Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

help doing weights

  • 03-10-2012 10:13am
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭


    There's a really good free weights toning class in my gym, problem is everytime I do it I can't walk for days afterwards. I do stretch, warm up warm down and all the rest, but obviously I'm not doing it right, specifically my thighs are excruciatingly painfull.
    I lose a good few days in the gym because of this and it messes up my routine, can anyone give me advice on how to limit this, I know stretch obviously, but specific links to videos etc and anything else people can think of


    Thanks


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,453 ✭✭✭jugger0


    Being sore after training is natural, the more you train the less you notice it, ya just gotta push through the pain!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    jugger0 wrote: »
    Being sore after training is natural, the more you train the less you notice it, ya just gotta push through the pain!

    I know it'll hurt but I'm scared to do my class today encase I still can't walk on Saturday, because I have a lot on (which include stairs). I'm looking for to see how to improve recovery time I suppose


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,390 ✭✭✭Stench Blossoms


    Keep doing it.

    In a couple of months time you'll miss the pain :(


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,535 ✭✭✭btkm8unsl0w5r4


    DOMS is the reward not the punishment...:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,878 ✭✭✭Burkatron


    There's a really good free weights toning class in my gym, problem is everytime I do it I can't walk for days afterwards. I do stretch, warm up warm down and all the rest, but obviously I'm not doing it right, specifically my thighs are excruciatingly painfull.
    I lose a good few days in the gym because of this and it messes up my routine, can anyone give me advice on how to limit this, I know stretch obviously, but specific links to videos etc and anything else people can think of


    Thanks
    How long have you being doing this class?

    Is it a sculpt/bodypump type class?

    What's your calorie intake like? If you understand this , how does your protein:carb:Fat ratio look? If you're not eating enough of the right things you're not going to recover!


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,923 ✭✭✭cloptrop


    Take it handy for first few weeks . Learn what is too much and slowly increase . Tell your instructor . This is a problem that usually lasts a few weeks then you miss it .
    If you are being completely dibbilitated your instructor should know better than push a beginner so hard.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 21,981 ✭✭✭✭Hanley


    It's one of the following:

    -not training enough to adapt
    -not eating enough kcals
    -not eating enough protein
    -not sleeping enough
    -the class is programmed poorly and designed to hurt you so you feel work, rather than improve you so you look, feel and perform better

    Soreness after training is normal. Don't just sit around waiting for it to go away, that's the worst thing you can do. Move, be active.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    There's a really good free weights toning class in my gym, problem is everytime I do it I can't walk for days afterwards. I do stretch, warm up warm down and all the rest, but obviously I'm not doing it right, specifically my thighs are excruciatingly painfull.
    I lose a good few days in the gym because of this and it messes up my routine, can anyone give me advice on how to limit this, I know stretch obviously, but specific links to videos etc and anything else people can think of


    Thanks

    Seriously? Like are you good sore or bad sore and yes there is a difference. You can't expect to do weights and not be sore, sore is good but only if it's good sore!

    Good sore = woah ya, that must have been a good workout, another few of those and I'll be looking good or
    Bad sore = This doesn't feel right!

    Which is it?

    And as another poster said, don't just sit around waiting for it to go away, the best cure is to do something the next day, it always cures me anyway.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    cloptrop wrote: »
    Take it handy for first few weeks . Learn what is too much and slowly increase . Tell your instructor . This is a problem that usually lasts a few weeks then you miss it .
    If you are being completely dibbilitated your instructor should know better than push a beginner so hard.


    I've had arguements and weights taken off me and heavier ones given to me ( I don't do the class if he's taking it anymore).
    It's a shame because I can really feel it doing good for my upper half but it hurts my legs so much I can hardly do anything for days, its also brought on head colds and other things which means I can't get a routine started.

    It's basically doing a lot of lungs and squats, some core and lots of arm reps, I think ill just use a ridiculously light weight today and assess tomorrow what to do. I did think that it was probably the only way to do it but as I'm not an expert I listen too much to other people at the last minute


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    I've had arguements and weights taken off me and heavier ones given to me ( I don't do the class if he's taking it anymore).
    It's a shame because I can really feel it doing good for my upper half but it hurts my legs so much I can hardly do anything for days, its also brought on head colds and other things which means I can't get a routine started.

    It's basically doing a lot of lungs and squats, some core and lots of arm reps, I think ill just use a ridiculously light weight today and assess tomorrow what to do. I did think that it was probably the only way to do it but as I'm not an expert I listen too much to other people at the last minute

    How heavy are the weights that you are using?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,923 ✭✭✭cloptrop


    Id say the head colds and stuff are due to pushing yourself on a bad diet and lack of sleep. The most important part of weight training Iv found is diet . I spent about 5 years never getting bigger when I started because I was neglecting my diet . Once I took it seriously I was pilling on the muscle within months.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    There's a really good free weights toning class in my gym, problem is everytime I do it I can't walk for days afterwards. I do stretch, warm up warm down and all the rest, but obviously I'm not doing it right, specifically my thighs are excruciatingly painfull.
    I lose a good few days in the gym because of this and it messes up my routine, can anyone give me advice on how to limit this, I know stretch obviously, but specific links to videos etc and anything else people can think of


    Thanks

    Seriously? Like are you good sore or bad sore and yes there is a difference. You can't expect to do weights and not be sore, sore is good but only if it's good sore!

    Good sore = woah ya, that must have been a good workout, another few of those and I'll be looking good or
    Bad sore = This doesn't feel right!

    Which is it?

    And as another poster said, don't just sit around waiting for it to go away, the best cure is to do something the next day, it always cures me anyway.

    My arms are good sore, my legs are bad sore, they give my knees problems because they jerk up and go tense. I've tried going for walks and still be hobbeling after a 4/5km.
    Im sure the walking helped and all but its was still 4 days still I didn't have pain in my.legs


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    I've had arguements and weights taken off me and heavier ones given to me ( I don't do the class if he's taking it anymore).
    It's a shame because I can really feel it doing good for my upper half but it hurts my legs so much I can hardly do anything for days, its also brought on head colds and other things which means I can't get a routine started.

    It's basically doing a lot of lungs and squats, some core and lots of arm reps, I think ill just use a ridiculously light weight today and assess tomorrow what to do. I did think that it was probably the only way to do it but as I'm not an expert I listen too much to other people at the last minute

    How heavy are the weights that you are using?
    Only about 4/5 kg in each hand


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    Only about 4/5 kg in each hand

    Ok, for a start, under no circumstances should your knees be hurting, if they are then your technique is very poor. This is the instructors fault, that's what they are meant to do, instruct.

    For lunges and squats it is of paramount importance that you do not push your knees out beyond your toes. Imagine yourself in a lunge position, you forward leg - knee should be 'in line' with the toe and without bending forward you should be able to see your toe. When you raise up and down into the lunge make sure that you are in a vertical postion, no hyperextension of the back or leaning forward (if you are then your weights are too heavy) Have you back completely straight, you are pushing up and down with your front thigh, its the thigh that should be sore not the knee. Look in the mirror, what you should see is your thigh going from parallel to the floor to raising to a position where your front and back legs are both straight and back down again.

    For the squats, same thing, knees should be line line with the feet, knees should not go beyond your toes. Back straight, visualise your backside pushing way out behind you, all the weight and pressure should be on your heels when you are lowering to floor.


    The most important thing to remember is that your thighs are meant to be doing the work not your knees.

    By the way are you male or female and have you much experience with weights because any of our new starters would always start with a 2/2.5kg - 4-5kg is way too heavy if you a female starting out with weights, they are going to effect your balance which in turn means you are stabilising with your joints not the muscle groups you are working, this = problems.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    Only about 4/5 kg in each hand

    Ok, for a start, under no circumstances should your knees be hurting, if they are then your technique is very poor. This is the instructors fault, that's what they are meant to do, instruct.

    For lunges and squats it is of paramount importance that you do not push your knees out beyond your toes. Imagine yourself in a lunge position, you forward leg - knee should be 'in line' with the toe and without bending forward you should be able to see your toe. When you raise up and down into the lunge make sure that you are in a vertical postion, no hyperextension of the back or leaning forward (if you are then your weights are too heavy) Have you back completely straight, you are pushing up and down with your front thigh, its the thigh that should be sore not the knee. Look in the mirror, what you should see is your thigh going from parallel to the floor to raising to a position where your front and back legs are both straight and back down again.

    For the squats, same thing, knees should be line line with the feet, knees should not go beyond your toes. Back straight, visualise your backside pushing way out behind you, all the weight and pressure should be on your heels when you are lowering to floor.


    The most important thing to remember is that your thighs are meant to be doing the work not your knees.

    By the way are you male or female and have you much experience with weights because any of our new starters would always start with a 2/2.5kg - 4-5kg is way too heavy if you a female starting out with weights, they are going to effect your balance which in turn means you are stabilising with your joints not the muscle groups you are working, this = problems.


    My knees hurt from walking the next day, because my legs are so stiff the jerk and wobble when I walk, not from doing weights

    I think ill go for very light weights. The instructures told me its a waste of time to do any lighter than 4 kg, I'm a female by the way.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    Burkatron wrote: »
    There's a really good free weights toning class in my gym, problem is everytime I do it I can't walk for days afterwards. I do stretch, warm up warm down and all the rest, but obviously I'm not doing it right, specifically my thighs are excruciatingly painfull.
    I lose a good few days in the gym because of this and it messes up my routine, can anyone give me advice on how to limit this, I know stretch obviously, but specific links to videos etc and anything else people can think of


    Thanks
    How long have you being doing this class?

    Is it a sculpt/bodypump type class?

    What's your calorie intake like? If you understand this , how does your protein:carb:Fat ratio look? If you're not eating enough of the right things you're not going to recover!


    I'm not sure on the break down, I'd have things like chicken and veg stirfry and brown rice, I'd imagine that's fairly balanced if your active, and I'd add in a snack if tuna/egg and bananas for protein and potasium. Would 150g of chicken and an egg or two not be enough protein?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    My knees hurt from walking the next day, because my legs are so stiff the jerk and wobble when I walk, not from doing weights

    I think ill go for very light weights. The instructures told me its a waste of time to do any lighter than 4 kg, I'm a female by the way.

    If they said that then they are severely misinformed. I train with a group of 20+ girls, we all started at around 2/2.5kg...the majority of the classes train at 3kg per hand, 4 train with 4kg and myself and 2 others train with 5kg. We are all very well built and toned but our instruction is excellent.

    Any of the girls that didn't want to bulk up vary between the 2.5kg and the 3kg and are in excellent shape, it's all about maintanence, diet and the variety of exercise. Any of us training heavier would have extra definition but the training is intense.

    Whatever the reason there is definitely something wrong somewhere, there is no way from doing lunges and squats that your legs should be so sore the next day that it is putting your knees under pressure.

    You might also like to consider icing your legs after your train, a bag on frozen peas on each, it might help speed the recovery and you mighten be as bad the next day.

    By the way, how is your diet? Are you getting enough food?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    I'm not sure on the break down, I'd have things like chicken and veg stirfry and brown rice, I'd imagine that's fairly balanced if your active, and I'd add in a snack if tuna/egg and bananas for protein and potasium. Would 150g of chicken and an egg or two not be enough protein?

    150g of chicken and an egg is not enough protein. You should be having protein with every meal.

    Breakfast
    Snack
    Lunch
    Snack
    Dinner


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,923 ✭✭✭cloptrop


    Protein should be taken in intervals throughout the day . Taking it all at once doesnt digest . You will poop most of it out . Even a pint of milf every hour or so would be better proteinwise than a big chunk of chicken once a day .


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    I'm not sure on the break down, I'd have things like chicken and veg stirfry and brown rice, I'd imagine that's fairly balanced if your active, and I'd add in a snack if tuna/egg and bananas for protein and potasium. Would 150g of chicken and an egg or two not be enough protein?

    150g of chicken and an egg is not enough protein. You should be having protein with every meal.

    Breakfast
    Snack
    Lunch
    Snack
    Dinner
    I'd have porridge for breakfast and a tuna/ chicken salad for lunch too with chickpeas etc,. How much should I be looking at? I want to tone up only, not gain bulk muscle


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,386 ✭✭✭another question


    I'd have porridge for breakfast and a tuna/ chicken salad for lunch too with chickpeas etc,. How much should I be looking at? I want to tone up only, not gain bulk muscle

    Ideally the body requires the same grams in protein that you weigh in kilos. People have more protein than they weigh in kilos if they want to bulk up but for optimum muscle tone - if you weigh 50kilos eat 50grams.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    I'd have porridge for breakfast and a tuna/ chicken salad for lunch too with chickpeas etc,. How much should I be looking at? I want to tone up only, not gain bulk muscle

    Ideally the body requires the same grams in protein that you weigh in kilos. People have more protein than they weigh in kilos if they want to bulk up but for optimum muscle tone - if you weigh 50kilos eat 50grams.

    I think I'd be close enough to that, I throw in linseed into my porridge, and have a small bit of cheese/yoghurt usually if I'm doing weights. And have a decent portion of protein with lunch and dinner.

    Today I had porridge with linseed and hake with a baked potato for lunch, would a chicken dinner and a soya yoghurt for a snack not be okay?
    I'm about 65 kg


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    Thanks everyone by the way, ill take it all on board, might need to update you if it doesn't help.

    Does it matter about protein before a workout? Assuming your diet is already balanced?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,878 ✭✭✭Burkatron


    If some of this seems like I'm being nasty I'm not, there's alot of misinformation been spouted on this thread so I'm just trying to help!
    Ok, for a start, under no circumstances should your knees be hurting, if they are then your technique is very poor. This is the instructors fault, that's what they are meant to do, instruct.
    If the OP has knee tracking issues the trainer will most likely not see this as they wont have the training or know how! Go to a physio.
    For lunges and squats it is of paramount importance that you do not push your knees out beyond your tloes.
    For the squats, same thing, knees should be line line with the feet, knees should not go beyond your toes. Back straight, visualise your backside pushing way out behind you, all the weight and pressure should be on your heels when you are lowering to floor.
    Wrong on squats, there are too many factors for this type of blanket statement.It can depend on muscle balance, feet,tibia,femur & torso length (&other factors)

    My knees hurt from walking the next day, because my legs are so stiff the jerk and wobble when I walk, not from doing weights

    I think ill go for very light weights. The instructures told me its a waste of time to do any lighter than 4 kg, I'm a female by the way.

    If your knees are wobbling and feel like they're going to give way you should be consulting a physio! Your trainer is wrong on the weights....& alot of other things by the sounds of it...Best to avoid his classes





    150g of chicken and an egg is not enough protein. You should be having protein with every meal.

    Breakfast
    Snack
    Lunch
    Snack
    Dinner
    cloptrop wrote: »
    Protein should be taken in intervals throughout the day . Taking it all at once doesnt digest . You will poop most of it out . Even a pint of milf every hour or so would be better proteinwise than a big chunk of chicken once a day .

    Oooh, I wonder what the intermittant fasting advocates will say on this 1!!?? I agree with you by the way but it's always interesting to hear different viewpoints
    I'd have porridge for breakfast and a tuna/ chicken salad for lunch too with chickpeas etc,. How much should I be looking at? I want to tone up only, not gain bulk muscle

    You're female (just realised you haven't said this anywhere...sorry if I'm wrong), you most likely (There's always an exception) don't have enough testosterone to bulk up to a monstrous size, (most men find this hard, you have nothing to worry about) especially using lightweights & high reps. Also,If you eat your maintenance calories or below you wont gain weight/mass.

    You haven't mentioned portions in what your eating! The food seems fine, it's the quantity you now need to get right
    Ideally the body requires the same grams in protein that you weigh in kilos. People have more protein than they weigh in kilos if they want to bulk up but for optimum muscle tone - if you weigh 50kilos eat 50grams.

    that's only 200 calories of protein per day, taking into account that (I don't agree with this but it's an example) the RDA from the powers that be is 2,000 calories for a lady you think that that's enough protein??


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,433 ✭✭✭Ant11


    cloptrop wrote: »
    Protein should be taken in intervals throughout the day . Taking it all at once doesnt digest . You will poop most of it out . Even a pint of milf every hour or so would be better proteinwise than a big chunk of chicken once a day .

    If taking protein all at once doesn't digest how do you explain that you will poop it out straight away??? Does it just swim through the digestive system without being digested, magically turn into poo and straight out your backdoor?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,923 ✭✭✭cloptrop


    Ant11 wrote: »
    cloptrop wrote: »
    Protein should be taken in intervals throughout the day . Taking it all at once doesnt digest . You will poop most of it out . Even a pint of milf every hour or so would be better proteinwise than a big chunk of chicken once a day .

    If taking protein all at once doesn't digest how do you explain that you will poop it out straight away??? Does it just swim through the digestive system without being digested, magically turn into poo and straight out your backdoor?
    Its an expression your body takes no more than it needs at one time.

    Edit; i think excess protein turns to fat . Could be wrong on that though.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,433 ✭✭✭Ant11


    cloptrop wrote: »
    Ant11 wrote: »
    cloptrop wrote: »
    Protein should be taken in intervals throughout the day . Taking it all at once doesnt digest . You will poop most of it out . Even a pint of milf every hour or so would be better proteinwise than a big chunk of chicken once a day .

    If taking protein all at once doesn't digest how do you explain that you will poop it out straight away??? Does it just swim through the digestive system without being digested, magically turn into poo and straight out your backdoor?
    Its an expression your body takes no more than it needs at one time.

    Edit; i think excess protein turns to fat . Could be wrong on that though.

    Number 5 about protein intake. Others are interesting too.

    http://www.leangains.com/2010/10/top-ten-fasting-myths-debunked.html?m=1


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 21,981 ✭✭✭✭Hanley


    cloptrop wrote: »
    Its an expression your body takes no more than it needs at one time.

    Edit; i think excess protein turns to fat . Could be wrong on that though.

    Yup, turns to fatty muscle. The opposite of lean muscle. It's the bad kind.

    The one that rides around in cars with blacked out windows, loud music playing, intimidating mary, nancy and kathleen :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    What should I aiming to eat protein wise on the days I do weights and the days after??


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 21,981 ✭✭✭✭Hanley


    What should I aiming to eat protein wise on the days I do weights and the days after??

    1g/lb bodyweight


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    Hanley wrote: »
    What should I aiming to eat protein wise on the days I do weights and the days after??

    1g/lb bodyweight
    Per pound? Somebody else said kg, that's a lot of protein. Surely that's too much, I'm trying to lose weight


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 21,981 ✭✭✭✭Hanley


    Per pound? Somebody else said kg, that's a lot of protein. Surely that's too much, I'm trying to lose weight

    No, more protein is good for weight loss. Keeps you feeling full, and has a lower net calorie load than other macronutrients.

    2g/kg if going off bodyweight in kg.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 425 ✭✭gingernut125


    Hanley wrote: »
    Per pound? Somebody else said kg, that's a lot of protein. Surely that's too much, I'm trying to lose weight

    No, more protein is good for weight loss. Keeps you feeling full, and has a lower net calorie load than other macronutrients.

    2g/kg if going off bodyweight in kg.

    Okay thanks!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,722 ✭✭✭nice_guy80


    foam roll and stretch (properly) before and after the sessions

    that will help. watch a load of tutorial videos online to get informed on the correct technique. your class instructor mightn't be able to effectively correct any bad technique if its in a big class.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 266 ✭✭size5


    In order to ease DOMS a hot bath with Epsom salts will make a massive difference to how u feel the next day. Also plenty of water straight after class


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,480 ✭✭✭Chancer3001


    just going to echo some advice.

    do SOMETHING to get rid of the soreness

    Ice after, warm bath later, walk, stretch, foam roll after (check youtube) more stretching after



    as regards protein, eat LOTS. 1g per lb is good. Youll find that just eating that much protein it will be a struggle to eat anything else you will be so full = lower calorie intake = losing weight.

    protein is key.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,462 ✭✭✭Orla K


    nice_guy80 wrote: »
    foam roll and stretch (properly) before and after the sessions

    that will help. watch a load of tutorial videos online to get informed on the correct technique. your class instructor mightn't be able to effectively correct any bad technique if its in a big class.

    Do this.
    I've had big problems with my knees, I started foam rolling before and after the gym and I learned when doing things like squats my knees went inwards. For me it was an ITband(side of leg) dominance and glutes(arse) doing nothing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,520 ✭✭✭passremarkable


    hi, need help with weights re eating and protein shakes.
    gonna start doing weights shortly, probably gonna do it in the evenings after work?when is best time to take protein shake and does it help?what is best food in general, im not planning on getting massive just a bit stronger


Advertisement