Is this tax calculator correct?

mathie

http://www.executive-connections.ie/salary_calculator.php#calc_results

thanks

namenotavailablE

My calculator at taxcalc.eu/monthlyss is accurate based on tests I've done with my own/ my wife's/ other people's salaries.
That one doesn't seem to be accurate- it seems to overstate net pay (in 2010? - it doesn't state the year for which the calculation is being done) by approx 10% for a single person.

Benny Cake

namenotavailabl wrote: »

My calculator at taxcalc.eu/monthlyss is accurate based on tests I've done with my own/ my wife's/ other people's salaries.
That one doesn't seem to be accurate- it seems to overstate net pay (in 2010? - it doesn't state the year for which the calculation is being done) by approx 10% for a single person.

This calc doesnt seem to be working at the moment......

namenotavailablE

When you say 'not working', do you mean:

• The download site is not available or
• The calculator can't be downloaded or
• The calculator 'breaks' when you try to use it.

I checked this morning and it seems to be OK but if you could give me more details I can check it out.

One possible thing is that yesterday [Saturday] at approx 10pm I uploaded a wrong file in which I had forgotten to update a piece of code. That was fixed and a new version uploaded at approx 10.30pm yesterday. I know that 3 downloads of the broken version occurred so it may be that you were one of the unfortunate downloaders! If so, my apologies - you can download a working version from http://taxcalc.eu/monthlyss

gleep

This one is accurate and working

http://www.hookhead.com/Tools/tax2010.jsp

namenotavailablE

The Hookhead one seems to have a problem- try putting in an income of €90000. The Health levy 'goes crazy'!