Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Unsatisfactory hygien standards at city butchers

  • 20-03-2011 7:13pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,155 ✭✭✭


    I was in a well known, long established city butchers on Saturday. I bought 2 chicken breasts and 2 pork chops. It was the first time I had been in this establishment since the 80's (when I was with my mother). I couldn't help but notice how they handled meat and money without wearing gloves or washing hands.

    I had a similar experience in another long established city butchers last year when i was buying sausage meat for the Christmas stuffing. On that occasion I complained and walked out.

    This disgusting practice can be seen by passers-by on the street so they are not even hiding their bad practice.

    I will never shop in either of these butcher shops again. I have never had such issues when buying meat at any of the large supermarkets where I almost always buy meat.


    End of rant.


Comments

  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    A lot of places use sanitizing hand gels, which mean they don't need to wash their hands or wear gloves. You should just ask them the next time you're in there.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 554 ✭✭✭TotallyEpic


    It's worse when someone handling food wears the same gloves all day, and handles money with the same gloves.

    I'd rather no gloves and regular sanitisation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 411 ✭✭NotInventedHere


    You cook meat , That kills germs, so your rant makes no sense


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,155 ✭✭✭ErnieBert


    A lot of places use sanitizing hand gels, which mean they don't need to wash their hands or wear gloves. You should just ask them the next time you're in there.

    I watched from outside afterwards. ALL of the staff go straight from raw meat to money with the same hands. They don't use the gel or wear gloves.

    They effectively handed me back meaty money for change. Uggggghhhhh.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,155 ✭✭✭ErnieBert


    You cook meat , That kills germs, so your rant makes no sense

    What about their hands that handled raw meat and gave me my change? That surely transfers the germs to my hands?


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators Posts: 7,423 Mod ✭✭✭✭pleasant Co.


    ErnieBert wrote: »

    They affectively handed me back meaty money for change. Uggggghhhhh.

    It's probably for the best that you don't think too long or hard about the handling of change/money in general, you may end up with a severe psychological condition.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,155 ✭✭✭ErnieBert


    Mactard wrote: »
    It's probably for the best that you don't think too long or hard about the handling of change/money in general, you may end up with a severe psychological condition.

    Those men in white coats are butchers, aren't they? ;)


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators Posts: 7,423 Mod ✭✭✭✭pleasant Co.


    ErnieBert wrote: »
    Those men in white coats are butchers, aren't they? ;)

    How else do you think the zombie apocalypse is going to start..it's all in the change maaaaaan :cool:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    A lot of places use sanitizing hand gels, which mean they don't need to wash their hands or wear gloves. You should just ask them the next time you're in there.

    Those hand sanitizers work once
    1. You don't mind if a big gloop of it on a 'just done' hand lands in your meat
    2. It is done frequently enough.

    If someone is going back and forth between money and raw meat, they'd need to do it right in the middle in order for it to be fully efficient. I'm sure the feces, cold, whatever bacteria which we *know* is on money, would just love the fresh organic meaty environment in which to make babies! :eek:

    You're right OP - YUK, never mind the salmonella etc..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,349 ✭✭✭Jimmy Garlic


    I know this hygiene freak that sterilises her whole house and won't let her children play in the garden because of her irrational germ phobia. Guess what, they caught everything going when they went to preschool, they had no immunity built up and it all hit them at once.

    As for the butcher touching money after touching meat... let me put it into perspective, hundreds of other people touched that money and god only knows what else they were touching. It is no big deal, get over it. That's they way old skool butchers have always operated and it never killed any of em.
    Lest hope the 'health and safety' Taliban leave well alone.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    I know this hygiene freak that sterilises her whole house and won't let her children play in the garden because of her irrational germ phobia. Guess what, they caught everything going when they went to preschool, they had no immunity built up and it all hit them at once.

    As for the butcher touching money after touching meat... let me put it into perspective, hundreds of other people touched that money and god only knows what else they were touching. It is no big deal, get over it. That's they way old skool butchers have always operated and it never killed any of em.
    Lest hope the 'health and safety' Taliban leave well alone.

    You're right to some extent! The hand sanitizer stuff is encouraging immunity in bacteria, breeding superbugs. But I'm sorry - I draw the line at people not *bothering* to wash their hands. When I was in college (not today nor yesterday!) I worked in a Deli, and we *always* had to wash hands or use gloves when moving between handling food and handling money. They teach you this stuff and test you on it when you apply for a food handlers permit.
    Our local butcher growing up used those little plastic sheets of paper or a sheet of butcher paper to grab the meat. There was a scoop for the mince, it was quite an art, his hands never seemed to touch the meat. He washed his hands often, whether it was busy or not. Laziness isn't an excuse, nor is it old school. And as far as it 'not killing any of us', there ARE way more superbugs now, sadly, and people get nasty stuff all the time from this - just look at our hospitals. I'm not a germ freak, but the stuff on money is pretty disgusting, and I do wash my hands still before eating.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,266 ✭✭✭Steyr


    If they did Hot food too and fish and red meat then you MAY have an issue where cross-contamination is concerned.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 78,580 ✭✭✭✭Victor




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 554 ✭✭✭TotallyEpic


    Adds a bitta flavour...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    Adds a bitta flavour...

    Mmmm:)..poo:p


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,290 ✭✭✭happyoutscan


    Personally I wouldn't be over bothered but I can completely understand why the OP or others might be.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,295 ✭✭✭✭Mrs OBumble


    As for the butcher touching money after touching meat... let me put it into perspective, hundreds of other people touched that money and god only knows what else they were touching. It is no big deal, get over it. That's they way old skool butchers have always operated and it never killed any of em.

    It may not have killed them, but salmonella may well have killed some of their customers.

    There are two issues: the germs put onto the OPs meat by from previous person's change, via the butcher's hands, and the cross-contamination across the various sorts of meat.

    As someone said, this sort of stuff has been basic food hygiene practice for a long time, the butchers need to GWTP, IMHO. Not shopping there, and telling 'em why you're doing so, would be a very good idea.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 19,986 ✭✭✭✭mikemac


    So you're going to go to supermarkets instead OP?

    I reckon a trained Craft butcher knows more about what they sell and how to manage it then the teenager in the supermarket


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    So you're going to go to supermarkets instead OP?

    I reckon a trained Craft butcher knows more about what they sell and how to manage it then the teenager in the supermarket

    Evidently not according to the OP. The butcher we had growing up never did this.

    And btw, there are plenty of teenagers (or people who look like teenagers ;)) in butchers, and 'craft butchers' who work for larger supermarkets.

    Plenty of excellent 'craft butchers' in Galway do NOT do this with food handling, their craft is too important to them to be closed down by health and safety. It just sounds like laziness imo.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,874 ✭✭✭EGAR




  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 13,252 ✭✭✭✭Madame Razz


    Certainly think that I know one of the butchers shops to which the OP is referring, and I would wholeheartedly agree. Although I also think that their premises is filthy, and that there is definately one member of staff behind the counter that looks like they could do with a good wash. This establishment is much praised by Galwegians too, which amuses me greatly, as anytime i have been in there, i have gagged and had to leave because, well, it is just not clean. As I am aware, these premises are subject to spot checks by the relevant authorities, so I do not see how they get away with it.

    Regarding the money/meat thing, I've never witnessed that myself. Money, by it's nature, is not exactly clean anyway, but raw meat is dangerous, and if you witness this sort of practise anywhere, then you should report it. It's simply not on. Some butchers, Tormeys for example, keep the cash desk separate to the meat counters. This keeps the queue moving, but it is also better hygiene practise. It probably cuts till errors dramatically too.

    There's no excuse for lack of hygiene at a butchers premises. Where I grew up, we went to a very old school rural butcher, think basic shop fittings, noisy saws and sawdust on the floor; but the place was and still is spotless. If a rural butcher in the backarse of nowhere can manage hygiene, then I see no reason why a city butcher can't tbh.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,210 ✭✭✭dolphin city


    the meat is raw - any "germs" on that will be killed in the cooking process,unless you eat your meat raw in which case the butchers hands are the least of your worries.

    regarding meat or germs on your change I would suggest that if you are worried about this that YOU wear plastic gloves. Money has been, is and will be the filthiest thing to handle - you get traces of cocaine on most money, and lots of it is stuck down the front pants of males - what happens when they go to the loo and stick their hand in their pocket afterwards. Don't blame butchers.

    Humans, especially adult humans are immune to most of these germs - and we can handle it - what age are you - you have been handling germs for as long as were alive.

    Wanting everything sterilised will break down your defences against germ and you will end up living in a bubble.

    Next time you are in a butcher and you get money handed out to you - just think - what other germs could be on the money - look at the customer before you - are they filthy - are you receive their "fiver" - where did they have it stashed.

    :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,210 ✭✭✭dolphin city


    speaking of butchers tho, there is one particular "supermarket" butcher that I have to avoid at all costs - the meat part of the shop STINKS to the high heaven. I don't understand why anyone would venture to purchase meat in it. Its diabolical.

    I do tend to get my meat at a butcher shop overall.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 19,986 ✭✭✭✭mikemac


    Nobody on this thread is listing the places they avoid. So not much to be learned realy

    If your story is true then post it up


  • Moderators, Technology & Internet Moderators Posts: 7,423 Mod ✭✭✭✭pleasant Co.


    Nobody on this thread is listing the places they avoid. So not much to be learned realy

    If your story is true then post it up

    There's truth, and provable truth - unless the OP has the latter the name of any of these establishments should not be listed....you know, the whole boards legal liability thing...

    Just to note, I totally believe the OP.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 19,986 ✭✭✭✭mikemac


    Mactard wrote: »
    .you know, the whole boards legal liability thing...
    .

    Way offtopic but I always found it strange I can log on boards and lash Eircom, UPC, Airtricity, Vodafone and any big company

    But if I named and shamed Tom's Dodgy Car Dealership in Tuam or some dodgy butcher in Galway, whoosh, it would be taken down

    Yeah, offtopic so I'll leave it at that :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    the meat is raw - any "germs" on that will be killed in the cooking process,unless you eat your meat raw in which case the butchers hands are the least of your worries.

    regarding meat or germs on your change I would suggest that if you are worried about this that YOU wear plastic gloves. Money has been, is and will be the filthiest thing to handle - you get traces of cocaine on most money, and lots of it is stuck down the front pants of males - what happens when they go to the loo and stick their hand in their pocket afterwards. Don't blame butchers.

    Humans, especially adult humans are immune to most of these germs - and we can handle it - what age are you - you have been handling germs for as long as were alive.

    Wanting everything sterilised will break down your defences against germ and you will end up living in a bubble.

    Next time you are in a butcher and you get money handed out to you - just think - what other germs could be on the money - look at the customer before you - are they filthy - are you receive their "fiver" - where did they have it stashed.

    :D

    Humans *aren't* for the most part, immune to strep, staph, e-coli though. While I hear what you are saying about over sterilization causing bug immunity, I think simple hygene still is important. People say things like 'ah butchers have been doing that for a thousand years' - yeah, and what was the average life expectancy then? You're absolutely right Dolphin City, money is disgusting - and for that reason I wash my hands before eating or preparing food. Of course there are bacteria everywhere, but places like the eyes, mouth (and raw meat) are much friendlier places for those bacteria to grow and live, than say a hand (which can transfer them). It's a bit like two wrongs not making a right, just because we are exposed to potential bacterial infection daily, doesn't make a case for greatly upping the odds by adding organisms and gunk to raw meat. Doesn't make sense. Cross infection between meats/ fish, hot/raw food can be just as bad. No one is advocating Howard Hughes behaviour, but without being obsessive, why not make our food a bit safer?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,109 ✭✭✭Cavehill Red


    inisboffin wrote: »
    You're right to some extent! The hand sanitizer stuff is encouraging immunity in bacteria, breeding superbugs. But I'm sorry - I draw the line at people not *bothering* to wash their hands. When I was in college (not today nor yesterday!) I worked in a Deli, and we *always* had to wash hands or use gloves when moving between handling food and handling money. They teach you this stuff and test you on it when you apply for a food handlers permit.
    Our local butcher growing up used those little plastic sheets of paper or a sheet of butcher paper to grab the meat. There was a scoop for the mince, it was quite an art, his hands never seemed to touch the meat. He washed his hands often, whether it was busy or not. Laziness isn't an excuse, nor is it old school. And as far as it 'not killing any of us', there ARE way more superbugs now, sadly, and people get nasty stuff all the time from this - just look at our hospitals. I'm not a germ freak, but the stuff on money is pretty disgusting, and I do wash my hands still before eating.

    Cock and bull alert. This, children, is why a little scientific knowledge is worse than none at all.
    This well-meaning but deluded poster thinks that alcohol-based hand sanitiser use is 'encouraging immunity in bacteria'. Nope, it's just killing the bacteria stone dead.
    But, they splutter, look at the superbugs in the hospitals? Yes, indeed. When we treat conditions with antibiotics, and lazy patients don't finish their course of treatment because they feel better already, then bugs develop immunity - TO THE ANTIBIOTICS.
    They don't get immune to alcohol hand sanitiser, though. That would be a bit like a soldier developing immunity to bullets. Not happening. It still kills them stone dead.

    TLDR: Hand sanitisers DO kill all the germs on your hands. Use them properly, children.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    Cock and bull alert. This, children, is why a little scientific knowledge is worse than none at all.
    This well-meaning but deluded poster thinks that alcohol-based hand sanitiser use is 'encouraging immunity in bacteria'. Nope, it's just killing the bacteria stone dead.
    But, they splutter, look at the superbugs in the hospitals? Yes, indeed. When we treat conditions with antibiotics, and lazy patients don't finish their course of treatment because they feel better already, then bugs develop immunity - TO THE ANTIBIOTICS.
    They don't get immune to alcohol hand sanitiser, though. That would be a bit like a soldier developing immunity to bullets. Not happening. It still kills them stone dead.

    TLDR: Hand sanitisers DO kill all the germs on your hands. Use them properly, children.

    Children? Children should wash their hands! :p
    is all sanitizer alcohol based? Just curious?

    Ok, I confess to not being ab expert on these matters, but a good pal is a consultant and in surgery at least 5 days a week. She was talking about how they've had to change their 'sterilization methods ' (that was the term I believe) as bacteria and viruses were becoming resistant to what they were using. Now, two things, I know bacteria and viruses are different, but I know they can be present in both 'meat' and humans. I made the leap from one form of 'meat' (on the op table) to the other. Perhaps that is the flaw in my argument. Maybe you can address that point for us 'little people', or (shock horror) is there a disagreement perhaps, in the scientific community?
    I'd hate to remain misguided ;)

    PS. I will admit that my superbug comment was a sidestep to the hygene thread, and read as confusing. The point I was making there is that we are not immune to buggy bugs, even in a sanitary environment like a hospital. And people do become immune to the antibiotics for more reasons than not finishing a course, as I'm sure you know! :)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,109 ✭✭✭Cavehill Red


    inisboffin wrote: »
    Children? Children should wash their hands! :p
    is all sanitizer alcohol based? Just curious?

    All the useful ones are. Anything else is at best just liquid soap.
    inisboffin wrote: »
    Ok, I confess to not being ab expert on these matters, but a good pal is a consultant and in surgery at least 5 days a week. She was talking about how they've had to change their 'sterilization methods ' (that was the term I believe) as bacteria and viruses were becoming resistant to what they were using.

    And do you actually know what a hospital consultant means when they talk about sterilisation methods? They mean protocols for preventing cross-infection within a hospital environment. You can be fairly sure they don't mean handling beef in a butcher's (gory and all though some surgeons can be!)
    inisboffin wrote: »
    Now, two things, I know bacteria and viruses are different, but I know they can be present in both 'meat' and humans. I made the leap from one form of 'meat' (on the op table) to the other. Perhaps that is the flaw in my argument. Maybe you can address that point for us 'little people', or (shock horror) is there a disagreement perhaps, in the scientific community?
    I'd hate to remain misguided ;)

    Yes, bacteria are different from viruses. There isn't much can be done about viruses, generally. You catch em, you suffer em, you wait till you get better (or not, if it's something serious like HIV).
    When we're talking about food safety, we're generally concerned about bacteria, specifically nasty bacteria that proliferates on food and can cause food poisoning. An alcohol based hand sanitiser will kill these bacteria stone dead on your hands. Then you won't pass them on to whatever food you're handling. Of course, there's more to food safety than that, as I'm sure you know. Correct storage is very important.
    inisboffin wrote: »
    PS. I will admit that my superbug comment was a sidestep to the hygene thread, and read as confusing. The point I was making there is that we are not immune to buggy bugs, even in a sanitary environment like a hospital. And people do become immune to the antibiotics for more reasons than not finishing a course, as I'm sure you know! :)

    People become immune to the antibiotics???


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 40 focuslfc


    I used to work in a butchers that had a fresh meat/fish and deli counter. There is a very easy system they could utilise here.
    1. Use gloves while serving the meat.
    2. Put the gloves in the bin.
    3. Serve the customer at the till.
    4. Wash your hands or at least put on clean gloves.
    5. Serve next customer.
    And the circle continues and becomes a routine.

    As for the hygiene I know every single day we had to clean every bit of equipment that we used for example the saw and the mincer would have to be cleaned inside out. Even the counters would be cleaned every single day and would get a deep clean on a weekly basis. The same applied for the fish counter. The butchers block would be sanded down on a daily basis if not more and all work top surfaces would be spotless. The same applied for the fridges and all the this was taught through haccp. There is no excuse for having poor hygiene in a well established business. I have an idea who one of the businesses the OP is talking about and i have never understood the reason why people go there.:confused:


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 18,300 ✭✭✭✭Seaneh


    gloves are pointless. People get lazy while wearing gloves and end up wearing the same pair for hours without once even running them under a tap.
    Washing your hands every time you handle raw meat or money would be much more efficient and practical.

    I actually HATE when I eat out and can see chefs wearing gloves, it immediately screams that they are trying to APPEAR to be clean rather than just using good practices.


    next time your in a deli, watch the girl/lad there touch their face, clothes, brush their hair out of their eyes, scratch their head, wipe their borw, handle cold and hot meats and then make people a sambo with the same gloves on.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,210 ✭✭✭dolphin city


    we could all just become vegetarian and use a bartering method instead of using money. That would solve it. But then, the problem would arise somewhere else.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 217 ✭✭yeehaw


    we could all just become vegetarian and use a bartering method instead of using money. That would solve it. But then, the problem would arise somewhere else.

    Perhaps you could eat something infected with a particularly nasty strain of something... for the good of this board.

    Mod note:banned for this comment


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,399 ✭✭✭✭ben.schlomo


    I bought meat in one of Galways best butchers in the heart of the city this morning and when he picked up the meat he used the outside of the plastic bag that he then put it in. he did not need to wear gloves and then i paid him. no problems. people would want to relax a bit. As long as you cook your meat properly theres no problem unless the place is a complete kip.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    All the useful ones are. Anything else is at best just liquid soap.



    And do you actually know what a hospital consultant means when they talk about sterilisation methods? They mean protocols for preventing cross-infection within a hospital environment. You can be fairly sure they don't mean handling beef in a butcher's (gory and all though some surgeons can be!)



    Yes, bacteria are different from viruses. There isn't much can be done about viruses, generally. You catch em, you suffer em, you wait till you get better (or not, if it's something serious like HIV).
    When we're talking about food safety, we're generally concerned about bacteria, specifically nasty bacteria that proliferates on food and can cause food poisoning. An alcohol based hand sanitiser will kill these bacteria stone dead on your hands. Then you won't pass them on to whatever food you're handling. Of course, there's more to food safety than that, as I'm sure you know. Correct storage is very important.



    People become immune to the antibiotics???


    All the best ones are? Ok, good, lets hope people use the best!

    Actually the conversation was about sterilization specifically in Theatre, not cross-hospital. You can't blame a comparison between the meats, really, can you?;)

    There are plenty of 'nasty' 'less serious' viruses that can lead to death - (often as a result of a secondary infection, bacterial or non), and on the other side of the coin, plenty of people hiv+ (a 'serious' one) who are relatively healthy these days.


    And yup!!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    I bought meat in one of Galways best butchers in the heart of the city this morning and when he picked up the meat he used the outside of the plastic bag that he then put it in. he did not need to wear gloves and then i paid him. no problems. people would want to relax a bit. As long as you cook your meat properly theres no problem unless the place is a complete kip.

    This is what our old butcher my family had as a kid did, or something similar with butcher paper, tongs etc. But sticking your paws in and then handling cash sounds like it IS a complete kip, no? Well cooked meat is way safer, but rare meat, which some like, and burgers, (where the bacteria is often in the underdone bit in the middle, and hard to kill) are what can get ya.

    One of the biggest 'old school' older butchers in Dublin does that thing with different people doing the cash to the meat - worked brilliant for years.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,266 ✭✭✭Steyr


    inisboffin wrote: »
    and 'craft butchers' who work for larger supermarkets.

    I work with at least 4 who really know their stuff. Top men.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,266 ✭✭✭Steyr


    focuslfc wrote: »
    I used to work in a butchers that had a fresh meat/fish and deli counter. There is a very easy system they could utilise here.
    1. Use gloves while serving the meat.
    2. Put the gloves in the bin.
    3. Serve the customer at the till.
    4. Wash your hands or at least put on clean gloves.
    5. Serve next customer.
    And the circle continues and becomes a routine.

    As for the hygiene I know every single day we had to clean every bit of equipment that we used for example the saw and the mincer would have to be cleaned inside out. Even the counters would be cleaned every single day and would get a deep clean on a weekly basis. The same applied for the fish counter. The butchers block would be sanded down on a daily basis if not more and all work top surfaces would be spotless. The same applied for the fridges and all the this was taught through haccp. There is no excuse for having poor hygiene in a well established business. I have an idea who one of the businesses the OP is talking about and i have never understood the reason why people go there.:confused:

    Your damn right its all basic HACCP Procedures.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    But, they splutter, look at the superbugs in the hospitals? Yes, indeed. When we treat conditions with antibiotics, and lazy patients don't finish their course of treatment because they feel better already, then bugs develop immunity - TO THE ANTIBIOTICS.

    No, that's now how it happens at all, at least no one in the scientific community would credit that theory. Finishing a course of antibiotics has nothing to do with whether a bacteria develops immunity or not, more down to overuse of antibiotics. Just had to point that out since you took such issue with someone else's scientific ignorance, which was a bit mean I thought.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    Thanks. Eloquence and tiredness do not mix.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 40 focuslfc


    I bought meat in one of Galways best butchers in the heart of the city this morning and when he picked up the meat he used the outside of the plastic bag that he then put it in. he did not need to wear gloves and then i paid him. no problems. people would want to relax a bit. As long as you cook your meat properly theres no problem unless the place is a complete kip.

    We used to do this aswell where i worked but make sure there is no print on the outside of the bag.:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,109 ✭✭✭Cavehill Red


    No, that's now how it happens at all, at least no one in the scientific community would credit that theory. Finishing a course of antibiotics has nothing to do with whether a bacteria develops immunity or not, more down to overuse of antibiotics. Just had to point that out since you took such issue with someone else's scientific ignorance, which was a bit mean I thought.

    Not mean at all. It's totally wrong to assert that HAIs are spread by alcohol-based sanitisers, and to leave that assertion unchallenged could lead to people believing it and failing to sanitise their hands in clinical environments.
    Incidentally, finishing courses of antibiotics has plenty to do with whether bacteria develop immunity, because it is the failure to finish courses which leads to the overuse of antibiotics in the first place.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 796 ✭✭✭TheBunk1


    No, that's now how it happens at all, at least no one in the scientific community would credit that theory. Finishing a course of antibiotics has nothing to do with whether a bacteria develops immunity or not, more down to overuse of antibiotics. Just had to point that out since you took such issue with someone else's scientific ignorance, which was a bit mean I thought.

    Actually it is a factor in the spread of antibiotic resistance and I don't know where you got the idea that no one in the scientific community would agree! Even though a person may feel fine after 2-3 days of a 7 day course (or whatever combination you like) it does not mean the infection is gone. Lower levels of bacteria may still remain; levels at which there is an asymptomatic infection. These persisters, having had sub-lethal pre-exposure to the antibiotic now have a greater chance to develop resistance.

    Every single course of antibiotic dispensed in this country has the words "FINISH THE COURSE" printed on the box for a reason.

    Not finishing the course can lead to re-infection and another course of antibiotics and hence the overuse you refer to!

    It might be an idea to get your own facts straight.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    Not mean at all. It's totally wrong to assert that HAIs are spread by alcohol-based sanitisers, and to leave that assertion unchallenged could lead to people believing it and failing to sanitise their hands in clinical environments.

    So you seem to be saying, that leaving my comments unchecked (when you did so graciously check them in such a witty and sweet manner)on boards.ie, would lead to trained professionals abandoning their own scientific opinions, and burning their bras, I mean hand sanitizer (alcohol based - wait, you started that one!) thus bringing on a massive epidimic of something itis.

    Wow. I'm glad I'm a kid and don't have to take this Internet stuff seriously, otherwise I'd be very stressed at what I did!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,109 ✭✭✭Cavehill Red


    inisboffin wrote: »
    So you seem to be saying, that leaving my comments unchecked (when you did so graciously check them in such a witty and sweet manner)on boards.ie, would lead to trained professionals abandoning their own scientific opinions, and burning their bras, I mean hand sanitizer (alcohol based - wait, you started that one!) thus bringing on a massive epidimic of something itis.

    Wow. I'm glad I'm a kid and don't have to take this Internet stuff seriously, otherwise I'd be very stressed at what I did!

    No, I said that your comments might encourage members of the public to stop using hand sanitisers in hospital environments, not the professionals who well know the importance of using them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,398 ✭✭✭inisboffin


    Oh I see.. That's what you were saying.
    So how do you feel about hygiene in butchers again?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,109 ✭✭✭Cavehill Red


    inisboffin wrote: »
    Oh I see.. That's what you were saying.
    So how do you feel about hygene in butchers again?

    Could be better in some places.
    I like to shop in butchers where I can watch how they go about things before I shop, personally.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    TheBunk1 wrote: »
    Actually it is a factor in the spread of antibiotic resistance and I don't know where you got the idea that no one in the scientific community would agree! Even though a person may feel fine after 2-3 days of a 7 day course (or whatever combination you like) it does not mean the infection is gone. Lower levels of bacteria may still remain; levels at which there is an asymptomatic infection. These persisters, having had sub-lethal pre-exposure to the antibiotic now have a greater chance to develop resistance.

    Every single course of antibiotic dispensed in this country has the words "FINISH THE COURSE" printed on the box for a reason.

    Not finishing the course can lead to re-infection and another course of antibiotics and hence the overuse you refer to!

    It might be an idea to get your own facts straight.

    Hmm, I should have clarified my writing more. It is a factor I grant you, but a small one and no where near the main cause. The only papers I have ever come across that show it happening in humans are in the extremely ill and in invitro studies. Most overuse is from over prescription.

    But sigh, thanks for missing my main point all the same, the fact that getting all haughty and snarky about science is laughable when answering in such a brief format and making broad statements. I swear, what is up with this forum and the bad-tempered way people jump down people's throats when Galway is such a friendly city.

    No need for that kind of attitude at all. You can actually make a point and not resort to insulting people believe it or not.

    Have a nice day now :)


  • Posts: 24,714 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    I usually buy meat from supermarket butchers who don't handle money but they always handle the meat, bag it and hand it to you, the same is done by butchers from what Ive seen. This is no different as the bag will have been handled by the same hands as the raw meat yet this is never noticed/bothers anybody.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement