dense Registered User
#1

https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2018/0909/992578-bus-safety-figures/


51% of buses which were tested on the roadside failed.

Last year it was much the same, with half failing.


https://www.thesun.ie/news/1411848/half-of-all-irish-buses-tasked-with-ferrying-kids-to-school-were-found-to-have-defects/


Both Robert Troy and Liz O Donnell have focused on school buses subcontracted by Bus Eireann even though the RTE report doesn't say whether school buses failed the roadside tests disproportionately or whether more private or BE vehicles failed.


https://www.joe.ie/news/research-safety-standards-irish-busses-reveal-extremely-639818

“I’ve requested him to ask Bus Éireann to immediately carry out an audit to ensure that every vehicle that’s currently contracted to Bus Éireann has road worthy vehicle certification and secondly to ask the RSA why they are not prosecuting contractors who are known to be breaking the law," said Troy.

Liz O’Donnell, chairperson of the RSA, has also sent a letter to Bus Éireann which expresses their concerns about the road worthiness of school buses that are operated under the School Transport Scheme.

https://mobile.twitter.com/MrJustinMac/status/1038767916446097408/photo/1


Mr. Troy has written to Minister for Transport Shane Ross asking him to instruct Bus Éireann to carry out a full audit to ensure that all buses carrying children have an up-to-date road worthiness certificate.

There was no suggestion in the RTE report that any of the vehicles which were tested failed to have a current certificate so I'm not sure why he's making an issue out of that?

AlekSmart Registered User
#2

dense said:
https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2018/0909/992578-bus-safety-figures/


51% of buses which were tested on the roadside failed.

Last year it was much the same, with half failing.


https://www.thesun.ie/news/1411848/half-of-all-irish-buses-tasked-with-ferrying-kids-to-school-were-found-to-have-defects/


Both Robert Troy and Liz O Donnell have focused on school buses subcontracted by Bus Eireann even though the RTE report doesn't say whether school buses failed the roadside tests disproportionately or whether more private or BE vehicles failed.


https://www.joe.ie/news/research-safety-standards-irish-busses-reveal-extremely-639818
https://mobile.twitter.com/MrJustinMac/status/1038767916446097408/photo/1


Mr. Troy has written to Minister for Transport Shane Ross asking him to instruct Bus Éireann to carry out a full audit to ensure that all buses carrying children have an up-to-date road worthiness certificate.

There was no suggestion in the RTE report that any of the vehicles which were tested failed to have a current certificate so I'm not sure why he's making an issue out of that?


Out of a clear blue sky drops a new issue for our ever compliant media to run with.

Obviously there is a requirement someplace to generate a "debate" on this,and what better way than to involve CHILD SAFETY !!

Very little is being made of the RSA's refusal to supply Bus Eireann with specific details on those failures in the contracted fleet.

A decision somehow at odds with it's oft trumpted focus on Road Safety above all else.

As any BE Contractor will attest to,the Inspection criteria for BE acceptance is far from a pushover as can be independently attested to by the Freight Transport Association.

No doubt Mr Troy will despatch his researchers to get to the truth of the matter before further commenting ?

1 person has thanked this post
marieholmfan Registered User
#3

Liz O'Donnell ; now there's a name I haven't heard for a looooong time.

AlekSmart Registered User
#4

marieholmfan said:
Liz O'Donnell ; now there's a name I haven't heard for a looooong time.


She never went away Y'know....

Slid in to Gay Byrne's old gig at the RSA.

dense Registered User
#5

AlekSmart said:


No doubt Mr Troy will despatch his researchers to get to the truth of the matter before further commenting ?



Doubt it. It wouldn't do for him to be having his nerves calmed.

1 person has thanked this post
Fann Linn Registered User
#6

I'd say Troy will have far bigger problems if BE decide to take 51% of the bus fleet, including school buses, off their routes to get sorted.

Stephen15 Registered User
#7

Are drivers for these operators not adhering to first use checks. I thought it was a requirement and if a bus fails their first use check then they won't be allowed on the until the problem is fixed.

1 person has thanked this post
Cookie_Monster Registered User
#8

Take a look at the garda twitter thread in Motors, the number of trucks and buses pulled for all sorts of violations is pretty shocking.

Victor Registered User
#9

Stephen15 said:
Are drivers for these operators not adhering to first use checks. I thought it was a requirement and if a bus fails their first use check then they won't be allowed on the until the problem is fixed.
In the school bus fleet, I imagine there is a lot of owner-operators and other small operators. Rule keeping may be poor.

3 people have thanked this post
Del2005 Registered User
#10

Stephen15 said:
Are drivers for these operators not adhering to first use checks. I thought it was a requirement and if a bus fails their first use check then they won't be allowed on the until the problem is fixed.


It's most likely like the HGV drivers problems. Highlight an issue with the vehicle and be told drive it or someone else will and you go on the dole, the company doesn't get the fine so they don't care.

The report said that they where targeting certain companies so it's obviously the cowboys who send drivers out in dangerous vehicle they are hitting.

dense Registered User
#11

Victor said:
In the school bus fleet, I imagine there is a lot of owner-operators and other small operators. Rule keeping may be poor.



Or it may be very good. The report didn't single out school buses for disproportionately failing roadside inspections compared to private or public coaches.


On your point, drivers for small outfits are probably going to be more reluctant to refuse to drive a vehicle they suspect has a fault because they wont want to jeopardise their or their boss's livelihood.


At 7am with a blown bulb and no replacement vehicle what will they do? Drive on in what they have.


A blown bulb now constitutes a "major defect", as the EU fault codes for vehicle tests have changed.


The NCT is similarly adopting this new categorisation system.

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!