Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

khan's new trainer

  • 07-07-2008 1:12pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 38


    I read at the weekend that Amir Khan is being linked to Freddie Roach, do you think that its too late or could he really improve him. I could be wrong but that might mean Khan being a sparring partner for Pacman which mightnt suit Khan, is Roach still considered one of the best if not the best around, What do yis think


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,549 ✭✭✭✭cowzerp


    Freddiecould definetly improve khans game, he's only a young lad..

    Rush Boxing club and Rush Martial Arts head coach.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    Freddie Roach could improve Khan a lot.........if Khan is willing to go to America and stay training at the wild card gym . Remember when Alex Arthur was 'trained' by Freddie Roach ?, well that is one of the reasons why Arthur had such a porous defence(something Khan needs fixed) because Arthur rarely actually worked with Freddie because he still lived in Scotland .

    If Khan wants a US trainer he should move to the US, otherwise he wont see the benefits . Now wouldn't be a bad time to move stateside being honest, ITV feel things are starting to get a bit stale and may not renew his contract, however Khan could easily sign with someone like Goldenboy and hey presto he's on HBO anytime he wants .


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,309 ✭✭✭T-K-O


    If Kahn goes to the state to train under Roach he would make waves at world level...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    T-K-O wrote: »
    If Kahn goes to the state to train under Roach he would make waves at world level...


    Roach won't take him.

    He already trains a guy in Khans division, namely Pac Man.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,309 ✭✭✭T-K-O


    Who knows how long Manny will stay at lightweight.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    T-K-O wrote: »
    Who knows how long Manny will stay at lightweight.

    Me, the answer is one more fight, Valero .


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    I can see no gain in going to California. More distractions than you can shake a stick at. Khans problems are in his jaw. Whats Freddie gonna do? Get him an implant??? Sure he can tighten his D but so can any number of domestic trainers. Bernard Dunne and AAA spent ages out there, did nothing for their chins or their attitudes.:(


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 968 ✭✭✭ODD-JOB


    Khan's re-signed with Frank Warren , so I cant imagine He's going to be living in the states.

    Khan's only rated under 2 bodies , the wbc and wbo.
    Manny Pacq is only rated with the wbc at the moment.

    Khan's rated #5 @ WBC, so its hardly likely they will spar together.

    Big Ears, I think you're a big fan of valero ? am i right ?

    Manny takes him by K.O !


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    ODD-JOB wrote: »
    Khan's re-signed with Frank Warren , so I cant imagine He's going to be living in the states.

    Khan's only rated under 2 bodies , the wbc and wbo.
    Manny Pacq is only rated with the wbc at the moment.

    Khan's rated #5 @ WBC, so its hardly likely they will spar together.

    Big Ears, I think you're a big fan of valero ? am i right ?

    Manny takes him by K.O !

    I like Valero, have seen plenty of of him and appreciate that he always brings excitement but I wouldn't quite call myself a fan of the guy .

    He's got plenty of power but all these ko's have got him to look for the knockout rather than use his pretty decent boxing skill to win fights . He's the type of guy who could benefit from a loss and if he were to fight Pacquiao I'd have little doubt he would suffer a loss . He's got a small chance due to his power but I just can't see him landing the bombs to take Pacquiao out and Valero himself can be hurt .

    Still Pacquiao v Valero will be great while it lasts and Valero brings just enough power to keep it interesting .


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,972 ✭✭✭joepenguin


    Any idea as to what Oliver Harrison is up to? Must be a serious kick in the teeth to get sacked at this stage.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    joepenguin wrote: »
    Any idea as to what Oliver Harrison is up to? Must be a serious kick in the teeth to get sacked at this stage.

    He's probably waiting for a Jamie Moore v Zaurbek Baysangurov fight to be set so he can prepare his man for that .

    Moore is the only big name Harrison is working with at the moment .


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,309 ✭✭✭T-K-O


    Big Ears wrote: »
    Me, the answer is one more fight, Valero .

    Yeah thanks for the Manny steps up to take on a super featherweight.....:D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    Whats the rush with Khan????

    We already know he is going to MISS the deadline to become the youngest British World Champ ever.

    So whats the hurry?

    Besides, whoever Khan fights next, his opponent after that is going to be AAA, so where's the impetus for a new trainer?

    If he can't beat TBA and AAA with his current setup, then he isn't going nowhere.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    Whats the rush with Khan????

    We already know he is going to MISS the deadline to become the youngest British World Champ ever.

    So whats the hurry?

    Besides, whoever Khan fights next, his opponent after that is going to be AAA, so where's the impetus for a new trainer?

    If he can't beat TBA and AAA with his current setup, then he isn't going nowhere.

    That dealine passes before his next fight takes place, it was never realistic in the first place and I don't think any(unbiased) person believed Warren would even have given him the chance by now .

    Roach is going to be his trainer:, if Khan moves to America while training this is a good move(obviously having resigned with Warren he will mainly fight in the UK), if not and he is trained like Alex Arthur was by Roach(that's before and upto the Gomez fight) then his defence isn't going to improve at all .


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    Steve DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDunce was on the tele today and, for once, said some smart things: this notion of these mystical magic working American fight gurus is a load of tosh. Roach can't make Khan keep his hand up and he can't fix his jaw. Stay in England and keep working. I agree.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 968 ✭✭✭ODD-JOB


    Good quote there Hero ...... just like Bernard Dunne was with Freddy wasnt he ?

    Anyway , Roach is suffering from Parkinsons , and its taking effect . He's not so much hands on physically as i believe.
    Didnt get to see Manny work outs pre diaz fight , but I would be surprised if roach still does the pads for him.
    Even still , he will be mixing with a much higher calibre fighter in the Wild-Card gym.

    I think the reason for Khan is raising his profile in USA.
    He might just gain notice now that he is associated with a established name like Roach. As much as he is talked about here , he's almost unmentioned in the US boxing media circles.
    Theres far too many talents @ lightweight , Khan dosent impose on any of them.

    The best thing to do for Khan and Warren is to finally let him fight somebody that shall give Khan respect if he should win.

    When people talk of Khan , its always about his lack of credibility as a world class boxer.
    Nobody can really vouch for him , not even walshB :)
    He's obviously got something good , as he made the olympics and did well.
    But since turning pro , he has consistently fought under-weight fighters, and not only a division or 2 below lightweight , but these guys are known to be particularly light fisted .
    The other match-type that can fool the average public is to fight established names that have long lost the abilty to fit into the upper echelon of the sport.
    AKA fighting Gomez / or Joe Calzaghe v Roy Jones Junior is a classic example.

    Best o luck to Khan , but he got it the easy way. He has a promoter/investor who is carving the easiest possible path to stardom. And thats fair enough , he's been lucky to have such advantage.
    If he was a South American from the barrios he would have had to fight and beat top tier tough nuts all through his career to have any chance of being noticed.
    Most top boxers prevailed against all the odds , from lives with the slimmest chance of sucess.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    You are spot on there- Khans father probably forbids Amir to behave in the same way Haye does...so running around getting into peoples faces is out of the question. Undoubtedly this would raise his profile. The Yanks are an extremely cynical hardnosed lot. The fact that Khan moves to the States would butter them up no end. It would play right into their "Come To America" attitude.

    But he could keep his trainer and just FIGHT in America and enjoy the same effect.

    Vitaly Klitschko did it and was packing out MSG and the Staples Center. As did Wladimir- not to mention what Hatton got up to.

    Khan probably can't match those guys for draw: Hattons had his legion of fans, the Russian and Ukie ex-pat community did a lot for the KLitschkos, Joe Cal came to prominence by beating the sh!t out of Lacy.....whats Khans ticket??

    If he stays at home, he's a big fish in a small pond. Hatton was the same. Warren brought him along just so...and by the time Hatton was ready, so was Tszyu.

    Warren knows his business. Khan ought to stay in England, make the odd trip to the US, get on some undercards. Keep his feet on the ground and his nose in the headlines.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 968 ✭✭✭ODD-JOB


    Top Rank are lumping Manny pac with Humberto Soto in November I think.
    Valero is being lined up for the under-card in a high profile night of lightweight boxing.

    So the other names in the division are on in mid -september.
    My point being that the Valero slot is vacant.

    if i were Warren I would slip Khan in there , its going to be a very heavily publicised fight night in the U.S.

    Ok its a risk , but if Khan is to make it to the top one day , then he'll have to face somebody of quality sometime.

    It would be a short-cut to a world title bout...

    Now , problem is that Valero is a big puncher .....


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 930 ✭✭✭Hero Of College


    ODD-JOB wrote: »
    Top Rank are lumping Manny pac with Humberto Soto in November I think.
    Valero is being lined up for the under-card in a high profile night of lightweight boxing.

    So the other names in the division are on in mid -september.
    My point being that the Valero slot is vacant.

    if i were Warren I would slip Khan in there , its going to be a very heavily publicised fight night in the U.S.

    Ok its a risk , but if Khan is to make it to the top one day , then he'll have to face somebody of quality sometime.

    It would be a short-cut to a world title bout...

    Now , problem is that Valero is a big puncher .....

    Slip Khan onto the undercard. I don't care if it is even before the doors open. It will end up on youtube at least. Fight in America, train in England. Let Frank Warren do his job.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 968 ✭✭✭ODD-JOB


    Derrick Gainer -
    Only managed to win 3 of his last 6 fights.
    Coming out of retirement.
    hasnt fought in well over a year
    Belongs to the Featherweight division
    37 years old
    Hasnt had a KO victory in 7 years.

    More world class opponents for Khan , Fwarren's a disgrace.
    Time will slip by , and Khan will find himself being 35 years old before he gets a P4P match-up.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    ODD-JOB wrote: »
    Derrick Gainer -
    Only managed to win 3 of his last 6 fights.
    Coming out of retirement.
    hasnt fought in well over a year
    Belongs to the Featherweight division
    37 years old
    Hasnt had a KO victory in 7 years.

    More world class opponents for Khan , Fwarren's a disgrace.
    Time will slip by , and Khan will find himself being 35 years old before he gets a P4P match-up.

    It's not confirmed by any means but he was previously offered the fight but had to turn it down as he was fighting on the Calzaghe v Jones bill then pencilled in for September. However he may now be available again.

    In the mean time Sports Network also offered the fight to John 'Fireball' Fewkes http://www.boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=271946&cat=boxer, Fewkes isn't actually a bad boxer but that ko record does indeed tell the whole story and he's not as skilled, experienced or as guileful as Willie Limond.

    Fewkes's team told Warren come back with more money and it will happen, so instead Fewkes is fighting Martin Gethin for the vacant English title, a fight which if he wins will give him a mandatory shot at the British title. Held by none other than John Murray.........the man Khan should be facing.

    Now I had been a big fan of Murray for quite some time, but some unspiring performances back to back and constantly failing to reach the level he had set himself early in his career left me feeling maybe he wasn't as good as I thought he was. You'd always hear the stories of how good he was in sparring(and that's from other fighters eg Michael Gomez) and Murray would claim that it was these short notice bouts and low key fights had caused the poor performances. That when he knew who his opponent was and was motivated he would show his level.

    He had done that against Dean Hickman, destroying him impressively in just 4 rounds. But Hickman isn't even at British level and when John fought poorly against a Mexican in vegas and then fought terribly against(admittedly very tough) journeyman Youssef Al Hamidi it looked as if John Murray was more myth than matter.

    But to be fair to him, The Al Hamidi fight was when Murray was originally meant to be taking on John Fewkes, Fewkes cancelled not long before the fight and as John Murray was going to be the night before the fight an opponent hadn't been found and as far as he was concerned there was a strong chance he wouldn't be fighting the next day. He woke up the next morning and was told he was facing Al Hamidi who while having a poor looking record has given some big names in domestic British boxing more than a scare and recently beat prospect Anthony Crolla.

    Murray looked crap, I wrote him off completely for the first time and with a lot of disappointment in my heart as I had felt early in his career he could become World Class. Good chance he'll still never reach that but I was starting to think he wouldn't even win a British title.

    Fast forward two months and he's in against an albeit slightly faded Lee Meager. Then we got this:
    Murray was controlled, patient, picked his shots well and just dismantled Meager.

    Warren will look to avoid Murray now, but how long is it going to take for Khan to step up to European level never mind World if he's still avoiding domestic challenges ?

    We kept hearing(from Warren) that Khan would fight Yuri Romanov soon, Romanov was always named as prospective opponent. Eventually Warren waited long enough that Romanov moved beyond European level and up to World.
    The now vacant title will be fought between John Thaxton(a faded fighter who was taken apart by Romanov but still carries plenty of power and heart) and Juan Carlos Melero Diaz, the former champion from Spain who was knocked out by Romanov but is pretty decent if a bit basic in the way he fights.

    Khan may take on Thaxton if he loses that fight, which I suspect he will.
    Both fighters would have to look terrible for Warren to take on the winner.

    The Gomez fight has put Warren in a terrible position. To the outside World everything looked to be going well with the win over Gairy St.Clair, who has proved to be a shadow of his former self since the Khan fight. St.Clair was at his best as a Featherweight anyway and he was a very small Super-Featherweight despite mainly operating at that weight and picking up a title at it.

    Which was followed with what seemed another progressive win in a World title 'Eliminator', while technically an eliminator it was never specified if it was a final eliminator, semi-final etc. In effect it turned out as a process to remove the seriously inflated rank of Martin Kristjansen the Dane who should have been nowhere near as high in the World rankings and didn't even deserve(or hold) a place as high in the European rankings.

    Michael Gomez brought everything back down to earth, Gomez gave a spirited display but showed the level he's at now in the Johanneson fight before it. Not a bad challenger for the British Super-Featherweight title nowdays but he ultimately came up very short and showed how far Khan still has to come.


    Michael Gomez partially threw forward something I suspected all along, that Khan's best opponent to date has been Willie Limond and since that fight over a year ago when Khan was in his greatest difficulty, in the 5 fights since he hasn't gone back up to that level. Kristjansen was a poorer more limited version of Limond. Limond is very smart in his defensive, he carries extremely good handspeed for a domestic/European level fighter(although obviously slower than Khan) and technically in many ways he's a better fighter than Khan. Khan's physical abilities allowed him to overcome this.

    Many people forget that Limond didn't just land one flurry of punches in that fight to get Khan in trouble. He made it a close competitive fight that had Khan thinking 'Allah what am I meant to do here ?'. I had Limond a point ahead after 6(the knockdown round) with it 3 a piece. Khan subsequently proved he does have one intangible in heart as he turned things around to drop Limond in the next and a sustained attack in the 8th convinced Limond's corner to retire their fighter with a suspected broken jaw. Limond's jaw actually wasn't broken but he did have a perforated eardrum.

    I think the best fight Khan could have for his next fight that is a rematch with Willie Limond to tell us how far Khan has really come. A perfect chance for the new trainer to show improvements he has made. But that fight can't be made, because Willie Limond has ambitiously taken an offer to fight Ukrainian Jew Dmitry Salita in New York up at Light-Welterweight. Salita often fights at full blown Welterweight and is none as a big puncher aswell as being pretty slick.

    The advantage with managing a fighter like Limond is you can take risks like that and if they pay off great, if they don't once the fighter isn't physically harmed then no harm is done.

    But if you've got yourself A Golden Egg prospect you can't just treat it like anything else. You've got to milk it for all it's worth and maybe some day it will hatch into a fiery all conquering bird of prey. Warren just better hope if that is the plan, that it doesn't fly away.

    After all he's got enough trouble suing Hatton in the past and Calzaghe now.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,380 ✭✭✭✭nacho libre


    I can't understand why some people on here rate Khan so highly. this guy, like Dunne, has a glass jaw which will ensure he is beaten by the very best.
    It doesn't matter care how good his handspeed and footwork are once he tagged by a fighter with any sort of power he is going down.
    Warren knows this so he is keeping him away from genuine threats before the cash cow runs dry.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    I can't understand why some people on here rate Khan so highly. this guy, like Dunne, has a glass jaw which will ensure he is beaten by the very best.
    It doesn't matter care how good his handspeed and footwork are once he tagged by a fighter with any sort of power he is going down.
    Warren knows this so he is keeping him away from genuine threats before the cash cow runs dry.
    He's not remotely like Dunne. Yes, he's been down; but the main difference is that he got up and won. You cannot take that away. His chin is sussy, but he is still unbeaten and still so young. To beat Khan, I think you will have to KO him, as he is going to be very hard to out box over 12 rds. He's super fast, fairly fairly fit and hits hard enough to gain respect.
    He's big and rangy. The verdict is still out, but as for now, he is a class act and improving.

    I can't see any reason to rematch with Willie. He beat the guy clearly by TKO and to match again would IMO be a step BACK!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,380 ✭✭✭✭nacho libre


    walshb wrote: »
    He's not remotely like Dunne. Yes, he's been down; but the main difference is that he got up and won. You cannot take that away. His chin is sussy, but he is still unbeaten and still so young. To beat Khan, I think you will have to KO him, as he is going to be very hard to out box over 12 rds. He's super fast, fairly fairly fit and hits hard enough to gain respect.
    He's big and rangy. The verdict is still out, but as for now, he is a class act and improving.

    I can't see any reason to rematch with Willie. He beat the guy clearly by TKO and to match again would IMO be a step BACK!

    Well, he(Limond) has been his toughest opponent to date. Unless Warren stops cocooning him it would be a good fight to have.
    Yes, Khan is way more skillful than Dunne and hits hard, but like Dunne he has a very dodgy chin.

    Back to Limond again, if he had any power at all Khan would not have been able to get back up. No matter how skillfull he is, when he is been knocked down by the likes of Limond, who is in no way regarded as a banger, i don't see how he can beat fighters who are physicially his equal and who have heavy hands.
    I suspect we'll just have to agree that we have differing opinions on how far Khan can go.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Nacho, we are on the same page. I too have reservations about his chin. That is a valid and proven point and it may well be his downfall. To be honest, all else is pretty solid. Yes, he has at times a leaky defense, but it is PRO boxing and you do get hit. The thing is, Khan to date has always did more of the scoring than the receiving. I am sure Khan has the potential, power and speed to beat the best 135 lb fighters, but the CHIN is his weakness, little else will STOP him dominating.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    walshb wrote: »
    I can't see any reason to rematch with Willie. He beat the guy clearly by TKO and to match again would IMO be a step BACK!

    He did indeed get back up and won, in a quite convincing manner. Doesn't take away from something I should have pointed out earlier on which is that Khan should have been counted out.
    You can see the referee count to 9, stop when Khan goes back down and then tell him to get back up and put his guard up. Doing his job he would have counted 10 and there would of been his first defeat.

    I don't see how Limond could be anything other than a step sideways at worst, Lawton, Earl, St.Clair, Kristjansen and Gomez have been step backs compared to Limond so it with actually be Khan stepping forward again.


    I like Khan as a fighter, he's exciting to watch and always carries the serious threat that he could lose at any moment aswell as being able to take the opponent out. But there is more than his chin that will stop him dominating. His defense is still poor and it's poor as a result of the way his offence is.
    Over 3 years into his pro career and he's still making amateur mistakes and coming in, in straight lines.

    A major problem that the trainer they have got him(Rubio) is known from his days as a Cuban amateur trainer, and when Khan's mistakes are that he hasn't rid himself of his amateur style then appointing someone who has done little in the pros himself and is known for his work in the amateurs isn't a great idea.

    He hasn't shown he can dominate in Britain, to even talk about World level before he steps up against so more domestic opponents and then European level is premature.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Of course he has more problems than just his chin; but so has every fighter got little areas they need to improve. I honestly feel that if Khan's chin was
    concrete he would clean up. He has all the necessary tools and is a big 135 lb fighter. Can you honestly see anyone matching his combination of speed and power? He is a very hard man to out box because he is so fast and busy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    walshb wrote: »
    Of course he has more problems than just his chin; but so has every fighter got little areas they need to improve. I honestly feel that if Khan's chin was
    concrete he would te. He has all the necessary tools and is a bif 135 lb fighter. Can you honestly see anyone matching his combination of speed and power? He is a very hard man to out box because he is so fast and busy.

    In a way his speed is his power, numerous opponents have said that he doesn't hit that hard just that he punches so fast and accurately.
    I think even with a good chin someone like Juan Diaz would beat him by outworking him. Nate Campbell could very well do the same.

    I wouldn't say Khan has little areas to improve on either, at the moment he has some very significant flaws imo which would cost him even if he did have a better chin.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,380 ✭✭✭✭nacho libre


    He can the speed and workrate to outbox almost anyone. I can't see Diaz outboxing him.

    Those defensive frailities can and will be eradicated by his new trainer. However, you can't eradicate someones glass jaw. This sadly will be his achilles heel. It's a pity as walshb mentioned he would clean up at 135 otherwise.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    He can the speed and workrate to outbox almost anyone. I can't see Diaz outboxing him.

    Diaz doesn't have to outbox him, he'd be able to back him up and beat him with constant pressure.

    Oddly enough it took someone to beat Diaz at his own game to beat him, and pretty surprising that Nate Campbell was the man to do that.

    If he could fix those glaring flaws he does have and didn't have a shaky chin I'd agree that he'd clean up. But as things stand even with a solid beard I don't think he'd be good enough to take everyone.

    I could definitely see Pacquiao outboxing him aswell, that would seem a strange thing to say a few years ago considering Pac used to be so one dimensional, but I guess that shows you what a good trainer can do for a fighter.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,430 ✭✭✭megadodge


    Have to disagree with you here Big Ears.

    I've always thought Diaz was a bit overrated, but was still a bit surprised when Nate Campbell beat him, but if Khan's chin is good (that's a big IF) there is no way either of these is beating him.

    They WON'T outwork him, as that means throwing more punches than Khan, which I don't see and he is definitely more accurate and way faster than either.

    He has some flaws, but they're not quite as bad as you say. I just think the chin is the major doubt/problem. If that's ok, then the sky is the limit.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    megadodge wrote: »
    Have to disagree with you here Big Ears.

    I've always thought Diaz was a bit overrated, but was still a bit surprised when Nate Campbell beat him, but if Khan's chin is good (that's a big IF) there is no way either of these is beating him.

    They WON'T outwork him, as that means throwing more punches than Khan, which I don't see and he is definitely more accurate and way faster than either.

    He has some flaws, but they're not quite as bad as you say. I just think the chin is the major doubt/problem. If that's ok, then the sky is the limit.
    I'm thinking exactly as you are. Big Ears makes good points and both Diaz and Campbell are capable of doing the trick over 12 rds, but my money is on the faster and harder hitting busier Khan. That's assuming his CHIN holds for the full bout


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,380 ✭✭✭✭nacho libre


    Big Ears wrote: »
    Diaz doesn't have to outbox him, he'd be able to back him up and beat him with constant pressure.
    .


    I don't think he'll be able to overwhelm him. Khan will simply be too busy and too fast for Diaz. Khan is one of the most skillful fighters at 135. His handspeed is just incredible. The only way he's going to be beaten by Diaz or anyone is because of his glass jaw.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    Nacho, your POST there seems a lot more optimistic than your first post asking why so many rate Khan so high?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,380 ✭✭✭✭nacho libre


    walshb wrote: »
    Nacho, your POST there seems a lot more optimistic than your first post asking why so many rate Khan so high?

    What can i say... it's down to your persuasive argument walshb:)

    I've never really doubted Khan's boxing skills just that i doubted whether they would be enough against a top fighter, who can can bang, when he has this one major weakness.
    That's why i was, in my original post, questioning people who were sold on him.
    I am more optimistic now, but i do still have reservations about his chin holding up, but if it does, and he cuts out a few defensive flaws - like keeping his hands low, i can't see many people beating him on points.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,004 ✭✭✭Big Ears


    Well yee all seem pretty positive, however I'm still not convinced. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

    Just a month now till his next fight so I doubt that is going to tell us much.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 57,370 ✭✭✭✭walshb


    What can i say... it's down to your persuasive argument walshb:)

    I've never really doubted Khan's boxing skills just that i doubted whether they would be enough against a top fighter, who can can bang, when he has this one major weakness.
    That's why i was, in my original post, questioning people who were sold on him.
    I am more optimistic now, but i do still have reservations about his chin holding up, but if it does, and he cuts out a few defensive flaws - like keeping his hands low, i can't see many people beating him on points.
    I'm glad to have showed you the error of your ways:D, Kidding mate!

    Serious, we are similar in our rating of Amir. Both a bit apprehensive due to his possible shaky chin. Here's the thing though; he has been hit and hit clean and knocked down, but he did get up, and I take a positive look at this. I know Limond is no Hearns in the power stakes, but the shots were clean and flush!


Advertisement