PFA Young Player of the Year

Xavi6

Kun

Turtyturd

Aguero should get it...Bale probably will.

G.K.

Joe Allen

Washington Irving

The media are gonna go crazy with the amount of English players there

Aguero has to win it though

SlickRic

hmm, this isn't even a contest.

not a close one anyway.

Kun.

easily.

PhlegmyMoses

Don't think it will be Aguero simply because players as established as him rarely win it. Ronaldo was eligible in 08 after his wonder season and Rooney was eligible in seasons where Ashley Young, who was older, and James Milner won it.

Maybe Hart? Tim Krul, even?

Tigerandahalf

Saul-Goode9 wrote: »

The media are gonna go crazy with the amount of English players there

Aguero has to win it though

Mclean :-)

CSF

Kun deserves it but I think Kyle Walker will win.

Xavi6

PhlegmyMoses wrote: »

Maybe Hart? Tim Krul, even?

Slight problem there buddy, this is the official shortlist. I didn't just pick 6 names out of my hoop

PhlegmyMoses

Ah right :P

There was no poll when I first looked at it!

cgpg5

Kun should get it and its a joke if he doesn't. Can see Walker winning alright

dahat

Kun is nailed on but i really like Walker as a player,top class prospect

Cantona's Collars

Aguero should win but an I'd say Bale will get it.

Why didn't Henderson get a nod? :pac:

kevohmsford

Aguero will probably get it. Chamberlain has been excellent for Arsenal when he has played. Amazing young player.

Vurnon San Benito

Danny Welbeck, Chamberlain, Sturridge - how?! Absolute nonse.

Chamberlain has had a few decent games all season, Sturridge the same - Welbeck has managed a few goals, nothing spectacular

Tim Krul anyone?
These nominations get more laughable each year!

Ganymede Glow

Aguero

markie29

No juan mata? Yet they have sturridge and chamberlain on the list....very strange. Maybe he is too old to be nomnated for this????

Jimmy Iovine

Has to be Aguero. I really hope Bale doesn't get it.

It's a year too early for Chamberlain I think. Next year he'll be a very strong contender.

Tigerandahalf

Maybe they got confused and thought it was a British selection. And threw kun in for good measure. Premier league has been poor standard this year. When you look at utd team, a lot of mediocre players.

steelcityblues

Aguero is 23. Why is he in this category?

mayordenis

Aguero is 24 in the summer I love the guy but I just think this whole young player thing is getting weird, it really should be under 21 tops in my opinion.

Tigerandahalf

No Newcastle player?

cgpg5

Balotelli? Seriously, he's better than Sturridge

Tigerandahalf

mayordenis wrote: »

Aguero is 24 in the summer I love the guy but I just think this whole young player thing is getting weird, it really should be under 21 tops in my opinion.

If it was they prob wouldnt have enough good players to nominate. People wouldnt be interested in it.

cgpg5

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

No Newcastle player?

Who really though? Cabaye Tiote Ba Cisse HBA Colo have been far and away our best players and all are too old.

Havermeyer

I went with Walker.

I'm surprised Aguero is on the list tbh. He's been around for quite a while now, and is 24 in a couple of months.

How old is young these days?

Tigerandahalf

cgpg5 wrote: »

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

No Newcastle player?

Who really though? Cabaye Tiote Ba Cisse HBA Colo have been far and away our best players and all are too old.

Perhaps more for senior player awarfq

Xavi6

The question about age qualification is brought up every year and every year it's still the exact same answer.

The player must be 23 or under at the start of the current season.

Tigerandahalf

How old is Tiote?

Vurnon San Benito

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

How old is Tiote?

25.

But between me and you, he's actually 34..

cgpg5

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

Perhaps more for senior player awarfq

Can't understand how Colo isn't up for that

mayordenis

Xavi6 wrote: »

The question about age qualification is brought up every year and every year it's still the exact same answer.

The player must be 23 or under at the start of the current season.

It wasn't a question it was an opinion as to what it should be.

Nalz

Aguero, although I'm surprised to see him on the list

Tigerandahalf

Tiote is like a man after a hard day in the bog. His father must have worked in the coal mines.

Vurnon San Benito

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

Tiote is like a man after a hard day in the bog. His father must have worked in the coal mines.

:rolleyes:

markie29

Tigerandahalf wrote: »

Tiote is like a man after a hard day in the bog. His father must have worked in the coal mines.

Que?

CSF

Am I alone in thinking there is no deserving Newcastle candidate and that there success has been moreso down to many players being very good.

Coloccini and Ba have been very good but neither have even been the best in their position.

cgpg5

CSF wrote: »

Am I alone in thinking there is no deserving Newcastle candidate and that there success has been moreso down to many players being very good.

Coloccini and Ba have been very good but neither have even been the best in their position.

Agree its been a more collective rather than individual effort tbh, we'd be more in line to get team of the season rather than an individual award which is fair enough.

Havermeyer

CSF wrote: »

Am I alone in thinking there is no deserving Newcastle candidate and that there success has been moreso down to many players being very good.

Coloccini and Ba have been very good but neither have even been the best in their position.

I'd argue that Krul has been as good as, if not better, than Hart.

CSF

nummnutts wrote: »

CSF wrote: »

Am I alone in thinking there is no deserving Newcastle candidate and that there success has been moreso down to many players being very good.

Coloccini and Ba have been very good but neither have even been the best in their position.

I'd argue that Krul has been as good as, if not better, than Hart.

Hart doesn't deserve to be there either. Should be Kompany.

shano_88

Wojciech Szczesny should be on that list imo.

prettyboy81

Aguero & he should have been in the senior category too!

Liam O

Doocey wrote: »

Danny Welbeck, Chamberlain, Sturridge - how?! Absolute nonse.

Chamberlain has had a few decent games all season, Sturridge the same - Welbeck has managed a few goals, nothing spectacular

Tim Krul anyone?
These nominations get more laughable each year!

Em, the big attacking young players getting their games for the top teams? Not all that outrageous imo. There are better nominees, I'd go for Smalling or Evans over Welbeck from United but the big joke is that 23-24 year oldsare eligible for the award, it should definitely be capped at 21. You mentioned Krul-who else would you have in there instead of the three you mentioned? There seems to be a lot of outrage in here, who are better candidates?

kryogen

Kun should walk this.

kryogen

CSF wrote: »

Hart doesn't deserve to be there either. Should be Kompany.

On the YPOTY list?

KaiserGunner

Am surprised that Woj Szez wasnt on that list ahead of Oxlade-Chamberlain from an Arsenal perspective. Aguero should win this award by a country mile as he has been first class most times that I have watched him play.

Jax Teller

Does the ox deserve to be there ? He's only played in 13 premier league games .

Dubit10

Balotelli scored 17 goals this season at the same age as Welbeck yet he is conveniently forgotten. Wonder why?

kryogen

Dubit10 wrote: »

Balotelli scored 17 goals this season at the same age as Welbeck yet he is conveniently forgotten. Wonder why?

Cause he's black?

Owen_S

While Aguero clearly deserves it, it is slightly unfair pitting a £38m signing against a homegrown player such as Welbeck.

Dubit10 wrote: »

Balotelli scored 17 goals this season at the same age as Welbeck yet he is conveniently forgotten. Wonder why?

Welbeck doesn't try to stamp on players and break their legs?

PhlegmyMoses

Dubit10 wrote: »

Balotelli scored 17 goals this season at the same age as Welbeck yet he is conveniently forgotten. Wonder why?

Lots more things come into this other than stats. Welbeck's work rate and attitude are far superior to Balotelli. It's also the relative jump Welbeck has made in his career this year in comparison to Balotelli. I would far prefer to have Welbeck than Balotelli in my team at this current point in time. Balotelli is more naturally talented, though.