Will someone give this girl a steak??

Miss Fluff

http://showbiz.sky.com/showbiz/article/0,,50001-1231846,00.html
Check out slides 1 and 11. She is BLATANTLY anorexic. I always thought she was just slim but she’s obviously got an eating disorder. Check out the shoulders. Views please. Is she dangerously underweight or do some people seriously aspire to be that thin?

xzanti

Christ almighty

Aisling(",)

Miss Fluff wrote:

http://showbiz.sky.com/showbiz/article/0,,50001-1231846,00.html
Check out slides 1 and 11. She is BLATANTLY anorexic. I always thought she was just slim but she’s obviously got an eating disorder. Check out the shoulders. Views please. Is she dangerously underweight or do some people seriously aspire to be that thin?

I know its like really un healty to be that thin and i dont aspire to be that thin (god knows that'd happen)but i know a few of my friends always seem to be permantly on diets to try and achieve the body shapes of celebrities such as vitoria,misha barton and paris hilton.I dont think most girls are happy with their weight and figures most people would love to loose some weight myself included.I dont think ive ever met a girl compleatly happy with her body.

Busterpuss

would like to lose a few pounds as i think all women do, but do not aspire to this at all. and how she can continue to claim her boobs are real?? Hello??!!

Kintarō Hattori

Indeed, it's just not healthy and as a red blooded guy, I just don't like someone to be that thin. Thankfully my better half has a beautiful voluptuous shape which I love. I would never like her to be that thin.

chump

She's wrotten and most men don't like people that thin, so don't start with the media paints an image of the perfect women malarky, and she is it.

She is not.

Madge

Keira Knightly at the Pirates premiere looks pretty skinny aswell, the dress is just hanging off her..
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/entertainment/2006-07/05/content_633451.htm

Nala

Have a look at the new photos of Nicole Richie in this week's NEW magazine- she's lost even MORE weight.

Rb

Madge wrote:

Keira Knightly at the Pirates premiere looks pretty skinny aswell, the dress is just hanging off her..
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/entertainment/2006-07/05/content_633451.htm

Shes disgustingly thin too. Victoria Beckhams head looks massive!

Nala wrote:

Have a look at the new photos of Nicole Richie in this week's NEW magazine- she's lost even MORE weight.

Didn't think she had any more weight to lose tbh, she was skin and bones already.

The three of them(Keira,Victoria and Nicole) are extremely unattractive imo, purely because of their weight. Each of them would be a lot more attractive if they put some meat on their bones.

panda100

Madge wrote:

Keira Knightly at the Pirates premiere looks pretty skinny aswell, the dress is just hanging off her..
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/entertainment/2006-07/05/content_633451.htm

Vistoria Becham and nicole Ritchie are not meant to be skinny and it looks unatural. Kiera Knightly however has always been very skinny so its not fair to slag her over something that she cant control. Jordan is actually skinnier then Kiera Knightly but doesnt look it cos of her big tits. I have exactly the same frame as Misha Barton and Kiera Knightly. Im tall lanky and cant for the life of me put on weight no matter how hard I try. Everyone always thinks Im waaaay to skinny but I cant help it cos its what I was born with,and i stuff myslef!I dont stop eating and exercise only occasionly.Its horrible to read these days how disgusting skinny women are and how all men go for curves. Some of us cant help but be skinny!!

Rogueish

Start worrying when you can count their ribs on their chest.....

Keira Knightly has always had a very slim frame and her weight does not fluctualte much. Nicole Richie is in need of therapy and Victoria Beckham is trying to oudo the other WAG's the only other way she can via her weight cos she can't do anything about her age...

abetarrush

wha ye mean not meant t be skinny?

Ur size is determined by your diet and exercise unless you have a medical condition

Im sure Ciara Kiera just had good exercise and diet always

panda100

abetarrush wrote:

wha ye mean not meant t be skinny?

Ur size is determined by your diet and exercise unless you have a medical condition

Not at all.Genetics have a lot to do with it. As i said before I eat loads,I never stop eating and apart from cycle to college occasionaly I dont exercise and you can see my ribs. Victorai Beckham and Nicole Ritchie look unhelathy being skinny cos they are naturally curvy. But I dont think Kiera Knightly or Mischa Barton do.They have always been skinny and they look really well cos they are true to their own body weight and dont try to be something their not.

[Jackass]

She's skinny, I certainly wouldn't call her anorexic.

This is anorexic:
Anorexic 1
Anorexic 2
Anorexic 3
Anorexic 4
Anorexic 5

But as we all know, these things can be overcome and some people make a full recovery.

Recovery

Faith

No, they're emaciated and near death.

Victoria Beckham is anorexic. She'll soon end up like those girls if she's not careful.

I thought Nicole Ritchie admitted that she had an eating disorder, and was getting help for it?

I think it'll take someone famous dying from anorexia before people cop on.

bounty_hunter

Faith wrote:

I think it'll take someone famous dying from anorexia before people cop on.

You mean apart from the famous people who've already died? Sadly I don't think it'll make much of a difference

Miss Fluff

Nick wrote:

But as we all know, these things can be overcome and some people make a full recovery.

LOLers at pic

Smellyirishman

Transform over on the Fitness board actually did a show on Ireland AM a few weeks ago about Victoria and Kiera etc... was a good watch, I put it up on you-tube so you can find it over on the fitness boards somewhere or I could link it later if anyone was interested.

brown*eyed*girl

Nick I remember seeing some of those pics on another website especially the first one and its been photoshopped. I will try find the link and post it here.

I've suffered with eating disorders on and off for 10 years. I've never been properly diagnosed by a GP but would say I'm EDNOS (Eating Disorder Not Other Specified). I restrict a lot now and exercise a lot too to control my weight and in my early twenties I used to have bullimia. I can tell you this much its not that easy to just say eat a steak. I don't want to go into too much detail here as its very personal but I think too many people think its a lifestyle choice and sufferers can just flick on and off the switch. I'm recovering at the moment but if I'm honest I don't think I'll ever be fully recovered. Its so hard to explain to other people that you still feel fat even though you're only 95lb. I get so angry when people slate Victoria or Nicole as its a psychological problem and its making it worse for them to recover with all the horrible things people are saying about them. Sometimes what can start out as a simple diet can often turn into a more sinister eating disorder. Once its gotten hold of you its VERY hard to go back to "normal".

Villaricos

brown*eyed*girl wrote:

Nick I remember seeing some of those pics on another website especially the first one and its been photoshopped. I will try find the link and post it here.

I've suffered with eating disorders on and off for 10 years. I've never been properly diagnosed by a GP but would say I'm EDNOS (Eating Disorder Not Other Specified). I restrict a lot now and exercise a lot too to control my weight and in my early twenties I used to have bullimia. I can tell you this much its not that easy to just say eat a steak. I don't want to go into too much detail here as its very personal but I think too many people think its a lifestyle choice and sufferers can just flick on and off the switch. I'm recovering at the moment but if I'm honest I don't think I'll ever be fully recovered. Its so hard to explain to other people that you still feel fat even though you're only 95lb. I get so angry when people slate Victoria or Nicole as its a psychological problem and its making it worse for them to recover with all the horrible things people are saying about them. Sometimes what can start out as a simple diet can often turn into a more sinister eating disorder. Once its gotten hold of you its VERY hard to go back to "normal".

well said! anyone who is starving themselves isnt a healthy bunny pyschologically and having been there myself too, albeit briefly, the hardest thing in world to do is to sit down in front of food, let alone eat it.
Yes Victoria and others look unhealthy, yes its a bad image to send out but instead of blaming these women blame the society that forced this unrealistic image of what the ideal female looks like on them and us.

brown*eyed*girl

..

The Sweeper

Knightley's a skinny bird and always has been. It wouldn't take too many days of skipping a meal or two to take her whippet figure down to being overly bony - in otherwords, she probably doesn't need to have an unhealthy obsession with food to be that thin. If she has a busy lifestyle and an athletic, high metabolism, a week of pre-premier stress could be all that she needed to take the rounding off some of her pointier bits and have her look unhealthy in that dress.

Anybody notice how V. Beckham's weight only became a major problem after her husband's alleged affair with Rebecca Loos?

Corruptedmorals

panda100 wrote:

Vistoria Becham and nicole Ritchie are not meant to be skinny and it looks unatural. Kiera Knightly however has always been very skinny so its not fair to slag her over something that she cant control. Jordan is actually skinnier then Kiera Knightly but doesnt look it cos of her big tits. I have exactly the same frame as Misha Barton and Kiera Knightly. Im tall lanky and cant for the life of me put on weight no matter how hard I try. Everyone always thinks Im waaaay to skinny but I cant help it cos its what I was born with,and i stuff myslef!I dont stop eating and exercise only occasionly.Its horrible to read these days how disgusting skinny women are and how all men go for curves. Some of us cant help but be skinny!!

Exactly, me too! I hate the coverage it gets for being repulsively ugly.

Miss Fluff

Minesajackdaniels wrote:

Anybody notice how V. Beckham's weight only became a major problem after her husband's alleged affair with Rebecca Loos?

Big time! Was reading about it one of my many celeb magazine reading frenzies and apparently when their relationship is in trouble she uses food (or lack thereof) as a tool to gain attention from DB, i.e. "If you don't issue this statement/take me out and take a united stance etc I won't eat". Before people jump down my throat and tell me not to believe everything I read, she DID become noticably cadaverous after the Floozy Loosy debacle.

Madge

panda100 wrote:

Vistoria Becham and nicole Ritchie are not meant to be skinny and it looks unatural. Kiera Knightly however has always been very skinny so its not fair to slag her over something that she cant control.

IMO, Knightley is still definitely underweight for a start. She's a member of the 'lollypop brigaid' - head bigger than body.
Compare Knightley to Nicole Kidman or Cameron Diaz. Both those ladies are tall and skinny, but no-one ever said they're anorexic. Why? Because people can tell their shape is natural.

Blondecrammer10

No shes not she like denied it on TV , she has a class figure id give anything to look like her...

Kold

Blondecrammer10 wrote: »

No shes not she like denied it on TV , she has a class figure id give anything to look like her...

It's generally frowned upon to drag up 2 year old threads.

simu

I was deliberating whether to move this to Showbiz or Fitness but given that it's old, I'll lock it.