2011 Inter Club Results Thread

thegen

Barton Cup, Preliminary Round.

Hazelgrove GC 1/2 - 4 1/2 Southcounty GC.

Hacker111

Barton Cup 1st Round:

Wicklow beat Glenmalure 4 1

Kilcoole/Woodenbridge v. Wicklow in next round

Paulusmaximus

Barton Cup - Preliminary Round.

Malahide bt The Royal Dublin 4-1

Malahide now play Corballis.... and ruin the chance of the eagerly awaited rematch between corballise and Royaler!!!!

f22

Paulusmaximus wrote: »

Barton Cup - Preliminary Round.

Malahide bt The Royal Dublin 4-1

Malahide now play Corballis.... and ruin the chance of the eagerly awaited rematch between corballise and Royaler!!!!

LOL, I would have actually gone to watch that match, it certainly wouldn't have been a friendly affair!

pinkdoubleeagle

f22 wrote: »

LOL, I would have actually gone to watch that match, it certainly wouldn't have been a friendly affair!

What is the history between the two clubs?

f22

pinkdoubleeagle wrote: »

What is the history between the two clubs?

Royal Dublin captain messed up the team sheet last year, Corballis pulled them on it and Royaler were disqualified as far as I remember. Nearly lead to violence!

Paulusmaximus

f22 wrote: »

Royal Dublin captain messed up the team sheet last year, Corballis pulled them on it and Royaler were disqualified as far as I remember. Nearly lead to violence!

From what i was told, royal dublin had two pairings at home, handicaps both 2 and 12... the captain's sheet had the two 2 handicappers swapped. Anyway match started and after 7/8 holes a Corballis guy returned with a print out of all the rules stating that an incorrect sheet results in the concession of the tie and not just the matches that are wrong.

Royal dublin felt that in the interests of sportsmanship, Corballis should have mentioned it on the first tee when the pairings are being introduced to one another as that is when Corballis would have known there was a problem.

anyway, it was an almighty f*ck up by the royal dublin captain...

Incidentally i believe Corballis where disqualified in the next round!

Fore Iron

Paulusmaximus wrote: »

From what i was told, royal dublin had two pairings at home, handicaps both 2 and 12... the captain's sheet had the two 2 handicappers swapped. Anyway match started and after 7/8 holes a Corballis guy returned with a print out of all the rules stating that an incorrect sheet results in the concession of the tie and not just the matches that are wrong.

Royal dublin felt that in the interests of sportsmanship, Corballis should have mentioned it on the first tee when the pairings are being introduced to one another as that is when Corballis would have known there was a problem.

anyway, it was an almighty f*ck up by the royal dublin captain...

Incidentally i believe Corballis where disqualified in the next round!

Even if they did highlight it at the first tee then surely RD would have been DQ'd anyway??

As you said, mighty error by the Captain and RD really can have no issue...

Paulusmaximus

Fore Iron wrote: »

Even if they did highlight it at the first tee then surely RD would have been DQ'd anyway??

As you said, mighty error by the Captain and RD really can have no issue...

not necessarily, from my understanding, Jack off 2 was to play with Bill 12. John off 2 was to play with Bob off 12.

the sheet said the pairings was John and Bill, and Jack with Bob.
Both legitimate pairings..

If it was said on the first tee, they could have legitimately played as per what was on the sheet...


thats my interpretation of what was said what happened...i may have picked up some of the facts wrong.

Fore Iron

Paulusmaximus wrote: »

not necessarily, from my understanding, Jack off 2 was to play with Bill 12. John off 2 was to play with Bob off 12.

the sheet said the pairings was John and Bill, and Jack with Bob.
Both legitimate pairings..

If it was said on the first tee, they could have legitimately played as per what was on the sheet...


thats my interpretation of what was said what happened...i may have picked up some of the facts wrong.

I see what you mean. Personally, I say no restraint!! I'd be doing whatever I could and calling whatever breaches have occured to try to get my team through to the next stage!

No use being all nice and firendly only to lose 5-0!!

ShriekingSheet

Yeah, it seems something like this happens every year now. Team Captains really need to know what they're doing. Truth is, these kind of mistakes happen regularly and aren't spotted/reported.

Russman

Fore Iron wrote: »

I'd be doing whatever I could and calling whatever breaches have occured to try to get my team through to the next stage!

Would you not rather win on the golf course ?

Personally I'd rather lose to good golf than go through in that manner (if the facts are as stated above).

There have been too many clubs in recent years that have tarnished reputations over stuff like that, they may have been in the right, but sportsmanship is still a big part of golf IMO.

Russman

Anyway, back on topic....:)

Barton Cup, first round
Slade Valley beat Grange 3:2

ShriekingSheet

Russman wrote: »

Anyway, back on topic....:)

Barton Cup, first round
Slade Valley beat Grange 3:2

Well done - that's a great result for SV.

Russman

Thanks sheet,
It was courtesy of a hole out from off the green at the 19th in the last match in the Grange I believe.

thegen

Russman wrote: »

Thanks sheet,
It was courtesy of a hole out from off the green at the 19th in the last match in the Grange I believe.

So I heard, a neighbour is a Grange member, they were not happy. He was telling me a 3 handicapper stuffed a few chips 10/15yds in front of him out the course. Should not have got to 19th, but he acknowledged that you can only beat whats in front of you and thats what SV did.

Paulusmaximus

thegen wrote: »

So I heard, a neighbour is a Grange member, they were not happy. He was telling me a 3 handicapper stuffed a few chips 10/15yds in front of him out the course. Should not have got to 19th, but he acknowledged that you can only beat whats in front of you and thats what SV did.

Bit harsh blaming one guy for losing three matches!! what about the other 2 pairings that were beaten!!!

thegen

Paulusmaximus wrote: »

Bit harsh blaming one guy for losing three matches!! what about the other 2 pairings that were beaten!!!

I dont think he was blaming one guy, just giving one instance. As he said you can't lose two at home and expect to go through.

upthe19th

Preliminary round Provincial towns

Enniscorthy bt bunclody 7.5 to 1.5

'scorthy

2008 winners Enniscorthy beat Arklow links today 4 - 1

thegen

Barton Cup:
Dublin City 1-4 Southcounty

mike12

Barton Cup
Bellewstown 3 Greenore 2

ernieprice

Barton Cup

Highfield 3 -- Kilcock 2

lowelife

ernieprice wrote: »

Barton Cup

Highfield 3 -- Kilcock 2

Nice one Ernie just trawled the web to find this result.

Nice game yesterday pity about the 9 down the 9th.

thegen

Just heard Beech Park beat Castle 4-1. Can anyone confirm?

Jacket111001

confirmed

moylano

Woodbrook beat Powerscourt 3 1/2 - 1 1/2

moylano

Anybody know the Delgany-Dun Laoghaire result?

AGC

Hollystown beat Westemanstown 4.5 to .5

Barton Cup

Sport101

moylano wrote: »

Anybody know the Delgany-Dun Laoghaire result?

Next Sunday as far as I know.

Nemesis

Kilcoole beat Woodenbridge in FBD Barton Cup.

3:2 I'm sure (I hope!)

Kilcoole had a 2 handicap/12 h'cap pairing who went 1 up at our 17th par 3. They won it with a 5 !!.

moylano

Greystones beat Old Conna 3-2 in FBD Barton Cup

Hacker111

Nemesis wrote: »

Kilcoole beat Woodenbridge in FBD Barton Cup.

What score was it? Close game?

royalcarlowgc

carlow beat gowran park in the barton

Sammo13

Playing for Druids Heath and we were beaten 3-2 by European Club.

Came down to the 2nd match in the Heath, EC bridied the 20th hole to win the tie. Heart breaker, we got our win in EC and we were hopeful of taking both ties in DH. Not to be.:mad:

Blainroe beat Druids Glen, they play EC next.

Paulusmaximus

Malahide beat Corballis in Barton cup

Malahide beat Balcarrick in Irish Mixed...

l

pinkdoubleeagle

Killeen Castle beat Lucan 3-2 with deciding match going to the 19th

thegen

Citywest 1.5 - Southcounty 3.5 in the Irish Mixed Foursomes.

AGC

Ashbourne beat Roganstown 3-2 in Barton Cup

ShriekingSheet

pinkdoubleeagle wrote: »

Killeen Castle beat Lucan 3-2 with deciding match going to the 19th

Good result for KC. Didn't think they'd have enough of a membership to field a decent team. Lucan are pretty good from what I know.

pinkdoubleeagle

ShriekingSheet wrote: »

Good result for KC. Didn't think they'd have enough of a membership to field a decent team. Lucan are pretty good from what I know.

Wasn't there so only got feedback yesterday in the club. Golf wasn't great I heard and ended up with Lucan losing two at home.

Good luck to Kileen Castlein the next round

Johnny_Fontane

Knightsbrook beat Royal Tara 3.5 - 1.5

A first win in the Barton for the club (I think):D

ShriekingSheet

Dundalk & Headfort went into extra holes yesterday evening and lost the light. They're back this evening to settle the fixture.

L.O.F.T

Dunmurry Springs beat Castle Barna 3-2 in the FBD Barton Cup yesterday.

Conman X1

Delgany beat Dun Laoghaire 4/1 in the Barton Cup and play Woodbrook in the next round

BUACHAILL

Coollattin beat Rosslare 3-2

ShriekingSheet

ShriekingSheet wrote: »

Dundalk & Headfort went into extra holes yesterday evening and lost the light. They're back this evening to settle the fixture.

One hole was played last night. Headfort won through.

PhilipMarlowe

Athy beat Gowran Park in the Mixed this evening.
/puts red club shirt away for the year

Was enjoying our game (1 up playing 17th) but called in because they won all 3 @ Gowran and the game in front of us too for good measure.

AGC

Ashbourne beat Laytown 3-2 in Irish Mixed today

getoffthepot

Newlands beat Castlewarden in mixed last Sunday

sodbuster77

South County beat Palmerstown House in the Metro on Saturday.