De Gea VS Joe Hart

Take Your Pants Off

Who is better Joe Hart or De Gea Overall.
I just want peoples opinions on what they think, I am having a debate with my friends and what to know what the people of boards.ie think.

El Horseboxo

Take Your Pants Off wrote: »

Who is better Joe Hart or De Gea Overall.
I just want peoples opinions on what they think, I am having a debate with my friends and what to know what the people of boards.ie think.

Better at what?

stampydmonkey

No competition...Mignolet wins....(its letting goals in yeah?)


...Dea Gea anyday btw

Donnielighto

De Gea would win in a fight.

Take Your Pants Off

El Horseboxo wrote: »

Better at what?

General Goalkeeper

PhlegmyMoses

Hoe Hart is better at ridding himself of disgusting dandruff.

De Gea is better at growing a neck beard.

Ryu Hayabusa

Joe Hart is a more complete goalkeeper

De Gea is afraid of the high ball, physically weak and unable to command his defence.

Blue giant

Is this a serious question? It's not even close. De Gea is on another level to Hart.

Dave0301

Ryu Hayabusa wrote: »

Joe Hart is a more complete goalkeeper

De Gea is afraid of the high ball, physically weak and unable to command his defence.

Haha. Love it!

LuckyLloyd

Hart is an average enough top level keeper.

De Gea is easily superior.

Skylinehead

:pac:

Diabhal Beag

Joe Hart is the best worst goalkeeper ever IMO. Second place goes to Fabien Barthez.

Cienciano

Do a poll. De Gea is better by a long way, Hart has his good games but is at fault for an amazing amount of goals.

Johner

Hart is a very good keeper but De Gea is younger and better at almost everything.

bad2dabone

De gea.

He's also improving, hart has plateaued

If you think Hart is better you're just wrong

Liam O

I thought Hart was quite good when he got back into City's team last season. Back to normal this season though.

De Gea has been the best keeper in the league the last 3 seasons.

Paul Tergat

De Gea is the obvious answer here.

Not been best in the league for the last 3 seasons though ^^^

Kirby

Ryu Hayabusa wrote: »

Joe Hart is a more complete goalkeeper

De Gea is afraid of the high ball, physically weak and unable to command his defence.

Have we transported back in time to 2012? Why didn't anybody tell me! I could have bet on stuff! :mad:

LuckyLloyd

Ryu Hayabusa wrote: »

Joe Hart is a more complete goalkeeper

De Gea is afraid of the high ball, physically weak and unable to command his defence.

Gareth Bale is an average enough left back, needs to leave Spurs for a club that might give him a few games further up the pitch imo.

monkey9

I voted for Joe Hart by mistake. De Gea is far far better.

Cantona's Collars

Ryu Hayabusa wrote: »

Joe Hart is a more complete goalkeeper

De Gea is afraid of the high ball, physically weak and unable to command his defence.

Guess who hasn't dropped one ball this season? It wasn't Hart.

Paully D

De Gea and it's really not close.

COYVB

It's not even close, De Gea by an absolute mile

jaykay74

I don't see Madrid chasing Hart or anyone else linked to him either

OctavarIan

Two years ago they were closer but De Gea has since far surpassed Hart.

Fuhrer

Hart hit his peak a few years back, De Gea is better then him now and is getting better all the time.

Look at his stats for last year(When he was also better than Hart) compared to this year in regards to the amount of times he catches the ball rather than punches it.

Essien

De Gea vs Courtois would be worthy of debate.

This just isn't.

darced

This post has been deleted.

SantryRed

darced wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

Joe Hart is a standard PL goalkeeper. He's still overrated by the English press.

COYVB

Brad Guzan is better than Joe Hart

Nalz

De Gea is the second best keeper in the PL

Hart is not even in the top 5

GavRedKing

Option C, Courtois

But for this debate its de gea IMO, younger, better and doesnt make stupid charges out no more like he did in seasons gone by that leave him horribly exposed.

Hes well used the EPL now so doesnt make as many mistakes and commands his defence and box a lot better.

Nailz

Hart isn't even the best English goalkeeper in the league, Forster is better. But yeah, De Gea is in the top 3 goalkeepers in the world, up there with Courtois and Neuer, not quite as good but getting there on Neuer IMO.

Take Your Pants Off

De Gea better then Lloris ?
I think De Gea is in top 4.
I cannot put him in top 3, just because of 1 good season.

Nailz

Take Your Pants Off wrote: »

De Gea better then Lloris ?
I think De Gea is in top 4.

I think he's better than loris, definitely. Lloris has Shay Given syndrome that he never comes for highballs more than 4 yards out from goal, for a lad of his frame that's a poor trait.

Take Your Pants Off wrote: »

I cannot put him in top 3, just because of 1 good season.

:pac:

Liam O

Take Your Pants Off wrote: »

De Gea better then Lloris ?
I think De Gea is in top 4.
I cannot put him in top 3, just because of 1 good season.

That's good because he's had 3 good seasons.

niallo27

De Gea is on a different level but I think Hart gets too much unwarranted abuse. If he wasn't English people would be saying what a great keeper he is.

RobertKK

De Gea is way better than Hart, also has a better scalp and doesn't need head and shoulders to treat his hair while playing a game.

Last season Hart was dropped for a period while he got his head in order.

pmasterson95

Most one-sided poll in a long while ha.

chicorytip

Hart has the greater natural ability of the two but always appears over-anxious leading him to make silly mistakes.Needs a few sessions with a good psychologist !

JamBur

If Hart wasn't English he wouldn't even be worthy of mention against top class keepers

niallo27

JamBur wrote: »

If Hart wasn't English he wouldn't even be worthy of mention against top class keepers

I think the opposite myself, because he is English every mistake he makes is magnified.

Liam O

chicorytip wrote: »

Hart has the greater natural ability of the two but always appears over-anxious leading him to make silly mistakes.Needs a few sessions with a good psychologist !

Is this in the same way Joe Allen has more natural ability than Iniesta? Because that's bonkers in fairness.

eagle eye

niallo27 wrote: »

I think the opposite myself, because he is English every mistake he makes is magnified.

QFT

I think this is a silly thread and really if we are talking this season then De Gea wins but if you take their best two best and worst seasons then it would be very close imo.

Owen_S

To be fair, you can't blame Joe Hart for the media's inflation of his ability. He's a young (in GK terms) English goalkeeper, a position where they have been lacking quality for a long time. Even Jack Butland was getting a lot of attention in the media!. His ability has never really matched the reputation, drops an awful lot of clangers which De Gea would be slaughtered for.

A Dub in Glasgo

April fool thread already

Mr.Nice Guy

But y'see the fing tha' lets the Spanish lad dahn is tha' 'e asn't got that British bulldog spiri' which Joe 'art 'as. Arty would be royht in the fick of fings when the pressure's on an' it's a wet and windy nyt in Stoke, but the Spanish lad he'd be finkin' all abaht 'is warm wevva back 'ome and he'd jus' end up letting ya dahhhnnnn.

UrbanFret

De gea obviously seems to make more saves but that's because of the rubbish that plays in front of him. Neither of them are great at coming off their line to either punch or catch crosses. De gea will never reach the very top because of his size which in no way is the 6 4" attributed to him. made for spain where only a few teams carry a big aerial threat.

Will I Amnt

pmasterson95 wrote: »

Most one-sided poll in a long while ha.

If it was a public poll it would be even more one-sided...

pmasterson95

Will I Amnt wrote: »

If it was a public poll it would be even more one-sided...

One of the 13 hit Hart by accident.....I'm confused by other 12