A heinous act but what should be her punishment?

Butterfly baby · 10-06-2009 5:31pm #1

This is vile to read so please don't read it if you are in anyway squmish

http://www.comcast.net/articles/news-national/20090607/US.Pregnant.Woman.Killed/

Now the point of my question is that in all other aspects she was a normal person but just seem to have acted out of impulse and, as you can see in the article, she's not the first to do it. There is also the point of if the child was alive or not during her actions bt no one can say for definite which should also be considered so what way do you think she should be treated (within the legal system)?

Choices:

!. Death sentence
2. Life in prison
3. Mental institute (But bare in mind there seems to have been no previous indication of mental problems)
4. Mental institute but studied (that sounds lifeless I know but should we try to find out why someone to just changes from normal to a murderer in a matter of days?)
5. Open choice, give your own if none of mine apply to what you think should happen.

Morlar · 10-06-2009 5:33pm

Butterfly baby wrote: »

!. Death sentence

Gets my vote.

Ruu_Old · 10-06-2009 5:33pm

Public flogging (until dead).

Holsten · 10-06-2009 5:34pm

Death.

easyeason3 · 10-06-2009 5:36pm

Death, no question about it.
Preferably if they could stab her & leave her to bleed to death.

SV · 10-06-2009 5:37pm

Cut out her eyes and set her on fire and beat her and....

Wait..

Nah i'm in AH, this is definitely a good answer.

who what when · 10-06-2009 5:37pm

Death sentence no doubt

eddiehead · 10-06-2009 5:39pm

I would like - Death sentence

Will probably get - Life sentence

If she were in Ireland - Suspended sentence

Dennis the Stone · 10-06-2009 5:39pm

Make her watch every episode of Fair City ever. TWICE.

thelordofcheese · 10-06-2009 5:39pm

Not this shit again....

In before people start posting their revenge fantas....

easyeason3 wrote:

Preferably if they could stab her & leave her to bleed to death.

never mind.

Maddison · 10-06-2009 5:39pm

An indefinate sentence in a secure mental institution. I think death would be an easy way out for this woman.

Professey Chin · 10-06-2009 5:40pm

Life...............no wait whats the opposite again?

Gulliver · 10-06-2009 5:41pm

I would say death too, but she has two children under 10. Tough call.

Dennis the Stone · 10-06-2009 5:42pm

Life should mean life.
Hanging's too good for them
A spell in the army would sort them out
THEY KEEP TO THEIR OWN

TheZohanS · 10-06-2009 5:42pm

Butterfly baby wrote: »

This is vile to read so please don't read it if you are in anyway squmish

http://www.comcast.net/articles/news-national/20090607/US.Pregnant.Woman.Killed/

Now the point of my question is that in all other aspects she was a normal person but just seem to have acted out of impulse and, as you can see in the article, she's not the first to do it. There is also the point of if the child was alive or not during her actions bt no one can say for definite which should also be considered so what way do you think she should be treated (within the legal system)?

Choices:

!. Death sentence
2. Life in prison
3. Mental institute (But bare in mind there seems to have been no previous indication of mental problems)
4. Mental institute but studied (that sounds lifeless I know but should we try to find out why someone to just changes from normal to a murderer in a matter of days?)
5. Open choice, give your own if none of mine apply to what you think should happen.

What is your opinion on it?

Robbo · 10-06-2009 5:43pm

5. The impotent rage 100,000 internets.

4zn76tysfajdxp · 10-06-2009 5:43pm

I'd give her a cuddle.

call d · 10-06-2009 5:44pm

seen a doc about this on Discovery or Nat Geo, it's not that uncommon, can't think of the name of the condition.

Dennis the Stone · 10-06-2009 5:45pm

I'd give her a baby. That's what she wanted anyway isn't it?

easyeason3 · 10-06-2009 5:46pm

call d wrote: »

seen a doc about this on Discovery or Nat Geo, it's not that uncommon, can't think of the name of the condition.

I'm-a-crazy-person-itis???

Not fit for society syndrome???

Keano · 10-06-2009 5:48pm

Put her in a small cell with a very small window and only let her out for 1 hour a day. All that should be in the cell is a bed and a toilet.... but wait that is probably against her human rights :rolleyes:

Captain-America · 10-06-2009 5:50pm

Two year suspended sentence.

She's probably lovely. Ye're all so quick to judge.

Pygmalion · 10-06-2009 5:51pm

Tago Mago wrote: »

I'd give her a baby. That's what she wanted anyway isn't it?

Worst punishment suggested so far anyway.

padi89 · 10-06-2009 5:51pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Put her in a small cell with a very small window and only let her out for 1 hour a day. All that should be in the cell is a bed and a toilet.... but wait that is probably against her human rights :rolleyes:

Judging by her picture id have that cell window overlooking a fast food outlet but all she would ever be fed would be salad.

ejmaztec · 10-06-2009 5:51pm

She could represent the US in the Olympic sport of Extreme Midwifery.

thelordofcheese · 10-06-2009 6:00pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Put her in a small cell with a very small window and only let her out for 1 hour a day. All that should be in the cell is a bed and a toilet.... but wait that is probably against her human rights :rolleyes:

yes, human rights for prisoners is sooo awful, whatever are they thinking.....

ahara · 10-06-2009 6:05pm

A short bout of community service, ideally working with orphans.

Butterfly baby · 10-06-2009 6:09pm

TheZohan wrote: »

What is your opinion on it?

My initial opinion was death sentence, when I read it I was sickened but I have the advantage of a day to calm down and now, after I've read it from a less angry position, I think that if anything it should be found out why she just changed like that. Mental institute and just studied is what I think now. I mean think about it, if she dies we learn nothing she gets off (because, like it or not, after death there is no punishment) but if she's kept alive and forced to face what she did she'll eventually have to face why she did it and I'd say that realisation would be worst than death.

4zn76tysfajdxp · 10-06-2009 6:11pm

I can already see where this thread is going.

carlybabe1 · 10-06-2009 6:32pm

thelordofcheese wrote: »

yes, human rights for prisoners is sooo awful, whatever are they thinking.....

They're not, no more than she was thinking about either the woman or the babies human rights. I mean who could be so re-DICK-ulous to think that if a person completely disregards another persons right to life and commits murder, that thats all the consideration they should be given when being sentenced :rolleyes:
I mean of course they're entitled to more than thier victims, isnt that evolved society ????

10-06-2009 6:35pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Put her in a small cell with a very small window and only let her out for 1 hour a day. All that should be in the cell is a bed and a toilet.... but wait that is probably against her human rights :rolleyes:

Actually, they make conditions good because a crazy prisoner will turn violent. And TVs are added not as a luxury, but as a sedative.

thelordofcheese · 10-06-2009 6:38pm

Annalise Modern Deck wrote: »

I can already see where this thread is going.

really, i was thinking something more like this

thelordofcheese · 10-06-2009 6:40pm

carlybabe1 wrote: »

They're not, no more than she was thinking about either the woman or the babies human rights. I mean who could be so re-DICK-ulous to think that if a person completely disregards another persons right to life and commits murder, that thats all the consideration they should be given when being sentenced :rolleyes:
I mean of course they're entitled to more than thier victims, isnt that evolved society ????

I have no idea what you're trying to say... Is this poes law in action or what?

Keano · 10-06-2009 6:46pm

thelordofcheese wrote: »

I have no idea what you're trying to say... Is this poes law in action or what?

Damn you... I had to Google poe's law

Poe's Law relates to fundamentalism, and the difficulty of identifying actual parodies thereof

thelordofcheese · 10-06-2009 6:53pm

Keano A Legend wrote: »

Damn you... I had to Google poe's law

Basically, you can't lampoon someones position (usually fundemantal christians, but it applies pretty much anywhere) without someone reading it as the poster being totally serious.

Mr. Presentable · 10-06-2009 6:54pm

Give her the death sentence,
or
a Man U shirt

johnnyskeleton · 10-06-2009 7:26pm

Heinous? Seriously?

Butterfly baby · 10-06-2009 7:39pm

johnnyskeleton wrote: »

Heinous? Seriously?

Yeah you're right, an unprofessional slicing a baby out of an unsuspecting pregnant woman is just a ciserian huh? what was I thinking using words like "Heinous" or "Crime"....

Butterfly baby · 10-06-2009 7:52pm

nipplenuts wrote: »

Give her the death sentence,
or
a Man U shirt

"LOL" how funny, Lucky for me I can be neutral and abuse all teams so it could be argued that it'd be no different to giving her a Liverpool shirt or an Ireland shirt since it'd be no different because when push comes to shove it doesn't matter what team you follow because you're all aggressive little brainless b******ds anyway so don't try to imply that football hooliganism is solely ristricted to Man U fans...

A heinous act but what should be her punishment?

Comments