Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Roads Budget 2011-2014 and Leo's Work Priorities

  • 01-04-2011 2:26pm
    #1
    Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 25,234 ✭✭✭✭


    Thanks to Leo for putting his briefing online

    http://www.transport.ie/upload/general/13086-MINISTERS_BRIEF_SCANNED_VERSION-0.PDF

    A lot of this document is about tourism etc, The Roads section is around page 48 of 322 on, here is a dirty OCR I made.
    PPP MARKETS
    The successful awarding of a major PPP contract involving private funding is challenging at any
    time but is particularly challenging in current circumstances where Ireland has been the subject
    of intervention by the IMF/EU. Until financial credibility is restored the international debt
    funding market will be reluctant to lend funds to finance projects in Ireland, the repayment of
    which is ultimately dependant on the Irish state.
    The original Transport Capital Programme as envisaged under T21 included a figure of over €S
    billion from the private sector through the PPP procurement of certain roads and public
    transport projects. ·To date approx. €2 billion of private sector funding has been secured, all of
    which has been secured for the First Roads PPP Programme. This programme has delivered the
    following 9 road improvement schemes; -
    • M1 Dundalk Western Bypass
    • M4 l<i|cocl<·Enfield— Kinnegacl Bypass
    • M8 Rathcormac to Fermoy Bypass
    • N25 Waterford City Bypass
    • N6 Galway to Balllnasloe Scheme
    • N7/NS Portlaoise—Cullahill/Castletown
    • M3 C|onee—l<el|s
    • N7 Limerick Tunnel Scheme
    M50 Upgrade Phase 2
    After the award of contracts under the 1st PPP roads programme and following on from a
    review of the Transport 21 Programme the NRA was authorised in January 2008 to deliver a
    2nd roads programme with a capital value of €1bi|iion by way of unitary payment (i.e. non·
    tolledj PPPs.
    Four schemes were identified by the NRA as suitable candidates for development as unitary
    payment (non -to||ed) PPP schemes. Two of these projects, the M17/18 Gort—Tuam and the N11
    Arklow-Rathnew/N7 Newlands Cross PPP bypasses have progressed to tender stage. The Gort to
    Tuam PPP is at the stage of negotiations with the preferred bidder but due to concern in the
    capital markets regarding lre|and’s overall Hnancial situation the NRA has so far been unable to
    finalise negotiations. EIB support was secured mid 2010 for both projects.
    The NRA is continuing to work with tenderers on these contracts and is still hopeful of
    concluding at least one ofthe contracts by end 2011 but at a higher overall cost.
    On the public transport side Metro North, the tunnel element of the Dart Underground
    Programme, Metro West and the Luas to Lucan were to be procured as PPPs. However due to
    cutbacks in capital funds to 2014, priority has been given to Metro North which has planning
    approval and is at an advanced stage of procurement. Timelines for Dart Underground tunnel,

    Metro West and Lucan Luas are under review. The EIB has committed to provide up to €50O
    million for Metro North.
    There is however an external risk to the Metro North PPP given the current economic
    circumstances and the recent International Monetary Fund and EU intervention in Ireland, The
    current programme for Metro North envisages the project reaching financial close in late 2012
    with engagement with debt funders required in late 2011 or early 2012.
    Financial close for the Metro North PPP will be dependent on lreland’s financial credibility
    internationally and on the prevailing position of the international funding markets towards
    providing funding to Irish infrastructure at that time. {See Metro North Key Issues note below
    for more detail),
    ROADS
    A. EMERGENCY ROAD REPAIRS
    National Roads
    The NRA has been allocated a total of €866.963 million for National roads in 2011. This includes
    €72O m for capital works, €42.9 m for maintenance works and €89.7 rn for PPP unitary
    payments, It has assigned €10O million from its capital works amount towards pavement
    improvement works and it should be able to deal with any necessary repairs (on national roads)
    resulting from damage due to recent severe weather from within this sum.
    Regional and Local Roads
    A sum of €375.176 million has been allocated for regional and local roads (RLR). Overall the RLR
    funding for 2011 is down 9% on 2010. The backlog of repair work prior to the recent severe
    weather was estimated at approximately €2.7 billion. The recent damage suffered by the RLR
    network will require the current year grant allocations to be directed towards repairing the
    recently damaged roads and will allow no progress to be made in respect of the backlog of work.
    In the 2011 RLR grants there is an increased focus on directing funding towards repair and
    maintenance works with over 85% of the grant monies to be spent on such works. The amount
    of money directed towards major new projects has been reduced. Discretion has been given to
    local authorities to revise their 3-year restoration (strengthening) programmes to assist them in
    targeting the repair of the recently damaged roads. Local authorities have been allocated €1O
    million to assist with the costs of Winter Maintenance (see also section on Emergency Planning
    which deals with salt management).
    B. A5 PROJECT (NORTH WEST GATEWAY TO AUGHNACLOY)
    In the context of the St. Andrew‘s Agreement the Government made a commitment to provide
    £400/€5S0 million to a roads investment package for Northern Ireland which includes the
    upgrading of the A5 road from Aughnacloy to Derry/Letterkenny to dual-carriageway standard.
    Work commenced in 2007 and to date all project milestones have been met on schedule. The A5
    project milestone and payment schedule envisages construction starting in 2012 and finishing in
    2015.
    An initial payment of €9 million from the Irish Government’s contribution was made in 2009
    following selection of the Preferred Route for the road. The next payment of E11 sterling was
    triggered by the third project milestone — Publication of Draft Orders and Environmental
    Statement- achieved in November 2010. The payment schedule envisages the payment being
    made in July 2011 subject to the agreed procedures governing the payment. As part of this
    procedure an agreed progress report on the project prepared by the Cross Border Steering
    Group was reviewed by the NSMC Transport Sector at its meeting on 9th February 2011. The

    next step will be approval of the payment by the NSMC Plenary meeting scheduled for June
    2011.
    The Department's Four Year Plan provides for a scheduled drawdown in 2012 on reaching the
    fourth project milestone. No specific provision has been made in this Department's allocations
    for scheduled drawdowns for subsequent years to 2016. The Department of Finance has
    indicated that it is envisaged that payments will be met from within the overall Government
    capital envelope. The anticipated spend profile for 2013 and 2014 is Stg£10 million and Stg£130
    million respectively. Further payments of Stg£120 million and £118 million are anticipated in
    2015 and 2016.
    C. MOTORWAY SERVICE AREAS
    Originally the NRA proposed up to 12 service areas on the Major Interurban Routes as well as
    two others are proposed for the N6/N18junction on the Western Road Corridor and on the N11
    near Gorey. Service areas are intended to offer food/convenience retail services, toilets and
    showers as well as extensive car, coach/HGV parking and Garda enforcement areas. Privately
    constructed or operated services areas are not required to provide all ofthese facilities.
    The first three service areas opened in 2010 (on the M1 and M4). The NRA has planning
    permission for four more at Athlone (N6), Cashel (M8), Kilcullen (M9) and Gorey (M11). The
    Gorey Service Station is due to be constructed as part of the N11 Rathnew/Arklow and N7
    Newlands Cross Junction Improvement Schemes (a PPP).
    While the previous Minister indicated to the NRA that it should seek non - Exchequer funding
    for delivering further service areas, the Minister did clear the purchase by the NRA of sites
    where planning approval had been obtained with a view to then testing the market for private
    sector development on these sites. NRA is currently evaluating the option of attracting private
    sector interest by bundling the development/operation of three service areas i.e. Athlone,
    Kilcullen and Gorey. In relation to Cashel, recent media reports indicate that Topaz and
    McDona|d’s will open a service station on the M8 at Cashel in late May this year. NRA has
    deferred a decision on Cashel in view of this.
    D. TOLLING -· FUTURE STRATEGY
    Statutory powers in relation to tolling are vested in the National Roads Authority (NRA) under
    Part V of the Roads Act 1993 (as amended by the Planning and Development Act 2000 and the
    Roads Act 2007). At present there are eleven toll schemes in operation in Ireland. The NRA is
    responsible forten ofthese schemes.
    In 2010, the Local Government Efficiency Review Group recommended the introduction of new
    tolling schemes on national roads, both new and existing, based on an equitable distribution of
    tolling points across the national network, with a proportion of revenue being used to invest in
    local and regional roads. The Infrastructure Investment Priorities document 2010·2016 also
    referred to the possible introduction of further tolling on national roads and recommended that
    any additional income generated through tolling should be retained by the National Roads
    Authority to help fund on-going road investment.
    In light of these recommendations, the NRA examined options for a new tolling strategy. Their
    preliminary report on options for a future tolling strategy was presented to the then Minister in
    November 2010. At this point, however, no decisions have been made in relation to additional
    tolling. The NRA is currently undertaking further scoping work on tolling options taking into
    account relevant EU legislation.
    Tagged:


Comments

  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 25,234 ✭✭✭✭Sponge Bob


    Of the €4.8 bn theoretically available some €1.7bn is already spent leaving only €3.1bn for the next 3 years across airports roads trains and ports

    Of that €1.7bn some €800m is retention payments on roads that are already built and opened.

    By my estimate in reading this ( and bolding the key bits ) only €520m is available for non PPP national road capital expenditures over the next 4 years being
    €1,820 Total - the €1.3bn committed already.
    CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROGRAMME
    Economic Difficulties and Reduced Allocations
    Transport 21 (T21) was the 10-year capital investment framework established in 2005 to provide
    for the development of transport infrastructure. At the launch of T21, a €34 billion investment
    package was announced which comprised €26 billion to be provided by the Exchequer and €8
    billion by Public Private Partnership {PPP) funding.
    In the first 5 years of T21 Exchequer expenditure amounted to a total of over €10.5 billion.
    T21 Expenditure 2006-2010* _'__
    vear w 2007 2008 W 2010 Total
    €billion 1.937 2.357 2.504 2.124 1.730 10.652
    In addition, the 1“ PPP roads programme resulted in private sector funding of approx. €2 billion
    Arising from the allocation under the National Recovery Plan in November 2010, a breakdown of
    the reduced transport capital investment programme for 2011-2014 is as follows:
    _ 2011 2012 2013 2014 mai
    €m €rn €m €m €m
    Public Transport 394 392 527 493 1,806
    swans @ sas 510 asc 2,865
    Other 54 S2 38 28 172
    mai 1,438 Q 1,075 1,001 4,aaa
    Note - Summary of Reductions:
    The original exchequer allocation provided for T21 has been subject to a number of adjustments totalling
    approx. €7 billion between 2008-2014 as follows:
    2008-2010: total reductions of approx. €1 billion were implemented.
    2011-2014: total reductions of almost €6 billion have been proposed for the four years covered by the
    National Recovery Plan.
    Committed Expenditure
    Of the €4.843 billion allocated for 2011-2014, it is estimated that in the region of €1.7 billion of
    this is contractually committed. Approximately €1.3 billion of this relates to committed
    expenditure for national roads including approx. €800 million relating to closeout payments for
    national roads projects recently completed.
    Over €300 million relates to committed
    expenditure for public transport projects.
    In addition, a significant portion of the overall transport capital investment programme is
    essential for on-going annual expenditure programmes such as railway safety (€400 million),
    road rehabilitation / maintenance (approx. €9OO million for regional & local roads), Coastguard
    1 Expenditure between 2008 — 2010 reflected various cuts in the capital allocation for T21 projects
    totalling approx. €1 billion.
    Economic Difficulties and Reduced Allocations
    Transport 21 (T21) was the 10-year capital investment framework established in 2005 to provide
    for the development of transport infrastructure. At the launch of T21, a €34 billion investment
    package was announced which comprised €26 billion to be provided by the Exchequer and €8
    billion by Public Private Partnership {PPP) funding.
    In the first 5 years of T21 Exchequer expenditure amounted to a total of over €10.5 billion.
    T21 Expenditure 2006-2010* _'__
    vear w 2007 2008 W 2010 Total
    €billion 1.937 2.357 2.504 2.124 1.730 10.652
    In addition, the 1“ PPP roads programme resulted in private sector funding of approx. €2 billion
    Arising from the allocation under the National Recovery Plan in November 2010, a breakdown of
    the reduced transport capital investment programme for 2011-2014 is as follows:
    _ 2011 2012 2013 2014 mai
    €m €rn €m €m €m
    Public Transport 394 392 527 493 1,806
    swans @ sas 510 asc 2,865
    Other 54 S2 38 28 172
    mai 1,438 Q 1,075 1,001 4,aaa
    Note - Summary of Reductions:
    The original exchequer allocation provided for T21 has been subject to a number of adjustments totalling
    approx. €7 billion between 2008-2014 as follows:
    2008-2010: total reductions of approx. €1 billion were implemented.
    2011-2014: total reductions of almost €6 billion have been proposed for the four years covered by the
    National Recovery Plan.
    Committed Expenditure
    Of the €4.843 billion allocated for 2011-2014, it is estimated that in the region of €1.7 billion of
    this is contractually committed. Approximately €1.3 billion of this relates to committed
    expenditure for national roads including approx. €800 million relating to closeout payments for
    national roads projects recently completed. Over €300 million relates to committed
    expenditure for public transport projects.
    In addition, a significant portion of the overall transport capital investment programme is
    essential for on-going annual expenditure programmes such as railway safety (€400 million),
    road rehabilitation / maintenance (approx. €9OO million for regional & local roads), Coastguard
    1 Expenditure between 2008 — 2010 reflected various cuts in the capital allocation for T21 projects
    totalling approx. €1 billion.

    Search & Rescue (€30 million), maintaining progress on accessibility (€5O million) and traffic
    management projects (€12O million).
    Existing Capital Investment Priorities 2011-2014
    Public Transport
    A total ofjust over €1.8 billion has been provided for public transport projects in the National
    Recovery Plan.
    • Metro North is the major component of the public transport allocation. Enabling works
    for Metro North are scheduled to commence in 2011 and the procurement process is
    continuing.
    • It will now not be possible to deliver the tunnel element of the DART Underground
    programme in the immediate period. However, provision has been made for funding
    some of the re-signalling and associated works, which have capacity benefits in and of
    themselves.
    · Funding will continue to be provided for vital public transport programmes such as
    railway safety, traffic management, accessibility and real time passenger information
    across the country. In Dublin the Luas extension to Citywest will be completed in 2011
    and a new public transport bridge at Marlborough Street will commence construction.
    • Planning will continue on a range of other public transport projects including Luas BXD,
    the cross-city link, Luas extensions to Lucan and Bray, Metro West and the DART
    Underground tunnel.
    • Funding will also be provided for the purchase of new buses for PSO services.
    • Further progress on Phase 2 of the Western Rail Corridor will be dependent on a review
    of the performance of Phase 1 and a full economic assessment of Phase 2.
    Roads .
    There is funding of €1,820 million for national roads and €1,045 million available for regional &
    local roads over the next four years.

    NRA have adequate money for rehabilitation and minor works in 2011 and will go ahead
    with the planned 2011 starts including Belturbet, Longford and Tralee bypasses , N4
    Downes grade separation and the Cork Southern Ring Road junctions. Two PPP projects
    are also scheduled to start in 2011; the M17/18 Gort — Tuam PPP and lvl11/Newlands
    Cross PPP bypasses.
    • No major schemes are likely to start in 2012 or 2013 due to the shortage of funds. Due
    to the reduction in funding from 2013 NRA plans to focus on maintenance of existing
    assets and the incremental improvement of national secondary roads.
    Other Funding

    • €172 million has been earmarked for other projects over the next four years. Almost
    half of this will be provided to support Smarter Travel Policy measures, mainly
    comprising of investment in exemplary cycling and walking infrastructure.
    • Just over €50 million is being provided to Maritime and Irish Coast Guard projects; the
    main focus of this investment being the cost of a new build S92 Helicopter for the Irish
    Coast Guard (IRCG) Search and Rescue (SAR) helicopter service and payments in respect
    of remedial works being carried out at regional harbours.
    • In addition, €2O million in total is being provided in 2011 and 2012 to partially fund the
    Cross-Border A5 Road (North West Gateway to Aughnacloyj project.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,476 ✭✭✭ardmacha


    Thanks to Leo for putting his briefing online

    http://www.transport.ie/upload/gener..._VERSION-0.PDF

    Scans of crappy documents are an amateurish way to put things online and does not bode well for professional approach for the actual projects.

    Thanks Sponge Bob for the OCR.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 25,234 ✭✭✭✭Sponge Bob


    On to Page 141 of 322 for more detail, this document is quite refreshing as it simply sticks to the facts not the greasy shyte spun in answers to PQs in the Dáil or in some annual report or other.
    The Transport Investment Division

    Assistant Secretary: John Murphy
    Principal Officer: Doreen Keaney
    Principal Advisor: Dominic Mullaney
    Overview
    The Transport Investment Division was established in 2010 amalgamating four Divisions
    involved in the delivery of investment in transport:
    1. Capital investment programme monitoring,
    2. Publictransportinvestment,
    3. Roads investment,
    4. EU Funding programme
    Key responsibilities:
    • To provide an appropriate policy and funding framework for investment in transport
    • To manage the Departments capital envelope including monitoring, evaluation,
    communication and reporting on agencies, projects and spend
    The Division also oversees / supports Cross Border transport initiatives and provides support for
    the implementation of the Sustainable Travel and Transport Action Plan.
    ln 2011 the Division will oversee a capital budget of €1,438 million for investment in transport
    (mainly for roads and public transport projects) and a current budget of €251,539 million to
    cover maintenance grants for National Roads, Regional & Local Roads, for PPP Operational
    payments and for NRA administration.
    ln delivering the transport investment programme the Division works closely with a number of
    state agencies primarily the National Transport Authority (NTA), Railway Procurement Agency
    (RPA), Irish Rail and the National Roads Authority (NRA). Since the establishment ofthe NTA in
    2009 responsibility for funding the construction of public transport infrastructure, promoting an
    integrated public transport system in the Greater Dublin Area (GDA) falls within the remit of the
    NTA. They oversee and liaise closely with Irish Rail, Dublin Bus, RPA and local authorities
    regarding investment for public transport within the overall framework set by Government
    under relevant strategic investment programmes such as T21 and the National Development
    Plan.
    The work of the EU Progranmes Unit is expected to conclude mid — 2011 with the expected closure of
    the relevant programmes. .

    1. CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROGRAMME
    Key Issues in this area are · f
    1. Economic Difficu|ties/ Reduced Allocations 2. Committed Expenditure 3. Capital Investment
    Priorities 2011-2014 _
    Please see separate Key lssues brief at ( already posted by SB) Section 3. Mn __
    Transport 21 Funding
    Transport 21 (T21) is the capital investment framework agreed by Government for the
    development of transport infrastructure for the period 2006 to 2015. At the launch of T21, a €34
    billion investment package was announced which comprised:
    • €26 billion to be provided by the Exchequer and €8 billion by Public Private Partnership
    (PPP) funded projects of which;
    · €18 billion to be invested in the national roads programme and €16 billion to be
    invested in public transport projects and regional airports
    • the National Programme to receive in the order of €20 billion and the Greater Dublin
    Area Programme to receive in the order of €14 billion
    In the first 5 years of T21 Exchequer expenditure amounted to a total of over €10.5 billion.
    T21 Expenditure 2006-2010° __ _ ____
    veal m 2007 zoos W 2010 Total
    €bi||ion 1.937 2.357 2.504 2.124 1.730 —__10.652
    In addition, the 1” PPP roads programme resulted in private sector funding of approx. €2 billion
    Economic Difficulties and Reduced Allocations
    Arising from the allocation under the National Recovery Plan in November 2010, a breakdown of
    the reduced transport capital investment programme for 2011-2014 is as follows:
    2011 2012 2014 Total
    €m €m €m €m
    Public Transport 394 392 527 493 1,806
    Roads Q ass 510 480 2,865
    Other 54 52 38 28 172
    Total 1,438 1,329 1,075 1,001 4,843
    The original exchequer allocation provided for T21 has been subject to a number of adjustments
    totalling approx. €7 billion between 2008~2014 as follows:
    • 2008-2010: total reductions of approx. €1 billion were implemented.
    • 2011-2014: total reductions of almost €6 billion have been proposed for the four years
    covered by the National Recovery Plan.
    Committed Expenditure
    ° Expenditure between 2008 - 2010 reflected various cuts in the capital allocation for T21 projects
    totalling approx. €1 billion.

    Of the €4.843 billion allocated for 2011»2014, it is estimated that in the region of€1.7 billion of
    this is contractually committed. Approximately €1.3 billion of this relates to committed
    expenditure for national roads including approx. €800 million relating to closeout payments for
    national roads projects recently completed. Over €300 million relates to committed
    expenditure for public transport projects.
    In addition, a significant portion of the overall transport capital investment programme is
    essential for on—going annual expenditure programmes such as railway safety (€400 million),
    road rehabilitation / maintenance (approx. €90O million for regional & local roads), Coastguard
    Search & Rescue (€3O million), maintaining progress on accessibility (€50 million) and traffic
    management projects (€120 million).
    Capital Investment Priorities 2011-2014
    Having successfully focused on the delivery of major roads infrastructure over the initial phase
    of T21, it was always the intention that the emphasis on new projects would shift significantly to
    public transport in the later stages ofthe programme. It was intended that the ratio of
    expenditure on new T21 projects between public transport and the national roads programme
    would be 2:1 in favour of public transport following the completion of payments for the major
    motorways programme in 2011. Due to the deteriorating economic circumstances, it will not
    now be possible to achieve a 2:1 ratio in favour of public transport during the period 2011-2014.
    However, the level of investment in public transport infrastructure will increase while roads
    investment correspondingly reduces from 2012 (see table above).
    Implementation Arrangements
    In the main, responsibility for delivery ofT21 projects from design/planning through seeking
    approvals, procurement and implementation rests with the Departments State agencies as
    follows:
    • National Transport Authority (NTA) · Since its establishment at the end of 2009 the NTA
    is responsible for financing the construction of public transport infrastructure in the
    Greater Dublin Area (GDA). The Department provides funding to the NTA which it then
    allocates to projects based on priorities identified in T21/ National Recovery Plan and
    having regard to its role in promoting an integrated public transport network.
    • Iarrirod Eireann - lntercity, commuter and suburban rail services
    • Railway Procurement Agency (RPA) -Luas and Metro networks
    • National Roads Authority (NRA) · National roads projects.
    The Department of Transport directly administers some capital funding in relation to Smarter
    Travel Policy, Maritime and Irish Coast Guard projects and various requirements in relation to
    regional airports, road safety, vehicle and driver licensing measures. [Further details available
    from relevant Divisional Briefs]
    Appraisal and Monitoring of Projects
    All capital projects are required to be properly appraised in line with the Department of Finance
    Capital Appraisal Guidelines and all projects costing over €3O million require a Cost Benefit
    Analysis (CBA) to be carried out. Since 2007, the Department has engaged auditors to
    implement an extensive audit programme to ensure that the State agencies with responsibility
    for implementing projects are compliant with the Department of Finance Capital Appraisal

    Guidelines and \/alue for Money requirements. All projects and programmes being funded
    under T21 are also monitored by the Department of Transport and the Transport 21 Monitoring
    Group to ensure that value for money is obtained at all times, that the projects are subject to
    cost-benefit analyses and proper evaluation and that they are implemented according to best
    practice and Government guidelines. The Transport 21 Monitoring Group was established in
    2006 to oversee the implementation of T21. The Group which is chaired by the Department of
    Transport comprises senior officials from the Departments of Transport, Finance, Taoiseach and
    Environment Heritage and Local Government, as well as the National Development Finance
    Agency. The Chief Executives of each of the implementing agencies (RPA, NRA, CIE Group and
    NTA) attend the meetings. The Committee meets every 6 months to oversee the
    implementation of T21 in accordance with the Government Decision approving T21.
    Department of Transport - Capital Investment Programme 2011-2014

    tablecapextrans.jpg

    ** It is proposed that the 2013 and 2014 costs ofthe upgrading of the A5 road from Aughnacloy to
    Derry will be met from the overall capital envelope {See Section 3 ·- Key Issues Brief- Land
    Transport Issues — Roads] ( already posted SB)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,284 ✭✭✭dubhthach


    ardmacha wrote: »
    Scans of crappy documents are an amateurish way to put things online and does not bode well for professional approach for the actual projects.

    Thanks Sponge Bob for the OCR.

    True but it's safer when you "black out" parts of the text. One of the US federal bodies got in trouble couple years ago when they released PDF's with black out sections. Turns out the text was still there under the black, you just had to "Copy-paste" it to retrieve it from document.

    If you black it out, and then scan it in crap way you guaranteed that people can't figure out what's under the "blacked-out" sections ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,476 ✭✭✭ardmacha


    If you black it out, and then scan it in crap way you guaranteed that people can't figure out what's under the "blacked-out" sections

    There are solutions to this problem. I suspect the mandarins would rather that nothing was released than make an effort to get a system to release documents with short sections redacted. In the spirit of open government they should buy some software for the job.


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 25,234 ✭✭✭✭Sponge Bob




  • Closed Accounts Posts: 185 ✭✭oharach


    ardmacha wrote: »
    Scans of crappy documents are an amateurish way to put things online and does not bode well for professional approach for the actual projects.

    Thanks Sponge Bob for the OCR.

    To be fair to Leo, he didn't write the document – it's a civil service brief on his new job. Clearly it was cobbled together by multiple authors, given his three responsibilities, but it seems impartial and accurate from what I've read, which is exactly what the civil service should be offering a new Minister. The priorities he sets for the department and the culture he instils will determine how effective it is, and he shouldn't be judged on that yet, but even the decision to publish his brief reflects positively.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 25,234 ✭✭✭✭Sponge Bob


    The section on Current Spending ( not Capital and including Roads) is Here

    http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=71474455&postcount=9

    I reckon any current spending saved from their being no PPPs over the next 5 years will be diverted into maintenance.


    There are other fragments on roads dotted hither and thither anywhere from pages 1 to 230. Enjoy finding them yeerselves :D

    EG The Leinster Outer Orbital is dead save where they _may_ choose to do fragments of it in future and the NRA will become TII of course after amalgamation with the RPA this year.

    On a related note we might as well close this sub forum today. :(


Advertisement