Manchester United Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread - Mod Notes in OP,22/7

Al Capwned

Al Capwned wrote: »

Any excuse......

Why'd ya leave the keys upon the table!!!

Ok, sorry lads, I'm done now!

GSPfan

The afro makes him look like a bit of a clown to be honest. Always hated it. If it is gone then maybe he wont look so awkward on the ball. Would love him to come good this year and prove he is worth keeping on.

Backstreet Moyes

Fellaini has been poor but in fairness he is much better than Fletcher, Anderson or Cleverley and Carrick was poor last season. Hopefully next season he will come good i don't believe he is as bad as he looked this season. He actually looks short on confidence hopefully LVG can get the best out of him.

I can't understand people calling for him to be sold when out other options are very very very poor.

GSPfan

Yeah I'd much rather sell Cleverley, Anderson, and Carrick before Fellaini. Carrick is just old now. Ando is pointless. Cleverley has been ruined.

Fellaini under Van Gaal may be a good thing. Certainly cant get much money for him right now so keep him on at least one season.

KombuchaMshroom

Am I too late for the system of a down references?
The one time my awfully chosen user name has any relevance in this the only thread on boards I ever use

Not at all late Kombucha, come right in and i'll put the kettle on, you take sugar??

Corvo

One sideshow of this whole Suarez transfer matter is that Barcelona's interest in Marco Reus has cooled considerably (I note he is also injured but still)

Could something happen there?

redbaron_99

Corvo wrote: »

One sideshow of this whole Suarez transfer matter is that Barcelona's interest in Marco Reus has cooled considerably (I note he is also injured but still)

Could something happen there?

I don't think he was going to move this summer, injured or not. IF there is a chance of him being available, we should make a bid. Fabulous footballer.

Cantona's Collars

Corvo wrote: »

One sideshow of this whole Suarez transfer matter is that Barcelona's interest in Marco Reus has cooled considerably (I note he is also injured but still)

Could something happen there?

"Marco Reus does not understand why after negotiating with his agent for months, Barca spent so much on Suarez instead". [Mundo]

Looks like he was all set to leave Dortmund.

brinty

Corvo wrote: »

One sideshow of this whole Suarez transfer matter is that Barcelona's interest in Marco Reus has cooled considerably (I note he is also injured but still)

Could something happen there?

is he not out with an ACL or something long term

he's young so maybe a target for next summer when he's proven his fitness and is still the same quality of player

LVG might look at taking him and Strootman in january/summer 15 once we're back in europe with more games and strengthen the squad numbers and quality up to that standard of competition

We've a limited number of games this season so best to concentrate on a small squad and focus on getting back into the Champions League for 15/16 and it allows LVG time to decide which of the current squad he hasn't already cut is of the standard to push on and win titles at home and in europe.

Billy86

Nuts102 wrote: »

Fellaini has been poor but in fairness he is much better than Fletcher, Anderson or Cleverley and Carrick was poor last season. Hopefully next season he will come good i don't believe he is as bad as he looked this season. He actually looks short on confidence hopefully LVG can get the best out of him.

I can't understand people calling for him to be sold when out other options are very very very poor.

GSPfan wrote: »

Yeah I'd much rather sell Cleverley, Anderson, and Carrick before Fellaini. Carrick is just old now. Ando is pointless. Cleverley has been ruined.

Fellaini under Van Gaal may be a good thing. Certainly cant get much money for him right now so keep him on at least one season.

As central midfielders, all those players are better than him bar possibly Anderson, even Fletcher with the illness. Fellaini simply is not a good centre midfielder, nor even a passable one, for a team looking to play the ball on the round. The thin he struggled with most last season was a sheer lack of talent in so many aspects to fit into a midfield that requires passing or basic control, and there is no coaching that..

Cantona's Collars

Sky Italia saying that PSG are planning to hijack any deal we do for Di Maria.

Giggsy11

Billy86 wrote: »

As central midfielders, all those players are better than him bar possibly Anderson, even Fletcher with the illness. Fellaini simply is not a good centre midfielder, nor even a passable one, for a team looking to play the ball on the round. The thin he struggled with most last season was a sheer lack of talent in so many aspects to fit into a midfield that requires passing or basic control, and there is no coaching that..

Fellaini is better CM than this Fletcher and Cleverley. I think Fellaini's role as #10 for Everton and for disjointed ManUtd has clouded many people's view on him.

Before he played as #10, he was a CM and a good one too. I hope he gets his chances with LVG. At least he deserves it more than Cleverley and Anderson.

Royal Irish

brinty wrote: »

We've a limited number of games this season so best to concentrate on a small squad and focus on getting back into the Champions League for 15/16 and it allows LVG time to decide which of the current squad he hasn't already cut is of the standard to push on and win titles at home and in europe.

I'd rather United concentrated on winning the league and not just qualifying for the CL. This is United ffs. We need to be challenging for the title in the run in or else our season is a failure.

I wont be able to take another season of Liverpool finishing higher than United. Balance needs to be restored to the universe.

bucketybuck

zerks wrote: »

Sky Italia saying that PSG are planning to hijack any deal we do for Di Maria.

I kinda hope they do. I really don't think we need him at all, the attacking power at the club is more than sufficient for our needs next season.

In my opinion every penny we have should be invested into the midfield and defence, with those areas massively strengthened you will see the likes of Nani and Kagawa become far more productive negating the need for the likes of Di Maria. Then think about players like that next season.

Maximus Alexander

Royal Irish wrote: »

This is United ffs.

This doesn't mean anything, unfortunately. The club has faded into relative mediocrity before - there is no divine and magical force driving the club to the top of the table. There was, but he's retired now.

I have no doubt that with the following and commercial success the club has, United will get back to winning ways, but I don't know why people think that a season of turgid football and a 7th place football would, could or should be followed immediately by a title challenge.

It's time to accept the new reality methinks. 4th would be grand.

TheDoc

Ed better set my weekend of to a flyer.

Mitch Connor

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

It's time to accept the new reality methinks.

A bollix defeatist attitude and one I would be disgusted to find shared by anyone at the club.

Maximus Alexander

Mitch Connor wrote: »

A bollix defeatist attitude and one I would be disgusted to find shared by anyone at the club.

We aren't at the club.

RobertKK

Marco Reus has an ankle injury, not an ACL.
Bid for him, bookies have Arsenal favourites to sign him, United as second favourites.

Reus is 20+ goals in league per season. United scored 20 less goals in the league last season while conceding the same number of goals as our title winning season in 2012.

Mitch Connor

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

We aren't at the club.

Whats your point? THat after decades of success we should take 1 crap season as a pointer to the real position of the club and be happy with anything better? Utter BS imo.

Everyone connected with the club, fans included, should be aiming for the top, it is failure to do or achieve otherwise.

Even looking at it from a pure business standpoint - only City and Chelsea can match us (or beat us) financially in England, so finishing below 3rd is unacceptable given the budget the team is ran on.

weisses

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

This doesn't mean anything, unfortunately. The club has faded into relative mediocrity before - there is no divine and magical force driving the club to the top of the table. There was, but he's retired now.

I have no doubt that with the following and commercial success the club has, United will get back to winning ways, but I don't know why people think that a season of turgid football and a 7th place football would, could or should be followed immediately by a title challenge.

It's time to accept the new reality methinks. 4th would be grand.

What changed between the last title and last season to warrant that pessimistic outlook ?

RobertKK

United are looking to win the league. Have no doubt, they are spending money with this as the target.

Cantona's Collars

TheDoc wrote: »

Ed better set my weekend of to a flyer.

TheDoc logs in this evening:

Maximus Alexander

Mitch Connor wrote: »

Whats your point? THat after decades of success we should take 1 crap season as a pointer to the real position of the club and be happy with anything better? Utter BS imo.

Everyone connected with the club, fans included, should be aiming for the top, it is failure to do or achieve otherwise.

Even looking at it from a pure business standpoint - only City and Chelsea can match us (or beat us) financially in England, so finishing below 3rd is unacceptable given the budget the team is ran on.

weisses wrote: »

What changed between the last title and last season to warrant that pessimistic outlook ?

Lads, it's not a pessimistic or defeatist attitude - it's realistic. There is absolutely no chance that United will win the league this year and you're deluding yourselves if you think otherwise.

Nowhere did I say that United, or the fans, shouldn't always want to be at the top. I'd have thought that goes without saying.

After a raft of changes at the club, all the experience being stripped from the club, a new manager coming in, and the worst season of football in my lifetime of supporting United, how could you possibly say "Well we should be winning it this year"? You're setting yourselves up for disappointment.

I'd rather enjoy the coming season by setting realistic goals and expectations. Getting back into the CL and having a good solid season will be a good jumping off point for what is hopefully a new era at the club.

I'm sure we'll have plenty of time for similar discussions over the next nine months when you're raging over the squad failing to meet your expectations.

FortuneChip

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

This doesn't mean anything, unfortunately. The club has faded into relative mediocrity before - there is no divine and magical force driving the club to the top of the table. There was, but he's retired now.

I have no doubt that with the following and commercial success the club has, United will get back to winning ways, but I don't know why people think that a season of turgid football and a 7th place football would, could or should be followed immediately by a title challenge.

It's time to accept the new reality methinks. 4th would be grand.

Liverpool jumped from 7th to 2nd after years without a title challenge.
United had an absolutely terrible season last year. They were champions the year prior.
You're awfully pessimistic if you think anyone at United is making 4th their target this season.

"The new reality" is that if United have one terrible season in 20+, they'll never recover? Nonsense.

The_Kew_Tour

poo poo.

no to other teams wanting what we want.

I still believe in Ed though, honestly.:D

Maximus Alexander

FortuneChip wrote: »

"The new reality" is that if United have one terrible season in 20+, they'll never recover? Nonsense.

Yeah, that's exactly what I said. :rolleyes:

MagicIRL

Today feels like a good kind of day. Wonder how things will progress over the next week. I'm on holidays from work, the UFC is in town next Saturday and the World Cup final is on this weekend. :pac: