Best Comeback of the year?

Amazotheamazing

Well which band unexpectedly managed to save their careers after a few bad albums/songs?

Personally I'm going with Oasis and the Importance of Being Idle, or Stereophonics with Dakota. Anyone else make it back into your good books?

Devon

Green Day by FAR. That American Idiot was their best work ever. They were as far as I am concerned dead in the water and then they blast back with that. More amazing than Amazotheamazing himself/herself.

Nalz

jerryadams wrote:

Green Day by FAR. That American Idiot was their best work ever. They were as far as I am concerned dead in the water and then they blast back with that. More amazing than Amazotheamazing himself/herself.

gotta agree there...American Idiot was a great improvement, and theyre reapin the rewards for it too. Oasis wasnt bad, but personally Im startin to get sick of them a little

Jonny Arson

Oasis never ''came back''..... they were always here! Heathen Chemistry was a fine album.

Yeah American Idiot is great and would deserve comeback of the year if it hadn't been released in 04' but heck they've had a great year and their success is well deserved even if they are a bit too commercial.

casanova_kid

Zane from MTV2 wrote:

Oasis never ''came back''..... they were always here! Heathen Chemistry was a fine album.

Yeah American Idiot is great and would deserve comeback of the year if it hadn't been released in 04' but heck they've had a great year and their success is well deserved even if they are a bit too commercial.

Oasis have really come back, making Definately Maybe repeatedly is brilliant, come on surely you guys can come up with something better.

munky

Amazotheamazing wrote:

Oasis and the Importance of Being Idle, or Stereophonics with Dakota. Anyone else make it back into your good books?

HAHAHAHA they didn't come back!they are still ****!
As was American Idiot!Come nobody actually listened to that album after about the second time!.....did you?!

Chardee MacDennis

oasis defo, standing on the shoulders of giants was pants except for Sunday morning call and be here now... what can i say. but Dont Believe The Truth is excellent and their show in the point was in the top 3 shows i've ever seen there with only David Bowie and Radiohead beating them.

Nalz

munky wrote:

HAHAHAHA they didn't come back!they are still ****!
As was American Idiot!Come nobody actually listened to that album after about the second time!.....did you?!

yes...yes munky, I did

hoody

Feeder - Pushing the Senses was excellent, cool how they've changed their sound over the years

gizmo

Well it depends on what you mean by comeback. Album wise for Green Day it was only 4 years since Warning was released and some times it takes bands that long to write a new album. Plus they still toured to promote International Superhits afaik so I wouldnt really call the album itself a comeback.

In terms of their careers though it has to go to Green Day. Fair enough American Idiot was released in 2004 but their domination of the mainstream music world only happened this year and its been a long time since they were this popular...IF they were ever this popular before.

Amazotheamazing

munky wrote:

HAHAHAHA they didn't come back!they are still ****!

Nothing wrong with some feel good tunes, or is there?

skapunkkeith

green day never went anywhere, they always had there fans, they giged when they were writing american idiot, also since warning they released international superhits, and shenanigans(sp), the had to record that and the origional recordings of there album were stolen then they wrote american idiot, they didnt have a comeback they had a spurt of popularity, there still as amazing as they were years ago

for as far as a comeback, either alkaline trio or millencollin, again they never really went anywhere but now there starting to get the respect they deserve