come up with a plan for uniting people wanting the same thing !!!!??
    Forget your speed dating and matchmaking agencies - something else must be waiting to be explored - shouldn't be this hard
    Anyone into events planning !!?? ;-)

    In my experience most singles events turn out to be 80% female no matter how much effort is put into getting men to attend.

    I haven't heard much good about matchmaking agencies but they can only work with what they get - a wide variety of accomplished women and very few men to go around.

    Once guys pass their 20s they become very eligible. If you were such a guy and you were reasonably sociable, had a job and didn't frighten the horses, so to speak, why would you need to join a dating agency? If you were single you might get matched with friends of your sisters / female cousins / work colleagues etc. A single man of a certain age is always in demand. Unless a man was very shy, lived in a remote area or had other problems which impaired dating (hygiene problems, bad personality etc.) he would have no need to fork out the guts of a grand to join a dating agency. That is why women have such dire experiences with dating agencies. The men just aren't there.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,192 ✭✭✭TeaBagMania


    Emme wrote: »
    In my experience most singles events turn out to be 80% female no matter how much effort is put into getting men to attend.

    sounds just like the kind of event im looking for :D how do I go about finding them?
    Emme wrote: »
    and didn't frighten the horses, so to speak

    This made me literally laugh out loud, that one goes in the vault


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    sounds just like the kind of event im looking for :D how do I go about finding them?

    Join a meetup group that organises nighttime and weekend events for drinks and dancing. New friends and lots of crack guaranteed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6 NobleBlack


    Most couples meet online and got married.... It works for some people ams don't work for some...

    In online dating, you may end up in hooking up with someone who only wants to use you and not truly in love with you.

    So you have to be careful on online dating.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Emme wrote: »
    he would have no need to fork out the guts of a grand to join a dating agency. That is why women have such dire experiences with dating agencies. The men just aren't there.

    (Jaw drops)

    H... how much?

    Going to meetups is free. And you meet the men directly. Cripes!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Emme wrote: »
    A single man of a certain age is always in demand.

    Most winos are single, and I am not so sure they are in demand, regardless of age.

    I think you may be omitting certain unspoken socio-economic requirements that the man must fulfill before he will actually have more than one woman interested in him.
    Emme wrote: »
    . The men just aren't there.

    For every single woman, it is statistically almost inevitable that there will be a single man.

    The idea that there isn't a single man out there for virtually every woman is nearly certain to be untrue.

    That said, what could be messing it up is stupid requirements on both sides. Like if I ended up single but said "I won't consider dating anyone other than Justin Bieber" I'd most likely stay single.

    But once both parties accept that people of their generation are going to have aged and that intolerance of physical imperfections is not going to lead to a happy love life, it theoretically shouldn't be much harder than putting people in the same room and ensuring that the music is low enough so that people can hear each other.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Here's a simple scenario, that should be free or at least low-cost. Anyone who likes can take the idea and put it into practice.

    Set up a meetup group. It's free.

    Specify that it's for people who want to meet others with the intention of finding a romantic partner. Not just purely friendly non-romantic craic. Literally all of the other meetup groups are for craic, so you're spoiled for choice if you want craic and also aren't looking.

    No matchmakers, but you will have people who lead icebreaking games (you can download hundreds online for free, some are fun and they all help promote human interaction which is the name of the game).

    All the women wear a 2-digit odd number badge, very clearly written, big numbers. Men wear an even number badge, avoid sixes and nines, or just use one or the other. All sevens must have a stroke in them to tell them apart from ones.

    At some point in the evening, everyone gets a bit of paper with their number on it. They put the number of the person they like in a sealed box. If they don't like anyone they write 00.

    The sealed box is later opened by someone who wasn't there, and doesn't know who the numbers refer to. He counts up the matches and makes arrangements to link up the people who matched, without knowing who they are. Then he burns or pulps the paper when done.

    So you're good for data protection, because nobody has identifying information, and nobody is humiliated in public by making a move and being rejected.

    It doesn't need to cost any money, or at least not much money. If every participant pays three euro, that should fairly reward the person who matches up the numbers and sends the messages. If it's an organised person, he should be able to send the matches out online easily enough within two hours.

    It's easy to send password protected messages.

    This takes care of all the essentials: you meet people who are looking, you get a clear chance to express interest without public humiliation, you can completely see and hear them, and your privacy is very well guarded, and only tiny amounts of money are involved.

    This is a trivially easy problem, it seems.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    Isn't that essentially how speed dating works?

    I'd suspect there wouldn't be a whole sea of matches anyway, with all the fellas going for the same hot girl and all the girls going for the same eligible bachelor :pac:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Isn't that essentially how speed dating works?

    I'd suspect there wouldn't be a whole sea of matches anyway, with all the fellas going for the same hot girl and all the girls going for the same eligible bachelor :pac:

    Not a difficult fix: every participant can only be chosen by 3 people. It requires a little bit more planning, but you can make it so that the sexiest people are maxed out quickly and people have to look at the middle-rank folks. And you can preserve anonymity too.

    There's some common sense that has to be applied. If it's a bunch of middle-aged ladies plus Katy Perry, maybe this isn't the right place for Katy.

    You can discourage extreme front-runners (whose motives might be a bit suspect if they're sniffing around people who are far below their league) in a lot of creative ways.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    erudec wrote: »
    Not a difficult fix: every participant can only be chosen by 3 people. It requires a little bit more planning, but you can make it so that the sexiest people are maxed out quickly and people have to look at the middle-rank folks. And you can preserve anonymity too.

    There's some common sense that has to be applied. If it's a bunch of middle-aged ladies plus Katy Perry, maybe this isn't the right place for Katy.

    You can discourage extreme front-runners (whose motives might be a bit suspect if they're sniffing around people who are far below their league) in a lot of creative ways.

    Fair enough. It doesn't eliminate the possibility of Mr Man-of-my-Dreams from being disqualified though because he wasn't lucky number 1, 2 or 3 who was quick enough to choose me (assuming I'm a massive ride...a correct assumption :D)

    I guess the reality is that you won't get the Katy Perrys of the world at these kinds of events, but if you take tinder as an example, online apps are littered with all levels of attractive folks in both genders and that really muddies the waters as far as the perceived "choice" that people think they have versus the actual reality.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    Calling all single ladies in the ladies lounge we need to come up with a plan for uniting people wanting the same thing !!!!??
    Forget your speed dating and matchmaking agencies - something else must be waiting to be explored - shouldn't be this hard
    Anyone into events planning !!?? ;-)

    Well, I'm off the market but I don't like seeing people single against their will ( because I didn't particularly like it myself) so I am all for people grasping the nettle.

    Go out and help arrange to kiss a few frogs before you meet your prince! Or, failing that, your Michael Jackson.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    And you sounded like a great catch !!!!

    Ya I think when I wrote that I was having a moment of optimism but I think the already existing Meet up groups is the way to go...I have signed up and if I go to a few and get to know some other members, then maybe getting an event organised through that channel is better, certainly not beyond the realms of possibility

    Watch this space 😬


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    And you sounded like a great catch !!!!

    Ya I think when I wrote that I was having a moment of optimism but I think the already existing Meet up groups is the way to go...I have signed up and if I go to a few and get to know some other members, then maybe getting an event organised through that channel is better, certainly not beyond the realms of possibility

    Watch this space 😬

    Knock 'em dead, don't be too shy, treat it like an adventure and take precautions!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    erudec wrote: »
    Knock 'em dead, don't be too shy, treat it like an adventure and take precautions!

    Meetup is for making friends, it isn't a knocking shop. There's plenty of that on Tinder.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Emme wrote: »
    Meetup is for making friends, it isn't a knocking shop. There's plenty of that on Tinder.

    That's very much down to every individual person at every individual meetup. Unless they require you to physically sign a "NO ROMANCES PERMITTED" document and pay a fee, there's no substance to what you say.

    I do hope that Joyless Puritanism has its own separate meetup from everyone else, though.

    It must be awful to be around happy people.

    As I said, using Tinder to find a long-term relationship is like trying to cut down a tree with a screwdriver. You might be able to manage it, but it's not the right tool for the job. It's a straightforward copy of a gay male anonymous sex app, which isn't really what most women, straight or gay, are looking for.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    Okay ladies I'll think we'll have to agree to disagree. I have never tried meetup groups so I am just casting my net a bit further.
    It's something for people like myself who have limited amount of single friends left to go out with anymore but I also like to "get out" and do stuff! Rather than be indoors on the Internet hoping to hit the jackpot !!
    I'm not knocking either and I do believe it's down to the individual and what their comfortable with.
    Peace out 😊





    Sent from my iPhone


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    Okay ladies I'll think we'll have to agree to disagree. I have never tried meetup groups so I am just casting my net a bit further.
    It's something for people like myself who have limited amount of single friends left to go out with anymore but I also like to "get out" and do stuff! Rather than be indoors on the Internet hoping to hit the jackpot !!
    I'm not knocking either and I do believe it's down to the individual and what their comfortable with.
    Peace out 😊

    Sent from my iPhone
    Go for it, sweetie!

    A few more random thoughts about Tinder:

    If you use Tinder you will absolutely certainly meet men on it. Just remember that all the other women on Tinder can also see the same men that you like, and unless you have extremely unusual tastes in men, a very large group of other women on Tinder will probably be as interested in him as you are.

    Women are not like men. When we find a very large group of men show an interest in us, most of us are not inclined to have sex with all of them one after the other, or at the same time.

    With men however, rather a lot of them want to do precisely that, subconsciously at least. Indeed, the men who have no interest at all in doing that seem to be a minority.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    Thanks !!
    Think I have enough knowledge now and as they say forewarned is to be forearmed.
    Good to get different perspectives on this as sometimes you wonder what your doing wrong.
    Appreciate all the advise/comments ....should have joined boards years ago!!??


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    Thanks !!
    Think I have enough knowledge now and as they say forewarned is to be forearmed.
    Good to get different perspectives on this as sometimes you wonder what your doing wrong.
    Appreciate all the advise/comments ....should have joined boards years ago!!??

    ;)

    Regrets are like hot potatoes: the longer you hold on to them the less happy you'll be.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    erudec wrote: »
    I do hope that Joyless Puritanism has its own separate meetup from everyone else, though.

    The people I know in meetup didn't initially join to meet a partner. Later on they might have got together with someone but it was a bonus. But they also had made a great bunch of friends.

    It is so obvious when somebody comes to meetup with the sole aim of meeting a partner. It's a source of amusement to the long standing members of some groups. The guy who gets drunk and comes onto every woman the first meetup he goes to or the girls who only talk to the guys in the group they would like to date.
    erudec wrote: »
    It must be awful to be around happy people.

    In my experience the happiest people in meetup are those who joined to make friends and have no other agenda. The most miserable are those who joined it first and foremost to meet a partner.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭erudec


    Emme wrote: »
    The people I know in meetup didn't initially join to meet a partner. .

    If they did, do you really think that you're the type of person whom they'd be comfortable enough to open up to?

    I'm guessing they'd be afraid of you shaming them for the crime of wanting to find love.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    erudec wrote: »
    If they did, do you really think that you're the type of person whom they'd be comfortable enough to open up to?

    I'm guessing they'd be afraid of you shaming them for the crime of wanting to find love.

    Wanting to find love isn't a crime but there are faster and more pragmatic ways to happiness and fulfilment. Some of us would prefer to get on with life and not waste time chasing rainbows.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    I'm all for people living their lives to the max and doing whatever it takes to get on and be happy with or without a partner.
    But that doesn't mean it's wrong to want to try and find other ways of potentially meeting someone if you feel like getting back out there. It's not my lifelong goal but I can't say


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 11 Mags2018


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    I'm all for people living their lives to the max and doing whatever it takes to get on and be happy with or without a partner.
    But that doesn't mean it's wrong to want to try and find other ways of potentially meeting someone if you feel like getting back out there. It's not my lifelong goal but I can't say

    I will rule it out for the rest of my life either


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1 Tramco1234


    Mags2018 wrote: »
    Agree with katgul. Don't part with your hard earned cash and hand it over to these the place I regrettably used was horrendous so unprofessional so so rude and arrogant - once they take your money you'll never hear from them and if you read all the previous posts on dating agencies they more or less say the same thing. Unfortunately I didn't read them before signing up.

    I also signed up with a dating agency and parted with a lot of money. I feel so upset about the whole experience. I was supposed to have 5 dates but after 7 months I went on one date.
    It all seems very suspect and the guy who deals with you over the phone is extremely aggressive and intimidating. When I spoke about being unhappy about having one date and the only other potential date being with a man who lived almost 3 hours away he scoffed and said I had unrealistic expectations and that I clearly didn’t listen when he first gave his pitch. The whole thing seems like a scam. He told me they arrange a hundred dates a week. I can’t understand why I haven’t had more than one if that’s the case.
    Sorry for the rant here but I’ve been so upset and it seems like there’s very little that can be done about how I’ve been treated. When I tried to find reviews about their agency I couldn’t find this thread. I wish I saw it before I signed up. I wish there was a way people could find these reviews easier and save themselves the cash and humiliation. This agency in particular prey on people’s vulnerability. It’s just wrong.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 41 swaner


    Tramco1234 wrote: »
    I also signed up with a dating agency and parted with a lot of money. I feel so upset about the whole experience. I was supposed to have 5 dates but after 7 months I went on one date.
    It all seems very suspect and the guy who deals with you over the phone is extremely aggressive and intimidating. When I spoke about being unhappy about having one date and the only other potential date being with a man who lived almost 3 hours away he scoffed and said I had unrealistic expectations and that I clearly didn’t listen when he first gave his pitch. The whole thing seems like a scam. He told me they arrange a hundred dates a week. I can’t understand why I haven’t had more than one if that’s the case.
    Sorry for the rant here but I’ve been so upset and it seems like there’s very little that can be done about how I’ve been treated. When I tried to find reviews about their agency I couldn’t find this thread. I wish I saw it before I signed up. I wish there was a way people could find these reviews easier and save themselves the cash and humiliation. This agency in particular prey on people’s vulnerability. It’s just wrong.

    I am sorry because of your bad experience, but in this of all those hookup apps and casual sex sites, why You need "dating agency"? I am just curious? Simply, no matter are you looking for a date or sex, today it is easier than ever thanks to technology. You have dating, casual sex, and their sites and apps, but you can use whatever you want for every intention you may have no matter is that seeking a relationship, sex, or friends... Just my 2 cents.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement