Irish Paper 1 (HL)

mathew

So what did people think??

Comprehensions were quite nice. Easy enough. One or two slightly tricky questions in the second one, but nothing too bad.

Essays were nice enough too. I did the very last one. The speach about Homeless People. Just started with Dia Dhuit, wrote an aiste as normal and ended with Go raibh maith agat!

Overall Im very happy. Hope we get a nice P2 tomorrow now!

cookiemonst3r

i didnt like the choice of essays at all. Just randomly picked the greed and dishonesty of young people aiste. no idea why. only realised half way through that i had nothin today!!

Does anyone else think 2hrs 50 is way too long for paper I??

analyse this

went very well. very easy sceal (tacaiocht) and the comprehensions were a doddle. except one of the question in the second comp. something about hawthorne insulting the irish immigrants or something. hadn't a notion what it was about:o

Haven't a Clue

Leamhthuiscint's were great. As the op said, the second one had one or two tricky questions. As for the essay, a lot of people were complaining about the choices but like the OP, I did the speech and made a pretty good job of it.

cson

The comps were sweet. The aistes were tough, no death on the roads essay :eek:! I did my best with the 'People have no control over their lives' essay. Whored on about the usual stuff.

mathew

cookiemonst3er wrote:

Does anyone else think 2hrs 50 is way too long for paper I??

Yes.. although i did stay in for the whole thing.. took my time, read over the paper about 4 times. Found mistakes each time!!

analyse this wrote:

except one of the question in the second comp. something about hawthorne insulting the irish immigrants or something. hadn't a notion what it was about

I think that was in the extract from something he wrote. In italics above his photo. He was saying how did they did any slave job, and had a fondness for whisky!

Havn't a Clue wrote:

Leamhthuiscint's were great. As the op said, the second one had one or two tricky questions. As for the essay, a lot of people were complaining about the choices but like the OP, I did the speech and made a pretty good job of it.

Great minds think alike

cson

cookiemonst3r wrote:

Does anyone else think 2hrs 50 is way too long for paper I??

It is a bit, the two leamhtuiscints took me an hour leaving almost 2 hours for the essay. Its probably too long but it is relaxing knowing you've so much time unlike English paper 2 where you have to go in there with the finger out and lash into essays as quick as you can.

cookiemonst3r

Ya but that keeps you awake and not half asleep. I sat there for most of the time thinkin about what to write in my essay!!

Steve01

It went grand for me. I did the scéal I had prepared and applied it perfectly to the tacaíocht question. After the two comprehensions I did the díospóireacht on how he don't control our lives these days and then finished with 50 minutes to spare. So ha! "Exam suicide" my arse.

Selphie

An-sásta freisin. I did the speech too. I took up half a page at the beginning saying that it was nice to be here speaking...yadda yadda yadda.... and it went very well, I think.
I spent twenty minutes at the start writing down the points I could remember from an essay I did on poverty before. I actually think it's great having all the time. I was able to read over the comprehensions lots and translate them, work out all the answers etc. Started the essay at three, finished it at four fifteen and spent five minutes going over it. I was the only one still there, which was kinda unnerving, but I had some mistakes, so it was worth it in the end!!!

blondie07

Yeah, i thought it was ok. didnt do spectacular but not too bad. was really disappointed with the essays, not just because road deaths didnt come up, just thought they were very boring topics. was practically falling asleep in the last 1 1/2 hours trying to think of stuff to write! did the thing bout how we have no control in our lives, it was a bit of making some stuff up on the spot, so probably lots of spelling mistakes, but well over the 700 with some good pieces of irish so happy enuf. comprehensions werent too bad, tried my hardest to put them into my own words, but i totaly suck at them in general so not too hopeful. lovely aural but i should done better, cuid c was a bit of a disaster

opinionated

All in all, I thought it went pretty good but the second comprehension was dodgy...

Fuzzy_Dunlop

I did the speech as well but i'm only after realising now after listening to the radio that it was at an international thing, and i was going on about how we need to get the government to give more support and the simon community and saying that i'm sure everyone heard about what happened recently when an old homeless man was found in the liffey(made up of course). Oh **** just thinking its going to totally mess it up, good thing 80% of the marks are for the irish

Seinas

ah i was delighted with how easy it was, i finished an hour early so i had time to drive to Tralee for McDonalds and be back in time for the listening

i did the essay on young people's dishonesty and greed.. I just wrote about drugs and alcohol and said these problems are the cause of it

Spank

I wrote my general Daoine Oga essay, went on about the education system and the pressure they are under. Half of it was praising them, half of it was saying they were awful anti-social things! Very messy, prob loads of mistakes, euggh. 2nd comp was disgusting I thought. Aural not great either. I'd say I passed though.... hopefully.

genericgoon

Anyone do the seanfhocail sceal? Casue its one of the few times i understood one of these. A nice easy story there too.

bebop!

Would someone mind posting the meaning of what the speech question about Daoine Gan Dídean was so i can really find out what a mess of it i have made!!

Haven't a Clue

playa3 wrote:

I did the speech as well but i'm only after realising now after listening to the radio that it was at an international thing, and i was going on about how we need to get the government to give more support and the simon community and saying that i'm sure everyone heard about what happened recently when an old homeless man was found in the liffey(made up of course). Oh **** just thinking its going to totally mess it up, good thing 80% of the marks are for the irish

No, you were speaking to an international group of something or another. You had to base your talk around the problems with the daoine gan dídean i mBaile Átha Cliath. I gave a brief synopsis about what my organisation did at the start, started on about the problems and finished with a "WE NEED MORE MONEY YIS BASTARDS" plea. All in all, I think it was solid.

ZorbaTehZ

Nice paper, nothing hard. Did the climate change essay and got about 3 and a bit pages done. I stayed right to end as well, as I have done on all the papers thus far and I plan to do the same on the rest as well.
So far (including the cluais.) 3 things have come on Galway. Woot.

Haven't a Clue

bebop! wrote:

Would someone mind posting the meaning of what the speech question about Daoine Gan Dídean was so i can really find out what a mess of it i have made!!

You are the Head (or CEO, something along those lines) of an organisation which helps homeless people. You've to talk to some sort of international group in Dublin about this problem in Ireland. Write the speech you'd give.

That's the jist of it.

genericgoon

My essay was reaching a bit of a cul de sac and I was trying to find a way to convince this character to go out. I didnt know what t say so I just made up a love interest on the spot! My story is so silly

bebop!

thanks ,,havent a clue!..well maybe im not totally wrong I gave a speech about homelessness in Ireland ,,, but i kept sayin what we have to do to fix it that it was the irish governments fault an all dat ,,, it was kinda directed to an irish audience rather than an international audience ,, hopefully it'll be ok:(

analyse this

The story options were very open. You could actually talk about anything. I pretty sure I got near 90 marks in the story. A great deal better than my 30/100 I got in the marks. Stupid examiner.

Marshy

Was I the only one who did the TG4 essay? Wasnt bad at all, easy to talk about in detail also.

Overall happy with Paper 1. Although slightly less confident over Paper 2.

CosaFada

what did you write about!?i started it but ran out of things to say!!

genericgoon

paper 2 is about knowledge and im much better at that than bloody writing good irish so paper 2 is preferable for me.

Fuzzy_Dunlop

Haven't a Clue wrote:

No, you were speaking to an international group of something or another. You had to base your talk around the problems with the daoine gan dídean i mBaile Átha Cliath. I gave a brief synopsis about what my organisation did at the start, started on about the problems and finished with a "WE NEED MORE MONEY YIS BASTARDS" plea. All in all, I think it was solid.

Ahhh thats alright then,pretty much what i did

emmerson

Hey all can I clarify something I took the Níl smacht ara shaol debate and I think I took it at another angle, I took it up as there is not enough discipline in peoples lives...spoke bout students often not being disciplined enough to study until the last minute (own personal experience!) and how they spend so much time on Bebo/watching TV etc, then went on to discuss drivers on the road (had to get it in somewhere) and their lack of discipline when it comes to speed and therefore death on roads etc, then bout polititions not being disciplined when it comes to jeopardising their jobs cos they borrow money from people etc and finally ref to discipline not being the same in schools as it was a decade r two ago...am I way off the mark here? I now realise most people would have brought in the whole control as regards alchohol/drugs/crime etc...? Help!:eek:

Captain Smiggy

Waffled about stadas na gaeilge for a while then talked about TG4 is unbiased and whatnot.....not three bad, maybe 60/100....

Marshy

CosaFada wrote:

what did you write about!?i started it but ran out of things to say!!

I just focused on some of the programmes and how they give an "insight" into different aspects of life.

Started off with ros na rún, went on to talk about hector and then how they're starting to show some sport events. Just said that the wide range of programmes give us a different view of the world through Irish.

Corruptedmorals

I did climate change essay. Manged to write about Kyoto Agreement, Power of One, c02 emissions, the weather and ice and An Inconvenient Truth. Was afraid it wasn't 500 words, but it was 588 Went back over it and corrected loads of mistakes, don't think the red pen can find a lot of fault with it tbh.

Comprehensions were grand, boringly long, and there was one part that was slightly dodgy, but the answer couldn't have been anything else so.. Managed to twist most of them into my own words also.

Don't think I'm out of the running for the A2 I want yet...Paper 2 could suck completely though

Corruptedmorals

cookiemonst3r wrote:

Does anyone else think 2hrs 50 is way too long for paper I??

Nope. Did the comps slowly but surely...essay took a good while, and had to re-read it and correct mistakes. Finished about 3 minutes before time.

E92

2 h 50 mins is sufficient time .... unlike in other subjects like Business in particular where you every last millisecond of time they give you.
Overall paper 1 in Irish went well, particularly the Essay or in my case the alt. The tape was a dream come true:)

Your Man

my teacher has always said your allowed to write an aiste on the sceal titles..never looked into it as i thought thered always be an aiste i could do, until today that is, anyone know if hes right? i ended up doing an aiste on tacaiocht

mathew

E92 wrote:

2 h 50 mins is sufficient time .... unlike in other subjects like Business in particular where you every last millisecond of time they give you.

Personaly I dont find that with business.. Im always finished very early. Geography is another story however.. thats a long exam!

chas_88

Marshy wrote:

Was I the only one who did the TG4 essay? Wasnt bad at all, easy to talk about in detail also.

Overall happy with Paper 1. Although slightly less confident over Paper 2.

i'm surprised the whole country didnt have an essay prepared on TG4! it was obviously going to come up, being 10 years old when they set the paper back in november. very easy to do as well, i was delighted when i saw it!
the léamhthuiscints were very straightforward, there wasn't even any difficult vocab, and the tape was a joke!

euwwy deuwwy

I did the essay on young people being disrespectful and dis honest. I dont think it was great though and it lacked alot of structure, i just kind of waffled on senselessly for a few pages. is 3 nd a half pages about average btw?

Selphie

Haven't a Clue wrote:

No, you were speaking to an international group of something or another. You had to base your talk around the problems with the daoine gan dídean i mBaile Átha Cliath. I gave a brief synopsis about what my organisation did at the start, started on about the problems and finished with a "WE NEED MORE MONEY YIS BASTARDS" plea. All in all, I think it was solid.

daoine gan dídean in Ireland in general, not just BAC. I sort of disregarded the whole idirnaisiunta thing, I didn't even think about it until reading these posts now. My thing at the start addressed friends and colleagues though, so that might be okay. And I did a paragraph on how we should copy the French...so....hopefully......