Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Lifting weights to lose weight

  • 14-01-2010 10:58am
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34,725 ✭✭✭✭


    I've been going to the gym for a while now. Set myself a target for weightloss and while it started off okay, I seem to be stuck. Part of it is diet, which I know I need to work on. My current routine was a mixture of cardio and weight machines, but I've seen people here say free weights are better. My current routine is:

    10 mins rowing machine
    3x10 50kg Low Pulley
    10 mins Crosstrainer (Level 6)
    3x10 40kg bench press
    15 mins bike (Level 6)
    3x10 50kg Lat machine
    3x10 25kg Leg curl
    3x10 50kg Abdominal curl (I think thats what its called)
    (+ stretches before and after)

    Last saturday, I asked the trainer to show me a few free weights to replace the machines. We discussed things and I told him I wanted a programme that I could do every day I went in (instead of arms on monday, shoulder/chest wednesday etc), I told him my main goal was to lose weight, and I wanted kind of an all over programme (one with arms, shoulders, chest legs, back etc that I could do every day)

    So after the rowing machine, he had me going some shoulder presses with dumbells, and some bicep and tricep curls, which were all grand. Trouble came with the bench press. I told him I used to do 3x10 40kg on the machine, so he started me off just lifting the bar 15 times, which was 20kg. I found that to be okay, as I was getting used to the balance. Then we did 15 reps of 30kg, which I found really tough. Then after another set of the dumbells and curls, had me lift 40kg 15 times, which I really struggled with. Then with the dumbells and curls, I really struggled through them as my arms were aching. Then when it came to the bench press again, I could only do 5 of 30kg before I had to stop. Even 4 days later, my arms were killing me.

    My concern would be that I feel this is too much work on just my upper body, with no work at all on my legs or lower body. Plus, there is no way I could do 4 sets of that programme 4 times a week, particularly the bench press, even at 30kg. And I wouldn't feel right about using the bench press to just lift the bar.

    I was just wondering if I could get some overall advice. Should I change it so I do work on different muscle groups each time? The reason I'm apprehensive about that is although I mostly go 4 times a week, sometimes I get bogged down at work and might miss a few sessions here and there. Should I do some free weights and some machine weights? Like I said, my main purpose is to lose weight, and I'm really not that strong anyway. Looking to lose about 3 stone over the next 6 months hopefully. Current diet is:

    Breakfast: Porridge
    Lunch: Brown bread sandwich of egg and turkey (probably need to change this)
    Dinner: Meat and half portion of potatoes, a bit of veg
    Snacks: Dark chocolate, yogurts, bit of fruit (have a nut intolerance, so thats out)
    Drinks: Water, low-fat milk, bit of orange juice every now and again

    So, all help really appreciated, on all parts of my workout/diet. I've lost almost 2 stone in the last 6 months, increasing my workout routine every few weeks, but now I'm just stuck in a rut


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,394 ✭✭✭Transform


    keep it simple

    For example-

    for a full body program you are going to need leg work e.g. lunges, deadlifts, squats, GHR, step ups and split squats.

    Then add in some back work as there was none in the workout mentioned e.g. seated rows, one arm rows, chins etc

    Overall if your trainer cant get the finger out of his butt and give you a proper program go ask another one.

    For a full body program you should really operate off 2-3 different programs every week and 4 days of the same weights program per week is wayyyy overkill.

    Overall the diet needs some sharpening up and the portions of the foods you eat are going to be the killer if you are 3stone overweight i.e. you eat wayy to much.

    A simple full body program for a beginner -

    Squats + Press ups 10-15reps of both for 4 sets and take 1-2mins break between each round i.e. do both THEN rest.

    Swiss ball leg curls + One arm rows - as above

    Standing over head dumbbell press + Crunches

    Plank position (30-40secs) + Reverse ab curls (20reps) for 4 sets

    Another full program would have different exercises and possibly a different structure.

    All the best


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34,725 ✭✭✭✭Penn


    Cheers for the reply
    Transform wrote: »
    keep it simple

    For example-

    for a full body program you are going to need leg work e.g. lunges, deadlifts, squats, GHR, step ups and split squats.

    Then add in some back work as there was none in the workout mentioned e.g. seated rows, one arm rows, chins etc

    Overall if your trainer cant get the finger out of his butt and give you a proper program go ask another one.

    This is where the trouble is, the trainers in the gym are useless. I asked another trainer before if free weights were better than machines for losing weight, I was told that there's no difference, but I should do more reps at a lower weight. Something which I was later told here was wrong. And on saturday when I asked this other trainer for help coming up with a programme, he kept going off to do his own workout too.
    Transform wrote: »
    For a full body program you should really operate off 2-3 different programs every week and 4 days of the same weights program per week is wayyyy overkill.

    Yeah, I realised that after the way my arms felt the other day. While I would like to be stronger, I'm mostly focusing on losing weight so I thought one all-over workout 4 times a week would be better, but I guess not
    Transform wrote: »
    Overall the diet needs some sharpening up and the portions of the foods you eat are going to be the killer if you are 3stone overweight i.e. you eat wayy to much.

    Yeah I agree. I calculated my calorie intake and worked it out to be just under 2200, but I think I need to monitor carb and fat levels a bit closer
    Transform wrote: »
    A simple full body program for a beginner -

    Squats + Press ups 10-15reps of both for 4 sets and take 1-2mins break between each round i.e. do both THEN rest.

    Swiss ball leg curls + One arm rows - as above

    Standing over head dumbbell press + Crunches

    Plank position (30-40secs) + Reverse ab curls (20reps) for 4 sets

    Another full program would have different exercises and possibly a different structure.

    All the best

    Sounds good. I'll have a look into that. Cheers again for the help


Advertisement