cd ripper a good one?

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 5:17pm #1

can anyone recommend a good cd ripping tool i know theres tonnes out there but i need something that is tried and tested other than audiocataylst thanks a lot guys

hostyle · 22-01-2004 5:19pm

Cdex

Mr E · 22-01-2004 5:26pm

If you're not in a hurry, Audiograbber is great ... its becoming freeware on February 9th.

http://www.audiograbber.com-us.net

- Dave.

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 5:30pm

thing is i need it soon cause ive borrowed 3 of my friends cds and im sure hell want them back soon thanks anyway any more suggestions?

ColmOT [MSFT] · 22-01-2004 6:41pm

How about Music Match...

http://www.musicmatch.com/download/free/?OS=pc&MODE=input&DID=&OEM=MMD

I use this one to rip...

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 6:46pm

i tried music match but cant find the ripping features in it

^whitey^ · 22-01-2004 6:47pm

Audio galaxy great if your in a hurry you won't notice the difference between it and something like:

EAC which is probably the best out there but very slow.

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 7:01pm

audiogalaxy i thought u used that for downloading songs not ripping?

^whitey^ · 22-01-2004 7:04pm

whoops audio catalyst sorry http://www.mp3-converter.com/audio_catalyst.htm

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 7:31pm

kewl i was looking for audiocatalyst since i reloaded my os

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 7:49pm

so which of these is the best then?

voxpop · 22-01-2004 7:53pm

EAC - Exact Audio Copy is the best ripper then I use bladeEnc or Lame at 160 vbr to encode to mp3s

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 8:08pm

thanx guys

Senor_Fudge · 22-01-2004 8:11pm

im getting a lot of jitter though with cdex 150 on one of the cds and its ****ing up the track anything i can do to help that

^whitey^ · 22-01-2004 8:42pm

im getting a lot of jitter though with cdex 150 on one of the cds and its ****ing up the track anything i can do to help that

Yea dump cdex and get Audio Catalyst or Exact Audio Copy EAC

quarryman · 26-01-2004 5:01pm

there's a good comparison here . It seems Lame is the best quality codec. This is used in dbpoweramp which is a great ripping program.

Stark · 26-01-2004 5:04pm

I use CDEx, it's the most convenient. There's also Exact Audio copy if you're totally paranoid about quality/have scratched cds. But you have to do the compression manually with this.

LAME is the best MP3 codec. Use --alt-preset standard for most archiving.

You may also want to consider switching from MP3 to Vorbis (www.vorbis.com). Supported by practically all software now, including the popular Winamp.

Acidflash · 26-01-2004 5:07pm

I usually use FreeRIP MP3, it's downloads the song titles if your connected to the net when ripping a CD which is useful.It's Freeware

^whitey^ · 26-01-2004 6:12pm

EAC uses LAME and it gets the song titles. its great if you have a P4 speced machine otherwise go for Audio Caatalyst or some other thing that doesn't use as much resources.

dahamsta · 26-01-2004 6:39pm

Originally posted by ARM
i tried music match but cant find the ripping features in it

Press the Record button?

n00bee_cracker · 27-01-2004 6:51pm

realplayer rips real fast and the encoding speed can be controlled i thinks there are 3 different encoding methods on it.
nero 6 has a good one too.

b20uvkft6m5xwg · 09-07-2004 3:07pm

Doing a reinstall atm and just deciding on what to put back on the laptop.

I had been using Winamp 5 for ripping which is fine but I'm gonna move back to winamp 2.92 cos I think its more stable, but no ripping facilities.

Any recommendations...
Usual stuff like ID3 tagging, VBR etc are needed.

Muchos Gracias

b20uvkft6m5xwg · 09-07-2004 3:12pm

Actually any thoughts on CDEX?
http://www.cdex.n3.net/

THink I used that at some point.

silverside · 09-07-2004 3:21pm

exactaudiocopy - cant beat it; has tagging facilities and can rip to various formats

Mutant_Fruit · 09-07-2004 5:15pm

EAC can rip to literally ANY format out there. It also has a choice between high quality error free ripping, and high speed error prone ripping. 95% of the programs out there only offer the high speed error prone ripping, such as music match, CDEX, realplayer etc.

For compression, Lame is the best choice if you want to go MP3, but that can be sorted later. For ripping i would always go with EAC. It can get the album titles off FreeDB (as can 99% of ripping programs nowadays), so you should have no problems there.

talking_walnut · 09-07-2004 5:53pm

Just thought I'd add my own little cd ripping method in case it's off any use to anyone.

Rip the CD to my hard drive using ISO Buster. Personaly I don't see the point in ripping and encoding in one, specialy if you've got more than one CD to rip.
I encode all my music into ogg vorbis as the quality is fantastic. This is a simple matter of drag and drop with OggDropXP. (you can get that here if you want)
Finally I tag the files using MP3 Book Helper. Can't recommend this program enough. Best tagger program I ever came across. Specially handy if your on a dial up like me cause it can get the tags of the albums you've ripped already automatically off freedb so you can wait till your online after 6

Get it here

I know this probably sounds like a lot of work to all of ye but it sounds more complicated than it is:) I also tend to go through bursts of ripping CD's where I'd be ripping half a dozen CD's at once and this is by far the best method I've found for that. Anyway, just thought I'd share my method in case it's of any use to anyone.;)

dahamsta · 09-07-2004 6:55pm

I was using MusicMatch up until recently, but then I found this fella. Great little app.

adam

Mutant_Fruit · 09-07-2004 8:31pm

Rip the CD to my hard drive using ISO Buster. Personaly I don't see the point in ripping and encoding in one, specialy if you've got more than one CD to rip.

Not really designed for ripping music (if i remember correctly, try ripping a scratched Music CD with it, and the results won't be as good as EAC in Secure mode. Iso buster is designed for "Data recovery from CD and DVD."

EAC has "burst" mode, which is just as fast as every other ripping program, and just as good qualitywise, and it has "Secure" mode, which is better than any other program (that i know of) and guarentees good results even on badly scratched cd's.

Its up to you, slow but good quality (on mildly/heavily scratched cd's): EAC (Secure mode)

or

fast and not that great on scratched cd's: everything else and EAC (Burst mode)

daveirl · 12-07-2004 10:20am

This post has been deleted.

b20uvkft6m5xwg · 13-07-2004 1:57pm

Originally posted by silverside
exactaudiocopy - cant beat it; has tagging facilities and can rip to various formats

I'm trying this now. I have downloaded a FULL DB from Freedb.oerg for offline/loacl use. EAC seems to want one exact .dat file to import the whole thing.

Anyone know how to do this as it dont seem to be working!?

Mutant_Fruit · 13-07-2004 4:58pm

I'm trying this now. I have downloaded a FULL DB from Freedb.oerg for offline/loacl use. EAC seems to want one exact .dat file to import the whole thing.

No need to do that

that is only if you want to import specific files.

What you want to do is to go to EAC>FreeDB/Database Options
Then go to the "local freedb" tab, and choose the base directory where you unzipped the files to.

EDIT: I'm not sure if this will work well. When i tried using a local database several years ago, the support wasn't great. Since there are so many albums, some "unique" album ID's are duplicated, in fact, practically all of them are duplicated by now, several times. So it makes it hard for an offline database to find the right song. That problem may have been sorted by now. I dont know.

cd ripper a good one?

Comments