Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Buffer Tank

  • 09-06-2008 7:54pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 43


    Where can I source a proper stratifying buffer tank for a wood pellet boiler installation that i want to reduce cycling on,.... also any idea of price?


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,555 ✭✭✭✭AckwelFoley


    Toyota1968 wrote: »
    Where can I source a proper stratifying buffer tank for a wood pellet boiler installation that i want to reduce cycling on,.... also any idea of price?

    As much as i would like to think i know i still dont know it all :D ... what do you mean by "stratifying" ?

    What size do you want? Buffer tanks are commonly sized from 200L to 1000 L


  • Posts: 31,118 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    snyper wrote: »
    As much as i would like to think i know i still dont know it all :D ... what do you mean by "stratifying" ?

    From what I've found out about the subject, it really to do with the water staying in layers in the tank.
    Hot water at the top & cooler at the bottom, water entering the tank from a heat source goes into a vertical open ended cylinder and rises if it's warmer or sinks if cooler than the water either end of the cylinder.
    This avoids the situation where hot water entering the tank is cooled by the water already there.

    must find the linky. edit: here's one but not the one I'm looking fore
    Solaris5zoom.html


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 188 ✭✭MickLimk


    Water will generally stratify (settle into layers of different temperatures, hottest at the top, coldest at the bottom) in every tank as long as it's not being disturbed by a high cold flow into the tank. A high velocity cold flow could create currents in the water mixing the layers and destroying the stratification.

    The position/orientation of the cold feed into the buffer tank/cylinder is important in this. The pressure of the cold feed also plays a part. There are some tanks (I'll see if I can find any specifics) that have tried to minimise the disturbance of the stratification layering by the design of the cold feed input. The simplest one is the addition of something like an upside down bowl that diverts the cold flow back to the bottom of the tank. See attached diagram.

    There are other more complicated 'tank-within-tank' and 'perforated tank-within-tank' designs that take the reduction of heat loss to a different level. Then there is something like this (http://www.alternativeheat.co.uk/power_tanks.php) which claims to reduce boiler cycling times etc. I've no connection with these guys, no idea if these things come close to what they claim, have never seen one installed or have no clue what price they are. Let us know if you do get a price!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 462 ✭✭Cuauhtemoc


    They have them here. Seem v expensive for what they do. Maybe i'm wrong though. I think it's the add on in the accessories further down the page


    http://www.rvr.ie/default.aspx?subj=catalog/ProductDescription&catIdPath=0_42_68_106&productId=ASK122

    C.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 43 Toyota1968


    idea with stratifying is exactly as described - hot water from boiler goes in top....... water out to rads etc goes out top...... cold return from rads goes in bottom...... cold out to boiler goes out from bottom..... idea is that when sensor say 1/3 of the way from the top of the tank says temp is dropping then boiler cuts in and runs until sensor at bottom of tank says full tank now hot....... then oiler cuts out and doesnt need to run again until cold level "rises" to top sensor..... idea is if you get good stratification you minimise boiler cycling and stabilise temps to rads i will try and do a series of ppics to illustrate


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 43 Toyota1968


    this shows the principle of stratification.....

    pic 1 - rads taking hot water boiler off

    pic 2 - sensor one goes cold - boiler switches on - rads still getting hot water

    pic 3 - sensor 2 gets hot boiler switches off - rads still gettng hot water

    pic 4 - back to step 1


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 25 redonly


    Hello

    I want to combine UFH (ground floor)/Rads (upstairs) oil condensing boiler a stove back boiler (i have tons of solid fuel free at hand) and 6sqm of solar panels. I am told the only way to get them all working together is to pipe them all into a combi tank/stratifying tank 600L plus in size. Is this the only way to do it or is there another solution?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 12 Bogtrotter1


    do a search on "pat lee", I was reciently at a promo where he was showing a new thermal store tank system with solar coil and stratifying baffle.
    D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 290 ✭✭Longboard


    www.rvr.ie - Kerry
    www.patlee.ie - Wicklow (I think)
    www.lapesa.es - Spain (Same tank as pulsar but half the price)
    www.maassen.ie - Donegal
    www.heatmerchants.ie - Nationwide
    www.pulsardirect.ie - Cork


    If you are going +300L, keep in mind the weight of the tank if you are siting it on the first floor.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 254 ✭✭Evergreen


    MickLimk wrote: »
    The position/orientation of the cold feed into the buffer tank/cylinder is important in this. The pressure of the cold feed also plays a part.

    This is an excellent point in relation to proper stratification. I have installed buffer tanks over the years and the best way to plumb a heating system into a buffer tank is to T it off the flow/return from the boiler to buffer tank. When the boiler is operating this greatly reduces the turbulance caused in the buffer tank.

    Also, pump speed is very important. I have often gone into houses where the plumber has stuck in a 25/80 grundfoss pump that just shots the water around the heating system at a ridiculas rate. The high speed causes sever turbulance in the buffer tank and can cause a 1650L tank to go from 85°C top 35°C bottom to approx 45° throughout and then the boiler stuggeling to get the heat above this level. It also means that the heating system in the house is operating inefficiently. I have chaged out such pumps for 25/50's or 25/60's with speed set to minimum and it has had a much better effect.

    A 1650 L with 100mm insulation will set you back around EUR1700 plus VAT.

    What size boiler do you have? I presume that it is over sized, otherwise the boiler would not be cycling as much as mentioned earlier?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 25 redonly


    redonly wrote: »
    Hello

    I want to combine UFH (ground floor)/Rads (upstairs) oil condensing boiler a stove back boiler (i have tons of solid fuel free at hand) and 6sqm of solar panels. I am told the only way to get them all working together is to pipe them all into a combi tank/stratifying tank 600L plus in size. Is this the only way to do it or is there another solution?


    Thanks for the help some good product available. Does anyone know how effective a system like this is works with space heating:
    1. Will the heating be as responsive as if the boiler was connected direct yo UFH/rads
    2. Is there any recommend/preferred size tank because i think 1000l tank is very big and heavy! (our house is to be 3000square foot with)
    3. Will the UFH/rads cool the water on their return into tank so much so that the burner would be working full time in the winter
    4. I am told the panels will keep the bottom of the tank warm enough to assist the UFH
    5. I am also told these stratisfying tanks loose only 1 or 2 degrees over 24 hrs with 100mm of insulation so once you get them hot they stay hot but is this only if the water is not moving?
    Has anyone any experience of any of the above cant make my mind up as to what way to go.

    I could possibly go down the line of UFH/RADS direct to boiler, boiler/solar panels/and back boiler to feed to 300l tank for DHW only.


  • Posts: 31,118 ✭✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    redonly wrote: »
    Thanks for the help some good product available. Does anyone know how effective a system like this is works with space heating:
    1. Will the heating be as responsive as if the boiler was connected direct yo UFH/rads
    2. Is there any recommend/preferred size tank because i think 1000l tank is very big and heavy! (our house is to be 3000square foot with)
    3. Will the UFH/rads cool the water on their return into tank so much so that the burner would be working full time in the winter
    4. I am told the panels will keep the bottom of the tank warm enough to assist the UFH
    5. I am also told these stratisfying tanks loose only 1 or 2 degrees over 24 hrs with 100mm of insulation so once you get them hot they stay hot but is this only if the water is not moving?
    Has anyone any experience of any of the above cant make my mind up as to what way to go.

    I could possibly go down the line of UFH/RADS direct to boiler, boiler/solar panels/and back boiler to feed to 300l tank for DHW only.

    1. There will be a short lag as the boiler itself heats up.
    2. It depends on the size of the solar array and wood boiler output, you need to check with the manufacturers.
    3. The burners should only run if the system calls for heat, if your wood boiler is only connected to the tank then it will only fire when the tank stat calls for heat, or if the boiler is connected directly to the CH/UFH then it will be on when the room stats call for heat.
    The return to the boiler can be fed via a mixing valve to keep the return temperature at 40C to improve the efficiency of the boiler - check with manufacturers first!
    4. only if the heat hasn't been already drawn off.
    5. That would be the case if the water is not used, unlikely in real life.


    HTH


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 endacoffey


    Hi Evergreen,
    I intend to fit a 32kw Atmos Wood Gasification unit to my 2100 sq ft house. I am fitting the boiler out in the garage which is 10 metres fro the house. The height from the garage floor level to the tank in the Hotpress (which will be fed by my buffer tank) is approximately 5.5 metres to the top of the tank. My buffer tank will not have any additional coil and my hot water will be heated in the smaller hot press copper cylinder. here are 13 radiators in the house. My plumber wants to fit a Grundfos 25/80. Do you think this will cause stratification problems in my buffer tank? Do you think a 25/60 would be better? and if so, will it be strong enough to pump water to my heating system from the buffer tank? I currently have a 25/80 on the oil boiler in the garage and now suspect that this is causing air to accumulate very frequently in one of the upstairs bedroom radiators. Does the underneath white 3 way switch adjust the speed? It's so close to the ground that I cannot see. I cannot find a manual for it online either.
    I just want to avoid these problems when I connect the new system.
    Any help that you or any other contributor can add is greatly appreciated.
    Many Thanks,
    Enda.

    Evergreen wrote: »
    This is an excellent point in relation to proper stratification. I have installed buffer tanks over the years and the best way to plumb a heating system into a buffer tank is to T it off the flow/return from the boiler to buffer tank. When the boiler is operating this greatly reduces the turbulance caused in the buffer tank.

    Also, pump speed is very important. I have often gone into houses where the plumber has stuck in a 25/80 grundfoss pump that just shots the water around the heating system at a ridiculas rate. The high speed causes sever turbulance in the buffer tank and can cause a 1650L tank to go from 85°C top 35°C bottom to approx 45° throughout and then the boiler stuggeling to get the heat above this level. It also means that the heating system in the house is operating inefficiently. I have chaged out such pumps for 25/50's or 25/60's with speed set to minimum and it has had a much better effect.

    A 1650 L with 100mm insulation will set you back around EUR1700 plus VAT.

    What size boiler do you have? I presume that it is over sized, otherwise the boiler would not be cycling as much as mentioned earlier?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 536 ✭✭✭Condenser


    endacoffey wrote: »
    Hi Evergreen,
    I intend to fit a 32kw Atmos Wood Gasification unit to my 2100 sq ft house. I am fitting the boiler out in the garage which is 10 metres fro the house. The height from the garage floor level to the tank in the Hotpress (which will be fed by my buffer tank) is approximately 5.5 metres to the top of the tank. My buffer tank will not have any additional coil and my hot water will be heated in the smaller hot press copper cylinder. here are 13 radiators in the house. My plumber wants to fit a Grundfos 25/80. Do you think this will cause stratification problems in my buffer tank? Do you think a 25/60 would be better? and if so, will it be strong enough to pump water to my heating system from the buffer tank? I currently have a 25/80 on the oil boiler in the garage and now suspect that this is causing air to accumulate very frequently in one of the upstairs bedroom radiators. Does the underneath white 3 way switch adjust the speed? It's so close to the ground that I cannot see. I cannot find a manual for it online either.
    I just want to avoid these problems when I connect the new system.
    Any help that you or any other contributor can add is greatly appreciated.
    Many Thanks,
    Enda.

    A 25/60 has a "head" of 6m, in order to properly size the pump you need to calculate the pressure losses/losses in head within the system. Simply saying a 25/80 is too big is too simplistic. Every pump has a curve where it can move different quantities of water at different levels of head. The amount of water can also be varied by turning down the pump speed. I would suggest that a 25/6 would be a little small on a 32kw boiler, but that will depend on plenty of factors, such as the size of the flow and return pipework etc etc. Does your plumber know the product or is he one of these shur that'll do merchants


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 142 ✭✭awnow


    Hi
    If planning to install buffer tank, is it necessary or beneficial to also use a colorifier, say a twin-coil colorifier? Heating sources are (1) condensng oil boiler and (2) wood burning stove. Under-floor heating d/stairs, radiators u/stairs. Possible future inclusion of solar panels. Any ideas/thoughts/pointers appreciated. :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 endacoffey


    Hi Condenser,
    Perhaps you may be able to help with a query.
    I am purchasing a 2000 litre Akvatherm Tank to go along with my Atmos 32 kw boiler. As I said previously, I intend to heat my DHW in an indoor cylinder in the hotpress. The problem that I may have is that when I am heating water only in the summer (rads switched off) the temperature of the water returning to the buffer tank may be too high and if pumped into the bottom of the tank, may upset the stratification.
    Have you any suggestions as to how I might overcome this?
    I would appreciate any input.
    Thanks for your help,
    Enda.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 536 ✭✭✭Condenser


    endacoffey wrote: »
    Hi Condenser,
    Perhaps you may be able to help with a query.
    I am purchasing a 2000 litre Akvatherm Tank to go along with my Atmos 32 kw boiler. As I said previously, I intend to heat my DHW in an indoor cylinder in the hotpress. The problem that I may have is that when I am heating water only in the summer (rads switched off) the temperature of the water returning to the buffer tank may be too high and if pumped into the bottom of the tank, may upset the stratification.
    Have you any suggestions as to how I might overcome this?
    I would appreciate any input.
    Thanks for your help,
    Enda.

    Hi Enda,

    Maybe i'm misunderstanding the concept behind what you're trying but I think you are using the 2000L buffer as the store for your heating system and a 2nd tank for hot water storage. If that is the case why are you bothered about stratification in the tank in the summer, as you won't be drawing energy from it anyway? Why would you route the heated water through the Buffer tank at all in the summer?

    Apologies if I misunderstand the system


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 endacoffey


    Hi Condenser,
    The Atmos system requires that all water from the boiler goes into the buffer tank. In the summer time, I intend to send water from this buffer tank up to the cylinder in the hot press. As I understand, the cylinder has a coil within which is part of the overall heating circuit and it is this coil which heats the water in the tank. I have the house zoned into upstairs and downstairs and therefore have motorised valves which close off the circuits to the radiators when I require hot water only. My problem / query is that, as the heat is not lost to the house via the radiators, the return temperature to the bottom of the buffer tank will be too high and in turn upset the stratification as it enters the bottom of the buffer tank and mixes with the cold water. Maybe I am missing something really obvious but I would appreciate any pointers as I have read some nasty problems with stratification on threads in the UK and I'm trying to avoid these and obtain maximum efficiency from the fuel that I burn.
    In an ideal world, I could draw a seperate hot water supply from the top of the buffer tank but the garage is too far from the house in which the buffer tank will be kept and it would mean digging up the driveway, extra plumbing, etc.
    Thanks for any help in advance,
    Enda


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 536 ✭✭✭Condenser


    endacoffey wrote: »
    Hi Condenser,
    The Atmos system requires that all water from the boiler goes into the buffer tank. In the summer time, I intend to send water from this buffer tank up to the cylinder in the hot press. As I understand, the cylinder has a coil within which is part of the overall heating circuit and it is this coil which heats the water in the tank. I have the house zoned into upstairs and downstairs and therefore have motorised valves which close off the circuits to the radiators when I require hot water only. My problem / query is that, as the heat is not lost to the house via the radiators, the return temperature to the bottom of the buffer tank will be too high and in turn upset the stratification as it enters the bottom of the buffer tank and mixes with the cold water. Maybe I am missing something really obvious but I would appreciate any pointers as I have read some nasty problems with stratification on threads in the UK and I'm trying to avoid these and obtain maximum efficiency from the fuel that I burn.
    In an ideal world, I could draw a seperate hot water supply from the top of the buffer tank but the garage is too far from the house in which the buffer tank will be kept and it would mean digging up the driveway, extra plumbing, etc.
    Thanks for any help in advance,
    Enda

    I think you may be wrong in your thinking that the coil is part of the heating circuit. My guess is that its not, its merely your method of dumping heat in the cylinder before the water returns to the boiler to complete the circuit. The coil heats the bottom of the tank and the warmest water will rise to the top. The warmest water will be drawn off the top by the circ pump for your rads and returned to the bottom of the cylinder afet passing through the rads. The water will self stratify depending on temp. Because theres very little turbulence in the tank, because of the coil, disturbing the stratification won't be a problem.
    Taking water from the top of this tank to the DHW cylinder seems like a huge waste of energy to me. Either divert the water to a hot water cylinder in the house before it enters the buffer when DHW is required or fit a DHW heat exchanger to the side of the buffer tank to provide you with hot water and forget about the cylinder inside.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 endacoffey


    Hi Condenser,
    Thanks again for your reply.
    I found a schematic of what I propose to do on a Firebird boiler manual. Can you prease have a look at page 12 of this link. http://www.firebird.ie/Portals/0/docs/4.3.4.%20Bio-Tec%20gasification%20boiler%20installation%20instructions.pdf
    It should be a similar set-up for the Atmos.
    I am concerned that the water at (7) will be too hot when returning to the bottom of the Buffer tank thereby upsetting the stratification as the buffer tank should naturally heat from the top downwards. I would imagine that this may be a particular concern if the radiatiors are not turned on and the heat in the circulating water is not being "lost" to the rooms in the house.
    Maybe I'm worrying about nothing as perhaps the Laddomat will recirculate any "over hot" returning water into the boiler and not the bottom of the Buffer Tank.
    As I explained earlier, the boiler and buffer tank will be going out in the garage where my oil burner is already located and I intend to connect onto the flow and return on this oil burner with some sort of non return valve. I hope to transfer the heating controls in my house that currently demand heat from the oil burner to the buffer tank and "demand" the heat from there when needed (whether it be needed for DHW in the copper cylinder in the hot press of the house or the radiators).
    What do you think of this? Is there any way of improving the system without bringing an extra pipe from the garage into the house which has it's own problems as I said earlier.
    Thanks for your patience with this, I'm just learning trying to get a good handle on it before I let the installer near the place. I've talked to a couple of them and even though they are registered to install Atmos with SEAI, they still don't seem to be 100% sure when I talk about Stratification, etc.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 536 ✭✭✭Condenser


    endacoffey wrote: »
    Hi Condenser,
    Thanks again for your reply.
    I found a schematic of what I propose to do on a Firebird boiler manual. Can you prease have a look at page 12 of this link. http://www.firebird.ie/Portals/0/docs/4.3.4.%20Bio-Tec%20gasification%20boiler%20installation%20instructions.pdf
    It should be a similar set-up for the Atmos.
    I am concerned that the water at (7) will be too hot when returning to the bottom of the Buffer tank thereby upsetting the stratification as the buffer tank should naturally heat from the top downwards. I would imagine that this may be a particular concern if the radiatiors are not turned on and the heat in the circulating water is not being "lost" to the rooms in the house.
    Maybe I'm worrying about nothing as perhaps the Laddomat will recirculate any "over hot" returning water into the boiler and not the bottom of the Buffer Tank.
    As I explained earlier, the boiler and buffer tank will be going out in the garage where my oil burner is already located and I intend to connect onto the flow and return on this oil burner with some sort of non return valve. I hope to transfer the heating controls in my house that currently demand heat from the oil burner to the buffer tank and "demand" the heat from there when needed (whether it be needed for DHW in the copper cylinder in the hot press of the house or the radiators).
    What do you think of this? Is there any way of improving the system without bringing an extra pipe from the garage into the house which has it's own problems as I said earlier.
    Thanks for your patience with this, I'm just learning trying to get a good handle on it before I let the installer near the place. I've talked to a couple of them and even though they are registered to install Atmos with SEAI, they still don't seem to be 100% sure when I talk about Stratification, etc.

    The way thats shown it looks like the cylinder used is a direct cylinder while i think the Akvatherm has coils. If it has then you could use the coil at the bottom for the boiler and a top coil to extract energy to the DHW tank. In that scenario you'd have no problem with stratification. Just make sure the bottom coil could handle a 36kw boiler.
    If you use a direct cylinder there are plenty of connections on the tank to tap the return water in at a higher level. There will likely be no more than 10C difference between the top and bottom of a 2000L tank in any case


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 endacoffey


    Thanks again Condenser. Can you recommend a 3 way mixer valve for the outgoing water. I see that there are manual and electronic versions and was wondering which was most efficient and cost effective.
    Regards, Enda


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 536 ✭✭✭Condenser


    endacoffey wrote: »
    Thanks again Condenser. Can you recommend a 3 way mixer valve for the outgoing water. I see that there are manual and electronic versions and was wondering which was most efficient and cost effective.
    Regards, Enda

    Hi Enda,

    Do you mean on the water leaving your DHW tank because I don't really see the need to one anywhere else, as the temp for DHW tank and rads will be similar?
    Have a look here, http://www.esbe.se/nav5174?prodid=3562
    they make good equipment


Advertisement